17:03 - 20:00 *DAMN!* I don't think I've ever seen somebody figure it out _this_ early in the movie!

I'm really impressed that you two got what was going on so early. Kudos!

I am impressed! you guys figured out the plot twist insanely early in the movie.

Never seen someone guess the twist that quickly 😯 I highly recommend the book, it will help you appreciate the movie even more

"if he got some sleeping pills, this wouldn't happen"... LOL

Favorite Part. When the bag tore open at the liposuction clinic and Tyler was trying to catch the fat. I remember laughing my ass off watching that.

I watched this to see how quick you both would catch the clues to the Alter Ego, and you didn't disappoint. You're faster than anyone I've seen and even Ryl caught how both men entered the car from the same driver's side door. You guys are brilliant and a joy to watch figure things out.

I think the reason why Tyler died even though he just shot himself in through the jaw was because it showed he was willing to do anything, go to any extreme, even kill himself to get rid of Tyler. And that was enough to make Tyler go away.

The bullet went through his cheek

I never met someone who understood before what was happening, including myself. You girls are really smart

There's a lot of ideas in the story. I think the main idea is it's about a society full of boys who were brought up fatherless & with very little love. So they try to fill their lives with materialism & job accomplishments, while going through life without any close relationships or ability to love.

That chemical burn, burned like hot MAAG-MAH 😅

this was the first split personality movie i'd seen, i put it together when Tyler was at the bottom of the stairs and said "this conversation is over"

You're probably a little young to know this song but... The end of the film with the Pixies song "Where is my mind"... For me the best ending of all time 😉

I was working at a movie theater when this movie premiered. I'd never seen so many people leave halfway because it wasn't actually a movie about fighting. I could get free tickets so I saw this one 5 times, bringing a different friend each time. I loved watching their reactions (like I'm enjoying yours).

I believe Tyler's explanation of the origin of soap is pretty historically accurate, hence the idea that fat from human bodies, when saponified with lye, makes the "best soap" and some of the most luxurious soaps still come from in and near the middle east.

i guess i never realized how obvious the twist in this movie was. haha

4:29 "Now he's going to have to create a group for that, for people who's addicted to groups, and pain." BOOM! You are both way too smart. :)

virtual hug

16:16 "grade school? what girl?😮" -jyn the proper reaction to hearing that. 😆

The Final Moments Of The Movie Are About Finding Peace Through Facing Issues Head-On. By shooting himself, The Narrator seemingly dismisses his Tyler Durden persona, winning the fight for control that he hadn't realized he'd been a participant in until barely half an hour prior.

👏👏👏 I watch a lot of reaction channels the ladies figured it the second fastest of all the other channels Dawn Marie figured it out fastest.

So I’m tripping out because I thought you guys already reacted to this lol. Oh, I’m stoked for this one!!! Lets go!!! Edit you guys killed the editing on this!

You gals are very Good.!!! You got it in 20 mins. Bravo 😂

I saw this movie when it was in theaters in Atlanta, Georgia. It was definitely a departure from the normal😂

You two are always quick with figuring things out well before the film shows or tells you, I knew you’d get it. Very quick witted and intelligent, for sure! Thanks for doing these, always enjoy hearing your thoughts and seeing your reactions.

Bob is Meatloaf.

Made me think of another movie though different a psychological drama also: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. One of the best low budget films since Night of the Living Dead. But loaded with movie stars between projects: Kate Winslet Jim Carey in first dramatic role and others. It was actually nominated for Academy Awards. One of my all time favorite movies.

You both figured it out the fastest! 👏🔥❤

This was such a great reaction. It's nice to see a channel really get that this movie is really freakin' funny at times, in spite of all the dark themes. Really cathartic dark humor. Helps people cope with life. The book is well worth a read, too. Even more rich and detailed than the film as is to be expected. I was 18 when I first saw this - 40 now - and feel stupid because I didn't realize the "secret" until the actual reveal. Good on you guys!

You girls are very sharp. Great reaction.

You two are forensic. Great work!

GIRLS!! The 1st Rule of Fight Club is you don't talk about Fight Club. So is the 2nd Rule..... My favorite sequences were him just yanking his boss's balls and doing whatever he wanted at work, not caring about his appearance, showing up with black eyes etc. The contrast between the normal 9 to 5 play by all the corporate rules milquetoast nobody vs a guy who is literally doing whatever he wants without fear. The other fav scene is Tyler showing no fear of the Mafia restaurant owner and turning the tables on him by bleeding and drooling all over him forcing him to admit they can keep using the basement. Great scene.

Kudos to both, you caught the twist earlier than most back in the day...back then I had to wait for the reveal lol.😊

“…It’s way-out… in the water see it swimming.” -Pixies One for the records, señoritas. Your deducting skills are impressive. Entertaining as always and quite naturally awesome. Keep on keeping on and Gritos from Tejas. “I am Jack’s complete lack of surprise.” -The Narrator

you're they only reactors who guess it right !!! nice! I never saw it coming when i saw this movie in theatre as it came out.

Awesome you two figured out the twist so early.

My imaginary best friend has always been Brad Pitt

You two are SOOO SMART! Most people never figure this out. They find out at the end when the truth is revealed. I did not figure it out. Well done!

You girls are smart as hell! It definitely took me way longer till i figured out Tyler was his alter ego! 😄 It wasn't until Edward Norton's character told Marla that "Tyler isn't here" and her looking at him scared that i was like "Oh, that's definitely what it is"

The first rule of Jyn x Ryl Club is you definitely talk about Jyn x Ryl Club. 😊

Hello JR Squad 👋

Best reaction channel

remember when i saw it in theaters - had an inkling they were the same person but wasn't sure really, and then once i saw the scene where the guys are standing on porch and tyler is on porch, then next cut he's up in window (they swap places) I knew for sure.

You guys figured this out way faster than anyone I've seen.

The lass on the right with her hair down. 🔥 Great reaction ladies. 👍🏻

Great reaction to a classic movie. Seeing those buildings pancake collapse like that at the end, four years before 9/11 was weird. GREAT reaction!

You guys are too smart! Figured it out really early.

"We're already OCD enough ", well recommending the Final Destination films is out of the question.

Impressed by your speed picking up the twist, but moreso by the attention to detail that you showed to pick up the clues....it wasn't just a hunch. Somebody else suggested this, but I think with your watching style, that you'd really enjoy a film called 'Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind' a genius film that doesn't get enough love.

Damn ladies….yall picked up the twist quick 🤯

i dono if i'm only one of the few who wasn't suprised and actually expected them to pick it up real fast.. albeit a diff genre.. i have watched their reaction to the Breakfast Club numerous times now b/c how concise and on point they were with their commentary on every single character.. especially Bender getting yelled at in the closet and how F'ed up that was.. i've heard other people empathise with Bender... yet still laugh at him at the closet scene where he gets getting unlawfully screamed at by their principal threatening him claiming 'he's all talk' not realizing he's literally a kid.. even if they eventually come to 'get it'.. these two nailed it from the first scene about every character.. they have a really awesome ability to immediately clock the issue and automatically pick up clues.. empathise with characters and give really heartfelt commentary.. or in this case.. immediately put the puzzle back together from the initial flight scene "they had the same bags".. this is how real commentary should be done on YT. Great job, girls. 💙❤ Also, if you liked this.. should check out "Snatch" with an amazing cast, Pitt included. it's much more thriller/awesome editing/hystericallll/and needing an ability to keep up with the fast pace i think you two could!

God dang, you guys figured that out fast. I’m really impressed. Also it was super funny to watch you laugh and retch at the same time.

You girls are SHARP. I've seen maybe 2 other reactors figure out who Tyler was before the reveal, and I think you two are the first to do it THAT early in the movie. You're amazing..! Anyway, I've watched this film countless times and thought about it a lot over the years. I think psychologically, it's more like Masochists Club. I think it's that the men who join feel empowered by being able to be beaten up, severely, and still survive, that the ability to fight comes in part from that. It's also social commentary that men are kind of evolutionarily adapted to fight to survive, and that the modern world has become so sanitized that since men can't do this anymore, they're wasting away chasing other forms of financial and commercial success they can't all achieve. So the fighting is partly them getting back to the core essence of "what men are supposed to do", and partly that, when spreading chaos, their ability to survive and thrive in such chaos is a flex. Because modern life is too safe, people aren't forced to prioritize whatever's truly important to them, and sacrifice the things that are lower priority. So they don't consider whatever time they have in their lives precious. (Also, Cornelius saying he heard Tyler was born "in a mental institution" is kinda funny if you've ever seen Brad Pitt's earlier film, 12 Monkeys..)

Jyn with the quickness. "Sometimes Tyler spoke for me."

This and 'Snatch' that came out around the same time are 2 of my favorite Brad Pitt films.

Sometimes Jyn and Ryl say "Ohhhh," at the same time and it makes me laugh

i tried to click it and it was gone but now its back! cant wait to see what you make of this very odd movie lets go

You keep it real, that's cool.

This movie is where the geniuses of the internet glommed onto the word "❄️"

The bullet went trough his cheek and maybe jaw, but Tyler side of his brain believed he really shot himself in the head, so he ceased to exist really believing he's dying. Most people figured out the twist when they literally revealed it near the end, at the time. You ladies were pretty observant to the clues and figured it out much earlier. Of course, this "split personality" thing wasn't as common in movies and tv shows at the time and the movie had good distractions to throw you off from those ideas but you two weren't easily distracted and discussed it enough during the movie to encourage each other's suspicion about it. I remember having that thought early similar to you but the movie went in so many interesting directions and I've brushed that idea off, as I watched it alone. I later figured it out again when Marla's reaction to the narrator saying "Tyler is not here, Tyler went away" but I don't credit myself too much about it as it's only about 5 minutes before the actual reveal.

You guys figured it out way earlier than most people

Both of yall are very bright! Love from West Virginia!

COOL that you two got it early but one clever thing happened when fat BOB saw him and mentioned Tyler's name. He DIDN'T say he started Fight Club, he said he was a Member and only went on Saturdays. He also used fake names at the Therapy Sessions so Bob didn't realize that he was actually Tyler, not until they were at Fight Club the same night! Brilliantly added scene to make you question whether you'd figured it out or not! But one thing I never noticed before is when he & Tyler both entered the drivers side of the car he crashed. WELL DONE!!! Most don't figure it out until much later or not until they tell you.

Jyn I wouldn't want to mess with! She seems strong 💪

"The guy with the tits" is the funniest way I've ever heard anybody refer to a movie character

Y'all got it quick, and can get it lol

I did make and sell soap for several years, and practically every man who walked by my booth asked me if I'd seen this damn movie. At that point, I hadn't, but felt as if I had.

you figured this out quick

If you haven't reacted to THE GAME yet, that is also a must see that will wrap your brain into a pretzel.

@18:20 This has to be a record. NO ONE figures that out this early. WOW!!!

This movie changed my whole way of thinking.

This movie was a mind-blower in the day.

u can find all sorts of sliced imaging in normal tv.

Right? I had no idea, the end was such a shock!

Not many reactors notice the first Tyler blip its when the narrator is at the copy machine tyler appears 6 times before the meeting

In the book, all he ate after work was peanut butter sandwiches. My theory is he had a mild peanut allergy which kept him from sleeping. This whole thing is because of peanut butter.

You guys picked up on the twist so quick! I first saw this in theaters and didn’t figure it out till the reveal. D.I.D or Insomnia wasn’t common knowledge in the 90’s unless you put an effort into researching and studying it…at the library

I think when he shoots himself, he fully intended to die and so mentally, he finally hit rock bottom and that free'd himself of Tyler. He was just lucky that the bullet went out the side of his face and so he narrowly survived. I never really understood the ending for quite some time and never really liked that part but I feel like I get it more now. Awesome reaction btw! :)

Ah a soft punch poor Edward because that was him throwing a real punch and Brad didnt know he was getting punched. The director told Edward to punch Brad before he was even expecting it. He wanted a real reaction. So the punch was real😂 and as you can tell he sucks at it because he was supposed punch him in the face or eye but landed on his ear. And who really expects to get hit in the ear so that why Brad had that reaction.

For me, it was around the time "Tyler disappeared" and "unnamed protagonist" starts flying all over trying to find him. Idk if you caught that or not, but they never give Edward Norton's character a name. It could be Tyler, or Tyler is the name of the alter.

17:13... Girl... you're too smart. LOL

Could’ve sworn they reacted to this already

You guys are sharp. Haven't seen many people figure out the twist so early in the movie. I didn't first time I watched lol

They both knew the plot twist and pretended not to.😧 just my opinion 🤷‍♂

At least Sisters knows ♥

I didn't figure it out until the final reveal at the hotel cause I was just chilling and not thinking much when I watch movies. I think it was the sleep disorder because he was working for a corrupt car company that has a high death rate and he can't really do anything about it other than go to the accidents, file the report about the bodies and such. Also because he doesn't feel any connection and is trapped by materialism so Tyler was his escape.

I’m mad y’all figured it out so quick lol I’m ngl 😅

you can figure it out a LOT of times until the reveal :D

Tyler had to steal a car so he could get to the narrators apartment while he was dealing withhis luggage issue, Tyler didn't have much time to set it up

Dude just wanted to hold hands and cry a bit

David Fincher director a great movie i watched many times , maybe if you watch it again you will get the sense of it .

26:10 "what!? dude!" -jynxryl

Angle was little off it went out of his cheek, but important thing was because he finally was free and did not afraid to even die, so no more need of Tyler, so Tyler died.

She said he got there fast because remember he sat the phone up on the top not hanging it up and left immediately to see her when she kept talking on the phone making her say wow you got here fast !

if i remember one theory say marla doesn't exist. my favorite movie with old boy. maybe one day :)

47:15 best break down I have seen from reactors to this film

I love Jamie as a character, but he's still a villain in this story. We see flashes of honor in him because he's a bit grey, so wr think he's growing, but when he threated Edmund's new born kid in Season 6, he's letting us know there that he's still the kind of guy who would push a child from a window.

I have insomnia, thank God not this bad😊

RIP ying yang table :(