No video

Code Geass and the Great Man Theory

  Рет қаралды 199,675

Kato

Kato

Күн бұрын

Consider supporting us on / katoyt
In this video, Kato's Zero discusses Code Geass's Zero.
It's pure coincidence.
Don't forget to like and subscribe if you enjoyed this video, and Hoodie will be back next week with a video on Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash.

Пікірлер: 397
@Tahkaullus01
@Tahkaullus01 5 жыл бұрын
If not a Great Man, Lelouch is still a Magnificent Bastard.
@hotamadeus2726
@hotamadeus2726 4 жыл бұрын
You mean waifu.
@lukasvillar9328
@lukasvillar9328 4 жыл бұрын
"Magnificent Bastard" You nailed it.
@bigboi_tony
@bigboi_tony 4 жыл бұрын
I’m happy with the ending and Lelouch of the resurrection
@gekoultima6668
@gekoultima6668 3 жыл бұрын
the only better moniker i could think of is glorious devil
@SwordTune
@SwordTune 5 жыл бұрын
Nunnally: Lelouch's heart Suzaku: Lelouch's will Schneizel: Lelouch's mind *Lelouch is equal to at least great people*
@risyanthbalaji805
@risyanthbalaji805 3 жыл бұрын
Nailed it
@camiloruizcastellar4740
@camiloruizcastellar4740 6 жыл бұрын
The real great man, is the guy who wrote that ending. The same reason why i dont want Season 3
@X3_lelouch1970
@X3_lelouch1970 4 жыл бұрын
The movie was good tho.
@PremierAlanMC
@PremierAlanMC 4 жыл бұрын
@@X3_lelouch1970 movies*
@X3_lelouch1970
@X3_lelouch1970 4 жыл бұрын
Adabie I mean Lelouch of the Resurrection, not any of the recap movies.
@PremierAlanMC
@PremierAlanMC 4 жыл бұрын
@@X3_lelouch1970 oh ayt, its good but not canon tho
@timetaker7816
@timetaker7816 3 жыл бұрын
@@X3_lelouch1970 meh, i mean i was expecting better. Like the theory that he became a code after his death. Though it is unlikely, a reimagining for possible futures from the ending is an endearing draw.
@balgafor
@balgafor 6 жыл бұрын
Every villain is the hero of his own story. All hail Lelouch Vi Britannna!!
@truthoftheuniverse4179
@truthoftheuniverse4179 5 жыл бұрын
i fuckign hate zusaku this dick is a idiot prick kissing the evil people ass
@KimyQueen_
@KimyQueen_ 4 жыл бұрын
All Hail Lelouch! T^T ♡
@attiladukai2121
@attiladukai2121 3 жыл бұрын
Was this quotation in Code Geass?
@risyanthbalaji805
@risyanthbalaji805 3 жыл бұрын
All Hail Lelouch
@BobBob-fe6vz
@BobBob-fe6vz 3 жыл бұрын
All hail lelouch!
@michealdrake3421
@michealdrake3421 6 жыл бұрын
I kind of view the Lelouche/Nunnaly dynamic as being very interesting. Lelouche is, in all ways except motivation, a villain. He's ambitious and arrogant to a fault and willing to commit the harshest of atrocities to achieve his aims. True, WE see his remorse, but to all outside observers, the civilian casualties, the total annihilation of what stability existed in the world, are of no concern to him. He is a man with a goal, willing to go to absolutely any means necessary to accomplish it. The one thing that separates him from being a supervillain is his motivation, to make a better world for Nunnaly. I would argue that without Nunnaly, he would still destroy Britannia, but he wouldn't care about the aftermath. He would topple the greatest superpower in the world, plunge the planet into chaos, and then walk away, his mission accomplished. Nunnaly is the angel to Lelouche's demon, the conscience that tempers and directs his ambition, without even knowing it.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
The interesting thing is, even considering Lelouch's good intentions, you could still call him a villain. Think of how many villains there have been who were trying to save the world in their own way. I also agree with you. Nunnally is very important to Lelouch's motivations, and as you implied, his nobleness. -Zero
@jaden577
@jaden577 6 жыл бұрын
Micheal Drake whether or not he would just destroy brittania and walk away is something that has yet to be seen. A nation isn’t tangible. There’s no real way to “destroy” brittania. All lelouch would be able to do is change brittania for the better. Changing brittania’s rotten core to something good for everyone is the only way to destroy brittania’s current existence. As lelouch stated, know your enemy, because it is not the people. The only way for him to ensure that the country would not go back to its rotten ways after lelouch did his part, would be to ensure that someone like schneizel never ended up on the throne, and that someone like euphemia and nunnally did. That’s the only true way to destroy a nation.
@dr.strangelove4665
@dr.strangelove4665 5 жыл бұрын
he is an antihero by all means
@bellabalms7319
@bellabalms7319 4 жыл бұрын
Another hero or maybe villain would be taylor from worm. She did rise above her situation but she committed atrocities in her mind that was right. Though like lechouch she did sacrife herself personality and humanity to save the world. Though she would always be viewed has a villian afterwards.
@ardacanertay5013
@ardacanertay5013 3 жыл бұрын
I totally disagree. Lulush was also in the effect of geas. Geas was causing him to kill people for his goals. But his goal was always to build a fairer world. To do this he was killing innocent people. When his killings were revealed he lost the trust of everyone including Black Knights. Then he set up a plan with Suzaku where he would deliberately play the role of a villian. His plan was to attract all the hatred of the world on himself. Therefore his killing would mean the fairer world. When he was asked "What makes a good leader?", he answered "Destruction". As a result he destroyed all the source of evil including himself (at least the world was seeing him as the evil) to build a fairer world. He sacrificed his life to build a fairer world! But Britania had to be destroyed to achieve this goal. And this wouldn't be possible by making some compromises within the Imperialist Britannia.
@neoth8647
@neoth8647 6 жыл бұрын
Lelouch was not only a Great Man as per the theory, but he was one that created other Great Men in the process to uphold and progress his legacy. Lelouch is not only a Great Man, but a Great King, with the wisdom and cunning that surpasses common human understanding.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
Well said.
@rsking6120
@rsking6120 4 жыл бұрын
Replying 2 years later lul Regardless, I wholeheartedly agree, but rather than a great King or and Emperor of Britannia, I see Lelouch as the Emperor of Humanity itself. His goals were never for any country, and although he fought from the countries of Japan and Britannia, his existence is something that far surpassed any national boundary. The very fact that he was able to use his strength, his Geass, to connect to the Ragnarok Connection, the collective subconscious of human beings, is the greatest testament to Lelouch's role as the hero of humanity, even as the villain of his world.
@c.c3375
@c.c3375 3 жыл бұрын
@@rsking6120 replying after 1 year lol. I comletely agree with you. btw very well sail
@stormsniper4765
@stormsniper4765 Ай бұрын
@@rsking6120I’m doom scrolling 4 years later but imma reply anyways. When lelouch connects to the connection he also has his arms spread wide like Christ on the cross in front of god. During the moment his 2nd eye awakens he also realizes his true goals and who he truly is inside his heart and as said. Know thyself know thy enemy. He knew his true heart and what he desired and would burn the world to make it happen. A Geass can be described as an an idiosyncratic taboo, whether of obligation or prohibition, similar to being under a vow or curse, yet the observance of which can also bring power and blessings. And Lelouch was the only one who overcame this power for the future of all humanity.
@hotamadeus2726
@hotamadeus2726 6 жыл бұрын
If Lelouch isn't a great man, he's at least a great waifu
@MarcAlcatraz
@MarcAlcatraz 6 жыл бұрын
husbando*
@damianalexander4274
@damianalexander4274 6 жыл бұрын
**waifu
@Atlazuko
@Atlazuko 6 жыл бұрын
lulu is best waifu.
@pandadestroyerv8462
@pandadestroyerv8462 6 жыл бұрын
Lelouch isn't a girl, lady, woman, female, chick, gal, mrs , miss, or base.
@vDorgengoa
@vDorgengoa 6 жыл бұрын
**Kaleen
@liz9284
@liz9284 6 жыл бұрын
Oh, one more thing about Zero-I think there was no power vacuum bc Lelouche recognized that people are fickle, so giving them an “immortal” symbol of what took place, was the only way to keep the peace. The rulers may change, but Zero supporting them gave people a constant. Many cultures have done this throughout history, passing the mantle of a great person or leader down through the generations, keeping the focus on the ideals represented by “the mask” instead of the person wearing it.
@Warsie
@Warsie 6 жыл бұрын
there was no power vacuum because the UFN was still an organization, note its shown that emperor lelouch browbeat them into accepting the Brittanian empire into admission. while lelouch was emperor he was creating the institutions to last after he died.
@SnowSNS11
@SnowSNS11 4 жыл бұрын
royal families are a symbol. But you can't be sure that the symbol will remain uncorrupted. Besides, there's always people who like to rebel to authorities. idk people like to complain and blame authorities whether there's real corruption or not. If it's real, it's justified of course. I've just begun having an interest with the Romanov family after watching Anastasia, so far I find the early ones awesome.
@Nonzerotonin
@Nonzerotonin 6 жыл бұрын
If only 2017 had been that awesome.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
I wish. -Zero
@lolosh99
@lolosh99 6 жыл бұрын
Umm do you mean war ?
@calinsa3880
@calinsa3880 6 жыл бұрын
LITERALLY YOUR FAULT IT WASN'T!
@howtheworldworks3
@howtheworldworks3 6 жыл бұрын
Hello clone.
@dephord8061
@dephord8061 6 жыл бұрын
You'll be revived this year, why are you here? ALL HAIL LELOUCH!
@TheBiolizardVII
@TheBiolizardVII 7 жыл бұрын
Cool video! I like that you showed a criticism against the Great Man Theory, then incorporated it into your explanation of how it actually supports the Lelouch as a candidate for the Great Man Theory.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 7 жыл бұрын
Thanks! I think the criticism offered by Herbert Spencer of the Great Man Theory is rather heavily influenced by his sociological work, but he seemed to be the most notable critic of the theory that I could find. I wanted to address the issues I had with his critique, but ultimately I wanted this video to stay about Lelouch.
@ineednochannelyoutube5384
@ineednochannelyoutube5384 5 жыл бұрын
+yatagarasuable A better approach is saying change cannot be affected without a fugrehead. 'Great Men' provide the spark for the barrel gunpowder that is social tension.
@humanbeing1080
@humanbeing1080 6 жыл бұрын
But sadly he will always be known as Lelouch the demon
@360bandman
@360bandman 4 жыл бұрын
Not by the people who know like suzaku nunally kallen and probably Jeremiah
@tearlach47
@tearlach47 4 жыл бұрын
He meant for everyone to view him as a demon
@Javetts
@Javetts 3 жыл бұрын
@@360bandman Jeremiah absolutely knew, as he said "onward, masked knight" after purposely allowing suzaku to pass him (because orange-boy season 2 would rofl suzaku outside of a knightmare). Sayako, Cecile, and Lloyd all knew, as they were told to betray Lelouche before he won to insure they'd be seen in a positive light after the zero requiem. I also believe some others figured it out. Cornelia and Todoh both knew lelouche and his persona zero personally. Also Xingke likely put it together as seemingly the 3rd smartest strategist (after Lelouche and Sneizel). Kaguya might also of figured it out from the hint CC gave her right before Lelouche claimed victory over the world.
@c.c3375
@c.c3375 3 жыл бұрын
yeah... but it wouldnt be like this his plan wouldnt work and the world woud still be in war...
@asakayosapro
@asakayosapro 9 ай бұрын
*The Demons of Razgriz have entered the chat airspace*
@Anarkey
@Anarkey 6 жыл бұрын
Nice video offering the great man theory and the counterpoint to the theory. The line from Oscar Levant can also be applied to Lelouch. "There's a fine line between genius and insanity" I believe the men that impact history were often seen as either genius or mad. Like Otto Van Bismarck. After conquering everything, he decided not to pursue conquest but rather strengthen the empire. The ministers around him called him mad but it was a brilliant stroke of genius. And there's plenty of examples in history. Nonetheless, a pretty good analogy of Lelouch. And the fact that he made the statement, "The only ones who should kill, are the ones who are prepared to be killed" also solidifies him as a great man. And he did fulfill that statement at the end.
@aminrosli9744
@aminrosli9744 6 жыл бұрын
any compilments about code geass, i like
@volition142
@volition142 5 жыл бұрын
Amin Rosli Nina was the best most smartest character ever
@Polo-rp9hk
@Polo-rp9hk 3 жыл бұрын
@@volition142 ...
@grizzledwarveteran2321
@grizzledwarveteran2321 3 жыл бұрын
Hi Johan
@Ankushdas2001
@Ankushdas2001 3 жыл бұрын
Bari bari gusha gusha baki baki gokun
@captainadmiral8439
@captainadmiral8439 6 жыл бұрын
Thank you for making me realise what drives my affection for many of my favourite anime. I've noticed that of those anime, most include some "great man": Mustang & Greed- Fullmetal Alchemist, Griffith & ~Guts -Berserk, Kiritsugu- Fate/Zero, Light- Death Note, Any Jojo- Jojo's Bizarre Adventure The Count of Monte Cristo- Gankutsuou, Kamina & Simon- Gurren Lagen But Lelouch is still my favourite.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
You have good taste.
@cestarianinhabitant5898
@cestarianinhabitant5898 6 жыл бұрын
I wouldn't quite agree that light was a great man, he was a fool. But other than that I agree.
@hotamadeus2726
@hotamadeus2726 6 жыл бұрын
Cestarian Inhabitant he wasn't a fool. His plans almost succeeded. Plus geniuses like him aren't generally subject to foolish behavior.
@captainadmiral8439
@captainadmiral8439 6 жыл бұрын
His plans did succeed. He won. But as the rules of power state; no empire lasts forever.
@cestarianinhabitant5898
@cestarianinhabitant5898 6 жыл бұрын
He was just a kid with a book on a killing spree, thinking he would be free from the consequences of his own actions, and that it couldn't be traced to him. He was a fucking moron and a psychopath, but genius he most certainly was not. Clearly he was stupid enough to get caught, he didn't plan things through at all, and his plans would have failed the moment they realized that he was killing them through the news, because no matter how far from there he could have gotten, all they'd have to do to stop him was stop reporting criminals as news material! His 'plan' was doomed to fail from the first second.
@ghostofanangel5476
@ghostofanangel5476 6 жыл бұрын
I also thought another reason for the world peace to continue after lelouch was zero as a symbol. He had victory after victory, was a knight of justice to the end, had respect for all people groups even britannians, as far as the world is concerned rose from the grave twice (after season 1 he is reported executed and I am positive after the black knight betray they claimed he died but maybe wrong about that but I still think it would make the most sense for them to claim that) and after he rose from the grave he came at the worlds darkest hour and slayed a demon. While we know the truth is less pretty this is what the world sees. There will be a huge cult of personality. Anyone who dares attack zero will not have to fight him but the entire world behind him. Of course one way to beat this is to reveal to the world what the audience knows.
@greycrimson3228
@greycrimson3228 6 жыл бұрын
A hero in my book aswell, even if a dark hero
@alexsikar6814
@alexsikar6814 6 жыл бұрын
Holy shit, I'd always seen Lalousch as an amazing strategist, but I'd never seen how far ahead he planned. I hope R3 continues the philosophy and thought the series has so far had.
@farn0153
@farn0153 5 жыл бұрын
Lalousch lmaooo
@louisev7202
@louisev7202 6 жыл бұрын
I definitely think Lelouch is one of the best examples we have of a great man and proves that you can easily be a great man (or woman) without being a GOOD one.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
Lelouch might argue that, to be a great man, you can't be a good one. I don't know if I would agree, lol.
@mazur1281
@mazur1281 3 жыл бұрын
@@KatoBeyond "There is not people great and good at the same time" CoD 4 quote
@grizzledwarveteran2321
@grizzledwarveteran2321 4 жыл бұрын
He’s similar to Batman in many ways. But the true fundamental difference is their philosophy in fighting opposition: Lelouch is a rule utilitarian and Machiavellian willing to achieve goals at any means, but Batman does his most to not break his rule of killing which can conflict with his goals - a Deontologist
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 4 жыл бұрын
I'd say Batman's philosophy borrows from both doctrines, but Lelouch is certainly more utilitarian and Machiavellian than Bruce is.
@joshuafogg6600
@joshuafogg6600 6 жыл бұрын
And now Season Three - a threat so great that Lelouch needs to come back.
@Baud307
@Baud307 6 жыл бұрын
Oh boy, here I go watching Code Geass again... for the 17th time now. Bloody hell I love this show; and your analysis was fantastic, adding yet further insight into the themes of Code Geass alongside development of characters. Thank you.
@ismorezro
@ismorezro 6 жыл бұрын
you die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain... humanity is a spiral, no matter what we do, there is only one way, down at the bottom. and yes, Lelouch was a great man.
@ardacanertay5013
@ardacanertay5013 3 жыл бұрын
Lulush was also in the effect of geas. Geas was causing him to kill people for his goals. But his goal was always to build a fairer world. To do this he was killing innocent people. When his killings were revealed he lost the trust of everyone including Black Knights. Then he set up a plan with Suzaku where he would deliberately play the role of a villian. His plan was to attract all the hatred of the world on himself. Therefore his killing would mean the fairer world. When he was asked "What makes a good leader?", he answered "Destruction". As a result he destroyed all the source of evil including himself (at least the world was seeing him as the evil) to build a fairer world. He sacrificed his life to build a fairer world! But Britania had to be destroyed to achieve this goal. And this wouldn't be possible by making some compromises within the Imperialist Britannia.
@Ankushdas2001
@Ankushdas2001 4 жыл бұрын
Fun fact: Schneizel is 6'8"
@notverypog
@notverypog 3 жыл бұрын
Everyone is taller than 6' in Code Geass lmao.
@pumpkingamebox
@pumpkingamebox 6 жыл бұрын
Great men are forged in fire, it is the privilege​ of lesser men to light the flame
@sourcesymbiosismetamorphis2228
@sourcesymbiosismetamorphis2228 6 жыл бұрын
Zero, Did you just roast all those generalized lesser men?
@pumpkingamebox
@pumpkingamebox 6 жыл бұрын
Source Symbiosis Metamorphisis As the smartest race on earth, we are dumber than every other living thing on Earth. Because we overthink things too much. We crave to better than the other. Thus we all want to be great. But sometimes you just​ have to accept your place in the world. That you are the lesser man.
@thecavefurball
@thecavefurball 6 жыл бұрын
Those who argue against great men, are simple scared of admitting they are lesser men.
@pumpkingamebox
@pumpkingamebox 6 жыл бұрын
Without arguing one would never know that he is the lesser man. Perhaps the outcome of the argument would be that you're the great man.
@pumpkingamebox
@pumpkingamebox 3 жыл бұрын
It's been two years. Not sure exactly what I mean by this last comment. Arguments even though determine who is a dumbass most often than not lead to both parties quitting the debate because of their own arrogance. Dunning Kruger effect I think it's called. As all the problems in the world come down to one simple issue. Idiots always think that they're right and the wise are always doubtful.
@SapphireLibra3
@SapphireLibra3 5 жыл бұрын
Code Geass is also one of my favorite anime, and thanks in no small part to Lelouch. You described why I love in perfectly, along with your longer video about the man behind the mask. Lelouch is someone that I actually look up to because of his conviction to his goals, and whenever I see the ending of Code Geass I always cry, because I know the meaning behind it.
@ZephWraen
@ZephWraen 6 жыл бұрын
One issue with Schneizel specifically is I'm not thoroughly convinced Schneizel won't one day break out of his Geass command. Don't forget, he's highly intelligent and the only man treated as and even spoken of as Lelouche's equal. All he would have to do is convince himself that the current Zero is not the real Zero since he knew Lelouche was the original Zero and Lelouche is dead. Then the command "serve Zero" would falter or even fail completely as Schneizel would no longer recognize Susaku as Zero. Sure, it's a lil bit of a stretch, but it's a surefire way to bring back one of the best antagonists of the series.
@oitr2551
@oitr2551 6 жыл бұрын
Why would schneizel be an antagonist? I thought both him and Lelouch fough for peace, just had different ways of achieving it. Now that peace is, there is no reason for him to try anything.
@ZephWraen
@ZephWraen 6 жыл бұрын
Schneizel wanted peace, sure, but he wanted it through fear and control (a typically antagonistic viewpoint). Even when Lelouch had made himself into the enemy of the world, and Schneizel was helping the Black Knights, Schneizel still wasn't a "good guy" because he was still trying to get his base into orbit to control the world with. Hell, he attempts to kill Cornelia when she figures out his plan. I'm not saying that's necessarily the direction they'll take his character in R3, was just suggesting a way to get him to break free of the geass command. Whether or not he'll be an antagonist we'll just have to wait and find out.
@kingrko9910
@kingrko9910 6 жыл бұрын
spoilers ahead their are two easy solutions to the problem of the geass used on schneziel lelouch said he was loyal to zero and in the end we know the zero requiem was meant to make suzaku the new zero and that orange already knew of the plan so with the geass already cast on schneziel why not tell him of the plan and that zero would be suzake then he truly would be loyal to suzaku is the first and more obvious of the two solutions the second and in my opinion more fitting one is that in the same way that lelouch made all of the Japanese who fallowed zero in to zero early on in season two he made schneziel a servant of the people more accurately the people he always looked down on a fitting punishment just like the punishments of suzaku orange cc and lelouch himself
@dannofdawn
@dannofdawn 6 жыл бұрын
He didn't want peace through fear and control, he saw it as the means to the end. And he saw himself as the right candidate to be Ruler of the World. Remember that Schneizel didn't do what he did because he hungered for power, he did it because of how the world was at the time, and he saw himself as one who could save it. So when Zero Requiem succeeded, even a Schneizel with free will wouldn't oppose it, rather he would still support it because that's the type of person he is. Schneizel is what Lelouch would be if he didn't have a sister he loves, and friends he cared about. This is a classic story trope - The difference between the villain and the hero is that the villain was alone, and the hero wasn't. That is, Schneizel became a cold-hearted lonely person due to his peerless intelligence, while being raised in a ruthless, vain, aristocratic society. He saw the state of the world, acknowledges his own capabilities, and enact his plan with pure objectivity in mind in order to better it. But because he was a loner, he failed to see the effect of his actions on others, because he couldn't perceive the feelings and perspectives of others. Which ironically meant he could only see things from his own perspective, and even with his intellect, he couldn't see what he was doing was no better than Charles. So with a mind like that, it made sense he would think WMDs was the way to enforce world peace through unchallenged rulership and control. However, once Zero Requiem succeeded, his goal of fixing the world was also achieved, he no longer has any reason to strive for power. The world is a much better place, one he also wanted, he just didn't know what it should be prior to Zero Requiem. Also, he didn't try to murder Cornelia, he just needed her out of his way - he didn't care about her at all, didn't matter to him if she was dead or alive, so he didn't bother finishing her. Cornelia said so herself to Guilford. But all of that is moot because he wouldn't be able to break free of Geass by himself. No one has ever done it, Nunually only managed to resist it for a few seconds. Orange would have to cancel it for him, which wouldn't happen because he is fully loyal to Marianne's children.
@hi44098
@hi44098 6 жыл бұрын
I am so glad this anime is coming back!
@nova8091
@nova8091 3 жыл бұрын
The main two differences between Zero and Kira is one leads one hides and doesn’t take charge and also one knows he can be wrong and one can’t let go of his ego
@Matthew_Murray
@Matthew_Murray 6 жыл бұрын
I agree that in the context of the narrative Lelouch is a great man. However, in the real world I laugh at the idea that history is lead by “great men” The biggest impacts to world history are smaller events like discoveries in science, medicine, and agriculture.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
I actually completely agree. -Zero
@misatrnka177
@misatrnka177 6 жыл бұрын
such discoveries are no coincidence. they often require great men to make them possible. certain social paradigms promote such discoveries and it takes great men to bring them about. To claim that one historical force has primacy over another is simply unnuanced, especially so when out of context.
@zetaforever4953
@zetaforever4953 4 жыл бұрын
@@misatrnka177 History and progress are not shaped by the actions of great individuals. Rather, they are shaped by the incremental progress caused by the actions of millions of people working on the same thing, in various places of the world at various points in time. Most progress can be attributed to changes in technology and/or social systems. And neither world-changing technology nor social institutions are formed by a single person. Democracy, as well as the light bulb, were invented, implemented, and perfected over a number of decades and centuries, with many people building on each other’s work. The contributions of certain individuals in this journey may have been greater than those of others, but no single person was responsible for any great social, political, or technological change. Darwin built on the works of other scientists to come up with his theory of evolution. Gandhi built on the ideas of other social reformers and philosophers to come up with his 'ahimsa' model. Some people become more popular than others, but that doesn't make them pioneers, much less the sole creators of change and progress.
@ravenwhiteduck3158
@ravenwhiteduck3158 4 жыл бұрын
@@zetaforever4953 great or small, sometimes all it takes is one man to be removed from the pages of history and what we know is forever changed, it's not like their are leonardo davinci's everywhere
@zetaforever4953
@zetaforever4953 4 жыл бұрын
@@ravenwhiteduck3158 sure there are. What do you think created Shakespeare? He became popular through a combination of talent, timing, and luck in a small country that later went on to colonize large sections of the world and spread it's language and culture around the globe. This colonization in turn allowed this country to kickstart the industrial revolution which made them rich and further helped to propagate their culture around the world. And that's how a talented regional playwright became a global icon. The same can be said for all "great men" in history. You really think there weren't any women with Da Vinci's talent or Shakespeare's? No black men writing in Swahili or painting in Zinbabwe? No transexual Indians? Why do we not know about them? People are removed from history all the time. If we had to read about every person ever born with Da Vinci's talent, we'd never read about anything else. It is a confluence of talent circumstances society history and future events (which they had no control over) that make "great men" what they are.
@AhmadSammy
@AhmadSammy 6 жыл бұрын
Possibly the best video on youtube
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
Oh, stop it, you're making me blush.
@bullymaguire2061
@bullymaguire2061 3 жыл бұрын
Lelouch ordered Suzaku to live no matter what. So when Suzaku starts aging, will he start to look for the fountain of youth? 🤔
@liz9284
@liz9284 6 жыл бұрын
I love your philosophical interpretations (so far I’ve just seen this one and the one on FMA, two of my fave shows:). I felt like such a dork going on and on about how utterly amazing FMA is, from the authors knowledge of what we call alchemy to her own interpretations of the laws that might govern such forces, so it’s nice to see someone else is delving into “the cores” of what these series seem to be about-I feel so much better now,, LOL. I haven’t finished Code Geass yet (though I know the story), but from what I’ve seen so far I totally agree with your Great Man Theory. Society may give people the skill sets and the tools required for true change, but they still have to decide to use those tools, and no one can do that but those who do. Giving society credit for what only a few accomplish, when so many others choose victimhood over change, is unfair, at best. Crediting society is, in its own way, tyrannical because it leaves those who may aspire to change things unable to harness the ability to do so-it diffuses the sense of responsibility-because if we’re all the same, then “someone else will take care of it”, and then no one does. I think this is why people like Spencer were so opposed to the Great Man Theory, because it keeps the status quo, but that’s just my two cents. Great videos, thank you! Keep it up!
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
Hey, thanks for watching.
@MichaelOyewole
@MichaelOyewole 3 жыл бұрын
Lelouch is most definitely a great man. He shouldered the burden and responsibilities of saving Japan from the animosities they were experiencing from the Britannians by experiencing them himself. No matter how you place it, in my opinion, neither Kallen, Ohgi, Tohdoh or even Tamaki could ever achieve what Lelouch accomplished by their own accord.
@generalRAAM95
@generalRAAM95 6 жыл бұрын
Ever since we learned about Carlyle's theory in College, I grew very fond of it. It's refreshing to watch a video that useas it. Good job, my friend. You made me realize things I didn't notice before that make this show even greater in my eyes.
@SupachargedGaming
@SupachargedGaming 4 жыл бұрын
Only point, the skill and intelligence he required may have been, or partially were, results of his environment. Prior to donning the mask of Zero, he had a lot of external factors pushing him towards success. Not towards Zero, or towards his personal goals, but towards the "skills and intelligence" required to achieve those goals. His education, his wealth, his familial connections, even just his location (He could've been raised in a more derelict location).
@DocsDota
@DocsDota 6 жыл бұрын
It's strongly hinted in the Code Geass universe that when a Geass user dies OR ascends to the immortal status the people affected by their geass are restored. C.C.'s love geass lead to her followers crucifying her when she became immortal, Nunally got her sight back because Charles became an immortal and also died, but took a while since she never thought she had her eyes for the longest time. So if this holds true, Schneizel would no longer serve zero after Lelouch either dying or ascending to Immortal status.
@mystycomega6547
@mystycomega6547 6 жыл бұрын
Unless lelouch kept his geass, as he took code from Charles but didn’t kill CC so he could become an immortal with geass, therefore the command over schneizel would remain
@christophercrafte
@christophercrafte 6 жыл бұрын
actually I dont think it was ever confirmed that a geas user dying will restore someone. In the case of C.C I think that her being loved Geas is a active effect that she would keep active rather than something you cast on someone like lelouche. and in the case of Charles and his geas It took Jeremiahs geas canceler to actually help Anya who had her memories altered for years.
@Swordsman99k
@Swordsman99k 3 жыл бұрын
The opposite is true. Marianne died years earlier and was able to maintain her geass in Anya.
@sheko1615
@sheko1615 6 жыл бұрын
On the whole, I think the Great Man Theory is something that applies most accurately to societies where power is strongly concentrated. One reason it may look less compelling to people who live in societies with more fractured power structures. Ina world like Code Geass after Lelouch is the literal emperor of the world (and before that only three great powers, only one of which seems to have a more spread out power structure) it makes sense that this theory carries more weight. The contrast I would point to in our world is that even when large changes occur at the Federal level of the U.S. government, the day-to-day lives of its citizens aren't strongly impacted until much later, and possibly not in the way that the leaders intend it to happen. The speed of power is also something I think is really important to this discussion, but I don't have enough time to write about it now, but basically if something can be said and made true quickly, then the Great Man Theory is more plausible than in a society of slow moving power.
@UpturnTheUncool
@UpturnTheUncool 6 жыл бұрын
The explanation of Lelouch's drive through Nunnally's wish at 3:40 had me LMMFAO XD
@cuggs2063
@cuggs2063 6 жыл бұрын
I am surprised that you have so few subs compared to other internet theorists, especially since you offer both arguments up to the viewer instead of only the argument that you favor. I really enjoyed this video , it's rare that I comment on videos but I felt I should comment on this one.
@calebbritannia6283
@calebbritannia6283 6 жыл бұрын
I have a theory, the Royal bloodline in code geass has anti geass properties! For example Euphimia was able to temporarily fight off Lelouch's geass, Nunalle was able to see again.
@rufusrhodes2081
@rufusrhodes2081 6 жыл бұрын
Caleb Britannia Lelouch states in the anime it was just against her nature but she was still taking over
@calebbritannia6283
@calebbritannia6283 6 жыл бұрын
What about all the other things that are against nature? All those people he told to kill themselves atleast one of them must have had an incredible strong will to live. Also look at the hatred Orange Boy possessed for Zero, he still obeyed without question.
@msroland23
@msroland23 6 жыл бұрын
Well,then it kinda isn't a big deal right? Here's my conjecture though Geass is the power of the King right?So for you to not obey orders you need to be someone worthy of being a King and also you need the have the will.You might say okay but what about Schneizel?? Well,he never got his hands dirty himself ,he also wasn't as strong willed as her. Another thing is that we have been shown that the geass gives a command to the enemies brain directly. You might say but everyone is the same right?sure someone he was killing had the will to oppose him. Well ,those guy's where always taking orders from someone so they can't oppose a King being mere underlings of another King. Those guys that will sacrifice everything for a dream or ideal are the kind of guys that can oppose the power of the king.I imagine it as being like an addiction ,your entire being is telling you to execute the command so by disobeying the order your are essentially going against yourself.There are few people that can overcome an addiction after all...
@Sigstrata
@Sigstrata 6 жыл бұрын
Orange was Geassed right at the moment zero emerged, and it is the consequences of him being Geassed that spurred his hatred for Zero. As for the suicide theory, while someone may have an extremely strong will to live at the moment, I believe the term "within their nature" means that if someone is at the lowest point in their life, everyone is capable of suicide. Since Nunally was geassed to hand over the Damacles' key, which to Nunally would be giving up on her dream of a gentler world ("how could the world be gentle when Zero has the FLEIJA's and command of all the armed forces?") she was able to resist it momentarily.
@AhmadSammy
@AhmadSammy 6 жыл бұрын
Schniezel showed zero resistance to it despite that the command was extremely against his will. Also Clovis and Cornelia didn’t resist at all.
@Emma-Queenofhell
@Emma-Queenofhell 4 жыл бұрын
The end when you said he probably wouldn't remake society if he didn't go through trauma your right. His Julius Kingsley persona proves that
@MemoryPhaseStudios
@MemoryPhaseStudios 6 жыл бұрын
This is a very clever and thought provoking video! And as for "Hero" applying to Lelouch it definitely does. Especially when you look at the older meaning of "hero", especially in Classical Mythology. Being a hero in that time didn't immediately make them "good people" merely "great people". And quite a few "heroes" in Greek Mythology were, to be frank, dicks.
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 6 жыл бұрын
Greatest anime ever.
@ate-leftnocrums
@ate-leftnocrums 4 жыл бұрын
I heard this one time; Lelouch is not a good person, but he's a hero
@the11382
@the11382 2 жыл бұрын
Counterpoint to criticism: Some of the great men are/were isolated or pariahs. Superman is clark kent in normal life, but as a full being he is isolated. He is adopted, with his real parents being dead aliens. Lelouch may be on the student council, but he is still a Britannian prince in hiding. In body he is there, but in mind he is isolated.
@yourgoat_5302
@yourgoat_5302 6 жыл бұрын
Amazing Anime
@bracoyote96
@bracoyote96 5 жыл бұрын
I'm so happy I found this channel today.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 5 жыл бұрын
Welcome, bipedal penis man.
@MemoryPhaseStudios
@MemoryPhaseStudios 5 жыл бұрын
It's worthwhile noting that he actually DIDN'T start off Zero Requiem planning for Nunnally to take his place. Since he thought she was dead until he put things in motion for it, for him to be the most hated man alive on Earth. So who did he pick before? I would argue he originally planned for KAGUYA to be so. He did trust her to act as Chairwoman of the UFN Supreme Council (ie effectively already ruling half the world) and she showed the maturity and capability to be a good leader (in fact he makes a question in that regard that likely confirmed he can trust Kaguya as his successor just before he "reveals" himself to be a Demon) despite her young age. But when Nunnally turned up alive and proved herself to him, Lelouch made adjustments to his plan with that in mind. Likely is easier in a way to put his own blood sibling in charge of the world than someone with no blood ties considering how succession works.
@triosciankliquit9982
@triosciankliquit9982 Жыл бұрын
That Spencer guy totally ignored the importance of the Nature of the Individual. While it's true that society shaped Lelouch mind that way, he was the one who pondered and responded in a certain way that he would change things. Lelouch is a great man, probably the greatest of all Anime antiheroes.
@nikgokuhil
@nikgokuhil 6 жыл бұрын
Lelouch did rise up, but one of the major difference was that he would not have if the world (C.C.) didnt give him the power to do so. Though just cause he was given the strength and motivation to rise above does not mean that he was not a great man, he was just written to be so. In Harry Potter, when compared to Harry we see feats of Dumbledore, Marauders and other great wizards as extraordinary as we didnt walk in their shoes. Even Harry himself didnt consider himself all that great because he clearly saw that he was there only because he got help from extraordinary people, he could never see why Dumbledore found him as extraordinary. That we related to Harry so much that we often found ourselves agreeing with him gives me a sense of satisfaction. No matter how inadequate we find ourselves to be, we are all potentially great men. Neville Longbottom was just as great and he proved it when the time came, he could as easily have been the chosen one if the adversity or world chose him. Similarly Lelouch didnt get where he was just cause of himself, it was because of his allies and enemies. Maybe the world did just chose the answer he led it to in the end, but they chose him as a vessel for the judgement qualifies him as a great man.
@ChieftainHawke
@ChieftainHawke 6 жыл бұрын
Not true, Lelouch mentioned in Episode 5 that CC giving him Geass only "sped up" his plans. Basically he would have destroyed Brittania anyways it just would have taken alot longer. The 1-2 years it took for Lelouch to fully enact his plan wouldve taken about 10 without Geass.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
There's some truth to what both of you are saying. Lelouch was talking about his plan to obliterate Britannia when he said that, but he may have undergone the same path either way. Really, it's impossible to know one way or the other for sure, but no one can say C.C. didn't play a huge role in Code Geass.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
Really, I just want to encourage the discussion.
@ChieftainHawke
@ChieftainHawke 6 жыл бұрын
C.C was of great help, but Lelouch could have done without it. give that kind of power to any other character like Kallen or Suzaku, and Brittania would have still been up and running. Lelouch didn't NEED Geass. Actually when you think about it, Geass simply gave him the motivation to enact his plans. And Geass made things worse for him and turned him into the tragic hero. Geass led him to finding out what happened to his mother, thus releasing him from that obsession which held him back for so long. But honestly, w/o it he just would have been more creative. And things probably wouldn't have ended up as tragic for him in the end. The Most brilliant things Lelouch did he did without his geass.
@nikgokuhil
@nikgokuhil 6 жыл бұрын
I agree that its not just the power, but what you choose to do with it that makes you great, however that statement of Lelouch is akin to boasting of a frog in a well. He was outmatched and defeated various times by people who didnt have Geass and he needed a miraculous power to save him then. You can argue that if it werent for Geass he would've got some other power, but in the end the point holds true that things would be out of his control and he shall need something from the world. While I do think that he would be defeated in a straight up battle by people like Charles, Schneizel, Li Xingke or even other Geass users, but even if we argue on that, the whole world was sitting on a giant time bomb called Charles Vi Brittania. Lelouch's timeline didnt make room for Charles plan with world of C, without geass and its knowledge, it was a checkmate
@paigeelliott9674
@paigeelliott9674 3 жыл бұрын
The show definitely does interrogate the great man theory in another way, too! Especially in the first season but throughout the series, lelouch is most often and consistently hindered-sometimes even outright defeated, debatably-because he underestimates the capacity and unpredictability of individuals! Like, suzaku’s not that smart, but he manages to be lelouch’s greatest obstacle for much of the series just because he’s one guy who’s really good at fighting and often happens to be in the right place at the right time to intervene! A LOT of major turning points in the series, lelouch’s biggest successes and failures, depend on random chance (cough cough euphemia whoops!) or the actions of individual grunts, like that guy who gets freaked out and records a video when they raid the lab. Schneizel is the closest thing here to an L to lelouch’s light, and he isn’t even involved in most of the major events of the series. I would argue that the show takes a measured view of the great man theory and pushes back against it, in that while none of the major events could have happened without lelouch, he certainly didn’t solely cause or guarantee their outcomes, either. There are so many variables at play in these complicated situations that even a great man can be defeated easily by the wrong bullet at the right time.
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 3 жыл бұрын
Schneizel is really more like Light than Lelouch is, lol. Great comment.
@SeroGrave
@SeroGrave 6 жыл бұрын
Just beautiful.
@marcohinojosa1191
@marcohinojosa1191 4 жыл бұрын
Cornelia Nunnally Sncheizel(?), and Lelouch are the only remaining members of the royal family. The F.L.E.I.J.A. nuked the capital of Pendragon which wiped out the nobility and everyone in line for the throne. Which meant Lelouch knew there would be only 4 possible contenders. Seeing as one was geassed the only competition was Cornelia
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 4 жыл бұрын
I had admittedly forgotten the rest of the family was nuked to death when I had written this, but there's also room to imagine other children of Charles existed out in the world.
@sweetkittykat2000
@sweetkittykat2000 6 жыл бұрын
Sounds like... Napoleon? Much like Lelouch, Napolean was born into a lower noble class and worked his way up through military leadership. He scrounged together an army and changed the tides of war, spread great ideals about equality that are used for the framewoork of todays society, hated rule by birthright and opted for a voting system yet decided to declare himself emporer.... Lots of uncanny similarities. maybe do a video on the paralells of Napoleon, because I would bet money that the creator based him somewhat on Napoleon.
@outthe.yinyang
@outthe.yinyang 6 жыл бұрын
very good video and so many lessons to learn from this series
@thegardenofesim1174
@thegardenofesim1174 6 жыл бұрын
Well lelouch peace will not last why? Season 3 will happen Even without the season 3 eventuality his peace would always end due to his failsafes are too reliant on the people he has chosen to play a role in his requiem For even with those being talented and good willed it does not count any anomalies that might rise cause even though his reputation at the end was the most evil man who ever lived his reign was far too short to really engrave the dangers of the allure of power to other people especially outside his circle There is no doubt that lelouch is a great man but great men does not always leave legacies they intended
@bunnyqueensippers2761
@bunnyqueensippers2761 6 жыл бұрын
Just found your channel and subscribed! I totally agree with you about the great man theory and lelouch, and i LOVE code geass too!
@markrogers4050
@markrogers4050 5 жыл бұрын
I know this is late but knowing lelouch Id like to believe that he left instructions such as a video or letter to his family and former friends and allies as a way to properly say goodbye and to insure those he left behind would help insure a better world as despite some of their feelings towards him they would probably want the same thing.
@Frescko
@Frescko 6 жыл бұрын
I could see in the code geass world 150 years later like: yeah the whole world government was built on the death of this one guy, he was a unparalleled example of the great man theory
@essieredhooded
@essieredhooded 6 жыл бұрын
happy to be your 16000th suscriber :) ; love your videos
@ChaoscastCM
@ChaoscastCM 6 жыл бұрын
I now have insurmountable respect for you because you mentioned my man Otto von Bismarck in a video about Code Geass god bless you
@jlion2439
@jlion2439 6 жыл бұрын
Man, Lelouch is a genius-god. Hope some of this is mentioned in r3.
@gtoyadhatagyab8013
@gtoyadhatagyab8013 3 жыл бұрын
If you merge the intelligence of Light Yagami and the heart of Eren Yeager together in one person, you'll get Lelouch.
@neelabhsingh2131
@neelabhsingh2131 6 жыл бұрын
Nunnally wasn't the first to overcome a Geass command. It was Euphemia. She overcame her command to kill japanese when she was talking to Suzaku before dying
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
You're right, I forgot about that moment.
@danielbasich2729
@danielbasich2729 6 жыл бұрын
He kind of reminds me of Oda Nobunaga
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 6 жыл бұрын
He would be considered a great man under this theory.
@John-bp8tx
@John-bp8tx 6 жыл бұрын
Bruh when he made that girl kill 11's, my heart and soul was broken.
@nithyaniranjani
@nithyaniranjani Жыл бұрын
What makes him a great man is that he is wonderfully in the moral grey area - Which is so realistic considering that, no men incline to one side completely. Not even the great men.
@lucaw.7663
@lucaw.7663 4 жыл бұрын
I just would like to mention, that it was not Bismarck's death that cause the collapse of his system of foreign policy. He was already asked to resign by the new Emperor of Germany Wilhelm II. in 1890, because Wilhelm did not want someone who already worked for his grandfather as an adviser. Wilhelm was also very keen on increasing Germany's prestige and colonial territory, which led to nearly all of Germany's former allies hating it.
@TheChintu-il3sq
@TheChintu-il3sq 3 жыл бұрын
great analysis video, i agree with the greatman theory!! i just finished code geass after witnessing the shocking ending of code geass i immediatly remembered itachi uchiha, i like morally graey charecters who are the representative of complexity of human nature instead of black and white morality, i believe that everyone"s grey but its all boils down to logic of which nature outweights which black or white, good or evil and logically explains means justifies the end. reason in harmony with emotion thats the highest reality of life!! so, actions of lelouch and itachi can be explained by greek philosophy of consequentialism, in which the morality of an action is to be solely and only be judged on the consequences as results, hope i helped someone out there intrested in grey charecters lol
@aryadev3149
@aryadev3149 5 жыл бұрын
This video is perfect! It was just amazing!!!
@IWasAlwaysNeverAnywhere
@IWasAlwaysNeverAnywhere 6 жыл бұрын
luluche embraced the man that society made him into he was a man of lies and thats all he knew that he never tried to change himself he instead changed the world who made him into the man he was into a better place
@ispinothing5229
@ispinothing5229 4 жыл бұрын
I don’t believe Nunnaly would take his place cause he didn’t want her to he wanted the world to have “an open dialogue around one table”. Nunnaly could be a symbol of peace or something but not the next ruler. Lelouch didn’t want rulers!
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 4 жыл бұрын
Nunnally did end up becoming empress of Britannia in Fukkatsu no Lelouch, but I see your point.
@emocomebackfromhell
@emocomebackfromhell 6 жыл бұрын
While I must admit I agree with much of what you posed. I have to also acknowledge that evil is necessary to accomplish good. Lalouch did many terrible things and was the reason for many innocent deaths. Though the ends may justify the means I find myself despising him for all that he did for selfish gain. Killing an innocent to save the world isn't morally right. It might make you a great man, but it doesn't make you a better man.
@tpopgboi912
@tpopgboi912 3 жыл бұрын
The problem with this theory is Lelouch planned the Zero Requiem believing Nunaly was dead. And wasn’t Lelouchs Empire broken up and the entire world United by the UFN? Leaving Nunally to rule the remaining Britanian territories that did not want independence from the Empire?
@habibisuckslol
@habibisuckslol 3 жыл бұрын
I think it was made before he thought nunally was dead
@prohn3898
@prohn3898 6 жыл бұрын
The Genocide was funny af because it caught me of guard But honestly everything he did was for a reason(Even his so called death)...Remember the Evil Paradox he asked Orange Boy?(Don't remember word for word) Be Just and surrender to Evil? Or Use Evil to fight Evil? If you've seen the show its obvious which one he chose to achieve peace.
@theujwalnambiar
@theujwalnambiar 5 жыл бұрын
The dialogue "What do you do when there is an evil you cannot defeat by just means? Do you stain your hands with evil to destroy evil? Or do you remain steadfastly just and righteous even if it means surrendering to evil?"
@VegarotFusion
@VegarotFusion 5 жыл бұрын
Although they show the story ends happily, (after a super sad moment) they could reveal something Lelouch did predict. When the Geass user dies all those under it's influence are released. I thought about this when I remembered Schenizel lives and serves Zero. WHAT IF - Geass influence died with Lalouch? I don't think Schenizel would do anything. He would quickly deduce the situation and what's happening. See the peace created and honor his brothers victory and dying wish.
@michaelkomsky1313
@michaelkomsky1313 6 жыл бұрын
let me answer that question with a little quote from a great book, "Codex Alera", - "The course of history is determined not by battles, by sieges, or usurpations, but by the action of the individuals. The strongest city, the largest army is, at its most basic level, a collection of individuals. Their decisions, their passions, their foolishness, and their dreams shape the years to come. If there is any lesson to be learned from history, it is that all too often the fate or armies, of cities, of entire realms rests upon the actions of one person. In that dire moment of uncertainty, that person's decision, good or bad, right or wrong, big or small, can unwittingly change the world. But history can be quite the slattern. One can never know who that person is, where he might be, or what decision he might make. It is almost enough to make me believe in Destiny." From The writings of Gaius Primus First lord of Alera - it is quite ironic as this paragraph appears in the prologue right after you open the very first book in the series, and only after you finish all 7 books you realize just how much this guy was right.
@polarisp8983
@polarisp8983 6 жыл бұрын
season 3 coming in three months oooooooo
@cestarianinhabitant5898
@cestarianinhabitant5898 6 жыл бұрын
Fully agreed with your video, also I had noticed all the things you mentioned, besides the great man theory anyhow, I'm not a philosophy student or anything... But the guy had another failsafe, in the event that anything goes wrong, he will rise from the grave as an immortal commander to fix it himself; which is what we will no doubt see in R3. It's a damn shame he can't fight like suzaku, but at least he won't be at risk of dying, which unfortunately won't make that much of a difference anyways because it only enables him to stage his own death which provides very limited strategic advantages and can only be done so many times. I can't imagine how peace will break down though, either it's gonna be quite something.... Or it's gonna be the biggest disappointment in my life! BBut it sorta makes sense, that all of these efforts achieved complete peace, but not eternal peace. Only a few years of peace, that is just how hard it is to create and maintain peace.
@angelsoren430
@angelsoren430 6 жыл бұрын
To counter your last point we should also ask "Was Lelouch rise to power a result of him attaining the opportunity (His Geass) to do so?" If so then would that mean "If someone else under the same social conditions as Lelouch had also acquired the same opportunity, would the outcome have been the same for them?". Essentially if society does make the great man then the only factor that makes a great man "great" would be the opportunities they were able to take advantage of. That would mean Opportunity and the ability to take advantage of it is what makes a great man, but if that were the case then someone with the same social outlook as Lelouch would be able to do the same if given the same Opportunity and drive to exploit it to its fullest. However, that would mean great men aren't so great because if Herbet Spencer is to be believed because that means everyone who has the same social outlook would make the same choices given they had the power to do so.
@hyperfox4494
@hyperfox4494 3 жыл бұрын
I kinda always looked at Lelouch as a Christ type character. Taking all the worlds hate and sin and dying for it.
@mackmiller3727
@mackmiller3727 6 жыл бұрын
My biggest problem with lelouch planning for nanalie to take the throne was that she was very easily tricked. I mean schneizel tricked her into shooting nukes at her own brother and put world Peace at risk simply because she was so naive, gullible, and easily swayed. Such a person could never lead a world government competently.
@timothymclean
@timothymclean 3 жыл бұрын
The biggest problem I have with applying the Great Man theory to the real world is that it obscures all the sociological factors that influence events, instead focusing on a handful of men who happen to have been in charge at the right time. Saying that Julius Caesar transformed the Roman Republic into the Roman Empire isn't _incorrect,_ strictly speaking, but it obscures the importance of the factors which let him take power in and reshape Rome. Focusing on the sociological factors at the expense of the "great men" is a sacrifice I'm willing to make, for two reasons. One, _Caesar was not unique._ Others sought power in Rome in much the same way as he did, both during his life and in prior generations; it was only a matter of time before someone tried to claim ultimate power as he did. Two, _Caesar is not alive today, but society is._ Attributing events to the skills and personalities of individuals makes it difficult to learn anything from history except dates and wars, but sociological factors can come up again and again. (And this should go without saying, but you can replace Caesar with any other "great man" from history and my argument would still hold, assuming you also replaced the stuff about Rome with the appropriate place and events.)
@PantsuGod
@PantsuGod 6 жыл бұрын
I'm pretty sure it wasn't said that there was no war or conflict of any kind, in fact they said quite the opposite. Something along the lines of there still being smaller conflicts, but a newfound peace had been formed.
@ZBoy-rc8zf
@ZBoy-rc8zf 6 жыл бұрын
I react to Code Geass cause its greatness
@BBB77132
@BBB77132 4 жыл бұрын
ALL HAIL EMPORER LELOUCH
@magecodi100
@magecodi100 6 жыл бұрын
In regards to the counter argument, could someone else have done it? Yes, but they didn't; that is why these people are the great ones.
@Elly3981
@Elly3981 3 жыл бұрын
I'm not sure if this has any truth to it but I've heard speculation among fans that Lelouch is actually the reincarnation of Dash, a previous contractor and possibly lover of CC's.
@habibisuckslol
@habibisuckslol 3 жыл бұрын
Dash is part of the manga, which is an entirely different story from the anime
@HxH2011DRA
@HxH2011DRA 7 жыл бұрын
Honestly I've always been one to say the great man theory by itself isn't effective as an explanatory framework (geopolitics being a good example as well as how our post neolithic revolution economy has spaced the formation of states around the world independent of any 1 leader) however I don't believe it should be discounted either (Take tesla for example. Had he been a "greater man" in the sense of finding a way to overcome Edison perhaps the entire rest of human history could have changed for the better.) If you combine it with other ideas it enhances both I feel
@KatoBeyond
@KatoBeyond 7 жыл бұрын
I'm not a huge supporter of the Great Man Theory as a model of the real world myself, but I do think it's a worthwhile tool in writing a story with consequences on a global scale. Lelouch's exploits make for a great example of that, which led me to make this video.
@Viciouseee
@Viciouseee 3 жыл бұрын
If the king does not lead how would he expect his subordinate to follow -Lelouch Vi Britannia I mean he really did it his successor follow
@CHITRANSHSHARMA
@CHITRANSHSHARMA 6 жыл бұрын
Why this channel so low on Subs
@khodexus4963
@khodexus4963 5 жыл бұрын
Another story that very much ascribes to the great man theory, and is also one of my personal favorite works of fiction of all time; Babylon 5. If you haven't seen it, you should check it out. You can stream it on Amazon Prime.
@blackrobbingaming1836
@blackrobbingaming1836 6 жыл бұрын
Excellent video
@hankishere007
@hankishere007 6 жыл бұрын
I think Lelouch's peace is doomed to fall apart over time. I'm also convinced he saw this coming and some how became immortal before his "death" in the last episode of R2. Either by taking C.C.'s code or by somehow getting the code that his dad isn't using. I thought this ever since R2 ended and can't wait to see if I'm right in R3. I'm surprised that I haven't heard other fans put forward this idea.
@ittiumimmortal9184
@ittiumimmortal9184 4 жыл бұрын
code geass is my all time favorite anime
@stephantape
@stephantape 4 жыл бұрын
I f*%#king love Code Geass too. I love it so much, my dream is to be a show runner for a live-action series based on it.
@itsvollx9684
@itsvollx9684 6 жыл бұрын
i just found your channel cool
@Warsie
@Warsie 6 жыл бұрын
Just to point out, the post zero requieum plan was not just Schneizel, Zero and Nunnaly. The Black Knights were still there, as well as th UFN. Presumbly after Lenouch was killed, the UFN representatives would be set free - so their rinstitutionl history would be preserved. And given the world of Code Geass seems to have a much weaker sense of a nation-state or westphalian sovereignty, it would be less a great man theory in that case and more a case of institutional maturity. though the great man theory does work in lelouch's older plans. Also you know Charles Zi Brittania was planning something similar with breaking the sword of akasha, but that's not per se geopolitics or international relations.
@zieknight5875
@zieknight5875 6 жыл бұрын
It crazy i won't cry for sad movie(romance) but i cry due to Lelouch's sacrifice 😭😭😭 He gave up his everything to create a better world
A Psychological Analysis of C.C.'s Death Wish
8:51
Kato
Рет қаралды 102 М.
Determining the Best Episode of Code Geass
18:37
Kato
Рет қаралды 171 М.
Little brothers couldn't stay calm when they noticed a bin lorry #shorts
00:32
Fabiosa Best Lifehacks
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН
Секрет фокусника! #shorts
00:15
Роман Magic
Рет қаралды 45 МЛН
Nurse's Mission: Bringing Joy to Young Lives #shorts
00:17
Fabiosa Stories
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
هذه الحلوى قد تقتلني 😱🍬
00:22
Cool Tool SHORTS Arabic
Рет қаралды 57 МЛН
Why Owlman Works and The Batman Who Laughs Doesn't
32:41
Batspecter
Рет қаралды 2,2 МЛН
The Importance of Mao In Code Geass
7:41
Kato
Рет қаралды 177 М.
How each Batman understood the character
22:56
Lancelloti
Рет қаралды 853 М.
Top 10 Most Philosophical Anime
27:29
Max Derrat
Рет қаралды 35 М.
When You Play The Villain A Little Too Well...
15:07
Renzy
Рет қаралды 904 М.
When Lelouch Stopped Using Geass
17:10
Kato
Рет қаралды 30 М.
Should Themes Trump Logic - Code Geass' Chess Treatment
10:52
Replay Value
Рет қаралды 147 М.
Little brothers couldn't stay calm when they noticed a bin lorry #shorts
00:32
Fabiosa Best Lifehacks
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН