The MAJOR different between ISLAM and CHRISTIANITY is God tell MUSLIMS what to Do____CHRISTIANS tell God what to Do.

William Craig is scary lol. He's definition of justice is weird. Does all the murders, rape, and everything can be punished by only one crucifixion ? It's like getting a slap for having killed someone

The Islamic concept of God is that He is loving, merciful, and compassionate. But Islam also teaches that He is just and swift in punishment. Nevertheless, Allah once said to Prophet Muhammad, "My mercy prevails over my wrath." Islam teaches a balance between fear and hope, protecting one from both complacency and despair. O people accept the Truth and Get ready of judgements.

Justice is punishment? Punishment is love? Some justice!!! I would much rather confront a God who can show mercy. The Christian God killed his son for the sins of others. Some justice!!!! Or did God kill himself? William Craig has got a lot of explaining to do.

Mr. William has not perfect evidence or theory, Praise only for Allah, peace and blessings on you Dr. shabir.

So the sin and evil that has existed for over 2000 years since the time of Jesus is all forgiven as long as the person believes that Jesus died for their sins. Where is the Justice in that? If Jesus died for our sins? Why is there still sin in the world?

It seems William Lane Craig is conflating justice and punishment ("A system of reward or punishment"). "Justice" is also defined as "Upholding what is fair, decent, and right; dispersing what is right." We can say the judicial system is unjust without contradiction.

Allah has 99 names..he is the merciful, the justice, the beneficent, the forgiveness...

So God is not allowed to be fair logical and balanced in his justice yet a God who sacrifices a human to pay for our sins somehow makes more sense?

If mercy is unjust what the point of "Judge" then. The contradict is to much William Craig, does this mean Every pastor seen those who work as Judge as unjust. Justice is require to show mercy, either way both require each other to function. If both were not present at the same time there will be unjust and mercy will be none. It would be different story if William Craig see justice is all about punishment(kill them and etc) without any forgiveness(after they compensate or repent for their wrong deed).

no judge on earth can agree with this!!! On judgement day no one will ask for god justice but they will beg for his mercy.....

worship almighty god a lone, with no partner .don't worship human being ( Jesus) son of Mary, what ever u do in this life ,u r responsible for it in this life and the next life ,so don't put u r sins or any criminal acts on another person (Jesus ) , ,,,look here Jesus ,has nothing to do with u r criminal record ,

Matthew 7:23 New International Version Then I will tell them plainly, 'I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!' those who cast out demon in the name of jesus.

Just belief in Jesus... U will be saved... Unbelievable

there is not such capital S in actual greek scriptures,nor does the old testament mention 3 equals 1,Christ says God is ONE,Christ is mentioned as the son of man 80 times more then than son of God,never does he say he is the actual son of God,son of God only means a righteous servant of God,God having a son is not and never will be pure monotheism

This guy can't say Quran or at least "Koran"? Every time he says it, it sounds like he's going to choke lol. He also don't make sense. Why does the son gotta die? If the father is the Boss and does not report to higher being why can't there be alternative? Also who is this sacrifice being made to? The devil? You got to use logic man.

Why does Craig pronounce Koran as KAGHAAN 03:00 :-)

for example go steal some thing ,when the police came to you tell them this sentence ( Jesus will take the charge) and see what going to happen to you ,so don't be foolish to put u r charges in innocent person

Original sin doctrine explains Christian God is Just, really? Doctrine of salvation also contradicts your twisting words? Based on this doctrine, you need to hurt yourself if someone wrongs you and seek forgiveness... What a joke? Jesus created his mom and then begets himself through his own creation, and then kills himself for the wrongs done against himself. Christians need to be reprogrammed because this shows they have lost the ability to think rationally,

William Craig is a bonafied trinitarian he wont budge from it

William Craig is trying hard to shove revenge withing his definition of the so-called justice. And, in doing so, he's struggling to attribute it to the Almighty Allah.

How situationally ironic is Mr. Williams’ unjust understanding of Quranic Justice. Even his tone is mocking and bitter towards Allah, while heightening Paul, rather than Jesus himself, on whom be peace. Sura The Bee: “Allah commands justice, the doing of good, and liberality to kith and kin, and he forbids all shameful deeds, and injustice and rebellion: He Instructs you, that you may receive admonition.” Alhumdullilah. Sura 16:90 “Whoever works righteousness, man or woman, and has Faith, verily, to him Allah gives a new Life, a life that is good and pure, and We will bestow on such their reward according to the best of their actions.” Sura 16:97 “Sura 17: “Make not your hard tied like a miser’s to your neck..your Lord provides sustenance…Do not kill your children for fear of want..We shall provide sustenance..nor come near to adultery: for it is a shameful deed and an evil, opening the road to other evils; Nor take life-which Allah has made SACRED-except for just cause…come not nigh to the orphan’s property except to IMPROVE it..Give FULL measure, and weigh with a balance that is straight..do not pursue that of which you have no knowledge…Nor walk on the earth with insolence: for you cannot rend the earth asunder, nor reach the mountains in height.” Sura the Israelites, 17:29-37. (Mindfulness teaching). Sura the Narration: (Those worshipers coming from previous Revelations? “Twice will they be given their reward, for they have persevered, and they avert Evil with Good, and they spend in Charity out of what we have given them.//And when they hear vain talk, they turn away therefrom and say: “To us our deeds, and to you, yours; Peace be on you.” (Sura 28:54). Islam, as Dr. Ally explains beautifully, does not prejudge or condemn other fellow religious people from possibly having salvation-other faiths automatically condemn Muslims and Islam: “There are among us some that are righteous, and some the contrary: we follow divergent paths.” Sura 72:11. Sura Balad: free slaves …and another Sura

"Parents punish their children" Sooo then why is child abuse illegal? If a child does nothing wrong and a parent is punishing them and beating them, then the parent(s) get arrested or at least in a lot of trouble because they had no reason to punish the child. So the most just God punished His innocent sinless son? Okay yeah, that makes so much sense -_-

If there is no forgiveness then there is no repentence but why jesus AS taught his disciples to repent.

What are so special by the death of jesus since the God can easily raise the death man.

I don't get the true purpose of these people try to reason, making excuses, and justifying their own intentional incorrectness.

3:00 This is literally what God have created us for. What else would you do if not fulfill your purpose of life? He believes that God created us simply because He can, and He sent us here as a punishment. Lol.

Matthew 15:26 It is not right to take the children's bread and toss it to the dogs. calling canaanite women is this a love.

Mercy is a quality loved by God. God is perfect; hence the mercy of God is also perfect. The natural instinct of man tends to be merciful. True bliss and harmony can only be achieved when the heart is filled with correct faith, a body that performs good deeds and a soul which overflows with love, kindness and mercy.........The mercy and love of God is far beyond the need that the blood of innocence, or the blood of Muhammed, Jesus or Abraham (peace be upon them) should be shed for the salvation of anyone. God loves to pardon and none can question him. A mother always judges her infant child to be innocent. God's mercy exceeds the mercy of a mother, God loves his creation. "We (Allah) have created mankind, and are aware of what he whispers to his inner self, and we (Allah) are more closer to him than his jugular vein" (Quraan sura qaaf verse 16)....................... In Hosea 6:6 we read: FOR IN LOVING KINDNESS I (GOD) HAVE TAKEN DELIGHT AND NOT IN SACRIFICE................... CHRISTIAN / BIBILICAL VIEW ON MERCY Exodus 33:19 And he said, I will make my goodness pass before thee and I will proclaim the name of the Lord before thee, and will be gracious to whom I will be gracious and will show mercy on whom I will show mercy. Psalms 51 :1 Have mercy upon me, O God , according to thy loving-kindness, according to the multitude of thy tender mercies blot out my transgressions....................................Chronicles 1 21:13 And David said unto Gad, I am in a great strait, let me now fall into the hand of the Lord - for very great are his mercies. Proverbs 3:3 Let not mercy and truth forsake thee : Bind them upon thy neck : write them upon the table of thine heart . Matthew 5:7 Blessed are the merciful: for they shall obtain mercy. Luke 6 :36 Be ye merciful, as your father also is merciful . ................................ James 5:15 and if he had committed sins, it will be forgiven. Deuteronomy 4:31 For Jehova your God is a merciful God. He will not desert you or bring you to ruin . Psalms 94:14 For Jehovah will not forsake his people...... Question - Was Jesus deserted and ruined on the Cross? According to present day Bible, Jesus is reported as saying "My God, My God why hast thou forsaken me?” (Matthew 27:46) ............................ DO YOU MEAN GOD CRY IN MATTHEW 27:46 ;) God does not demand sacrifice but mercy and supreme kindness. ....

As a student of programming, what I see Conditional Mercy of Allah as absolutely logical, just and applicable to all humans all times. Come to me, and I forgive, JUST come to me, to my prophet, a very simple bargain. God in Christanity says: I'll use You, Jesus, as a escape goat for a sacrifice to show my mercy, just and forgiveness ONLY to those who will accept 'such sacrifice' (may be sighted not to accept God in first place).

If you want justice for yourself, then you should think about all the people you have sinned against. They may want “justice” too. We want Mercy on the day of Reckoning. Mercy is ONE of the BIGGEST features of the Quran. Every Surah opens with it (except Surah 9). Even the Bible itself says “GOD WILL HAVE MERCY AND NOT A SACRIFICE, and the Knowledge of God...” (Bible). We Muslims will pray for God’s Mercy because APPARENTLY the Creator has INSCRIBED the rule of Mercy in the Bible and Quran.

This entire argument could have been resolved with defining the word "justice", because Dr. Craig seems to find that righteous judgment involves fulfilling a penalty to its full extent regardless of circumstance 💀

God is also a just God, who will pour out his wrath upon many.

We sacrafice lamb, cow etc and distribute meat to the poor. We present our good deed to God. But Jesus was sacraficed dan presented to who ? To Himself ? Then you heard they say " God is His own Son" which will spin your brain even faster

Your argument is false by its own root. God sacrificing himself would make Him a mortal; absolutism and eternality would then fail miserably and it won't require a discussion of either Islam or Christianity afterwards.

I am astounded to hear advocates speak of the nature of God (all praise to Him) in absolutes and then complain that God does not meet Their criteria for Justice. IIRC we Humans are unable to know the totality of action and consequence. So where does this person find the arrogance to question the Will of God?

The biggest gap in Christian theosophy is the self-induced concept of "ever loving God, a God who ONLY loves humans and forgives". Notice there's no room for discussion in this on accountability of actions, submission to a rule of law. Whereas, plenty room for nihilism, error, mistake and injustice, all in the name of "forgiven no matter what by the loving ONLY God". That's exactly what has tainted many in previous centuries who conducted atrocities in the name of "penance".

How can he say it with a straight face? How can you say an innocent man died for the sins of humanity? And then say that that's Justice? That human beings throughout time can commit sin after sin after sin? And believe Jesus died for them and they're saved nunsense!

you cant compare the mercy and judgment of god to that of a human he created us he knows us a blunder wont damn us if we repent from our hearts and ask for forgiveness realizing our own mistakes thats what our god is we say it so many times when worshiping him daily

Cristians put a limitation on god .God forgive for himself God knows people's intentions

His first example doesn't show how the Islamic view of justice and mercy are compatible, he uses an example where the person hasn't done wrong and needs no mercy.

William said Hebrews was written by a Jewish Christian🤔🤔🤔 A (Jewish) (Christian) how does that work? Paul wrote Hebrews, Paul also wrote Romans, Timothy, Corinthians and many others.. Romans 2:16 "In the day when God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ ACCORDING TO MY GOSPEL!" 2 Timothy 2:8 "Remember that Jesus Christ is the seed of David, & he was raised from the dead ACCORDING TO MY GOSPEL!" 2 Corinthians 12:16 "But be that as it may, I did not burden you myself; nevertheless, THE DEVIOUS PERSON THAT I AM, I TOOK YOU IN BY DECEPTION!"

According to the self-registered Christian accounts, Christ was historically dragged to the site of crucifixion all while abused. There was no willingness on his part, not that he had a choice against Pontifus Pilot anyways. This argument doesn't hold true in spirituality either, since supposedly Christ was physically mutilated.

Murderers rapists belief in Jesus u will b forgiven n u will be saved.... Is That justice to all the victims?.... 🤷‍♂️

My ears bleed every time WLC says Qur'an.

The God of Christianity has no authority also. The difference is his character is absolutely righteous thereby unwilling to let any sin go unpunished.

Hebrews 3:3-4 For Jesus has been counted worthy of more glory than Moses-as much more glory as the builder of a house has more honor than the house itself. (For every house is built by someone, but the builder of all things is God.)

None of them could have been a Son with a capital S, the Son is not a created being like we are but one of the three persons who make up the One True God. Isaiah 53:5-6 But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned-every one-to his own way; and the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all.

the explanation of Dr Craig is crystal clear. it is the reader of the bible that can make it more understandable while quran says violence is one of their teachings which make it more diffudult for them to be saved.

Ally is a great speaker. Still funny to have to spaghetti monster adoring 'scholars' argue forgiveness, absolute justice, and so forth :)

Why does he say kagan instead of Quran

William craig is uot of his mind is it just to kill your son just to forgive other? Very funny

@abdirahman ali Stop believing a man as your saviour and accept The only lord Allah,Father so accept him as your lord and saviour so you can be saved. Was killing the sun even for love and what in the world system can we kill the Innocent and lets go the GUILT.

Could you elaborate upon your last sentence?

In both Bible and Quran, there's clear and repeated mention of at least three other profits who were held highly esteemed by God on earth: Ibrahim, Moses, and Jacob. And, yet, none had been chosen to be the "son". All three messengers were assigned a much bigger mission, for which they lived a plenty challenged life. Christ on the other hand had a very short duration on earth, didn't endure nearly as much a life full of challenges as much as his predecessors. All could have been "sons".

Question Who is Jesus ? God Who die on the cross ? Jesus Who kill Jesus ? God So God kill himself ? ⁉️ What a beautiful believe ?

Jesus had to die on the cross. He lead by example. No matter how much someone wrongs you , we are asked to forgive our offenders. I believe this is why God gave this mission to Jesus. You will die a terrible death, but you must forgive them. This is TRUE love. That is why Jesus is the Son of God. He showed us how we should Love our neighbor, do good to those who hurt you. Be a servant to all, not a Master . For those who want to be first must be the least amount us. Jesus lead by example. Otherwise , a victim could always say, " how can I forgive that horrible thing he did to me. ?" Look at what they did to Jesus.

According to Craig and other Christian God is child abuser?? What s blasphemy! God is the creator of all sons and daughters and it doesn’t befits his majesty to have a son. Christian has been lying about son of Mary Jesus for two thousand years and has invented many about him which he did not say while on earth. Son of Mary Jesus is just a prophet, servant and creature of God nothing more.

Hypocrite Christian: God of Islam can not be just because he forgives without payment. But our God just kills himself like a lunetic and we call that payment and love. Muslim: Thanks. But keep your idea of Lunetic God to yourself. We don't believe in such a lunetic God. Such a lunetic can never be a God that created heaven and earth.

Matthew 26:51-54 And behold, one of those who were with Jesus stretched out his hand and drew his sword and struck the servant of the high priest and cut off his ear. Then Jesus said to him, “Put your sword back into its place. For all who take the sword will perish by the sword. Do you think that I cannot appeal to my Father, and he will at once send me more than twelve legions of angels? But how then should the Scriptures be fulfilled, that it must be so?”

Allah is the most Just because he use Justice between his creation on the day of judgement. exemple if somebody stole something from you or he harmed you or maybe killed you ... Allah on that day he will use justice between you 2 . so the victime take his full rights from the oppressor and the oppressor get his punishment justly. in the day of Judgement even the unbelievers will take their rights from the believers even they will go to Hell but they will not enter Hell until Allah Judge between them. THIS IS JUSTICE. in Quran says about the Disbelievers when they see Allah Justice they will say i hope i was just Dust. this is why THE MOST JUST is one of his names. another exemple even tho Allah know everything the disbelievers did, he will not just throw them in Hell without giving them their books and order them to read their Bad Deeds and ask them. why you do this and this and that ?! and he will call the witnesses also who wrote their Books ( the 2 Angels or recorded all his work ) since Allah know everything without the need of the books and the Angels who recorde the Deeds. he can just throw you directly to Hell and tell you shut up i know everything and you don't need to argue with me. but since he's the most Juste he will show you why he will punish you and he will bring the witnesses to testify against you if you deny your horrific deeds. but when it come to sins between you and Allah in that case he use Mercy. and Prophet Muhammad PBUH said no one will go to paradise with his good deeds he said even me a prophet of Allah i'll go to Paradise only by Allah's Mercy. the Good deeds they just give you the key of his Mercy Subhanahu Wa Taala. we all know the story of the righteous man who wanted to go enter Paradise with his Deeds because he had mountains of Good deeds. and Allah said to him fair enough then i'll use Justice and Allah put only his eyes sights on the balance and he lost all his Good deeds for his eyes sights that Allah gaves him. we can't thank Allah enough for the blessings he gave us even if we spend all our life prostrating. this is why we Muslims are so scared to lose his Mercy because only with his Mercy we will go to Paradise.

This william again and again claim his delusion as "according the qur'an".....LOL...wonders whether that qur'an is the one he revealed in a dream...???

In Judaism and Christianity, the following five claims are made: (1) He who is eternally un-created is God. (2) The eternally un-created is the “Father” of all creations. (3) The Father of all creations did not create Himself. (4) The Father of all creations did not create His Word. (5) The Father of all creations did not create His Spirit. * Therefore; there are three who are eternally un-created: (1) God, (2) Word of God, and (3) Spirit of God. But God is different from His Word; and God is also different from His Spirit. In order to maintain and to remain true to the formula of monotheism, Judaism and Christianity also hold true to the following claim: “The three who are eternally un-created (God, His Word, and His Spirit) are also eternally joined together as one and the same God.” This claim is known in Christianity as the “Trinity” - The Blessed Three-in-One: (1) The Father, (2) The Word of the Father, and (3) The Spirit of the Father. * Islam sees it differently. Islam accuses Judaism and Christianity of “Shirk” - the un-forgivable sin of joining partners such as the joining of “God’s Word” to God, and the joining of “God’s Spirit” to God. Thus, Islam introduced the “Tawhid” - the “Oneness of Allah” which eternally separates partnerships from Allah - partnerships such as the joining of Allah to his words, and the joining of Allah to his spirit. * Both the Bible and the Quran speak about Baal - the three-foot stone god (idol) of the Canaanites. Baal had words which his worshippers obeyed. Baal’s words demanded infant sacrifices. But Baal could not speak his own words; because Baal’s words are eternally separated from Baal. So, too, are the powers of Baal. Baal could not exercise his powers, because they (Baal’s powers) are eternally separated from Baal. * There are many similarities between Allah and Baal. Both Allah and Baal are each “one and only” in the sense that there are no other gods known to mankind or in existence who bear the name “Allah” or “Baal”; and neither one of them (Allah or Baal) “begets”, nor is “begotten” - because a stone (or a moon) which is lifeless and un-spirited cannot beget, nor can be begotten. Not only are both Allah and Baal’s words and spirits eternally separated from them, but there are no miracles (signs and wonders) recorded in their names. When challenged by the Hebrew Prophet, Elijah, at Mount Carmel, Baal could not perform miracles for his 400 prophets. [See Bible: 1st Kings 18:20-40.] Allah did not accompany (escort) his prophet, Muhammed, with miracles. Interestingly, when a god is eternally separated from his words and from his powers, he is both dumb (speechless) and impotent (powerless) even though his worshippers may (or may not) attribute to him words and powers. * By accusing Jews and Christians of “Shirk” - the joining of God to His Word and God to His Spirit as one and the same God, Muslims have risen up Baal, the speechless and powerless stone idol of the Canaanites, from extinction and have given him a new name - the name “Allah”.

The Father was the one who sent the Son that is how we can love him just the same. The Father and the Son have the same characteristics and nature and are both worthy of complete love.

@MrNatty513 Man logic some one goes to lose.

The Lord Jesus Christ wasn't forced to be sacrificed against his own will, he willingly submitted to the will of the Father.

"justice yet a God who sacrifices a human" God sacrificed himself....learn christianity FIRST then make a comment...the ignorance is overwhelming...disagree with what was done, but pete sakes, dont be ignorant....wow.

pwnd