I need to do this blind and see who wins.

I love Old Forrester 1920, never have known about the single barrel Rye. I have the JD Barrel Proof Rye, and they do vary greatly depending on the barrel, proof and warehouse. I love the one I have, bottled in 2023, so much going on with this pour, orange peel, buttered toast, coconut sugary and then the savory rye notes-pepper, salami ?

When you picked what you thought was better, you picked your right side and said it was the jack because jack was your first love. At the beginning you said jack was your first love but during covid 1920 became your favorite. Then when you were wrong and it was actually the old fo you said old fo was your first love, after twice saying jack was your first love. I havent had the old fo SiB rye, yet, but i will soon. I requested it on a local stores allocated list when i finally showed up the other day, just waiting for them to tell me to pick it up. Jack SiB BP rye is amazing. It guna be hard to beat, especially value wise since the jack is cheaper. I been watchin reviews of the old fo SiB rye, and tho everyone says its good, they all said the jack was better. Only seen 1 vid where he didnt like the old fo SiB rye, said he doesnt find anything in it that makes him want to go back to it, but the bottle was 7/8 gone, so he obvi went back to it many many times. I really dont care which is better, as long as the old fo is as good as i have heard it was since im paying $100 for it.