If someone tries to tell me this roster is WORSE than the Patriots, Panthers, Broncos, or Raiders, I immediately disregard their football knowledge

I haven't bought into all the talk that this roster is that bad. On defense I think they've got 2 holes. DT2 and CB2. I'd like to see Hawkins at CB2 because he has the size and athleticism to be a very good corner. I think we've got several DBs that can man the slot and do a good job of it. The question is who can step up and fill in next to Dex. There's some possibilities. On offense it's all about the O-line. I think overall if this team stays healthy and gets a little good luck coming their way they can make the playoffs. I saw a clip of Ndomkan Suh saying the Giants will win 10 games.

Great show, all questions will be answered by trade deadline

Something has to give...If the "expert" analysts are correct and we suck then S&D are on the hot seat. If the "experts" are wrong then this should be a fun season. IT ALL DEPENDS ON IMPROVEMENT FROM THE OLINE!!!!!!! A decent oline and Daboll calling plays might surprise us!

I think we finish somewhere between 7-10 and 10-7. Possible Wild Card berth.

I still stand on my prediction we start 2-0 and possibly go 4-3 first 7 games! We end up 9-8 at worst! As long as healthy.

Valentine said it right off the bat. This is a young, unproven roster. Count how many times he said “If _____ works out, that position group should be fine.” Spoiler, he said it a lot. So it potentially could be the worst roster. It also could be much better. But there are not a lot of reliable established above average players on this team currently. So we’ll see, but now we have to take the arrows bc our counter argument is pretty weak

Ed, did you cancel audio / podcast version of this? for weeks i have no new episode of Big Blue View in my podcast app, only here on youtube. What happend?

Every analyst judges the Giamts based on 2023 results. That team was not ready for the start of the season and lost a key player after first series. Season was over after that.... These Giants are substantially better than the 2022 team. Young, unproven but talented. These coaches claim to be teachers..... If the Giants can fix OL.....these Giants can surprise.

Is Giants' QB that bad?

Teams will have to play us differently because they will have some weapons, I think Nayqaun made us one dimensional and easy to defend dabs wants to pass we have some weapons ee could go 9-8 10-7 we signed better oline players who don't get hurt availability is the best ability, DJ like other great giant QBs will show why he was picked to follow Eli, same characteristics Eli and Simms were called busts until they won in the playoffs! It happens this yr the defense will be top 10 the pieces we have are solid and above average, youth will flourish

I think it's a reasonable assessment. If not the worst then at least bottom 5. No QB, only 1 legit O-line player, no depth anywhere, no secondary etc etc. 3-5 wins this year imho

Most unproven. OK. Worst in the NFL. Totally disagree

Your whole video was spend saying we hope this or that peraon at said position is better than what they have actually shown themselves to be. THIS is why we actually have a bad team. Other teams have proven good players at those positions.

Yes, yes, giants suck. Terrible talent, terrible, just terrible! We need all the disrespect we can get. Let them do all the talkin so our players can assemble optimus prime like and do the walkin.

This team stinks