BUT WHAT IF THEY CUT OFF MY EARS!??

the werewolf watching dylan and ryan stop in the middle of the path to flirt: ill give them a second

I like how Dylan wasn't bark and no bite. When he notices Nick's infection, he suggests cutting the limb off. But when he himself gets infected, he also doesn't hesitate asking Ryan to cut it off.

Those two practising their phone call to 911 was the most relatable thing I've ever seen in a game

"herd of bears!" / "yes, i've heard of bears?!" -- and in one single moment, dylan went from one of the middle tier characters for me to being my absolute favorite.

Kaitlyn is the most under utilized here she is literally a master at shooting guns and shes stuck being a babysitter.

“what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” Sean: “BUT WHAT IF I-“

The developers must be SO ECSTATIC that someone chose to open the trap door, because they never imagined someone would take the bait

Dylan: “Do I look like a doctor?” Also Dylan: “I think we need to amputate his leg”

Emma: "I'm going to die a horrible, gruesome death" Me: *shocked when Emma dies a horrible, gruesome death*

Sean: there is a monster behind that door Emma: there is a monster behind that door Sean: opens door Monster: is behind door Sean:👁👄👁

Probably too late, but for anyone who's playing the quarry.. Here's a fun fact: If you hear the crow cawing that means a tarot card is nearby

‘Why are you covered in what I hope is strawberry jelly?’ ‘Oh! Yeah, no this is blood’ literally my favorite interaction in any horror media

54:13 Not gonna lie I hate an extreme comedian in a horror movie, but “Herd of bears?” “Yes I’ve heard of bears” was so hilarious

Emma: jokes that opening the trap door will kill her Jack: nah, the game wouldn't *really* do that, right? Emma: gets her throat ripped out

tbh dylan is the most accurate depiction of a gay teenager ever

Like how did nobody notice Nick slowly healing? He was essentially dead when he was 1st attacked. By the time the other guy gets to him to save him, he can speak coherently and stand on his own AND keep a jogging pace through the woods. When he is back at the fire, I thinks his wounds are only superficial at that point, and it's mostly shock at that point. Once he is in bed, he is just laying there chilling, talking to abide like he isn't missing 3 organs and 6 pints of blood.

“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” takes on a new meaning when not getting killed potentially means turning into a werewolf thing

Just remember guys, none of this would've happened if Jacob hadn't stolen that car part

I love how Laura became a werewolf hunter w/in 2 months of her first encounter. I don't care if it's realistic or not, I like her being such a badass lol.

I love the fact that whenever Abigail is freaked out or anything, it’s like her hair senses fear and danger.

It's odd, Brenda's motion capture looks like 2x better than everyone else's. Most close-ups of her look almost photo realistic in some way

Jack playing The Quarry: **Calmly and carefully de-escalating every situation** Jack playing Until Dawn: "Fuck it!!! Fuck you!!!" 😂

Dylan with that “yes, I’ve heard of bears” for me, went from “ehh don’t care about you” to “please don’t die now Dylan”

It's actually very intelligent of Katlyin to give Abi the notebook. It's something she finds comfort in, something that will keep her focus and let her body get vitals like breathing under control and they end up with a better idea of what "thing" they're looking out for. Smart.

Emma: "if you open the trap door I'm going to die" Jack: Opens door. Emma: Dies Jack: Surprised Pikachu face.

The way they keep saying “it’s a bear” makes me wonder if any of them have ever seen a bear before or know how bears behave.

The scene where Dylan gets his hand cut off is definitely one of my favorites. It's not so much the gore that makes it my favorite but Dylan's reaction to getting his hand chopped off. He had gotten bit (more like mauled lol) and he knew that his hand was going to get infected because of Nick. His decision to tell Ryan to amputate it was incredibly smart in the moment. I also find it very impressive that he was able to make that kind of decision with how much stress he was under. From looking through the comments I've seen so many people ask "why was Dylan not screaming his head off? He had just gotten his hand sawed off!" Though that is a possible reaction for some people getting an improv amputation Dylan was under extreme stress like I mentioned earlier. Coupled with the pain Dylan's brain most likely went into shock to protect him. That's why he seemed incredibly calm and even started laughed after. When people are in shock don't really feel any pain so thats also probably why he didn't start screaming bloody murder. My favorite part about the scene though is when he realizes that he just got his hand amputated. His reaction seems so genuine as if his voice actor went through the same thing. Many kudos to his voice actor, who did a beautiful job. Anyways, with the shock fogging up his brain he gets confused wondering why Ryan chopped off his hand when he practically demanded him to and then he says "well that was a bad idea" like getting your hand chopped off is comparable to getting into trouble for being too mischievous. Again many kudos to his voice actor and the team who wrote the script for the game and everyone else who worked on this amazing game. (Sorry for rambling lmao this game is one of my all time hyperfixations)

Abi: gets thrown across the room like she weighed the same as a tic tac. Abi's hair:🕺🕺🕺

I'm not gonna lie, Dylan's ridiculous rambling at the radio hut is the moment I decided to protect him at all costs. He's an idiot and I love him.

Dylan: “do I look like a doctor?” Dylan 3 seconds prior: “I think we should amputate.”

"nothing bad has ever happened to people going up in horror movies" Matt and Em from Until Dawn would like to disagree.

"Whatever doesn't kill you, makes you stronger." *exists* Jack: BuT wHaT iF iT cUtS oFf My-------

Kaitlyn:"If Emma's on the island she's fine." Me: If only they knew that Jack was controlling her

I swear, Emma's mouth is too freaky to ignore. It's like if they tried to animate The Jokers mouth and slapped it onto a character in another universe.

Sean saying he thinks the hunters are trying to help in the house scene yet doing the qtes to avoid them kills me every time

I like how Jacob stores the memory card in his speedo for safe keeping

“Herd of bears.” “Yeah I’ve heard of bears, but…” Omg. I didn’t think Dylan would become one of my favs in this game. 😂

"Do we open the trap door and die a horrible, painful death?!" Well that's a depressing callback to Ashely's possible death in the first game.

Jack: "If a character dies, so be it. Whatever happens happens. It's part of the fun" Jack, 2 minutes later: *Restarts scene because Emma died*

Swarm of bears? Yeah… Herd of bears. Yeah, I’ve heard of bears. Oh my God… Okay, that was pretty damn funny.

The most impressive thing about this entire game is that Em's phone allows her to use the torch and camera simultaneously

Game: *Literally tells you exactly what is going to happen if you do this thing* Sean: WELL IF IT ISNT THE CONSEQUENCES OF MY OWN ACTIONS

Love that the replay gives you the chance to get her horribly killed again in the exact same way.

1:13:06 I didn't realize that was Jack talking, I thought it was just some random woman's voice and it scared the shit out of me...

Someone needs to make a compilation of Jack questioning the slogan “What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger”. Just a bunch of what if they cut off my *insert body part*

Dylan is a badass for even staying conscious through that.

Abby: "I dont know if he was gonna hurt me" Also abby 5 seconds ago: *Gets flung across the room into a wall*

58:26 I was wondering why it said path unlocked or whatever then I realized that’s the cabin they “broke into” in the first episode!

"They're nice people, they seem fine, they don't want to hurt us" *proceeds to do all the QTE's to avoid detection*

The hunters keep acting creepy yet they have every chance to just act normal. "Oh yeah, the blood will keep them werewolves off ya." "Don't worry, we're just trying to kill the infected people, not the normal people." "The economy is trash." "I would like to announce in this cabin that I do not want to kill anyone."

i love how awkward Dylan and Ryan are it's just great

13:59 "I'm not like a bitch or anything" -The bitchiest character in the game

Just think: all this started because Jacob couldn’t let go of Emma.

Emma and Jacob are literally the instigators of half the things that happen in the story.

Something I caught is that Eliza will whisper the names of the people that can die in the chapter they’re in. Not all the time but most of the time.

As soon as he said “ im just hungry “ I was like YOUR TRANSFORMING !!!

I love how they see a humanoid figure that doesn’t at all resemble a bear and they are just like, hey have you guys seen those bears? They are faster than normal bears and they can run on two legs, must be super bears. Definitely 100% bears.

Dylan: Why did you do that? Ryna: You told me to??? Dylan: Fuck that was a bad idea I love Dylan so much. Jack I am crossing my fingers that you keep him alive he is an absolute GEM

I think we are all glossing over what I'd consider to be the most important question of all... Where the hell did Jacob store that memory card from the camera?

Hearing Sean scream: "THE PREMONITION WAS WRONG! IT WAS WRONG!" was the funniest thing I heard all week :D

“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” Jack: “BUT WHAT IF THEY CUT OFF-“

I can’t take it seriously when a character is in danger and Jack just looks completely naked in my peripheral vision.

In the very beginning, when you're wandering through the woods as the girl, you come across a "cage" that says "Silas, the DOG BOY" and a bit later it talks about the mother, who now wanders the woods, looking for her son and she'll "turn you into him" if she catches you alone - the spooky story. The fire that destroyed the caravan obviously had this fortune teller woman, who may be the ghost/mother, but Silas was definitely a werewolf on display when he turned under the moon. If Jack remembered this bit, he'd have a lot less questions. Maybe it'll come up again later as a reminder.

54:42 The way the creature is first startled when it catches sight of Ryan was well done. Just like what a lurking wild predator would do if it knew it was being watched. I love that tiny detail.

“what doesnt kill you, makes you stronger” Jack: and i took that personally

omg i just realized the cabin that abi, kaitlyn, and nick went into is only unlocked because emma kicked the door down! this game has all sorts of helpful lessons, like breaking and entering will help your friends escape monsters

my favorite BTS knowledge is that when ryan looks out of the window of the radio building and sees the werewolf but doesn't say anything, the actor said he was told on set that the werewolf was so far away that ryan couldn't see exactly what was out there. they did him SO dirty in the actual game because you can see that thing CLEAR as day

Nick was agressive, because he was turning, he didn't do it out of his own will, He lost it because it got into his head, and, well his body exploded into a werewolf Nick, great video btw

This is what I believe gen z would be like in a horror game. The sarcasm, the phone call anxiety, jokes when people are literally dying. It's so good!!

anyone: what doesn’t kill you, will make you stronger jack, every time without fail: but what if they cut off my-

"WHAT IF I CUT MY HAND OFF?" If you hadn't cut off Dylan's hand, he would have turned into a Creature! So yeah, I'd say it made him stronger!

The one thing that really bothers me about this game is that none of the characters ever seem scared. Even before any monsters showed up, when they were just walking through the woods in the dark and hearing an unidentified sound, that would scare most people. But none of the characters ever show really any fear, even when they are actively running from things. When I watched the Until Dawn play through you could feel the tension and fear in the characters. I feel like this game would be scarier if you could feel the fear the way you could in Until Dawn. Just an opinion from a viewer stand point because I never play these games I only watch Sean play them. Also, why was there not a lot more screaming and bleeding when Dylan got his hand chopped off? I love the play throughs though and will be continuing to binge the series this evening.

I really like Dylan's character development- he was masking to try and fit in and not come across as his normal nerdy, awkward self I feel that tbh

ngl, I like Dylan's character, he has a strong intuition regarding things and composure while dealing with things around him which are great traits to have in survival situations. From the start, when he saw the camera footage in the office, I have noticed that he has been a good skeptic about the situation while others like Ryan gave him really vague reasons ("could be bears?" lol) to let things go. Even when he saw Nick's infection he had a great reason (and simple might I add) to suggest amputating it which was dismissed by others.

Sean's responses to "what doesn't kill you will make you stronger" cracks me up

best part about him choosing the trapdoor is that you can literally hear the monster in the attic moving around

Can't wait for them to find out this is literally all Jacob's fault cause he broke the car instead of accepting that the girl who said she was just having a summer fling at the beginning of their relationship actually meant it.

Emma: "I will die a horrible death if I open this trapdoor!" Jack: "OKAY" *proceeds to open the door and die a horrible death* Man, the devs knew what they were doing lmao

I've watched many playthroughs at this point... and damn he deduced most of the story quite early. Everybody I've watched so far just fumbles "Wait... who is Chris!?" This is the best playthrough I've watched so far. Someone genuinely following the story is a nice change of pace.

**Intense and serious things happening** Meanwhile, Sean: "But what if they shaved off my eyebrows and plucked out all my eyelashes??? How does THAT make me stronger?!?"

I genuinely love Dylan, and his actor is nailing it. I hope he doesn't die... p.s. "herd of bears?" "yeah, I've heard of bears" is one of the best fucking lines. This game has had some genuinely funny moments.

1:25:53 Fun fact, miles robbins (Dylands voice actor) stated that dylans cat was named Schrödinger

I hate these games sometimes. Like, why didn't _any_ of the CAMP COUNSELORS tie off Nick's leg with a belt/shirt. Or the dude not explaining he saw the guy get bit and shoot off his finger. I hate it when people make the _worst_ decisions like they're the most clueless people on earth.

“my nipples would cut glass at this point…… defense mechanism!” -Jackscepticeye 2022

Its funny how Jack plays this like its a horror dating simulator; good majority of his decisions are decided by "Will this get them together?" lmao

dylan being stressed is stressing me out man. he seems so real

“Monster comes at me… stab him with a hard nipple!” -jacksepticeye

The fact that Dylan was able to so quickly tell Ryan to cut his hand of was pretty impressive

Love how Sean is constantly trying to find an exception to “what doesn’t kill you will make you stronger”

As soon as Emma said she would die a horrible death I was like “Do it. Do it. Do it.” Emma is my least favorite character lol.

ANYBODY in a horror movie, who sarcastically says, “Oooo what happens if I [DO THIS THING]?! Will I diiieeee??? Ooooo well here I go then! I guess I’m gonna totally dieeeee!” is ABSOLUTELY GOING TO DIE 100% OF THE TIME IF THEY DO THE THING! We all know this. You don’t mock death in a horror movie and live!

Dylan is the type of person you need when stuff like these happen, he knows how to help and immediately says to cut his hand before it spreads. Being able to not pass out is something, but being cool with it and having the strength to crack jokes is something else.

What doesn't kill you makes you stronger" Jack: But what if they cut off my hand? Dylan:

I appreciate jack being ready to shoot nick when he starts to get mean

My absolute favorite part of this series is just hearing Jack come up with new ways to become weaker but not die after one of the characters says the catchphrase

Kelly Clarkson's "What doesn't kill you make you stronger" keeps playing in my head every time Jack says that sentence

The real mystery here is how in the hell did Emma still have her phone after swimming across the lake to that island?

I like how Mr. H said Don't make lots of noise and when something bad happens, thats what everyone did

i like how they are not suspicious of nick just walking around normally