This needs to happen more often between you 2! Great little series

I'm glad that I found you, Will! These two videos (you and Aaron) were just great entertainment! They were so low-key that I felt a part of the group! I loved that! Thanks to all of you there for the "contest"!

Friend hanging out with food they harvested themselves is the key to happiness

I liked when Will, Aaron and Madeline were judging at the end

This was awesome, having you guys all together again for a cook off but next time, I'll volunteer to be the taster.

Zach Freeman in the background made my day me and his grew up together I love seeing him

More, more, more of these please. This should be a series on its own. The chemistry of the 3 of u is magical. I smiled the whole time.

The DYNAMIC here is why we LOVE you guys! You have something special together 100%!

Both dishes looked phenomenal, very different and unique. Erin might consider adding some roasted pecans on top for contrast and texture. Roasted nuts just add that finishing touch. Keep the videos coming, l really enjoy watching you cook. Bon Appetit.

Loved this!! I was drooling over both dishes. I was seeing the dumplings as my appetizer & grouper as the main course. Since Aaron has the advantage of the boat, you should have the opportunity to buy at least some of your protein. A mixture of fish, lobster & stone crab dumplings would be killer!!

Too hard to call … if I had Will’s entree and Aaron’s main, I would consider myself one happy customer … and happiness filled. Great effort

Another awesome video thanks Will 👍👍

This was amazing, I’m a new subscriber from Aaron’s channel. Next time the judges need to come in after the food is plated so they can judge it blindly. They need to score not knowing who cooked what then you know for sure it’s not biased. Food looked amazing! ❤️

Fantastic! I had a smile on my face throughout this double episode. You guys might want to consider raffling off the opportunity to be a guest judge on your next Iron Chef Challenge.

I have watched every one of the videos you both have aired (some multiple times), I really enjoy seeing how competitive the two of you can be with one another. I hope that this can become a series that you guys produce more frequently. Everyone that participated & viewed the 2 videos walked away winners!! Thank you guys for sharing!

Great to see you back hangin with Aaron

When you crack the shells with a spoon.....you are a mantis shrimp!!!! Sweet potato is a sugar/butter/maple/marshmallow delivery device.... I call shenanigans!! Good job guys!!

Aaron’s dish looks so decadent. One of those plates you really don’t want to know what went into it, but I know it was delicious. Really fun mellow vibe here! Good job.

Will…You guys are awesome!!! I’m a true fan but… Aaron cooks like I do! I put butter on everything!!! Real butter! I would luv to have been there to try everything!!! I ALL looked so damn good!!!!! Great to see you back in KeyWest !!!!! 😊👍

The three two of you back together again. Congrats to madeline she gets to eat the rewards..lol

Dude, you were repping the Canadians again with the PEI shirt! I love it!! Glad the CRV made it! Keep the vids coming my man!!!

Aaron had me at Grouper/Stone Crab up until the sweet potato. But I for one appreciate the skill and ingenuity of Will. + 4pts for Will!

Aaron, A cheap black rubber door mat on top of your cutting board. The best hack ever. The fish stays put, no slipping. Cleans with just a few shakes in the water. Take it on the boat..... Turns any flat surface into a cutting board. Nice clip. AGAIN. Thanks.

I Always watch BOTH channels and love them both equally !!!! Love that yall are friends and Madelline cracks me up with how much she loves too eat !!!! Keep up the great videos !!!!

I wish both your channels nothing but success..so much entertainment. Thanks for your time.

I'm just going to take back everything I said earlier . Erin you absolutely killed it , literally . Great job Erin , You get a 10 in my handbook

I give you guys both credit for picking something you have not done before.

Awesome job both of y'all made beautiful plates they looked delicious that grouper key west waterman caught was beautiful tks for the video y'all take care.

Great time with friends. There is no loser here, you all winners !

Amazing episode. Could watch this weekly. You’ll get em next time Will 😂

Come on The Clamster you got this . Good luck Erin . Hello Madeline hope your enjoying all that delicious food .

awesome collab! both dishes look amazing. usually skip the "cook" parts of the vids, but you guys made it fun to watch and I learned some new things! def will watch more of your content!

👋Well.... Aaron knows me a little bit. And I have wached yuo "the clam is back" (lol) for about 4 months or more. This is so good that I can wach this al day long and night‼️ I wish I was there 🐠🐟🐡🦈⚘️⚘️⚘️❤️

great idea combining these - Will, you just got a new subscriber - will definitely try both of these dishes - Thanks for inviting us along

Can't wait to watch the next challenge with all da BUTTER!

New to your channel. I found you through Key West Waterman Aaron Young. I'm loving the cook offs!!! Keep doing what you're doing and we'll keep watching

Wow this was an incredible episode 👏 I think next time you should compete with the same ethnicity of food or a theme. But all the same guidelines. I think that would be exciting

Get em next time! Fun stuff guys!

Omg. Do these videos again and again. Looks like so much fun. Thanks for sharing 👍.

The judges didn't lose that's for sure. Both dishes looked delicious. How do I get to be a judge? Keep up the good work !

Glad to see you made it back to Key West and though I’m going to miss seeing Mamma Clams, it’s great to see you & Aaron back at it. This video was absolute fun! My face hurts from smiling for 30 minutes straight. BTW, and for the record, Aaron’s heavy handed use of butter was borderline cheating….. Butter and bacon should be banned from these competitions.

I think the dumplings would have worked if you used some chopped Napa cabbage, shitake mushrooms, soy sauce, and julienned carrots, and you are missing the main ingredient for gyoza, dark sesame oil. I know people have mixed feelings on their dumplings (some things can be fighting words). If you are judging sea food don't have a judge who doesn't like fish. Never have someone like me judge sushi or sashimi, I was stationed in Japan for 12 years, married to a Japanese woman yet never acquired the taste unless it was extremely mild and accompanied by a lot of Kirin Lager. I do love smoked salmon sushi (nowhere near raw fish) and sushi rice which I can eat stand alone. The videos were awesome thanks a lot Will and Aaron!

I love these. You gotta get judges with more mature palates though😂. Everyone is gonna vote for butter and cream.

Make a time limit. Iron Chef is organized madness. Plus more courses would add elements of no planning. a twist would be fun. From two small channels great job guys. 👏 A add on to the catch and cook.

You both deserve a 10 imo. Great series! We thoroughly enjoyed it. New subscriber!

Loved y’all’s videos. Sorry but I flipped it before I commented on Aaron’s video. You guys need to do this more often. Thanks

When you guys get together for this stuff its crazy good. Keep it up. Next challenge you decide on each others ingredients

Can't stop smiling...you guys rock! I'm definitely going to be stealing some of your ideas.

I really enjoyed this competition. Both dishes looked delicious and your banter is very entertaining. Thanks for sharing!

The Clam is Back!!! Awesome video

Awesome video and awesome content. Great seeing a couple buddies have fun and bring us all along. Thank you for sharing!

This needs to be a running series. Loved it

Woohoo! Glad you are back in the keys!

This is so entertaining. Those dumplings are super creative. I learned something today.

ya'll keep it up Been watching Dibs for awhile .and then found you,, you two make a great team keep up the cooking videos

You guys are awesome! Cook till you drop. Some really fun times.

I probably would have called a tie. Will won on plating. Aaron won on taste because of texture. You tied on creativity Aaron with the syrup and crab meat, and Will with the homemade dough. 😋 Wish we could have been the judges. Next time the judges can't see anything, a real blind test. Bring the judges in two the plates sitting on the table and no talking to them until they are done judging.

Been waiting for this one! Thanks know it'll be awesome already 😎

Awesome video. Glad to see you back in Key West. Keep the vids coming.

Dibs your my man, however, clams you food looks awesome. Also, what a fun video. My mouth watered for each dish.

I’d pay top dollar for both plates. Super well done!!

Great vid y'all had a blast with this and knocked it out of the park! Love y'all all together! Keep em coming and thanks again!!

Both dishes look very appetizing. Great job fellas!

Will's the man, glad the Honda made it key west LOL.. Aarons looks really good, i love sweet potato's and that cream sauce looks super good. Aaron made his own sauce, will didn't. Wills dish was more time consuming. I would of loved to of tasted both. well done, awesome episodes!!!!!

What a fun episode, love you both. I'm drooling over both of y'all's dishes, great job.

I truly enjoy your competitions!

That was a fun one! Great going guys!

Haha this was such a fun episode, well done epic stuff!

Epic way to return to Key West Will, love both of your channels!

Wow…I envy the Judges❤ great Vid enjoyed it!

Clams!!!! Welcome home bro!

Fantastic job, guys! Quite educational AND entertaining. Cheers!

This was fun.!! I have to admit I’m liking the grouper and sweet potato!! Dumplings with fish gotta try them both👊🏻👊🏻

Great episode and collaboration! Fun to watch both videos

This is great!

You guys all do a amazing job. Good friendships, laugh smile together that’s what life is about. Love you guys. Keep the videos coming Key West waterman cooking with clams. You guys are both winners.

Glad to see you back!

Y'all are so great and fun!

Very good! Totally enjoyed it.

So much fun!

That was fun !

Hilarious! Loved it. Really felt like I was there, you guys are all so natural that it makes people feel comfortable. Keep it up. You guys are great! All of you, loved the end of the video.

We need more of these!

You all are hilarious!

You guys make awesome videos. Keep up the good work!

What a fun video to watch. Really good stuff!

Love the comp... I was rooting for ya...

Nice job guys, good times!

Great collaboration. You guys did an awesome job. Great video!

I used to be in the same boat with Madeline for years regarding asian food/flavors and now I cant express how much I love that kind of food. Its like my tastebuds for it just switched one day I love it. Now I wish that would happen for seafood for me I still cant anything from the water. But it always looks so good wish my plate would change to like seafood so bad.

Fun one!!!

This was a great way to show off both of your strengths and how you still attempt what you may not be comfortable with. Thank you for sharing

Awesome!

Nice video man....i enjoyed it

❤I love this‼️ Best of the best ❤️‼️

Great combo video guys

Damn Aaron! I’d pay for that dish!!!

Great show, really enjoyed it and looks like you had fun!

Fantastic episode....nice going guys 👍🏻

Aswome! Definitely do this more