C#/D5* 😏

@@BAZISSINO94 her D5 is kinda questionable sometimes, C5/C#5 is fine for now

@@endutzky Hmm did you watch her recent songs ? she phrase D5s just fine, whiny but not too tense.

@@bigmamafan1773 yea her recent D5 is fine, but its not enough material, lets wait her D5 more its a bit similar with haewon's case, her old D5 is questionable but her recent D5 is good, thats why we need to wait, however yeah i can see why yall gave her C#5/D5

@@BAZISSINO94 we’ll talk about it when you quit gate keeping and drop those Ds🤣

guess i’m a bit of a diviner then because nobody told me about her😅 lmao

Her cover of "Fate" is literally spamming vibrato

4th is my channel main thingy not necessarily my fave🤣 personally haven’t heard her doing alright enough above C5 consistently but i might have missed some

i don’t, unfortunately. but i can tell from the top of my head that Sunset had B3 on the verses, mixed E5 on Jihyo’s chorus and falsetto up to F#5 on Nayeon’s. Mina sings E5 at highest, it’s falsetto too. After Moon had C5s in the chorus and D5s by NaHyo, falsetto also goes up to F#5 and Sana hits F#3 on the first verse.

@@sootzubae wow, Thank you so much for your response! I really appreciate that

she is, i think Sonamoo debuted in 2014 or something and their songs were main bangers but their company were… erh

@@sootzubae ohh sonamoo, wasn't expecting it but nice... it quite unfortunate, actually no... just down bad that the company is like that ;-; checked out their songs and they're really good ;-; a wasted potential 🥲

​@@sootzubae btw she debut solo last year i believe. So, can She include as 4th gen soloist ?

@@light_bit no that’d be like including Nayeon as a 4th gen soloist, she officially debuted/was more active in the 3rd

​@@sootzubae i mean. Her group already over at 2021. And she now more of soloist out of her group. Her ex company also gone because of bankrupt. So, i just thought that maybe she can sneak into 4th gen.

sumi jo - if i leave

i’m not familiar and i don’t think she has enough material yet, nor that she’s on par with Haely whose are not at the same level to begin with. i think that Nvee girl is A, maybe A to AA but nothing more than that

This was already discussed tho. She's nowhere near them, she's a bit below Seulgi.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bMdmabZ-3pmpoZ8.html you mean this one?

​@@sootzubae yepp thanks a bunch 😊

she’s aa (not sure)

@@PauloLima-gk2uh i am also not sure so let's wait for sootzubae to reply

yeah i give her AA but a mid one aaat most because her fifth octave is not always cute

@@sootzubae Some of the clips you used are old though, I have looked into her recent ost and comeback and support seem consistent up to around C#5 atleast even if whiny.

@@bigmamafan1773 some? i think most are old because her recent stuff ain’t making up a video i know u know that😂 i’ve been told that, think i saw that too… not against giving it in i don’t think that changes LOTS in her ranking though

High.D was sent in other kshows too and regarding Minjae i believe she’s either A or A to AA, i also plan a showcase for her so we will know soon

​@@sootzubaeFor a moment i though you started using letter tiers but then i realised High.D is a name 😭

​​@@sootzubae How about the lead, Euijin? W-A?

@@pretendtheresaname9213 yeah Eunjin is W to A

higher than i initially thought lol not sure yet how high but i’d guess on the higher parts, ahead of Haewon and all

Lol the "!!!" But yeah agreed

AA

Yoohyeon, Siyeon, Sua and Jiu can

yes