I know that most people don't believe Shirley's case anymore. But, one aspect is still unexplained to me. It is a rule in the artistic world that it is considered theft if you put your name on someone elses canvas or art work. When Shirley died, the bank which held her mortgage hired a cleaning company to prepare the house for market. A small door was found hidden behind a cabinet which lead to a small storage room. This room held all of Shirley's canvases. They were all group by signature. They were sent to a university for appraisal. The university wanted to contact the "different" artists as they were all very good. As it turned out, the university testified that each group was unique onto itself. The university also testified that uniqueness in technique comes from the brain. Yet all of the pieces were from Shirley in different stages of personality. In other words, it was not possible for Shirley to imitate someone elses brush strokes since that comes from the brain directing the hand in how it moves on the canvas. The university said it was not possible for the same person to have created the diffferent pieces. Shirley had done so in different personalities.

The doctors questions are very leading

I was treated for DID. While I questioned the whole time- and still do - the veracity of the diagnosis, there is no doubt that talking about my issues as though I was different people helped me find a strange place of safety from which to confess some traumatic events that had actually happened to me or behaviors of which I was now fearful of admitting. Eventually I was able to “integrate” Or become at peace with these different pieces of me and found deep healing that had previously eluded me.

The human mind is capable of things we can't even begin to understand.

She did what! She cash in on her story !! How is that ethical. How a doctor do that to her patient. What the hell!!

And now every other person on TikTok pretends to have it

The interview with Eve and her other personalities, its super interesting. The entire interview in on KZfaq.

Ive been diagnosed with DID since 1986. In my case it's real. I have been doing EMDR and realized I was a child survivor of child pornography. Today our system lives a peaceful life in the south, enjoying our grandkids ❤❤❤

I read an autobiography about a woman who innocently went in a psychiatric ward to be misdiagnosed & suffered years of inappropriate medications & false memory recall which were planted through a psychiatrist. She slowly got well via stopping medication & avoiding the pursuing psychopathic doctor & returned to a healthy weight through exercise after suffering obesity also. I think that was bipolar her false diagnosis. Apologies I cannot remember book title. Several autobiographies I’ve read aren’t available in shops. I returned them to the owners. This one was a library book.

5:50 Women used to dress in shiny ball gowns just to appear on a tv talk show? I don't remember that.🤔🎭

And yet some people have no personality!

It's now called dissociative identity disorder and is a spectrum disorder, not usually manifesting in separate "selves" or alters. Back in the '90s I remember everyone claiming they were "multiples", and tons of magazine articles came out about "MPD" and how it was related to early trauma. When I saw a trauma psychologist in the '90s, I said, "You must see a flood of people with multiple personalities", and she said, "I've never seen one." Her belief was that early trauma can compromise boundaries to the point of not being able to develop a cohesive "self". But imagination can rush in to fill the gaps, and the culture was then actually encouraging people to "tell their stories" about being "multiples" (Roseanne Arnold claimed to be one after her then-husband Tom Arnold told her that HE was one). I had one friend ask me, "So, have you named them?" "Named what?" I asked. She knew I was seeing this trauma therapist, and I guess just "assumed".

10:09 bingo! That’s the problem! There’s a difference when we’re playing in front of other people by changing our behavior to fit in the environment and when you’re not playing, when you’re not playing then you’re sick, it’s in them.

We have been diagnosed with the dissociative identity disorder. It's a real disorder and diagnosis takes years before you get an official one. DID is very hard to live with. People only think about the alters with DID and it's more than that its trying to heal from the abuse and dealing with the PTSD and memory loss that happens because you disassociate so much. When it comes to alters yes each of them are their own personhood in our system. They have different opinions and lifestyles than the others. Each alter has a role to play in the system. Our alters front freely during our weekly therapy sessions. Our alters know our therapist well.

he should not be be urging or saying sweetie a lil much sweetie could be a trigger word

One of my cousins went through some type of hypnotism therapy to access repressed memories several years ago. While, it had nothing to do with DID, she did end up“remembering “ a lot of terrible, sick, Traumatic events. Many of these memories involved my mom and my aunt (two people who would do anything to protect a child from abuse, Who simply aren’t capable of allowing something like that to happen to her.). My other cousin - the older sister of the one with the supposed repressed memories - even denied that these things had happened. It was very hard on the whole family, but especially hard on my aunt and my mom. Do you have your own daughter/niece accuse you of being a part of such horrible abusive behavior, would be so heartbreaking. She tried to talk to me and my sister about it a few times, and it was so uncomfortable. She truly believed that these things had happened to her. She still does believe that they happened, to this day - although she has forgiven my mom and aunt for what she claims happened, and they have made progress in getting their relationship back to semi normal. But, it’s hard to get back to normal with a relationship in which someone truly believes that you allowed terrible things to happen to them, especially when you didn’t. Unfortunately, there are many people out there who claim to be able to do these kinds of therapies. They may even believe that they are doing some thing helpful and that they really are unlocking repressed memories. But it can be very dangerous and it could potentially make the person’s problems in life far worse than they already are. Another point of interest, is that my cousin’s memories were very similar to a few of the biggest news stories that were happening around that same time - or shortly before. So that made me very skeptical as well. Who knows how someone’s brain might work in piecing together information. A lot goes on in our subconscious mind. It’s dangerous to mess with this kind of stuff unless you know 100% what you are doing.

I read the book back then…I was 26 or so. It was horrifying to learn what had been done to her.😢

Mass hysteria follows the publication of a scam book. Great for attracting attention to the patient and for health professionals making money.

Coming back to watch this after the TikTok DID trend….. I hate that real people who suffer from this are now having to defend themselves all over the place.

It was the first US Sybil War.

I’m not a doctor but I believe people who have had very traumatic events happen to them as children have many different ways of handling it. Maybe personalities are a way they protect themselves or they are associating how they felt at the time of trauma. That’s my speculation. Idk.

It's caused by Trauma. Also, I'd say Psycho was the first time it was depicted in a story.

but back then everybody called women "hysterics". so i dont think it wasnt valid to call the doctor a hysteric.

There are people who possess traumatic memories that they are simply unable to handle. What better way to have to possess trauma that is just unmanageable for 'you' than delegating it or them to a person or personality better able to temporarily hold on to it for you. People also possess some characteristics which are simply better suited to some alternate version of themselves. That's not necessarily pathological.

It’s called dissociative identity disorder

I had a friend who was diagnosed with this. Destroyed her family with what turned out to be false memories. For a space of time it was a fad. A common diagnostic method for a time, rarely hear about it nowadays.

Can be many souls sharing a body from spiritual POV

Many so called professionals are doing their best to convince everyone that “repressed memories “ aren’t real. And many of those have a very good reason to do so, some allegedly have been abusers themselves, or know others that are. Childhood trauma does causes memories to be forgotten, until the child is an adult and the mind can deal a bit better with the severe trauma the young mind couldn’t. It’s TRUE and there are allot of coverups being done to convince the masses it isn’t! Because someone has a PHD in their name… doesn’t mean they aren’t liars!

WOW. It was a totally different facial expression and mannerisms when he asked to speak to Eve Black.

I'm slowly to identify myself..I might fall in this category. The next minute I totally happy but the next day I just wanna die..

Living with did now..I have 2 personality. Just had a disagreement with my family. Now im isolated in my spot in the garage watching this...35yrs now and still having trouble knowing my triggers and switching..13 months receiving treatment..Lord help me.

The doctors garment tape is showing on her chest where her dress comes away. The doctor that said they’ve been looked at for hoaxes. She didn’t notice that?

I have schizophrenia and my voice is a fully formed personality. So it is possible to have other personalities in your head

I knew someone with DID who did psychedelics. They let you truly unravel and re-experience your unconscious. She was able to remember things from her infancy and early childhood. DID is real.

Didn't learn a thing It's a definite maybe.

Shirley wrote to Flora Schreiber after the movie was released. Shirley stated she needed to "go public, show my real name and face identity". That never happened, wonder why?

Full split is uncommon, but dissociation from severe abuse is not uncommon at all. How would we survive the horror without dissociation?

SulphuVanished from Traditional Markets ok

Who r watching after aparichithudu movie

3:26

Brains are like computers! It has RAM! I believe only geniuses understands this further!

Us at kid called her Fruit cake Alice.

I used to work as a Psychiatric Aide. Every now and then, we'd get someone claiming to have this. Hilarity always ensued. What a load of crap. So no. It doesn't exist.

Kind of reminds me of the trans fad we're going through now.

Demon possession.

Zakhm J9 theekbNa Ho Dart Recommend Open. Genuine people take proper care to c that it generates till Dry Layer Ed Skin is Formed ok

I don't know, but it seems pretty real to all of us.

Zakhm Simon KS Badly Chalaney Says HainHum Hindustani.

Strictness Bet Ho Us Beta Don't Bhagwan Lee DennIss Dhartimaa Parr.

I forever worried for my health , aware of this condition. But now we are fine.

It's a real menthal illnis.

Multiple personality disorder does not exist in modern day psychology.

What happened to the horrible mother??

For goodness sake…she probably had a personality disorder. Maybe she did have DID. To let your client read the only book on DID, then to years later begin treating that same client again, then to quietly ignore the fact that not just a therapist but the same therapist (you) suggested a book on DID to her then to deliberately turn the client into a cause celeb in order to sell a book of your own, then to make the client financially dependent on you while racking up a lifetime of debt in unpaid fees, to make the success of the book the escape from paying back those fees, then to continue to profit off the story Dr. Wilbur should have been arrested for this. But to pretend that this is where DID comes from and to use it as a straw man to knock down…many many plausible DID cases, dating from way before and after “Sybil” to pretend that DID is all that strange compared to other phenomena like traumatic (dissociative) amnesia and serious delusions, to equate it always to lying and factitious disorder, that is incredibly stupid. If you have an experience of another specific identity with a separate volition repeatedly taking over your actions, whether you are fully unaware or fully conscience of it or something in between, then it’s basically the core elements of DID P-DID, or OSDD. That dies not mean that these identities have more reality than you experiencing them. It does not mean they necessarily come out every other day or have as complex a “personality” as you do (though that is a possibility).

hello! i have DID (formerly called MPD) and it's definitely real. there are entire communities of DID systems who can vouch for it. we talk different when we switch, dress different, hold ourselves differently. of course there can be misdiagnosed patients, though.

Suuuuure 👌

"Why did I leave Congress?" - repentance

Do I believe Dissociative Identity Disorder exists, yes I do. Do I believe that Shirley Mason had DID, no I don’t.

I don't like the fact that it's trying to make it seem like this is not a real thing. Yes. Some doctor's may have chosen to be unethical, and influenced their patients to lie or what have you. But this don't mean that it's not a real thing that some people suffer with. Also when you have dysfunctional family members, they can and will convince you that something didn't happen, or you lied, or exaggerated. When it really did happen, and you just ended up suppressing those memories or what have you. That's why SO many people tend to have some sort of mental illness or personality disorder in the first place.

Anyone who can 'call upon', 'invite to join', or 'bring out' multiple personalities at will isn't a person with MPD, it's someone with good acting chops and desire for attention.

What's really happening is there's demons inside the person and they need deliverance in the name of Jesus Christ!!! 🌈☝️✝️☝️🌈

Expliotive Doctors and capable ,suppressed actresses!!!Why no male MPD's !!?? shown,

Someone who has multiple personalities is unaware of them, and each is unaware of the other

Funny how they were pushing people to have multiple personalities, now they're pushing for gender dysphoria. All comes to money in the end..

Bs attention-seekers.

that's not right. you aren't them. i have DID i know what it is like. :l I am NOT THEM.

My therapist said up to about 18 percent of ppl have it and aren't aware so it is not 1 percent. :/

A real load of bs!

How can one person have less than one personality without a lobotomy.

Sounds like two women,sufferer and 'expert',who just wanted attention. I find it highly unethical. (EDIT* Now I understand my parents when they said,(during my childhood),that Americans are obsessed with mental illnesses/diagnosis', understand,it's no criticism towards America or Americans in general).

demon posssession

DID is a misnomer. MPD makes so much more sense. They are all real They are individuals with different life experiences There is no one they can trust, because if there was ever trust, it was broken They all share a Body, but the Body everyone else sees is only one Body, one person, not many.

for me all those multiple personalities sound as possessed by multiple entities....

Acting maybe?

i have yet to meet a woman with only one personality- it's more common than reported

300 personalities is bs

If DID is so rare, then how do a third of the comments claim to have a diagnosis?

Some would suppose it might be demonic possession. Either way there are some Sicknesses that only the Lord Jesus can Heal!

Just another woman

I find this video terribly annoying. It is not *remarkable* for a trauma survivor to split into various ego states and, for someone who tends to be naturally creative, naming those ego states would not be surprising. This video is extremely biased.

I believe they are demons possessing them.

@11:48 " it's important to understand which "stories" are true and ..and are false" . NO Sh!t Sherlock. Yet nevertheless, you wrote "Sybil Exposed"- basically a compilation of suppositions based on random cases which MAY OR MAY NOT BE REALATED PHYSIOLOGICALLY NOR PSYCHOLOGICALLY to Sybil's case; knowing zero intricate details. What a tool.