The data you provided is excellent, but I have some comments regarding how you calculated the difference percentage. Your stamina regen is the amount of stamina you regenerate over time, so using the data from 4:20 as an example you get 108/181=0.597 stamina per frame without stalwart, and 108/151=0.715 stamina per frame with stalwart. Comparing these two values, the increase provided by stalwart is actually very close to 20%. Using the same method on the nothing vs nimble+stalwart comparison at 5:20, the stamina regen goes from 0.597 to 0.777 which, again, is very close to the expected 30%.

i think you calculated it wrong to conclude if stalwart works or not. nimble and stalwart accelerates the regeneration by 30% but it doesn´t mean that the total time saved is 30% percent. the ratio of 100% speed(no buffs) and 130% speed is 76.9230769%. ( difference 23%~) which matches your observations. In other words: with no stalwart and no nimble you would reach 77 stamina while with stalwart and with nimble you would be full by that time. if we calculate it back the solution would be 77 stamina * 1,3 = 100 stamina to get my point across here is an extreme example: if there was a bufffood which increased your stamina regeneration by 100% you would cut the amount of frames by 50%. 100% speed through 200% is 50%. 50 stamina * 2.0 = 100 stamina Still great video. thanks for your work. for me personally i will keep using nimble

Thank you for the mention. Super interesting revisting this topic again. Some great content right here 👌

I’ve been wondering about this perk since cores video. Thank you for putting this video out!

Awesome information! For your next Video. Huge QoL would be having some usable filter to sort your items by perks and applying filters by pressing perks when selling items.

based on muscle memory between playing with nimble on my main and not on my alt, I can 100% tell the difference, and for me it's totally worth it even as a light bow player since I dodge between almost every shot for empower

There's been situations that the extra se one or 2 from having nimble has saved me from PvP. It's barely noticeable but using it as an assassin I think is necessary, especially if you don't use hearty.

I'd like to see nimble get a small buff, but then again I already use it, so I'm biased. The effect is very small, but none of the other competing options really grab me as hugely impactful either. Refreshing Toast + either Purifying or Healthy toast are the big ones. The third perk options beyond that all feel fairly minor.

Love these nerdy number crunching vids 😄

Love your videos. As a 4k hour player, i still dont know how crit and keen work especially with a dex spec. Can you do a new video? :) add that to the ongoing vicious vs enchanted debate and dex is a mystery.

Thought u might add Sturdy Energy aswell and see how big the difference is witht hat perk

Good video 👍

These perks need a look because there needs to be some trade off between hearty and nimble.

I’d like to see one on vigor and invigorated. I think invigorated might be good for gs if you take the passives and have the perk on your weapon but in small scale like arenas. Not sure about opr and wars

To sum it up short, nimble is still awesome! I played with it 70% of my 3000+ hours in New World. And its a big difference. Good video

Can you test sturdy energy next? None vs 1 perk vs 2perk.

Didn't knew that the difference was under a second, but as a PvE tank, I could see the difference with, and without nimble.

I hope you make this available to New World devs.

For angry earth dps...on a hatchet...rogue or flame attunement?

I assume all clips was recorded with stable 60fps?

I'm often at 1 or 2 stamina after a dodge, which is keeping me out of being exhausted and so save my life. Without nimble that would not be the case. But yes, for a lot of other builds it may not be worth it.

I tested both nimble and focused and focused having the highest percentage increase still worked the same as nimble both were disappointing. Even with sacred's 50% increase to mana Regen coming close to a 100% Regen didn't make much difference. Running a different perk like refreshing or evading refreshing would be better. And for the earring regeneration for range and refreshing still better options.

What greatsword are you using?

Has anyone tested nimble +stalwart+ cranberry compote (20%) - must be crazy for arenas

Is the % based on 100 Stam or 110. Seems like most things are rated off of the base value. Maybe that's why the numbers were off? Also, I think regen is way stronger if you are playing off point etc.

Nice video even if nimble got 10% it just not worth.

NIMBLE IS GOD TEIR LOVE IT ITS BIS IF YOU LIGHT ROLL bruiser

Nimble + stalwart + strong conditioning (spear perk) = ???

I personally only use Nimble as Tank (cuz blocking/defiance). Besides that single class, Nimble is an extremely niche perk thats not valuable enough compared to the other options. Refreshing is simply better for all the Dex & Focus builds, Regenerating (or Purify Toast) helps massively for Str Bruisers against all the dot damage, Mana Toast (or Refreshing) is just an obvious pick for Mages (even if you dont need the mana its a 10% HP Pot on a ~15 secs CD), and Beloved is the best PvE Earring perk you can literally get in the game.

sounds like stalwart most important nimble is ehh

Tested this 1 year ago, nimble is shit in pve but try vs WH exhaust in pvp

I miss the tanks perspective.

So alone not that great but together v nice got it lol

Is he using Leeching on GS?