+Miranda Phelan (Beaniegurlz) I second that!

He'd be thrilled that Lady Gaga performed it. She lives it.

Yaaaassss speaking facts ❤️❤️❤️

@@sharonsparks900 Absolutely. John Lennon would have loved this - and loved her, too.

For sure!

Couldn't have said it better myself :)

+Ninguém Me Segura I thought he committed suicide.

+X Moore No he was murdered taken out into a field and beaten so badly he died in the hospital 2 days later. He died october 12th 1998. Even though I never knew him and I was just a child I will forever remember what that day means.

You have my full respect. Your truth that you typed touched my heart because of how pure and true it was. Im not even kidding. Thank you for that, man.

I have no words but just to say thank you for this really

She is so amazing. I pulled off 'Edge of Glory' at a karaoke night, once, and it felt beautiful. I taught the infant daughter of some of my dearest friends (the girl's name is Athena) to dance to that song before she was even a year old. That little girl still smiles and runs up to me whenever she sees me, and I think Gaga deserves some of the credit for that.

'girl' lol

Jess T Lady Gaga is a girl, yeah.

Agree!

@@kristinajonsson7497 shes a woman plz have sum respect

I think it sounds good only when Lennon sings it

***** That is one strong opinion, and a little harsh.

***** - Glad to see that the song has really spoken to your soul and has made you so peaceful. That was sarcasm, in case it was lost on you. This is why the world has no peace. Someone can't even have a differing opinion without people like you getting all militant.

george foster too bad john lennon only wanted peace for white, heterosexual, cis males... whereas gaga actually wants equality for everyone

lord lucy Just stop. Please.

Amazing, right

too genius 🙌🏼

@@dutchvanderlinde7494 Dutch, why are you watching Lady Gaga when you should be making your plan?

nunya biznez Preach!

true dat

+nunya biznez exacto.... is simply hear the message this song.....

well said..

YEPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP A BIG APPLAUSE FOR YOU

Yesss

YAAAASSSSS! best comment ;D

This made my day thanks :D ♥

Teubees DeBunker woehoe we got a jealous bitch here! Shut up and go f*ck yourself :)

Same❤

I've been saying that I feel as Gaga is not my idol but my friend like I feel like I know her but don't, that's how you know she is close with her fans

💓

Still so powerful

that's right, i know people may argue that it's just a parasocial relationship, but it's strange, it's like i feel like i've known her forever or from a past life, she's just so close to my heart, no other pop artist or celebrity causes that in me.

Today too;)

@@christinehall1316 And tomorrow!

@@amigopiojo11 and forever ❤️

And ever 💖

Lukey Gaga she sings here so gooooood that all their favs can't sing like she did here XD

no wasnt great

well ya the piano has changed alot over the years

are you sure it is the best one. how about john lennon's one? are u kidding?

each piano has its uniqueness my piano(harvard and son) is good when pedaling some pianos have better natural sounds. of course the pianist improves it further. sorry about lennon i was in a psychopathic condition but now i have recovered.

Bullshit. Exhume Lennon's corpse and his dead ass will still give a better performance than this garbage.

I do fucking know that. But the fact that she didn't write the song doesn't mean she can't share lennon's message now that he unfortunately can't spread it anymore. Your point doesn't make sense. So according to you someone who cares about a certain message and try to spread it, as she did covering this wonderful song, is an attention whore? Judging her because of her eccentricity and her appearance is only for narrow minded people. I'm not saying that she's a legend like lennon, but I think she's trying to do her best to spread a message of peace and your comment doesn't get on with lennon's ideas. And yoko ono is gaga's friend and I am sure she was very glad of that, and so would john.

Evie Hammond and it did

no she wasn't. but she have played his piano though. Sean Lennon twitpic'd it and caused a minor uproar. pretty sad how people who adore Lennon are able to give that much hate.

Its a real piano :3, she's so fab, lennon its so fab. both are so great.

chaiburana I was aware that Yoko let her play John's piano. It was this knowledge that led me to believe the piano in the video was his. I think she purposefully selected one of this make and color to resemble his.

GengarLyrics I prefer her acoustic piano performs to her electronic dance-pop tracks. Both are good, but her live, raw, lounge-singer-esque performances are clearly superior. She certainly has my respect as one of the world's best performers and musicians.

George Michael had John Lennons piano that he played imagine on And it wasn’t the one in the video

or they just don't like the cover....

I don't see where's problem

so everybody who didn't like this cover is automaticly a hater? That's a childish way of thinking, isn't it? You do realize that with the way you talk about the disslikers, you are the hater? :-) More important, by hating you'r totaly missing the point of this song. Maybe your love for Gaga is clouding your mind a bit?

I wrote this because I've seen in many comments from fans of other artists, who Interpreted this song, criticized the interpretation of Lady Gaga. It was mostly Madonna's fans. There's nothing wrong and no, I'm not a hater :)

Flip Tee she teased speechless with this performance :) it was intentional...shes so great! no word!

ember fly Except for religions like Lavayan Satanists. They are cool! My sons mothers religion ( Jehovah's Witnesses) is a cancer that is malignant.

QueenFanPiper62 I'm an atheist also, but Jehovahs Witness - Although a faulty religion - isn't such a bad one. It promotes the thing most religions do, like no Lying, stealing, cheating etc. Although I'm not JW, they're not bad people.

Cheyenne Stirling they brainwash their people. Just look what they forbidd you because of a stupid fucking imaginary book.

TheBlueberrychips I know their rules. No witchcraft. No celebrations. Nothing like that. And I don't agree with anything they say. But if people want to believe and agree with those rules then let them. But as soon as they start forcing it onto people then I have a problem. But as far as I'm concerned the PEOPLE aren't bad... I'm an atheist so I agree mostly with what you said lol

***** That's what I'm saying. JW is a faulty religion. But judging the people that choose to agree with the person who changed the rules is kinda ignorant.

Женя Коваленко Maybe someday...

Женя Коваленко I'm guaranteeing it

Bogart Shears thank you, you must be a good person :)

The life is for them, the people who live in peace. No cares if are other people that make war, and hate, if are people who live in peace.

Женя Коваленко Unfortunately not. Einstein once said that as long as there are humans, there will be wars.

mi gusta

you mean that's the REAL john's piano? the one that he always playing to?

+Sir Winston Lennon u fucking kidding me with this b8?

+Sir Winston Lennon gr8 b8 m8 i r8 8/8

+TheSeriousDirector You're too serious.

Alysha Ray u fell for the b8 m8 run fast m8 before spooky pill man chases u

+Alysha Ray she sang it with passion but that's John Lennon's song

TRUE

And honestly, in what universe would Lennon be mad at people covering his song about universal love, acceptance and tearing down walls that separate people from each other? Could he even fucking disapprove of this without demonstrating incredible hypocrisy?

people don't like it when others cover Lennon's songs

lennon fans with tiny mind

+Frank Warhol yeah of course not the fact she can't sing

You must be deaf.

Starman Gaga can't sing? lol u must live in a cave to have not seen the oscar last year. And let's be honest, you say that someone can't sing being a bowie's fan? c'mon bro