From research I also found that MAOLANA was against muslim league. The reason is that literally Muslim league was not an islamic party. Its struggle was based on nationalism .That's reality u r right.

Words may get bitter, but practically molana was right, and today we can see this practically, opinion may differ but it must be accepted that molana forcasted it, As a suggestion instead of sharing con's try to share pros as well, so listners can get balanced approach. Another suggestion, try to read his books like khilafat o malokiat,. Shahadat e haq, and many more. Respect !

I am not a Jamaat guy nor do I appreciate Maududi. However, he was right, that in the Muslim League, people were not at all Muslim in their personal characteristics and were in fact non-Muslims. The entire party was a creation of wealthy landlords and businessmen who were absolutely westernized in nature(Aga Khan/Jinnah). Grassroot activism was very low as compared to the Congress party. This is the reason why there is a class conflict in Pakistan even today.

You always feel pain because, Maudidi defeated red revolution with his movement

And what about those secular communists who were also against the creation of Pakistan? (Bacha Khan and Wali Khan),you as a communist support them

in this hard world, some things are pretty harder. for instance, understanding the mindset of people call themselves researchers and "the prudent", but unable to pick the difference between "tarjuman ul quran" and "tafheem ul Quran". some people are deliberate liers, well so-called "the wise". There is a big difference between truth and propaganda and you are a propagandist. people who have read Maulana Maududi can understand the language of Maulana, and most of your excerpts are utterly not of Maulana. there can be ideological differences with any movement, surely he had.

this is a great description by you. Thank you so much for this explanation.

I agree with Maududi. Pakistan was and is a confused state which cannot decide between east and west. It mostly went with the western style thinking with flirting sometimes with eastern thoughts. A confused nation.

واہ کیا بات ہے پائی جان

I appreciate your work Mr. Taimur, i really do. But tbh my grandfather has spent time with Maulana Maududi, he knew him personally i mean my grandfather really admired the guy because he helped my grandfather find faith again, my grandfather's a former Marxist himself. He said Maududi Sahb was pro Pakistan, i mean let's actually ask people from the people who actually know the guy instead of the internet. No disrespect towards ur work tho. Thank you

Really very interesting .. came to know so many things. thank you so much for sharing..

Sir, is there anything in the fanatical account of Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind? Did they eventually change their stance towards Jinnah's secular viewpoints?

Taimur Bhai.. I am doubtful about the "style of writing you read". If possible share its pdf version so that we can confirm it from Mansora. Hope You will cooperate.

All misquoted reference , Facts are: 1. The only book 'Two Nation Theory' use by Muslim league in Independent struggle was written by M. Maududi. 2. Maulana Maududi was assigned to give lectures on Radio Pakistan for Islamic Government by Quaid-e-Azam. 3. Allama Iqbal has referred Maulana Maududi for muslim spiritual future and asked to come to Punjab from Hyderabad. 4. In the Shaitani world any group struggle to for right ideology will be opposed. 5. There was a bigger picture for muslims as a large population will remain in India; and there are many points which shows that your analysis is wrong.

There is no contradiction between secularism and Islam. Original version of Islam accommodates every human with open heart. This is what I have extracted through original teachings; I might be wrong.

Very interesting & informative Prof ...I started watching ur channel few days back ..I'm completely awestruck with ur clarity of thought & incisive view point ! Have u written any book on partition of India ! Pls share details ...as this subject has always haunted me coz my ancestory goes to Pakistan Punjab !!

Dear Taimur Very good and nuanced program.

Can you share the links maududis statements which read over here

Funny story my uncle when he was living in Pakistan he was liberal when he went to south Africa and UK he become a very conservative Muslim

Your references are incomplete, please elaborate these references , I didn't find one of these quotations correctly. I'm waiting for your reply Sir

ترجمان القرآن کتاب نہیں۔ یہ لینگویج مولانا مودودی کی نہیں۔ جلد پندرہ کس کتاب کی ہے?? پورا ریفرینس دیں

This man is indeed a brilliant scholar, he should concentrate more on his teaching job and less on his political engagements. The real beneficiaries would be students and young people of Pakistan . Leftists are always very good in history and they are the ones who had lions share in writing the history in India , off course I don't think it's so in pakistan. Professor sahab thank you very much for your brilliant commentary on Pushtuns, their plight, their aspirations and their present predicament . In early this year the Pushtuns were very much in news for their protest marches, meetings and their slogan........ iske piche wardi hai ! . They were indeed perturbed over killing of their young man by a karachi police despot. They had a formidable presence on KZfaq and handled PTM portal very well . The entire lot of people appeared very genuine, hard-working and their leaders appeared very honest and simple. There were few ladies also on forefronts, who were very dignified and spoke so well about their people's problems. Yes there is no news about them in last one year, their portal also disappeared. We knew about Bacha Khan, his Khudai KhidmatgAr party, friendship with Mahatma Gandhi and his role in freedom struggle. But today listening to you I got the real perspective of his role in emancipation of societies in Pak-Afgan bordering areas. Your commentary on Islamic Majahbi parties was so well articulated and factual. Moudadi - Barrister Jinnah feuds, mistrust is subject of so many books. Bhutto Sahab's downfall from power was also accelerated by PNA ( Pak National Alliance ) at whose core were majhabi parties ! Best wishes prof. Sahab and also to your students

would you like to provide us your all given lectures on videos in book format?

Taimor Sir big fan of you. I have never seen such a great scholar and philosopher and teacher

Maulana Azad was not kattar. Many liberal Muslims also opposed the division of Muslims into three parts.

Thus, as per your argument, Jinnah wished Pakistan to be a welfare state as some European State may have been, all encompassing, pluralistic. And obviously, Maududi sought it to be on the pattern of Madinah, in his perception, theodemocratic and religious oriented. Of course in either of the cases, there was a search for betterment on behalf of the propounders. But neither Jinnah nor Maududi got what they wished it to be bcoz the masses whom they addressed have yet (even after 70 years of self-rule) to prove their collective civilized character.

State policy of every country should be secular , personal life of Pakistani Muslims should be religious but it should be chosen by that person itself.

I want to highlight three points, 1)Yes, some religious parties and their leaders opposed partition and Jinnah. It was not only Ulama but also many non-Ulama/mainstream Muslim leaders who opposed Jinnah and partition. Why are we only targeting Ulama ? What does Ulama's opposition prove ? Opinions of parties, individuals and groups are based on their analysis of situation, which can prove wrong or inappropriate. It happens quite often in our own lives as individuals. We have seen many political parties in Pakistan or elsewhere who have committed mistakes/blunders and many of them accept it. What is wrong in it :) 2)You are also missing the point that there were religious parties and many ulama/mashaikh who supported Pakistan like Shabir Ahmed Usmani, Azad Subhani, Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi, MufitShafi, Maulaha Muhammad Ibrahim Sialkoti, Pir Ghulam Mujaddid Sirhindi, Amin-ul-Hasnant Pir Sahib of Manki Sharif, Pir Sahib Zakori Sharif, Pir Jamat Ali Shah, Maulana Sanaullah Amritsari. 3) Your quote from Ali Usman Qasmi's book re Tafhimul Quran is absolutely incorrect. It is not in the book of Mr Qasmi. It creates doubts about your other references as well.

سارے ملا مذہب کے پردے میں اپنے ذاتی مفادات کو پورا کررہے ہیں. شکر ہے کسی نے تو اس سچ سے پردہ اٹھا یا کہ ملا کی کیا حقیقت ہے. بہت خوب جناب 👍

Please give references of Moudoodi's statements.

Aaj ki Surte hal kay Mutabik batien Bilkul sahi han.. Fark sirf ye hay kay Moududi sab ki nhe han. ✋

I was born in Pakistan. I have completed my graduation in Pakistan. Mr jinnah was my hero and I admired him a lot. Few years back I came to USA and I studied more history about tahreek e Pakistan and their leaders. After studying history, I realized that Mr jinnah was good politician , but he wasn’t that good. The partition of subcontinent was planned by England. They had too many reasons for that . Amir of Afghanistan, Amir abdur rehman khan wrote a book named “ taaj ul tawa’reekh” According to him, british were planning to divide subcontinent in to two parts. This book was written 47 years before the independence of Pakistan. How he knew it ?

Most of the statements he has taken are out of the context. This is very unfortunate that he has actually misquoted and misinterpreted Maududi and tried to misrepresent him.

آپ مسئلہ قومیت پر جمیعت علمائے ہند کے موقف سے آگاہ نہیں ہیں۔ اس حوالے سے آپ کو چاہئے کہ مولانا مدنی اور ابوالکلام آزاد کے موقف کو پڑھیں۔ ان دونوں نے مسئلہ قومیت پر جو بات پیش کی تھی، آپ اس سے بالکل مختلف بات کررہے ہیں۔ آپکو پڑھنا چاہئے۔ مولانا مدنی کے خیال میں مسلم قومیت کا کوئی وجود نہیں تھا۔ وہ قومیت پر اسی موقف کے حامی تھے، جو جدید سوشل سائنسز پیش کرتا ہے۔

All fake and baseless allegations without reference. I thought you might present some intellectual things but I really disappointed.

sir pir maulana shaber ahmad usmani ne kis bena pe Quaid e azam ka sat diya,kia wo be secular state ke hame te?sir please guide me

Thank you for imparting knowledge to all those who couldn't get admission to LUMS ;) Keep fighting the good fight, Sir.

Sir please make videos in political system and history of Pakistan.

Sir I need ur help Will you explain a poem 'Jinnah's typewriter ' by Shadab Zeest Hashim

برائے مہربانی مولانا مودودی کی جس کتاب کا آپ نے حوالہ دیا اس کا نام اور جس نے ترجمہ کیا اس کا نام بھی بتا دیں۔ ساتھ ہی یہ بھی بتا دیں کہ جب کیا آپ کو اردو میں کتاب نہیں ملی جو آپ اس کا ترجمہ پڑھنے پر مجبور ہوئے۔

Beautiful, Maududi sahib was a great religious scholar and an intellectual person. The likes of Dr. Israr Ahmad learnt from him. His house I remember on Ferozepore Road was a center of learning. He had a large following. Getting back to your point I think you are so right the creators were secular or beyond. To learn to tolerate others you have to have multicultural societies/ countries. It’s cannot be monolithic. That is why most western countries put it into law. We need to educate that will emancipate us from the drudgery. Thank you great to find your channel

Dr Taimoor, I understand that you want to highlight the difference in religious parties' thought back in the 40s and 50s and now, but this could have been done better. Having seen a video coming from a scholar like you, I was expecting a detailed analysis of Maududi sb's ideology but instead I found rhetoric only. Picking and choosing certain excerpts from a scholar's essays out of context, with snide remarks, just to make your point isn't something I expected from you.

The reference about Jinnah sahab quoted by you from Tafheem ul Quran is wrong i guess.. It may be tafheemat but not tafheem ul Quran..fobara check kr lain..

Can you pls do this video in English or add Eng subtitles?

Liaqat Ali used to drink liqour wrapped in handkerchief while in prime minister office but he reprensented objective constitution.

آپ کے مطالعہ کو سلام ہے آپ مساوات کی کٹنگ کو مولانا مودودی کی ترجمانی کے لیے استعمال کر رہے ہیں

where is video which you are referring at start kindly share link.

You did great work in ARAB ISRAEL CONFLICT.. History & creation of KSA was missing in that, Could you please creat video on this topic. Thanks a million for your work.

I bet most of the jamati followers dont even know about this.

Jothoon par Allah ki Lannat.. Sir Moududi sab kay about jo batien is ne ki Apko Moududi sab ki kisi book me milen to muje lazmi btaiega.. I Challenge Everyone...

1947 - Assembly of 300,000 Khaksars in Delhi to Overturn British Rule When Allama Mashriqi called for 300,000 Khaksars to assemble in Delhi on June 30, 1947, the Government not only fast-forwarded transfer of power, but also imposed section 144 in Delhi and formed police pickets on all entries into Delhi. There were standing orders to arrest the Khaksars entering Delhi. According to the Khaksar circle, the overthrow of British rule was around the corner, but Muslim and Hindu leaders were directed to accept the partition of India before June 30th (which they did). These leaders ruined the pride of the Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and others for not conquering the Indian sub-continent’s (now Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh) freedom. Pursuing a transfer of power also speaks loudly to the fact that these leaders did not have power in the streets.

Aoa sir me css ki aspirant hu please ap muje suggest kre kuch books muje b ap ki trah intellectual bnana hy

Kuch logon se such bardasht nehi hota

I am great fan of you Sir, I have learnt alot from you by telling us the actual history

Secularism in means right to practice religion We have our own legal social and judicial law that why we are protecting secularism but in case of Pakistan 99%muslim why do need secularism To misguide people from islam☪️️

where I will find the book muslim against the muslim league ?

The World HQs of tabliquee jamaat, Nadwa, Deoband, Barelvi school of though is in India.

o bhai india mein muslims ke minority hai aur secularism un ke survival ke liye vital hai

Can you share Online links please Thanks

Maulan maududi justified the creation of Pakistan in accordance with the Quran and Sunnah in his book "Musalman aur maujuda siyasi qashmakash". The muslim league couldnt bring any justification for the creation of pakistan except a national argument. It was naulana maududi who justified pakistans creation in accordance with islam.

You are one of the greatest teacher I have come across, thank you so much for enlightening us with your great knowledge of things, Pakistan needs more people like you

Kal ki video ki link den.

Very informative video , no doubt

Sir mudaudi ke en statements ke koe link dai dai plz

Allah Taala Maulana maududi Ko Jannat ul firdus me aala maqam ataa farmaye.

Sir I appreciate your effort please continue to make this kind video clips

Can get ur videos on Instruments of foreign poliecy

Sir, how to interpret the contradiction between Jinnah's Secular State concept and Two Nation Theory leading to the creation of Pakistan? Kindly, make a separate video, if possible...

Maududi ney to Pakistan ko Masjid kaha tha sahab!

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 From INDIA ( Maharashtra)

@TaimurRahman Sir link is not working

Dear sir, I'm not sure how you derived that Jamiat Ulma e (not ahle) Hind was supportive of pan islamism. Their whole struggle and coalition with congress was on the basis of nationalism. Please revisit your theory

اگر یہ صاحب مولانا کی کتب اور تفہیم القرآن کو خود سے ایک بار ہی پڑھ لیتے تو آج خیالات بالکل مختلاف ہوتے مگر ہدایت اللہ۔جسے خاہتا ہے اسی کو عطا فرماتا ہے

Taimoor sir ! I love the way of your teaching style but please unite this already dispersed country. Do not spread hate among us. We want peace and only peace ! 💖

Brother your one and only reference in video description speaks aloud how much "research" you have done on the topic.

Or bhai shb jhoot ky be paon hoty hen koi banda apsy pochy ky jis katab ka name he "tarjamanul Quran" hu us katab mn tarjamy ky ilawa or kia hu skta hay?

Sir make a video about Abul Kalam azad.

بالکل سچ کہا آپنے. یہ ہے ان ملاؤں کی حقیقت ہے. اب انکے حامی جتنا بھی شور ڈالیں لیکن تاریخ کی حقیقت کو کیسے جھٹلا سکتے ہیں.

It's true that most of the members of the Muslim League were not practicing Muslims, but they used Islam in their political campaign to advocate for the formation of Pakistan. Hence, the creation of Pakistan was truly based on religious terms, rather than in a secular sense. This is why Muslims from different backgrounds, whether Punjabi, Sindhi, Bengali, or Urdu speaking, were able to unite because of the religious ideology introduced by the Muslim League

I appreciate your work sir Taimur

ملاں کو جو ہے ہند میں سجدے کی اجازت ناداں یہ سمجھتا ہے کہ آزاد ہے اسلام اقبال

آپ جو بات بات پر تفہیم القرآن کہہ رہے ہیں آپ نے خود پڑھیں بھی ہے

All the statements have their contexts. He has tried his hands on pick and chose quite sharply.

Waiting for the vlog on Senate polls ... sir

پاکستان کا پہلا کونسا ترانہ تھا جو ہندو نے لکھا ہم نے تو ایک ہی سنا اور پڑھا جو کہ حفیظ جالندھری نے لکھا.

Sir buhat intizar karwaya AP ne (for next video)

Well done Taimoor bhai

Is this also in English?

Why do you want to open a new pandora box?

Famous hony ka bht acha tareeqa hy k aik camera on karo or jo marzi bakwas nikal k upload kr do

Plz sir recommende book?

Excellent point of view, equal rights for all Pakistani citizens.

Hahaha amazing! Madudi and the other mullahs need to be exposed like this.

Secondly, always quote Maududi sb directly from his books or periodicals because a lot of lies have been associated with Syed Abul Ala Maududi by other Islamic schools of thought.

If you think Taimur Rahman is ignorant, I hate to break your bubble but he is very well read and very educated on various subjects ranging from history, politics, social sciences. He is a rarity in a country where a large number of people don’t read nor think out of the box. Your works are very educational Taimur and keep up the good work.

What about his will asking people to publish a portion of his book to be published 30 years after his death. ?

Love from India 🇮🇳 If Jinnah was secular why he demanded separate Pakistan state?

ہمیں خلفائے راشدین کے نقشِ قدم پر چلتے رہنے کی ہدایت کی گئی ہے

There is no doubt that Jinnah was a Secular person just like Ataturk but the generations who came after him baptized his political legacy in the name of Islam.

Show books with pages zoomed with camera, please.