What got me was Higgins, after being told to preserve his phone, snapped the SIM card, and threw the phone and sim card away in separate dumpsters on a military base.

Brian Albert was not retired at the time of the offense. It was after John’s death that he retired, moved and rehomed his dog.

I’d like to know what the neighbors REALLY caught on their ring camera

This is 1000% a case of a group of dirty cops eliminating the threat to their racket. I grew up near Canton and can affirm, those cops are corrupt af.

What a shit show this case is. The entire investigation or lack Of investigation from start to finish

His brain injuries are consistent with blows to his temple areas, more pronounced on his left temple. His arm is undeniably cut due to multiple dog bites. And the FBIs experts (both have PhDs in physics related fields) testified that if the laws of physics prove that both his injuries couldn't have come from being hit by a vehicle and the damage to the vehicle wasn't from hitting a person. Boston cops killed another Boston cop, refinished the basement flooring, gave away the dog after it attacked another dog and two people (and have no idea where the dog is apparently) and sold their house. Then changed their numbers, deleted calls and texts, denied verifiable calls, changed their lies multiple times under oath and will likely get away with the murder.

Jen McCabe is Brian Albert’s sister in law. 😂 her sis is married to Brian.

They may have planned on painting it on the snowplow driver, but then they saw that she had a crack in her tail light and thought that was even better

Proctor said horrible things about her. He claimed he was going to make sure she was guilty.

Don't forget the victims Apple health data shows him walking into the house and climbing up and down stairs, then walking another 80 steps after Karen Reed is already home.

Ring camera footage was also tampered with at the Albert’s!!

All the cops were in on it. Full stop.

Brian Higgins giving investigator Procter a hard drive of his phone texts after deleting chosen texts is an indication of guilt.

i went into this case thinking she was guilty. Then i watched the trial & evidence or lack of. i believe she’s innocent.

Jenn pinned it on Karen by twisting the "did I hit him?" to "I did hit him!" So they all jumped in on the false narrative.

jen mccabe is brian albert’s sister in law. why would they cover it all up? 1) brian albert was a boston cop of like 29 years. he has a giant pension 2) bryan higgins is an atf agent. 3) chris albert, brian’s brother, is on like the city council and if i know the time line correctly was in the middle of an election cycle for like city council. he also owns a pizza joint in downtown canton. 4) they covered it up because they all had careers to protect. imagine if your months away from retirement or work for the feds and it gets found out that you killed a dude.

She is innocent. I don't understand what is taking so long

Even if she isn't innocent, it sounds like negligence from the cops will make it impossible to do anything. And it's far too coincidental to be true.

They never planned to pint it on Read but when she was out of her mind at the crime scene the opportunity presented itself. That is exactly why 8 of them met at that house later that morning.

This was a great synopsis of the case! Great job!

TurtleBoy was the first to brake this story wide open

Karen Read is innocent. Proctor, Higgins and Lally should be fired. The Albert’s, McCabe’s and Higgins should be charged with obstruction of justice and perjury! Unfortunately at this point they can’t say all who was involved with John’s murder so true justice will never be done for him.

I don't know what killed John O'Keefe, but I can say beyond a reasonable doubt, to a moral certainty, it was NOT getting hit by a Lexus.

Proctor (Trooper) Text with mates: Home owner will get heat? Proctor replied: Nope ... He's a Boston Cop too.

They knew to blame it on her; possibly when John showed up, they asked where Karen was and he said she dropped me off and went home. Then they looked at the doorbell ring camera and figured where she turned around at.

A few items incorrect but overall an absolutely excellent summary of the case. As to how they decided to pin it on Karen, I think it was just a matter of taking advantage of the opportunity. Original plan was probably to say he got hit by a snow plow. Then Karen shows up, hysterical, without a clear memory of what happened the night before, having cracked her taillight on John’s car, and Jen McCabe figured they had the perfect patsy...

FYI- There’s a difference between innocent and not guilty. No one is proving her innocence. It’s guilty, not guilty or a hung jury. If they find her not guilty that does not mean she’s innocent! It means the Common Wealth did not prove their case to the jury beyond a reasonable doubt.

Scary as hell that a jury can sit for months, listen to the same discrepancies that you outline in your video, and have yet to reach a verdict of not guilty after days of deliberations! Seriously, what are they debating? Any one of the evidentiary anomalies pointed out is enough to establish reasonable doubt, there are literally dozens of such anomalies. Unfortunately,a jury of our peers can often include members of very marginal intelligence!

The McCabes and the Alberts could have saved John O'Keefe's life, but they knew he would speak about how they beat him up, so they left him to die.

ummmm she is obviously not guilty… there is proof that the tail light was still intact on the camera… so, obviously someone broke it to try to frame her… why is there even a debate? 😂

Jen McCabe came up with the KR story!! The players in this story have not kept their mouths shut!! Colin is involved and has been in on the assault with BH!!

Karen had the same confusion as the guy in the movie My Cousin Vinny when he repeated what he was told. She didn't kill him.

They need to go after the real murderers and all their cases need looked into because this is disgusting.

Calls are not deleted, just erased from your phone. The call data is retained by the provider forever.

It only takes a *player,* and a *ref.* to *”fix”* a championship.. NOT the whole team. In the case of Karen Read, it only takes a *”Proctor,”* and a *”McAlbert,”* …once the fix is in place, the rest will lead the way… *SHE. WAS. FRAMED.*

I’m not saying she’s innocent but she’s not guilty based off the evidence the commonwealth presented therefore she should get a not guilty verdict

Those dog bites on him look just like the wounds I had when I was mauled by a large dog. Exactly like my wounds.

It doesn’t even matter if she’s guilty or not. They can’t prove that she did jt. There are too many questions and too much reasonable doubt. The cops are corrupt, they need to let her go

Brian Albert and Higgins took iphones to military base, destroyed them.

Also he needs to know there wasn't a lot of snow when they found John's body their ended up being a lot of snow but there was no more than two to three inches which isn't that much considering they had a leaf blower and six people shoulder to shoulder searching and found zero tail light pieces

She landed in their laps. Luck of the Irish.

INNOCENT, NOT GUILTY

The biggest problems for the prosecution are the ones where the evidence disproves their own theory. 1. They firmly stood by their claim that Karen's vehicle taillight struck John. Experts explained how the human body cannot break the polycarbonate on that taillight. Maybe karen hurt john in some other way, who knows, but the prosecution stuck to its claim that karen broke her taillight on John's body. It's not possible. 2. The prosecution stuck to its claim that John was wounded at Fairview at 12:45. Karen's cell phone would have already been gone as she reconnected to John's wifi at 12:36. The prosecution couldnt adjust their timeline because there were people that would have seen Karen strike john before 12:45. Yes, there is ALOT more, but in a court of law facts are what matter and these two items squash the ability to find her guilty.

Reasonable Doubt 💯

its simple: if the car didnt hit - you must acquit

Funny thing about that 24 mph backing in the snow, ever spin the wheels. 😂 This was a huge coverup

Thanks for the straight to the point summary of the case!

They were going to try and pin it on the snow plow driver first until Jen seen Karen's tailight cracked

Those two kids you mentioned lost their mom and their dad within two months and then this happens with their guardian. This family is going through hell.

It's not like they had to come up with some big elaborate plan to frame Karen Read. They knew the snow plow would be coming by once it started snowing, and if they left him out by the curb then they could just blame the plow driver. They weren't originally planning on framing KR, but when she called and showed up at the house looking for JOK in the early AM before the plow driver or some other person could discover his body, they had to change their story on the fly. Karen was in shock and didn't understand how her boyfriend was lying near the street, dead in the snow, when he was perfectly fine a few hours prior when she dropped him off. Obviously she's not going to automatically assume the friggin cops inside 34 Fairview murdered him and left him outside to die, so she's trying to come up with some logical explanation as to why he's lying there near the road, dead. So she asks "did I hit him? Could I have hit him?". Then Jen McCabe's evil ass hears her say that, and decides to run with it.

Awesome summary thank so much ! New sub ❤

INNOCENT

The injuries/wounds to Mr. Pledge do not correspond to being struck by a vehicle, but do correspond to being the victim of a beating and dog attack.

That Lexus did not hit John and Lally knows this. The tail light was cracked Jan 29 at 5:07 AM when Karen bumped into John’s Traverse. It was cracked, not yet shattered, as of Jan 29 afternoon in Dighton. It was destroyed by shattering it into dozens of pieces after Proctor had the Lexus brought back to the Canton PD sally port. I can’t understand why the trial went on so long. I had hoped that the prosecution’s job is to find justice (and by “justice” I mean find the guilty person) but it appears to be gaslight the jury and win the case at all costs. The sally port picture shows hardly any lens remaining and it’s on the wraparound right hand side of the tail light. This taillight was only cracked, not decimated, all the way into Jan 29 afternoon. Lally, who is detail oriented, gaslights the jury by not acknowledging the two levels of tail light damage: cracked and missing a piece vs shattered into dozens of pieces AFTER the Lexus comes back to Canton. At 5:08 as the Lexus is leaving Johns driveway (immediately after bumping into the Traverse) to meet up with Jen McCabe and Kerry Roberts, John’s security camera shows the running and brakes lights working with plenty of red light showing and a dark spot on the right tail light. Kerry Roberts testified Day 16, May 22 (KZfaq, Law & Crime @3:15) observing the Lexus tail light at Jen McCabe’s house shortly before John was found the morning ofJan 29: “And I looked and there was a piece missing… but it was caked on with snow… you could tell there was a little black hole…” Dighton Police Sergeant Barros testified Day 22, June 10 (KZfaq, Law & Crime @2:04) about his observations in Dighton of the cracked tail light Jan 29 afternoon shortly before Proctor had the Lexus brought back to Canton: “I saw there was some damage to the right rear tail light… um... to my best ability and recollection that tail light was not completely damaged. It was cracked and a piece was missing, but not completely damaged.”

So the question is who really did it.

Not guilty real bad police work!!!!They drop the case all the way !!! Should have never been brought to many lies in state case!!!

Anyone who believes she's guilty is proof that there are people in this world who aren't too normal up there in the🧠 P.S, that includes the jury

Not enough evidence to proof her guilt

Maybe karen opened the narrative when she called Jen Mc Cabe looking for John …. The spotlight switched from the plow driver to Karen

Nice breakdown, thanks girl!

My daughter was at this court today and said: All the fucking people outside with party gear. A man fucking died and they have no respect

They were going to blame it on the plow driver until Karen supposedly commented did I hit him and they then had their cover up and turned it into “I hit him, I hit him!” i cant wait for the Not Guilty and I pray they go after the McAlberts!!

Free Karen Read she is 100% Innocent 💕

So all those police, EMT's, Fireman, and others are going to risk their careers and risk heavy prison time to cover up an accidental death for someone many of them didn't even know; without any one of them deciding to snitch; and then pinning it on some innocent person. What a stretch.

New subscriber. You have a knack for true crime. Impressive critical thinking skills. ❤️‍🔥

Good summary from this host. Finally someone with brains

Excellent summary of the case.

I am not even considering the "hos long" because it may or may not be registered at 2.27 because thats the time the tab in Safari was opened. Even without this smoking gun it is absolutely impossible he was hit by a car. Solo cups, dog bites wounds and experts engineers confirmed my opinion.

I just hope the jury reads and understands the verdict forms and find Karen not guilty!

Definitely watch the town Select Board Meeting from last night (Chris Albert is a Selectman) is was insane. The town wanted the police chief gone- she recently hit a 67 year old man with a reflection vest on using a cane while he was in a cross walk and it was covered up for months. Then there is the death of Sandra Birchmore. She was a pregnant 23 year old that supposedly killed herself, but after a reexamination it looks like she was murdered by a cop in the neighboring town that had sexually abused her from age 15, and passed her around to other cops. She lived in Canton and a lot of the same cops are involved- including Kevin Albert. There is also a group of McCabes and Alberts- including Colin and town selectman Chris Albert that harrased an assaulted a blogger known as Turtleboy and his girlfriend Sunday night on camera on the street. Two people have charges over this. This incident showed me who these people are in public, which leads me to believe in private and very drunk they are quite dangerous.

Don't forget about the FBI's investigation that basically provided all the additional evidence and the two experts

The friend and family network covered up John death to protect themselves and framed Karen (She is a outsider) Watch the closing statements, the defense went hard and Brian Albert was sitting behind the defense, trying to intimidate the jury, pissed off.😂😂Brian Albert didn’t come outside to check on the dead cop on his lawn but he came to court to see Karen be convicted, total coward.

Not GUITLTY Karen Read Not Guilty

Great overview!!! 👌 Also, the dog had a history of biting/attacking people. And isnt it wild to think that without alcohol none of this would have happened? Alcohol is practically the root of all evil... Or at least it coaxes evil out and unleashes a lot of hell on this planet. An incredible number of terrible and unspeakable things would never happen if so many people weren't drinking. Furthermore, a lot of people are walking around with a slight case of undiagnosed fetal alcohol syndrome which doesn't have the physical markers of full blown FASD but causes severe emotional issues, impulsivity and negatively affects one's capacity to make sound life decisions. Sorry this turned into a rant about the perils of alcohol in our society lol ... 😆 Anyway, this case is the craziest one I've ever seen.

That's why I bought a Wyze Camera. And not a ring camera.

Look up the case of Sandra Birchmore in Canton!

No, it said “ hos long to die in cold”

idk if she did it or not. But the prosecution did not prove beyond reasonable doubt. I think Karen's story is odd. I think all the evidence the investigators have is odd. If I had to guess what happened, there was a lot of drinking going on and an argument ensued. John gets knocked out, left in the cold, isn't checked on by anyone at the party, possibly assuming his wife will be there to pick him up. Evidence gets set up so an officer, and possibly the people at the party aren't charged with voluntary manslaughter. If I was on the jury, I would immediately say not guilty based off the ring video "coincidentally" not working during the most critical time. Just like with the Epstein death situation for example, and how the prison cameras weren't working when he "committed" suey. It opens the path for reasonable doubt. In a world of surveillance. I don't trust any camera just coincidentally not working during the times of a crime, and then suddenly working again a few hours or half hour later. Bizarre case.

Lucky 🍀 plow driver was the hero (knew Albert family for Decades) but told the Truth! He originally was the scapegoat.

Idk how the jury is hung this is a not guilty

Tail lights started at 3 , at all …..turned out 15 pieces in 3 weeks ‼️

I have trouble with her drinking that much because of her intestinal problem. With what she did drink, I believe she needed to go home and care for herself. If so, John was being so so selfish. Or he could have just wanted to make an appearance and then leave. He didn't get a chance to get away from them. Jen (as she testified) was the lookout, because she was reporting about karens movements with her car. I'm sure, also, watching to see if karen would walk up to the house. Karen leaving, may have saved her life.

When Karen said did I hit him could u hit light bulb went off in Jen head!!!!

Turtleboy 🐢 broke the story. It went viral. His Blogs are great well researched.

Jen was looking out the window and saw Karen’s car in the driveway when she and John 1st arrived. She most likely saw John get out & Karen leave in a hurry due to a disagreement with her bf or saw John was upset when he 1st got in the house from the argument which in turn gave a premise to an alternative explanation to those who were desperate to hide what they had done

It was, how long to die in the cold.

I just came across your video! I've been following this case for awhile and on verdict watch right now! But to answer a question you asked about why did the frame KR because she was a civilian!

This case has too many dirty hands in it, and the evidence and police testimonies have been clearly manipulated and twisted....

You are incorrect. The M.E. never gave a cause of death that's the whole point.

How did Proctor even know about Karen's heath issues? Who told him about that?

Excellent breakdown. She is being framed. Reasonable Doubt 🙋‍♀️

Chris Albert is John O’Keefes neighbor and they were kinda feeding because their kid was cutting through his yard! Albert’s got all “Karen” on John.

Don't forget the snowblower and red solo cups!

My gut tells me Karen is Guilty but the trial tells me shes innocent if that makes sense😅..

I think the narrative started after they saw her tail light cracked when she backed into Johns car

We are all innocent. Correction on your tag, not guilty or guilty. 😊

Another scenario, John was at the Albert's house front door, the Albert's dog was let out the back of the house. Khloe came around the house, saw John and attacked his arm. John ran toward the street to get Karen's attention who was leaving in her SUV so he threw his drink glass at the SUV which broke the tail light and while running, John slipped on the snow covered road and hit his head on the curb. He drug himself to the flag pole. The blizzard conditions covered up this trail. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Karen had shown Jen McCabe her tailight was cracked when they were outside Okeefes house (missing Ring video) right before finding him on the Alperts lawn. Gave Jen the idea and she made up the rest?🤔

After tearing up a portion of the basement floor, the Alberts sold their home for $50K under market value. I spent too much time this week watching hours of testimony. This case has so many details. Brian Albert says the call he made to the investigator at 2:27 am was a butt dial while he was having sex with his wife...... I think Colin Albert beat O'Keefe up in the basement where the dog then attacked him. Chris Albert, Colin's parents were next door neighbors to John OKeefe and John complained about Colin throwing beers cans in his yard .... you need to see the photos Chris Albert took of himself and his wife straddling OKeefe fence and then sent the photo to John with the text, look where we are..... Alan Jackson is a genius. Alcohol played a major role in this tragedy. Camera footage shows how many vodka's Karen had ..... Brian Higgins left the party at Alberts because they only had beer. The text messaging between him and Karen over a couple weeks is cringe adolescent .....

Not only did they use solo cups, but six of them they only tested one of them