Amazing how she had nothing but laughter and smirks during Camille’s speech but then turns into a “victim” when her lawyer is up there. Honestly..I can’t even with Amber

She and her team have 100% been reading things posted in regards to the trial. It's quite obvious. If she wins I will officially have zero faith left in the justice system and humanity itself. There may be a few instances here and there where she might be telling the truth a tiny but I truly feel it's all projection. Everything she says he did, is what she actually did to him. *Thanks for all the likes yall! Also, I know they're allowed to check social media. I'm just saying she changes things up and mentions things only bc they've been spoken about in the media. Just saying that they make it very obvious that's what they're doing. Chill!

She ONLY puts a sad face when her team is talking about how "horrible" her marriage was but when the defense team speaks, she looks at them like she want to kill them or their existance mean nothing to her, she can try to act all she wants but her narcisistic traits screams louder than her fake crocodile tears.

She can’t blame Johnny for humiliating her - she’s doing that all by herself - she is counting on us to believe her garbage - there is not a genuine bone in her body

Amber's lawyer: He apologized for his abusive behavior, which proves he did it. Also Amber's lawyer: Yeah, she apologized for something she didn't do, because that's what victims do to de-escalate!

Oh yeah, him breaking things in the house is abuse, but her openly hitting him, smashing his face with a door, and cutting up his finger with a vodka bottle isn't. And it's just convenient that he has medical reports and several witnesses and she has nothing, right? Purely coincidental. What a joke. Edit: If Elaine can't get clients after this, she should try her luck in Hollywood. She has better acting skills than Amber 😂😂

The moment when Johnny tried to turn off the camera scared me. There is no way I would willingly provoke a man in that state. Amber is not afraid of him, which is strange for a victim who wakes up at night screaming and can't stand to be touched. If things are done to you that horrible, you'll want to be away when the abuser is in a bad mood. Amber tried very hard to videotape Johnny hitting her, but couldn't do it because that probably didn't happen. Otherwise, why film the spilled wine and face in bad light when you could get a video of a man drugged and drunk, oblivious to himself, hurting you? There is no logic here. Neither is her changing mood in the courtroom. Neither is her blank face and joy the day after she showed up with a bruise on her cheek. I've seen women who really have been beaten by their husbands. Amber is nothing like them.

Amber's lawyer (Rottenborn): He apologized for his abusive behavior, which proves he did it. Amber's lawyer (Bredehoft): He never apologized for anything he did, he always blames it on someone else! *PICK ONE*

I literally burst out laughing when this tool said "He blaims other people for his problems". Wow, if I remember correctly, Amber is the only one that takes zero responsibility...

Having to walk on eggshell because she's afraid of what will set him off......but she'll chase him, belittle him, berate him, call him a baby, hit him....yeah, SOOOOOOO SCARED!

She recorded everything she could. Why wouldn’t Ah record the worst injuries she claims she suffered? It is unbelievable

One thing puzzles me...during the trial great mention was made about "bruises" on her face. Surely if Johnny HAD punched her as often as she claimed, especially as he was wearing his rings, she would not only have bruising and swelling, she would have numerous CUTS on her face? Also, if she was sexually assaulted by Johnny using a bottle, she would have suffered such extensive internal injuries she would have needed to be RUSHED TO HOSPITAL FOR EMERGENCY SURGERY? Instead, she decided she didn't need to go. This must surely have suggested that she was NOT assaulted in any way, therefore was not injured?

Her defense attorney sounds like he’s having a hard time believing the shit that spewed out of her mouth. Now he hast to convince the jury! What a freaking joke!

It’s painful hearing them spew her lies like they are facts when there’s clear evidence of her being abusive and plotting all of this stuff for her own gain .

Elaine says throughout that "Mr. Depp never takes responsibilty for his actions" Meanwhile those of us that have been watching have seen him own up to the drug/alcohol abuse throughout the trial.

Didn't he contract an MRSA infection in his wound? Even without this, it would have been excruciatingly painful to hit somebody with an injury as severe as Johnny's. Why would anybody do that to themselves, Amber?

I hope the jurors see that Elaine is not only lying, but she’s being super disrespectful to Johnny and his attorneys. I cannot get over the lies coming out of Elaine’s mouth.

I did hear her in a lot of her recordings, and someone who is such a victim of abuse would never be so antagonizing. I find it disgusting that anyone could believe any of the crap coming out of her mouth.

Its intriguing to watch both Amber and her legal team throughout. When Johnny's lawyers were closing Amber was smiling, acting like there were no issues, but her team was clearly stressed and frustrated. As soon as her lawyers come up she stops smiling, looking down trodden and like she is the victim.

I’m dead 🤣🤣 47:47 when the lawyer says “they’re calling her a gold digger “ and Johnny says “SHE IS” 😂😂 SHADEEEEE

Do you notice how, with the stairwell story, she makes you completely forget that she and her sister fighting was the cause of the whole thing? Instead you focus on JD getting in between them then Amber punching him. This is a really good example of how manipulators are able to throw you off of their bad behavior to make you focus on something else. Instead of “yeah I was fighting with my sister and Johnny tried to break us up” it’s “Johnny got involved and I thought he would kill my sister! So I punched him to save her.” She made it about him and supposedly her fear of him when the true story was her attacking her sister on the stairs. I so hate people like her !

When a victim is blamed for everything for years it becomes a habit to say “I did/said this or that”. That poor man, whenever he tried to stand up for himself he ended up apologizing for things that she did to him. It is very common behavior. We feel ashamed what they did to us. Whatever is the outcome AH is over. For weeks she mentioned more and more evidences and she never showed us anything. I am convinced that whenever Johnny tried to stand up for himself AH pumped him up for ‘evidence’. And she knew he would feel bad about himself. She is a monster. I am worried about her child.

If he blames everyone else for his problems then he wouldn’t admit to being a drug addict, an alcohol addict, he wouldn’t have admitted to knowing that he’s late to sets (as if that somehow means he’s a wife beater). He is completely open about all his own problems. Not once did amber open up to any of her flaws. She always denies responsibility for her actions.

Their whole closing argument was “we all know and you know” they really have no evidence or anything lol

Pretty unprofessional of an attorney to call someone names. “Animal” “Disgusting” …etc. Like, I get you have a client and reputations to uphold..but being an asshole is ridiculous.

I am glad that this is almost over, I pray Johnny finally gets the justice he deserves.

This was hard to watch. Being abused and having fingers pointed at you destroys you, you can see it on his face. Heart goes out to the captain I feel the pain.

Elaine bredehoff is not giving a closing argument she is once again giving testimony on the floor as she did throughout the trial. The reason why Elaine remembers so much is that she helped Amber concoct every lie that was told on the witness stand by Amber Heard. Elaine's performance in that courtroom was unethical and contemptible and should be looked at closely by the bar association.

I was Not on a side until seeing evidence and watching just a little of this! She better pray karma never puts her in a real abusive relationship because NO one will believe her after this BS she has done to this man!

It’s not Johnny’s fault that she doesn’t have jobs anymore, it’s her fault for all she orchestrated against Johnny and her lies. A person like this doesn’t deserve anything.

To be honest she attracted all the hate to herself, bullshitting everybody, constantly lying and making herself look ridiculous

Dude he legit admitted to what he did wrong He never lied He faced it like a man Elaine obviously wasn’t paying attention! She was too busy trying to find the mics button ! Lmao

Victims of domestic violence DO NOT and WOULD NEVER provoke their abuser and insult them and be all psychotic! She's so pathetic and crazy!

Amber's lawyers, scraping the bottom of the barrel, grasping at straws, is humiliating. This lawyer, is like a dog, chasing a parked car. Amber, just ruined her teams career.

Damn, her lawyers suck… Stumbling on words here, getting facts mixed up there, confusing the jury everywhere…. Doesn’t look good lol

He says the tape of Jonny saying for her to cut him or he will was awful. It was awful to hear a man in that pain and mental anguish

This, has to be one of the weirdest closing statements that there is. It's almost like when you ask somebody to give you a recap of a show...and they start acting out the whole thing. It was not coherent, it lost me so many times

If my daughter told me her husband made her bruises, I would call the cops at a minimum and certainly wouldn’t still send them friendly and loving texts.

This is sleezy as hell. I know they have to go as hard as possible, but to fully gaslight the jury to tell them abuse is things that could happen to anyone is disgusting

The officers never said they would make an arrest. They said they saw no injuries on AH/ damage to property.

More to the point, she can't prove that he abused her. He has certainly proved that she abused him. And she admits as much!

Surely the jury finds her lawyers as repulsive as I do. Elaine is nauseating with this ridiculous argument. Everything she’s saying about Johnny is actually exactly what Amber has done! It’s unbelievable! There’s just no way Johnny can lose. I’m praying the justice system comes through for him.

It’s difficult to take Elaine seriously. Her closing arguments had so many discrepancies with hearsay evidence I just started zoning out. Even the evidence of vile text messages, as damning as they are, don’t prove JD did anything more than talk shit after losing his temper.

Imagine paying 6M on legal fees to be represented by 3 clowns 🤡🤡

What made me feel like she was NOT a victim was her filming him smashing cabinets. When my dad would start smashing things in a rage, the last thing i would do is film him. I would actually go in another room and hide so i wasn't in his sights and he wouldn't start taking it out on me. She didn't seem scared AT ALL! Almost like she was hoping to catch something exciting... like a sick freak!

"It was heart rendering for her to HAVE to do this"...the ONLY times she has looked sad is when she was on the stand, trying her damnedest to produce real tears(which she never has). She has sat by her lawyers smiling and smirking every time Johnny's injuries were brought up. For some reason, they let Spiegel ramble on about all the characteristics of what makes someone a narcissist, and EVERY SINGLE ONE of them was something we've seen or heard from Amber throughout the course of this trial. Yesterday, she was sad while her guy questioned her, but as soon as Camille got up there, she went stone faced. Camille berated her with question after question and she didn't break down crying like a true victim would, sitting there being hounded about what ACTUALLY happened to her. No, she started getting angry. But as soon as 'Objection' was called, it was like a director yelling, 'Cut', right back to stone faced. 'Overruled'('Action!'), right back to angry! There has been ZERO evidence proving that Johnny abused her, but overwhelming evidence that she abused him, falsified evidence, falsified testimony, and admitted yesterday that the Op-Ed was indeed about Johnny

The amount of abuse she claims she's gone through...she'd legit have been going out on stretchers multiple times to hospital. Punching in the back of the head? Bruh, those punches are illegal in boxing because they easily cause bleeding in the brain...that's with cushioned gloves. She got punched in the back of the head, multiple times with huge ass rings round the person's fingers? And she was absolutely fine? Yeah okay...

Now we found out she didn't pay $6 million for her defense. Two insurance companies paid for it. Now they are suing her. Karma is a B...

She obviously never walked around eggshells around him, she taunted him, that does not make any kind of logical sense to taunt your abuser. I truly believe she staged a lot of the supposed evidence, she's not stupid. Abusers do not surround the abused with family and friends, they isolate them

"She would have to be the dumbest person in the world to say, 'I'm going to commit an abuse hoax but let's do it before I go on national television.'" Rottenboy described what Amber Heard did perfectly with that statement. Also, on a serious note, it's sadly not the first time a woman has lied about being abused/assaulted by a man. It's women like Amber that make it hard for ACTUAL victims of abuse to be believed.

Just in case you read this…. It’s actually rare to see objections during. Closing arguments because its a jerk move to do so. Ben chu objected and won every single one because she was mis-representing evidence and witness testimony. She also misstated the law multiple times, was really shady and rambly

I can't stand it and it's so frustrating to hear Amber or her lawyers telling all these lies and false accusations! All the things she accuses Johnny of are the things she did to him and she did a lot more than we know! Johnny might be lucky he's still alive, she would've done anything to get what she wants!!!

She refused to leave when he told her to. she didn’t leave his property and wouldn’t accept he wanted out of the relationship... that in itself is serious abuse.

I want to see AHs face when she loses. I really hope the jury can see through the lies we've all had to witness.

I actually think that AH being shamed and mocked and her claims debunked on social media is very important. I dont agree with death threats but the backlash against her is because there is overwhelming evidence against her. HER actions, no one else's and she continues to lie and lie and lie. She is utterly vile

I swear I don't know who's the worse liar, Amber 💩 or her legal team !!

I think it’s funny how she only seems to get “emotional” when her lawyers are the ones up talking. Otherwise she’s very smug.

If they let amber win they send the message that as a man, no matter how much evidence you have and no matter how many times the abuser lies under oath, you will always lose.

so in my old AP World class, our teacher would show us a documentary about the Duke Lacrosse Trial and would have us write an LEQ an hour into it (where we only saw the evidence of the victim) and then the next day we’d write one after the doc ended to see how it changed. Almost all of us sided with the victim at first, but nobody could side with her after the hard evidence that proved her wrong. I have a feeling that this teacher will be using Heard and Depp’s trial in coming years

U don’t have to be perfect u just have to be an actual victim and tell the truth

You know what her counsel did? They were like, “what the hell do we say….” then ELAINE was like, “Pretend that depp is amber and act like we’re talking about him and just pin all her crimes on him.”

This woman doesn’t walk on eggshells for anyone. She could take up cage fighting, in fact, that may be a good idea as a new career path because she sure is going to need one. She never shows fear ever in any of the recorded conversations. She is a real hag in all of those conversations. She’s definitely an antagonist which is exactly what you would never be if you were genuinely afraid or a real victim if violence. No merit in this argument. Perjury charges should be next. Refund the settlement to Johnny. Charge her pocketbook for her donations never fulfilled. Press perjury charges. Perhaps a Tonya Harding vs Amber Herd cage fight match.

I went through living my childhood with my sister who is a narcissist very much like Amber. They will cry wolf to get your sympathy or to get you to put your defenses down then come at you with a full on assault. It was horrible growing up around a narcissist and always feeling vulnerable, I never felt safe!

"If this was a hoax, she'd REALLY do it up" Even with this, IF she was gonna do anything, she's gonna do it right! Her lawyers tried but, hard to do that with Amber Turd. My god, the reverse Uno card attempts are amazing.

I just love how AH is smiling and laughing as JDs attorneys are speaking, but as soon as her attorneys start talking she instantly goes to a frown, shaking her head, closing her eyes and putting her head down. She is so damn predictable. If you're gonna lie and make these disgusting allegations, then ya better learn how to STAY IN CHARACTER! She is just grotesque! IMO, after hearing all of the audio, I am shocked that he kept his cool as well as he did in those situations! They act like him destroying objects, paintings, clothes, etc is "abuse", but OBVIOUSLY he was taking his angers out in that way to keep from hitting her!!! Kudos to him! Most people could not restrain themselves over time of taking that much abuse from someone! 💯 TEAM JOHNNY!!!!

"Miss Heard doesn't deny that (she punched him square in the face)" Uh, She absolutely denied ever hitting him.

"court cases are abuse" is a fun way to lower the standard for abuse and simultaneously hurt your own argument by seeming unreasonable about what is and isn't abuse

What in the flying hell is wrong with these folks? I would quit this case if I knew I had to lie or manipulate this hard

i'm crying with how Elaine really dragged the whole thing out, it's like those people that just tell a story for so long you forget what they're even talking about so you just start nodding along

If she had really been covering bruises for 4 years she wouldn't have told the jury the wrong order of colour corrector, foundation & concealer!! She even said the 1st & 2ns days were redness but a min later said the 1st & 2nd days are purple. Plus you would NEVER put the colour corrector on top of foundation & concealer, it always always is used first!! She described the order of how to create a bruise with her bruise kit which is actually captured in the pic of Johnny with the spilt ice-cream!! A theatre bruise kit is on the table!!! You can find the same one online.

I thought the closing arguments were very interesting and Johnny’s team did an awesome job of orientating the jury to what was expected of them to reach a favourable decision for Johnny. I’m Australian and stayed up all night watching it live, the eye bags today were totally worth it. Amber’s team did make some interesting points but had so little time they had to speed through which as a jury member at times would have been hard to keep up with. I think Johnny’s team were stronger and the fact that they had about 40 minutes for rebuttal statements really played in their favour. Amber’s team had 6 minutes for rebuttal which basically gave them no real scope to answer back Johnny’s lawyers except in a superficial way. I did think on balance their were interesting points made by all but Johnny’s were founded in fact. They tried to discredit him again and play up that all his witnesses were on his pay roll and the fact that he was so well known meant people came out of the ‘woodwork to testify for him’. They couldn’t miss this last jab to pull him down, even mentioning how he’d hurt his kids. Johnny’s face at that made me want to cry. In fact their whole closing argument had me emotional as I saw in a nutshell how this man was treated and watched the anguish on his face as he relived it yet again. In contrast Amber sat there with her resting bitch face on, only coming out of it to smirk at things said by team Johnny and pass notes to her lawyers. She even maintained eye contact with the jury and pulled her ‘I’m such a victim’ face. I hate that she thinks she represents true domestic violence victims. Most importantly I pray with all my heart that the jury take time to weigh the facts and find for Johnny. On a side note Amber’s team bought up that she was being humiliated in public etc., how did they know if they didn’t view social media or other media platforms? God I hate the lies she fabricated and the web of hatred she spun around Johnny. She’s like a black widow spider, seduce her prey then ‘kill’ (discredit etc.) them when they are down!

You know I have worked with women and children who have been physically and mentally abused. They have a difficult time talking about the things that happened to them, some go into this very emotional state, they have a tendancy of tembling, sweating, inability to look at others in the eyes or to hold their heads up... all of the women who were in abusive relationships never dared argued back or with, laughed at or challenged their abusers. These women have all said there was ZERO, NONE, NADA eye contact, physical contact with, communication of any sort nor fostering friendship with ANY males whether it be long time friends, co workers, or just any male strangers. They were also afraid to trust or get romantically involved during or after being in an abusive relationship. Amber Heard was sneaking men into the penthouse, had no problem snuggling and cuddling with her boy toys while being married to someone whom she and her leeching friends and family refer to as a monster... lol and whom she claims to be so afraid of. Smh

Elaine is an intellectual insult to all educated Americans. She should be ashamed of herself for bombarding the jury with this unhinged, manic rant, especially after arguing on behalf of her client in bad faith for so much of this trial.

Elaine is a real piece of work, I was wondering what kind of things she would be saying, only to find out that it was bullshit from start to finish. Like legit her beginning statement was to blatantly disregard everything JD had shown when we, who had been following this case, all knew was true, literally lying to our face the second she came up. This is honestly baffling

"he has never accepted responsability for anything in his life" "he has blamed everybody in the world, his agent, his manager, his lawyer, amber, his friends, everybody, but he's never accepted responsability for a thing he's done in his life" well aint that a lovely summary of amber herself huh

Just thought I'd add, Ben's objections during Elaine's closing was because she kept crossing the line and saying things that she really shouldn't she was breaking rules like crazy. I.e. when she said Waldman planted ideas in people and when she misrepresents peoples testimonies. So he wasn't just throwing her off he was doing his job and actually they really don't like objecting during closing arguments and the judge agreed with his objections that's why they stayed at the bench so long... I learned all this from Emily D. Baker who is a lawyer and stuff

AH’s attorney’s did a HORRIBLE job stating her case. That was bizarre! Elaine literally scolded the jury with her tone. She said “YOU KNOW he did these things” but have NO PROOF!! Why would anyone believe such serious accusations without a stitch of proof?!?! I wish the Australia audio was easier to hear and allowed to be included. Amber’s entire story could be thrown out if they heard that audio.

The “I chopped my finger off” argument means nothing. If someone pushed me, and I broke my arm, I’d say “I broke my arm…”

She can’t hide her smug reactions and feigned ptsd sadness. It’s hard to have compassion for someone who’s tried to defame someone else due to their own insecurities.

She destroyed everything, Johnny never touched her or anybody else in his life, he should be given a medal for keeping up with her and keep his cool, he lived in a hellish nightmare from the moment he met Amber Heard!!!

Everything her lawyer is saying has already been proven as lies. The jury straight up heard the main guy say her subpar acting was the reason they didn't want her for the next movie 🙄

Watching Johnny's face is heartbreaking, you can see that this has just brought everything back up and you can see how much it affects him thinking about it. Everything Rottenbourne is saying sounds like he's talking about Johnny... apologising for things that aren't your fault and your abuser trying to make you feel like you're in the wrong so you dont realise how bad they are. Also yes Amber apologised, but it was sarcastic and mocking him so it's not really an apology, just more abuse.

The fact that amber was fighting Johnny about not putting her on his will one month after their wedding says a lot about her mission…she wanted Jonny’s fortune…end of story

Amber's lawyer: "Filing for defamation is an attack on free speech. Now here's Amber's defamation claim."

I found Rottenborn's speech DISGUSTING in parts. Playing the game of saying that the jury is sending a message with their verdict....VERY INAPPROPRIATE. They should rule on this case only. I felt that JD was being traumatized again in real time by some of the things he said 🤮

If I were a juror I would be angry if a lawyer told me that they were going to speak quickly in order to give me time to deliberate, and then waste more of my time than any of the other lawyers combined. That, to me, indicates that they are just full of lies, if they can't even hold a tiny promise like not wasting my time.

The thing is, if she had kept her accusations milder, if she had claimed he slapped her occasionally, yelled, was verbally, mentally and emotionally abusive and broke things around her, threatened her, then I think with the evidence she provided, a lot more people would have believed her. I guess lucky for Depp she made such outlandish claims that no sane person would believe the punching till she lost count, numerous broken noses etc. would have not left any serious marks. She not once needed medical help. There was never any swelling, just some light discolouration.

Amber..., the puppy that just pissed on the rug look is absolutely hilarious! 🤣 🤣 🤣

The sexual assault she claimed, she had access to a nurse and did not seek her attention? WTF, a woman getting assaulted like that would be sore for ages and other people on site would have questioned her State. It would be hard to hide. Common sense it would affect her for days. Plus if that assault was committed during intoxicated attack it would have been even more brutal. What a crock of sh1t. This alone should see her charged for a serious false claim

My favorite part about all this I Amber Heard and her lawyers never meet us halfway...she is NEVER the aggressor. She is ALWAYS the victim. 100% of the time. If she ever hit Johnny or threw an object at him it was self-defense or it was in retaliation to him hitting her. Johnny and his team have stated explicitly on several occasions that he's by no means a perfect person; he gets drunk and takes pills...he sends acerbic text messages that, although probably a part of his dark sense of humor, were often poorly timed, to say the least. He has admitted to "headbutting" her, which he claims was purely accidental, and I'm inclined to believe him. He has owned up to hitting her toes with a door; again, an accident. Amber Heard, however, never instigates anything, and she lived in complete and total fear all those years they were together because she never knew when she was gonna set him off. I mean, one time all she did was ask him what one of his tattoos said and he beat the shit out of her (yeah, that's completely believable, because that's what people do). I f'ing hate Amber Heard.

Wtf is she talking about??! He’s been extremely accountable and in the most vulnerable part of his life...his addictions. AH is the one who has absolutely ZERO accountability for her behaviors. Is this the twilight zone?! I swear if JD doesn’t win this will be a gut punch to most of the world following this. Justice for Johnny!!

As a person who who survived my ex husband’s abuse….Usually when there’s a bruise by the eye…..there is some swelling.

What scares me is that only 1 jury member has to believe one instance was true for Johnny to lose. It's awful.

This "Lawyer" just ruined his career. What an egregious liar. Literal walking fallacy

I did my best to remain unbiased while watching this trial, but I must admit, I was pretty disgusted with Amber Heard's lawyers closing statements.

Listening to the AH lawyers talking about Johnny Depp and his life with her leads me to think that they should be charged with defamation of character. Verbal abuse and lies.

The audio of her saying i didnt punch you and insulting him. Just overpowers any claim by amber

He could have been saying "oh, yeah, the day that i chopped my finger off" sarcastically if Amber has blamed him for the finger saying he chopped it off himself. There is no way to tell.

The reason I think these closing statements are such a car crash is because AH has spent the past three days sitting in court writing them and instructed they be delivered verbatim rather than take any advice from her council

Interesting how he keeps choosing not to play tapes/recordings bc “you remember,” but Camille had plenty of video and audio to back up her point in ambers own word every time.