This is such a beautiful song. I've come back to it several times throughout the years. Katharine McPhee is an incredible talent and deserves much more recognition.

Why is the girl not A mega star,I have always loved her.Her voice is amazing

My God... that`s what I call singing from the heart... One of the most beautiful songs I`ve ever heard and such a heavenly voice!

This is still one of my fav pop albums. I love her sweet voice

why shes not a mega star is beyond me....her voice is ELITE and shes gorgeous...total talent...if you want to hear another magnificent performance by her...check out her duet with bocelli "The Prayer" wowow fantastic

In 4 years, not even 2 million views yet. What a shame.. Good music goes unnoticed all the time while crappy music be having like over 100 million views in less than a year.

she's underrate and deserve more than this,she's talent and her voice is beautiful.

Chase said that to Cameron "did you ever loved me?" The song is good, and so binge watching House.

Paige Dineen (scorpion)....Robert Chase (Dr house) simply beautiful..... Amazing voice of katherine mcphee!!!

specifically searched for this video just to watch Jesse Spencer. and, of course, i wasn't disappointed

The song is so sad but it makes u cry more when u realize the song is about him leaving her when he commits suicide

If I seem distant Baby I am Words are like scissors in your hands And there’s no script to follow So I just close my eyes That way it won’t hurt so much When we say goodbye I feel just like an actress Up on the stage I can’t believe What I’m hearing myself say And the porch light is my spotlight So I play along with this life That way it won’t hurt so much When we say goodbye Did you ever love me? Does it even matter? Did you even notice the whole world shatter? I just want to hold you ‘til you know I’m sorry But I just keep it all inside That way it won’t hurt so much When we say goodbye My heart feels like a circus It’s to much to take in It’s hard to lose love But you were my best friend So I walk this high wire Alone….tonight That way it won’t hurt so much When we say goodbye That way it won’t hurt so much When we say goodbye

Katharine McPhee is definitely one of the best singer from AI. I love her voice, the song is beautiful and Jesse Spencer is so goddamn hot ♥

"Words are like scissors in your hands" - one of my favourite lyrics of all time.

I love me some Jesse Spencer - I adore Dr Chase! Such a sad but beatifully shot video. Very haunting.

Never heard this song before. Beautiful. Never knew Jesse Spencer was in this video.

This is the most amazing video and song that she has done. So emotional! Buy Unbroken if you haven't already.

wow.. beautiful... my relationship of 4 years is on a tight rope right now, and i don't believe any song has quite captured my heart as well as this one. it's been Years since i first heard this song, but just stumbled on it now when i most needed it. thank you Katharine McPhee for sharing your stunning voice and heart with the world!

This song reminds me the saddest moment that was happened in my life :(

OH MY GOD! WHAT A BEAUTIFUL SONG. IT'S THE FIRST TIME I'VE HEARD.

I'm not even going through a breakup but listening to this song I might as well be... that's when you know a song is great, because it evokes strong emotions. Bravo.

This song is so emotional. It reminds me of life just before and after my stroke. My partner left me. And for a good year after they were all I could think about. But hey ho life goes on. With or without you. x

Her voice is phenomenal . Their is a perfect emotion for the song and the quality of her voice is world class ! She need to be a superstar !!!

This song is so sad yet beautiful. This video now makes me interpret the song in a different, more tragic way.

Oh man I forgot how much I love her voice

Dr.Chase aka Jesse Spencer...! and the beautiful Katharine McPhee! love them both :)

she is amazing, he is amazing, the song is amazing!, what else can i ask for? :)

One of the most emotional, touching, and beautiful songs i"ve heard in my life! Love you Katharine!

How am I just now hearing this, nine years after it was released!?

2019 around the corner, and this is so achingly beautiful I don't know where to put all the feels.

God! I could listen to this lady all day! She is so exceptional. I feel every note that she sings..

Wow! Why haven't I seen this before?!?!?! Jesse is a wonderful actor!

Awww, such a perfect video for a perfect song. It makes me feel a little sad. :( Love Kat, love her voice. And love Jesse!! ♥

This song make me cry...

I cry 😢each time i watch this video. The entire 3 minute song told the whole sad story and the emotions so real. Katharine is amazing. She is an exceptional talent. It takes so much to take in. I cry every time.

Jesse Spencer

beautifully written...beautifully sung...beautifully performed....touching

I didn't know that Jesse Spencer (Matt Casey from Chicago fire) was in this music video even though it is one of my mostly listened to songs. I love jesse's acting.

I was looking for videos of Jesse Spencer singing and this popped up and I'm so glad it did, what a beautiful song! ❤

Jesse!!! I LOVE HIM!!! beautiful song

Dr.Chace aka Jesse Spencer...! and the beautiful Katharine McPhee! love them both :)

I heard this song like 7 months ago in my car while driving home... Then suddenly tears started flowing in my eyes unstoppable that I had to pull off the nearest gas station as I can no longer see the road ahead of me. I so hated this song then, as it so reminded me of how I entrusted my heart to someone and just shattered my whole being when I learned he and my best friend made a fool of me until I learned a day before my wedding day about them. This song is like an absolute and complete package of my love life. Now I listen to this and falls in love for the very first time with a smile in my face. Stronger, wiser and maybe even happier... I learned that now. I learned that there is no hurt aches time can't heal... There is no tremendous pain time can't mend... There is no love, no matter how strong is irreplaceable... Love as I see it is just a feeling... Life is stronger... I am stronger now... He is not at all worth it! I was young to believe that nothing in life matters after a love is wasted... I am still free and single, yet free to feel and free to choose my own happiness... So now I said goodbye to the past and it includes everything about it... I just wonder now if there is a song that is the exact opposite of this one...

the way she smiles when she says ' but you were my best friend'... is just heart rending. i broke down.

Katharine is SOOO GORGEOUS here! She looks like Posh Beckham! One of my fav song from this album....

This song is freakin beautiful......Yes Kat Mcphee

I didnt realize that this beautiful woman is also an actress. She sings like an angel and when I heard her sing with Andreaa, it gave be goosebumps!

"It’s hard to lose love, But you were my best friend." I miss you Damien

Two words for this song: stunningly indescribable... Miss. McPhee please come to Mexico

I have love this song since day one,great to see it officially released as a video and single to radio.

2018 ..and i still listen to her and this song...everyline just makes sense and the melodies just great.. not a typical love song but i dig it

why's this song not taken in "in my dreams"? what a beautiful song!

She could now carry a large Broadway role with this talent. Ticket sales would fly .

Her songs are filled with so much emotion. and this just killed me.

I was with him for almost 5 years. I was incredibly happy with him. he made me feel the best feeling in the world... and thats falling inlove and being loved in return.. I never imagined us being apart coz I never wanted it to end.. but life sucks.. and we came to that moment where we just cant be together anymore.. :( and yes it hurts so much to say goodbye :'(

OMG so happy she released a video for this song ! this song is so emotional and raw , Katharine's voice is so amazing and its a shame she's so underrated.

Each songs in her album Unbroken is pure goodness. I've shed tears countless times almost whenever I hear them. Her voice is so magical, there's so much feeling in it. Not only that, her expressions also! Even though she smiles a lot (she has great smiles) Her eyes is always so sad. I wonder if she feels lonely and isolated all the time like I do. I love the gentleness in her voice. She deserves more appreciation! Comon, Unbroken, out for 2 years, sold 45000 copies??? What the hell people??

My heart was in my throat from the moment I put this video to the words...this happens to someone everyday..hauntingly beautiful and very well done by Katharine...

Beautiful song should have waaaaaaaaaaaaay more than 2 million views.

this remind me of summer! in the night on the dark i listen to this!

why is this girl not more famous??? shes amazing

This song is amazing! One of my favorites off of your new album. The video is also perfect for it! Completely captures the emotion that you've put into your song. You are one of the few artisits who can say so much with such a simple song. Love it.

Perfect voice and perfect actor.

ah this video deserves more than just 399,611... it needs to go up!! such a beautiful song and video.

She's always been my American Idol! :-)

2020 for jesse?

CSI:NY brought me here...love this song😍😍😍😍😍

yes, that is jesse spencer aka Dr. Chase. this is a great song with beautiful melodies

i love this song. Sometimes i played this song in the morning.

2019 and I'm still listening to this :(

I feel her song. every note it stubs my heart sadly. huhuihu

I guess by now I should know enough about loss to realize that you never really stop missing someone-you just learn to live around the huge gaping hole of their absence.

OMG! McPheever all over again. We love you here in the Philippines. ♥

Jesse Spencer looks better and better with age!!!

Hauntingly beautiful but oh so dark! Kat's voice never sounded better or more soulful. This is the genre of song she was meant to sing-- it fits her voice perfectly!

That last shot of her in black and white is so stunning

Oh God... Beautiful... I'm very happy that her record company select this song as a video!!! Sorry by my english!!! This song have a lot of time. Love it!

Um... is it just me or is this song not getting enough views? This song is amazing!

how come i've never heard of her? she's absolutely amazing

The most beautiful break-up song ever! She's the best and certainly is the prettiest. ;)

I'll be remembering every memories everytime i hear this.. :)

Katharine and Jesse ♥♥

Saying Goodbye to someone I thought would always be in my life. He doesn't care about me or want me in his life so I'm moving on. I know that one day someone is going to fight for me as hard as I fight for them. And that there is a man out there who would kill for a woman like me. All I have to do is pick up the broken pieces & keep moving forward. It's time to say goodbye.

gosh this song means so much to me, i cry so hard when the words really make sense in everything that i was feeling... but i guess it always hurts when we say goodbye...

dr. robert chase with katharine mcphee !! yeah ! very good

She is so talented !!...LOve her voice!...what a beautiful video!...She should be up in the charts as number #1

Love this song, she has a wonderful voice and is gorgeous !!

Carol, I miss you so much. I cry everytime I here this song. I can't beleive you are gone. I need my best friend so bad. I know all about keeping it all inside. You can never be replaced, RIP, Carol.

I cried. I could relate to this song so much. So beautiful. Happy to see you back as a brunette Katharine. It looks best on you. :)

I can feel every word of this lyrics. It's full of pain...what I feel..

My Idol always. She is pretty from her beauty to her Voice. Love her so much 😍

this is the only video that had me in tears within the first minute of the song... :'(

The whole album is magnificent, underrated to say the least. All of her songs from Unbroken should be top 10 hits. But unfortunately; kids these days don't appreciate good music anymore. And yes, great video too!

God bless Katherine McPhee she can bring to the young people what real music sounds like in the beauty and talent shines.

First song to give me chills!! WOAH I never knew what people meant when they said that, but now I know! I actually shivered!

A tearjerker of a song if ever there was one!

My best blessings have come from my worst days--the days when I continued even as I thought my heart and soul, my mind and body would break. These are the gifted days of willingness that have tagged my being, thrown my spirit into "overdrive" and turned my life into an adventure of courage, honesty, self-allowing and potent love....

All in one woman! A near perfect creation of the Almighty!

I have no experience with break-ups or things like that, but this song really makes me cry...T_T I remember when my grandpa died....this just hits me...

I could have used this song when I got divorced! Brought a tear to my eye.! Thank you.

This song gives me chills.