Q111

1. Afghanistan didnt defeat the 45 countries, nor those 45 countries entirely made their army invade afghanistan, afghanistan was under control of the US for 20 years and kept taliban at shoe, because of domestic problems and taliban recruits from different countries + they had more problems to deal with, they left afghanistan 2. there is no socio-political system in Islam, you may have heard the hadith that one man went to Muhammad PBUH for judgement, then went to Umar, this proves it 3. It was the right of the individual if he wanted to take which judging method, the jew one, christian one, islamic one etc in the time of Muhammad (PBUH), it was not imposed like state law, state law was brought by colonial powers and now is the system only. Now you may ask, "but a person can leave his faith just to avoid the punishment", this further proves that religion is a matter of Man and God, nobady else can intervene

So

Till Khalifat-e-Rashidoun there was no problem between two major sect until a dynasty was about to appear (Ummayah)

Imam Malik gave fatwa on forceful bayah of Caliph for which he was beaten. Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal was beaten and then he was martyred and 8 Lac people participate in his Janaza among them were 60,000 women. So the scholars did stand against the Kings and dictators when they didn't follow the rulings of Sharia. And what you sure that a Man made law is better than the God's Law. Do you people think that you are more wise than Allah who is your creator. For example, I am a Computer Scientist. If I make a Graphics Cards (GPU) I know how it should work, in which environment it will work properly, at which room temperature it will be safer because I created it. So, Allah who has created this whole universe and us, He knows what is good for his creation and what is wrong because He is Wise. This is why in Quran Allah always gives the logic that he is most wise. And secondly, tell me which was the first democratic state in the world some people say it was Greece and some say it Roman Republic and by the way computers never existed bacj then. And some say that New Zealand which was first to extend voting rights to women near the end of 19th century, should be considered the first- and true- ever democratic. And computers never existed back then. Why you democratic people give such silly arguments like technology, computers, electricity, etc. Look I'm Computer Engineer according to me these things are irrelevant to politics. These things has nothing to do with basic human rights. Basic human rights are employment, education, health, security, etc.

True but in these matters policies varied regionally and temporally.

Well in Islam there is no one way to choose the Khalifa. I think that can easily be proven by history.

Islam gives the best way to choose the khalifa I think I can prove it mohtram professor...

Hareem madam ... in laws ko execute krny wali authority b honi chyia or wo khalifa ha ... legislative procedure goes to Allah Almighty pr ab wahi ni a skti,hm kese west ko compete kr skty hn ...so respected sir already proclaimed that IJTIHAD must be continued because the settlement of the contemporary affairs ... or continuation of ijtihad is the duty of fiqa... only issue in the system is elections for Khalifa.... so sorry to say madam and other commentators that don't be blabber ... think 100000000 times to comment about the Knowledge of respected sir Taimor ur Rehman sb. Respected sir love u so much for ur incredible services ❤.really me and thousands like me can't afford u in universities... So plz honourable sir keep it up.🙏🏻

@@munawarali3870 u r very right sir....these people even did not hear what professor sab talking about.

@@mnaprofdrnaveedraheem4318 sir, let me know I am very keen to know this,

"how to earn power to dominate the world"? like isis? explain... And Islam is not a political system at it's core, it's a personal connection between man and Allah and yes it teaches us about akhirah and to get success in the afterlife, but this has nothing to do with politics. It does give us guidance and values and some prescriptions in politics but thats about it. The Shariah is an abstract notion related to state. The traditional muslim states/Khilafat, after the 4 caliphs, aren't something which was from The Quran or Sunnah, They were the result of a system which was suitable for that time. In this age, it's outdated. I'm not advocating for political secularism, but what I'm saying is that to forget about the traditional state systems.

@@immasavagebro2845 By following the teachings of Allah and Prophet PBUH it is an very easy job to earn power. Power is not main thing i am talking about it was figure of speech on wider side it is fact that if you are on right side you will get power you have your own school of thoughts which i respect and thanks for sharing your thoughts. Caliphate is also the symbol of power for Muslims in those times and today too. ISIS is an terrorist bunch made by USA in order to defame Islamic rule of law I oppose that ISIS before and will continue doing this till i die. Any ways thanks stay bless and happy.

@@immasavagebro2845 Does lslamic concept of social justice is outdated?

Allah ho akbr , dear professor , apny hisse m ye sab may laiye .....

@@whiteholeeducationcenter yes obviusly

Your information is not correct. It was a republic till 27 BC (meaning senate based on the slave owning class voted). And after that it came under the rule of an Emperor.

This is your understanding. Strict manifestation of Islam means an effort to push Islam towards deep crisis. Any proposition that doesn't allow to produce questions can't be scientific. We should understand, jobs of a government is not to provide Jannat or duzakh to the people. But to resolve material issues people faces each & everyday.

@@quamrulhassan8205 show me one ayaah or hadith which is anti prosperity. Infact Islam provides solutions for economy by making it more humane and individual specific.

@@qtube8403 Prosperity of whom? Muslims or mankind?

Again, r u serious? I think either u didn't read Quran or failed to understand meanings. Thank u.

@@quamrulhassan8205 i said show me one ayaah or hadith which is anti prosperity or progress? Back up your arguments with facts rather than your opinions.

Because lmams have no power all power resides with the deep state

Jese?

Maslan?

The Roman republic was not a democracy in the modern sense of the term. All political rights in Rome were based on property and the status of the family.

Do you know even after Prophet pbuh death, the controversy of selection of khalifa began. Every khalifah is selected in different manner. There was no " smooth" process of electing khalifa. That is why it crumbled in just 30 years.

It makes it possible to have mass representative systems. This was not possible before.

All humans are progressive because those who are static are in graves

The Ancient Greek concept of democracy excluded women, slaves, and anyone without property. It was restricted to property owning men.

نظامت امامت اور خلافت ایک ہی شے ہے

Siasat hai kya?

For their protection. Because, jiziyah gives tax to the government. And more no Muslim means more tax. This allows a ruler of lslamic state not forefully convert their non Muslim population because otherwise they will not get Tax. Secondly this encourages the ruler to attract more non Muslims to his kingdom because if more non Muslim will come the more tax they will get

@@whiteholeeducationcenter see thiskzfaq.info/get/bejne/gd2VdqmZptO3g6c.html

@@whiteholeeducationcenter in a government, it is not seen that a person is muslim or not, every person has to give tax

No we can't reject the religion

@@mansoorahmed8026 then you aren’t following true communism.

Million curse on Markxism you also go to hell with it 😡😡

@@birdoflaments Oh Pagal Butt you go to hell with communism. Why we follow this. Even yor Abba was also not follower of communism. Butt Pagal Ho gia

@@mansoorahmed8026 do you really think ki tumhe marne k baad 72 hoore milengi... This idea is shit bro... Marne k baad na to hure milengi na hi sahad ki nadiya

Science A-moral hai. Science sae hum apnae lia asania too pada kar saktae hai Par Zindagi nahi guzar saktae .

He is a nice intellectual. These things should be discussed openly.

Yeah he did this .....he is not explaining it that right ......

Printing press s murad aik instrument hua krta tha jo us dor mn likhne k kam ata tha us k bad printing press modern form mn aya tha

Aj s almost 350 saal phle aese instrument bna liye the jo print krte the pr bht time taken the or bht km print krte the

Nice analogy but you clearly missed the actual point. This issue runs deeper than "hunger" which is a fundamental issue that always persists. But what does Hanifa say about the legality of recent scientific advancements such as surrogation for example?

Islam is a religion. Not a “system”.

Sir its your interpretation.Sir islam is more than religion it is Deen (way of life) system , with due respect plz go through scientific invention in Islamic golden age and try to see more than 400 years of history.... You will find political solutions also. If I summarise "economy without ethics" means "everything allowed to earn money ". We are not able to solve our issues it's not because of Islam, it is our own incompetency as a nation "hum sharab ki bottle pr shehd ka label lga kr bechny ki koshish kr rhy hn Jo k nhi biky ga". This is Islamic Republic of Pakistan, where government doesn't want to go for Elections..... Democracy 🤫

@@mentalmoon5745 yes it is a way of life, not a way of government

Kyu nahi chal sakta Kyq intrest nahi par ban nahi hona chahiyah Kaya Hording nahi band honi cHAHIYAH Kya choor ko saza nahi milni cHAHIYAH Kaya aorto kj property mei right nahi milna cHAHIYAH Kaya ma bap ki izzat nahi karni cahaiyah Kaya haram kama nae sae nahi bachna cHAHIYAH Aur ap mugae yah bate Pakistan mei too Shariat ha hi nahi Yaha too Anglo Saxon law hai . Constitution of lndia 1930 sae inspired

@@whiteholeeducationcenter apne joh kaha woh hona chahiye, magar Islam ka jo makhsos governing daira ham ne banaya hai usse bahar

@@whiteholeeducationcenter plus, ab interest pe ban nahi hosakta, because of capitalism and world bank

@Humza Khan It's rashideen in Arabic as well when using as noun.

@Humza Khan علیکم بسنتی و سنۃ الخلفاء الراشدین المھدیین

Dear, make a video on ur views.

Bhai tu pehlay Lectures ke spelling theek kr k aa.

@Imran Ahmad Tru, gramerr is totalee overretatded butt when challenging intellectually one better consider brevity correct grammar and properly structured sentences, if wanted to be taken seriously. Nahi te mauj malangaa di, aan dawo fer jo moo ich aaye. :D

Us dor mn politics thi tabhi qabeelo k sardar bhi the or Hazrat Muhammad SAW sb ki help krte the ap bhool gae ho kiya k Quran Pak mn Khilafat ka hukm h to kia yh politics nj h ? Us cheez ko counter kren jis k bare mn knowledge ho bilawaja tanqeed na kia kre

Kya baat ghalat hai meray dost. Nishan Dahi karo.