Jonathan Shreve It's treason, then.

This is where the fun begins

Take a seat, young Shreve

Shreve Palpatine

How can you be one of the best Star Wars movies and not get a score of 5?!

"Good with objective flaws" is how I feel about all of the films except for ANH and ESB.

@@IndyDefense me too, except for the sequels, the flaws overshadow everything else for me in these new movies

R.I.P. Morad Sumar

That's how I feel about The Last Jedi.

Same my all time fav Star Wars film.

It will be done my lord

@@AndreNitroX *Orders 66 Pizzas*

@@PorktatoesSSRB this partys over

RoTS: doesn’t get 5 starts Me: It’s treason then.

julianzolo Palpatine wanted to make Darth Vader weak enough that if he tried to overthrow him, he would be able to stop him because of the suit. He was tortured by Palpatine and the Jedi order didn’t trust him. I think it was a great movie that bridged the PT with the OT

Especially if you watched the clone wars before it, everything is amplified

Nik D'Agostino yea Whitney Anakin iS tHe BEsT!!?:$38-.7!4'wmwkiwjwnwnfhydj

Did you watch a different movie?

Dafuq you talking about? What story? What structure? You're pulling my leg right? Right?

Montross Bruh, your probably 56 if all you like is the original trilogy. To be fair, I’m impressed you made it all the way to KZfaq.

Hello there

@@AndreNitroX General Kenobi!!!!!!!

It's over Anakin! I have the high ground!

@@ionryful This partys over.

Dew it

2nd Airborne Productions If give this film an average of 3 stars and call that generous.

Violator It’s treason then.

When revenge of the sith doesn't get an average of 66 stars: *commander Cody... The time has come...*

Then you are lost!

Ganondorf Dragmire then you are clueless

Actually, I'd say the first 20 minutes of A New Hope is perfect. But Revenge Of The Sith is a damn close second

Return of the Jedi opens off pretty great too

@@2ndairborneguy790 a new hope is more iconic but I still think the opening battle and build up to it is so sensational

Absolutely! IMO, Palpatine is the star of the prequels.

@Salmon The opera scene is fucking legendary. The way he tells the story is just riveting.

LSG UNLIMITED P O O W E E E E R R R R R

@Kevin Huang no it s realistic that he is so strong in combat windu s vapid style helps

@Kevin Huang and Yoda is really hard opponent fast as fuck and hard to hit

I was in the theater for RoTJ on opening night and I loved rogue one.

Rogue one is the only good SW from Disney imo

Finally something interesting will happen.

I'm hoping for a Jar Jar vs Rose spinoff

Maybe Jar Jar is keeping guard on his tomb out of guilt.

CC Karaoke If Rey has to fight Darth Emperor Jar Jar, I will be rooting for him every single time I watch that movie.

@@jaharv111 Yeah, after Rose sabotages Fin and says "This is how we win... by saving what we love"; at that point a hooded figure should have walked onto the cliffs overlooking the battlefield, and said "No, THIS is how weesa win", and released a bunch of those blue plasma balls bouncing onto the field, destroying all the walkers.

John Piland the novelization makes the movie so much better.

@@mamunestor It truly does

My personal prequel favorite is The Phantom Menace (1999) Jar Jar really was the key to all that and his removal made Episode's 2 & 3 suffer for it. I can't believe George Lucas would chicken out like that.

Tarkin and the Darth Plagueis novel were bad ass as well.

Yeah the novelization gives so much more to the story overall.

I actually didn’t knew solo existed till the film theory episode

Crabs I might watch it, along with episode 9, on Netflix in a couple of years (if bored).

YES! I associate with many Star Wars fans and I can attest that a number of them did not even bother to see Solo.

I watched it on Netflix, I will not be doing a second viewing, I don't really remember much about it nor care for it, but I still place it above 7 and 8.

I know not this movie you mention, what is this soylo you speak of?

"Sissstahhhh...."

One of the last times I watched that scene I cried. A powerful scene, no doubt, and the music only adds to the emotion.

I can hear that music playing in my head right now.

@@EchthelionII I love it when a movie as that kind of impact.

I cried watching that scene myself a few times when i was young. Now i only cry when i sober up.

Agreed. Ep 1 had too much cartoony humor. Ep 2 had a dreadful 'love story.' Ep 3 was the 'purest' SW of all the prequels. Totally BA, as we like it.

Apart from most of the love story, I like Attack Of The Clones. TPM is my least favourite prequel but it's okay.

That might have been true before Lucas sold it, but now we OT loyalists are just relieved you don't think it's something from Disney.

Pretty much, lol. I adore the accomplishments of RotS, but my goodness, this film was so unevenly executed.

I'm an O.T. stan but I adore revenge of the sith

@Darth Cameron I... don't have one? The dialogue is the weakest part of any George Lucas Star Wars movie, even the good ones.

@Darth Cameron A lot of ROTS dialogue lines were so bad, they became the most powerful thing in this world. Memes. So a defense would be how the dialogue has aged. It's hard to emulate such a phenomenal fuck-up. Also, ROTS' high points were the highest in the franchise. When it nailed something, it nailed something. Especially the finale leading to Vader, where Yoda vs Sidious swapped with Obi Wan vs Anakin. The music also slapped.

@Patches O'Houlihan LOVE the handle...

Hey Patches, if you can dodge a wrench you can dodge a ball! Good name my friend.

To me, my favorite is also the best one.

Patches O'Houlihan empire is overrated and too constricting for me to enjoy as the best.It feels very robotic and contained. Sith packs an emotional punch

@@iloveyourgyatttt The OT had better writing, and actors, there were no "I don't like sand." lines, but anyway we all love Star Wars and you have a right to your opinions, so do I, we will agree to disagree my friend, best to you.

So bad. I wish you knew the joy of seeing the original, then the utter disappointment of all the prequels. Doesn’t matter bc TLJ killed Star Wars forever.

@@elijahtalbott8898 what do u mean? Im 41 years old, i saw all the movies in the theaters except star wars lol

@@elijahtalbott8898 TLJ was insanely good though... Oh wait, did i say GOOD? I meant FRIGGIN terrible, and an embarrassment to everything star wars that came before it... i honestly wish disney DID strike it from canon and did a remake like that petition was asking for... Or, that ep9 opens with a 30 second flash montage of ep8, then u see a close up of Luke as he opens his eyes, looks stunned, and goes "wow, that was some meditation session, i have to do everything in my power to make sure those events dont come to pass..." And then the next scene is Rey showing up with his lightsaber lol... the "it was all a dream" cop out is cheap, but in this instance, i think it might cause a nationwide standing ovation

@@elijahtalbott8898 aaayyyy screw the originals, the prequels were more fun

@@FPV-wi8fw i wouldn't go so far as to say SCREW THE ORIGINALS lol... but it depends on your taste. Im a big jedi, jedi vs sith, lightsaber fighting guy, so the prequels are huge for me, obviously, as well as TCW show(s). And that is kinda what really sucks for me with the sequel trilogy, besides the obvious "what sucks" stuff about them lol... That's why i love and really want the old republic trilogy or show so bad. That era is all about what i love about star wars

Jeff Jenkins God give me strength...

@@violator7964 Jesus Christ, grow up you fucking clown

Found another simpelton

I think revenge of the sith had cool idea’s that gave the film a lot of potential, but idea’s are only as good as the execution and in terms of the execution, I mean… Revenge of the sith is very poorly written, poorly directed film that is ridden with plot holes and contrivances that could’ve been easily avoided. Sure its the best of the prequel’s, but that in itself isn’t exactly that impressive

I think we're about to get that in season 7 of the clone wars.

It would be awesome.

Citlali Cervantes That is actually just going to be the Bad Batch and some other things Hopefully Season 8 is the remastered version as so many people say that TCW Anakin and ROTS Anakin do not feel the same so they could show they are the same via Season 8

Freddy Krueger There isn’t going to be a Season 8. 7 is the last. The show is going to end with the Siege of Mandalore which is where Rex and Ahsoka are during the events of Order 66. This will be Dave’s explanation as to why they aren’t in RoTS. The reason Anakin and Obi-Wan aren’t participating in the siege is due to Palpatine being captured.

I’m praying for that, even if it’s a quick montage or epilogue that would be great

You need to watch more films

End game had to be one of the most boring movies I've seen but its still better than starwars sequels

@@tylarjones9281 How can you know that he hasn't watched enough movies? I have seen plenty of movies and Rots is my favourite of all time.

@@t3jf not to be rude whats your idea of a “not boring” movie?

@@longinuscyclone213 star wars 1-6, Indiana Jones, matrix, iron man, goonies, alita battle angel,terminator 1-2.

Darth Xemnas It fucking fumbled the ball! The last 20 minutes of the movie are hilarious in how knee jerkingly paced they are in order to try and make everything ‘fit’ with what follows. It’s entirely and embarrassingly obvious too - even the visuals change in a scene just so we can go ‘oh, now everything looks like A New Hope’.

Force powers in Revenge? What powers? Anakin can't jump higher than 20ft except he can and Obi-Wan and Anakin fight with force push for 10 seconds. It makes little sense, looks nothing special. I think you ned to watch the movie. The spin Yoda does with the seats in the senate chambers are cool but that's it, unless you saw a different movie than I did.

What movie were you watching i don't give a shit about force powers and lightsaber fights well you do you

@@SporkyMcFly you just answered your question

@@darthdare4734 I didn't. He's giving the effects a 10/10 and I am baffled. When I was 12 it was cool, I'll have to admit, because I had no filter or quality control. An adult person praising the prequels because something was cool when they were 12 is perplexing. But hey, if mediocre computer effects and overly choreographed lightsaber duels make movies 10/10 for you then I'm glad you like it. I'll stick to story based narritives like the OT and sequels even if the sequels fail to encapsulate the Star Wars magic.

1. That's usually how this works. 2. What you say makes me weep for the younglings whose first SW movie was made by Disney.

Empire Strikes Back is mine, but no Star Wars movie can match the lightsaber duels in Revenge of the Sith.

Then you are lost!

I love democracy, I love the republic

You are correct. It might be a book line, I suppose.

Qatrebew The prequels are objectively horrible films. You don’t even need to care about SW to reach that judgment. You just need to understand what makes a good film.

@@violator7964 give some examples with words then. Objective is a ludicrous term to use when talking about how YOU feel when watching a MOVIE You've been watching too many pseudo-intellectual frauds like RLM if you honestly think a work of art can be quantified.

@worldd777 The movie(s) made total sense. RLM try to 'break' the movies' logic, but all they really do is turn off their brains and don't actually analyse or READ the movies. Nitpicking, making up idiotic arguments ("qui gon jinn is a bad character, we can't remember what he's like!") just show they are not interested in trying, they're being dishonest and they have an agenda. You can view the prequels as a tragedy in a shakespearean way, as a conspiracy movie, as a critique/allegory on modern society or as a critique on the world of star wars itself.

@worldd777 Ok. First we can start with delving deeper with you explaining what "bad" dialogue means? This is the problem with RLM reviews. They say dialogue is bad, when they really mean dialogue is not snappy or "hip". They want the movie to sound more like jurassic park, or a marvel movie. In reality, George Lucas just created dialogue that doesn't sound naturalistic, but rather evokes an earlier time of cinema and theatre. It's, like everything else, to serve a point. RLM are projecting their own ideas of what everything SHOULD be on the movie, ignoring the TEXT (the actual substance). They are wrong about the role of the jedi, narratively, of anakin, of obi-wan and of palpatine. They think Anakin is too "awkward" and "stiff" when that makes perfect sense for his character, and is part of what makes that young slave-turned-jedi character work. They think the jedi are too "stupid" when in fact the jedi play the role of an idealistic but decadent and corrupted institution that doesn't understand its already influenced by the dark side.

@worldd777 you completely missed the Point regarding midichlorians. It's true that the jedi are using midichlorians to determine who is worthy or not, but we should not take that as a true representation on how the force really works. Rather, it should illustrate just what state the jedi are in, during the prequels. They are literally blind, they use technology (remember the Death star trench run??) instead of using their spirit. Anakin is chosen based on a mathematical number, further increasing his alienation and pride. Anakin had already been stewing and brooding under jedi leadership for his entire adult Life, but was still very loyal, and turned palpatine in. He received only suspicion. Add to the fact that HE can see very vivid force visions, which made him CERTAIN that padme was about to die. Going with palpatine was his only choice, after helping kill windu, he would use his efficient killing ability against the jedi instead. For Love. It makes total sense, him being capable of mass murder since Episode 2 has been established, and his animosity towards the jedi, and his complex towards padme (mommy issues!). It was a done deal, all palpatine had to do was give him a push. Remember Anakin was already a fascist in episode 2, and had his doubts about the whole system of government, he was a slave when the jedi ruled the republic, and Everything that transpired can, in his mind, be traced to the fact that the jedi are weak, and do weak, cowardly decisions.

I'm really, really curious to see what score Empire gets in a few weeks here...

@@thorskywalker Empire is gonna get the highest rate... i predict a 60~% 5 star rating...

@@thorskywalker but u and i are cut from the same cloth and Jedi will always be our favorites. We feel almost exactly the same way about that movie and the great parts that make it our favorite. And i think if he had gone thru with Kashyyk(spelling?) and wookies instead of Endor and Ewoks, it would be the consensus best movie of the bunch. But i overlook the Ewoks because of all the greatness in that movie. In fact, i find that if you overlook the bad in every movie, its hard to complain about any of the 1st 6 films. Dont get me wrong, its hard to overlook Jar Jar, some of the dialogue in the prequels, and character assassinations (Grievous!), but if you can do it, u can really enjoy them all a lot more

Nick Siringo Yes! I want to see this. All of my friends are in their forties and up and love SW and not one of them could vote a prequel film as anything more than average at best. The majority of these votes have got to be coming from millennials, but even then that hardly excuses it. I didn’t watch The Maltese Falcon when it was released at the cinema but I still recognise quality when I see it. I fear for the future...

Yea so we can see only people over 60 like the originals better than rots

Violator that’s interesting because I’ve never met somebody who wasn’t a 70s or 80s kid who can even tolerate the originals

@@tmlfan7785 Really dude... the originals are timeless classics. I find it incredibly hard pressed you haven’t found people who love these films. You can go around saying you like the prequels all you want but don’t you dare slander the originals. I’m only 17 by the way.

Jackson I honest to god have never met somebody under the age of 30 who likes the originals.

And Obi-wan and Yoda fighting all the way through to the archives, 2 changes I would make to make it the absolute best Star Wars movie.

Victor Bruant There will be no dawn... for the Jedi.

You nailed it!!

Combo of my favorite 2 trilogies right here

ViperChief117 That’s not saying much at all but it’s entirely true.

And it could have been so much more. Rots paid for all the mistakes in the first 2 movies.

Best one out of all 9 by far

That's why I read them all. A lot of the time there are some truly great ones with few or even no thumbs up... likely because they got posted later and just lost in the mix.

I make a ton of great comments but I always only get about one like. Which is fine I just wish my opinions got more exposure.

@@CharlieZColt sooooo if u get one like, do you REALLY make "a TON of GREAT comments.." ??? Lol... just ribbing ya

MAsterr Serch if you watch the video a lot of the comments he shows are “6 days old” meaning that if you don’t post it on the first day you’ll get buried under all the other thousands of comments because the first day’s posts are the ones that get upvoted because they got all the likes. But yeah 😂 lmao

CharlieZColt I feel you man, I hate that KZfaq algorithm shows the most popular, earliest and most liked comments. But I guess that's the easiest thing to do.

I know people who watched the prequels first and they love them. Doesn't mean they don't have issues with some stuff it's just not a huge deal with them. In non-English speaking countries in general prequels are better appreciated and certainly higher than the sequels.

Don’t think they get made or people make it to the third honestly

Empire can beat it

If its your favourite you should definetly vote it as great.

Totally agreed

Fat man behavior, people who doesn't care that opinions existed. I could name a few.

I couldn't agree more.

@@Yeagerbonebone They really arent biased. I keep seeing this argument a lot. Sure you can say you like the prequels if you want but you gotta realize that when the original Star Wars came out virtually everybody who went to see it liked it. Alternatively, a lot of people have been saying the prequels are good as of late but when they came out pretty much nobody liked them. When the prequels came out virtually nobody liked them. It’s kinda obvious that the children who grew up with the clone ears series are growing older and r now defending the prequels. It’s kinda y’all who are biased

Its a great movie. Personally its my 2nd favorite sw movie after rots.

Ian Mcdiermid: Hold my blue milk

Sarge PalmettoVIP Yeah, Revenge of the Sith is sort of underrated, but I wouldn't say that it's quite as good as the original trilogy.

Conor Stack I think nothing can beat the empire strikes back it's so classic

It’s treason, then.

Really? I think Revenge of the Sith easily surpasses Empire.

gnc623 “and THAT is why you fail” -Yoda. (J/k)

When anakin pledges himself to sidious it looks like he’s drunk on the dark side that’s how I knew he had been corrupted

@@quasarsoul3647 - I agree that he wanted to save her... but through the prequel movies, at the times when we see Anakin at his "worst" has been with regard to the actions of others to him... Such as with the Tuskans in "Attack of the Clones." They'd already tortured his mother when he found her and she died in his arms which was to represent a great deal of emotional pain to him... particularly as he was still emotionally attached to her, even in "the Phantom Menace." Thus when she died, he took vengeance on those responsible for her death. And with the movies... we don't see anything that would indicate that the Temple Younglings treated him poorly or did anything that would leave emotional scars. Perhaps there is something in the Legends expanded universe that shows this in a book or a comic, but it's not shown in the movies. Thus with what is shown in movies... one think there would need to be more than just Palpatine's order, because the Younglings had done nothing to him on screen. And while there is some "issue" with the "Rule of Two" that the Jedi would be aware of to a degree... Both in Legends and in Canon the Sith Order DID expand. You had Dooku who trained both Grievous and Assajj Ventress. So... if there can only be two... then why was Ventress trained? And then after the formation of the Empire, the Sith would expand to include a host of inquisitors, many of who were former Jedi. Look at Jerec in video game series where you play as Kyle Katarn. And in canon its all the characters that showed up with their helicopter lightsabers in "Rebels." So it's not like the Sith Order couldn't expand if need be and that it would be impossible to do so. And that's where my point on making the offer and only applying lethal force if it is resisted. If they turn, Palpatine gets an Inquisitor, if not, the Youngling has then done something that could be taken as justification for lethal action.

@@AndreNitroX - With what they show... I think Anakin was still largely confused at that point. He cuts off Mace's arm and then says, "what have I done?"

Easily one of the best scenes of the whole saga. So much emotion without a single word being uttered.