you can tell, when someone knows what she is talking about! And Mariah knows Music. She really understands it. All aspects of it. Even if this is a show, her knowledge and love for music shines through!

A judge with a brain, humility, experience and a heart of gold! 💛

You can tell Mariah really wanted to help and took her job seriously. I wish she did another idol.

Mariah definitely knows how to sing and what kind of technical abilities she needs to use, that is what I love in Mariah

THIS IS ACTUALLY THE MOST USEFUL INSIGHTFUL PROFOUND JUDGING IVE EVER SEEN IN ANY TALENT TV SHOW. MC IS THE BEST.

MC is so humble so kind

shes the best judge of all season on AI.

She gives the feedback in a loving way, not an awkward, condescending way. Love her.

This woman is resplendent. I love Mariah to bits.

Mariah shines through her true words and through being natural as she truly is, can be and always remain!

She deserves to be the judge of all time on music industry. Go Mariah.

this shows that the season what just Mariah and Nicki fighting as the media or ppl portray it to be. Mariah was by far the best judge here. she was an experienced musician who gave objective and constructive criticism.

Mariah looks so young here wow

(9:37) for the people wondering, “tour de force” is an achievement or performance that shows great skill and attracts admiration ❤️

I love Mariah Carey red dress

Her look is so natural and classy at the same time

she seems really sweet... like a nice person like she always tried to say things in the nicest possible way and i respect that. i respect when ppl deliver honesty with kindness. some people think the two are antitheses of each other and its stupid. you can be honest and also be nice.

Mariah is the best judge ever, want her back on a show so bad rn😭

Her vocabulary is so big

Such a legend Mariah! Nicki was struggling!

I love Mariah she is a legend and her voice takes me somewhere else I’ve never been

imagine having mariah carey, only the greatest vocalist/songwriter of all time, as your mentor

Why Nicki is giving us attitude and she’s there texting on camera on a live show ? Like why ? And people said Mariah was dramatic during Idol !

Think of the insanely useful insight and advice Mariah could give a singer? She’s the greatest vocalist of all time and she’s so well-schooled on the technical side of singing. It’s so sad that Nicki inserting herself for drama overshadowed the purpose Mariah could’ve served the contestants.

The Biggest Female Vocalist Ever 🦋🦋🦋💖

Does Mariah even know how perfect and unique of a LEGEND she is??! Clearly she is a beautiful person the diva is just an act... We see it here!

Mariah looks absolutely gorgeous stunning like the fierce Queen she is

She’s so legendary ❤️

Mariah is ageless, the wand thing at the beginning is so youthful lmao

This is one of the moments when Nikki Minaj looking so insesure as ever. Mariah outshined her and Mariah will always be the diva.

The QUEEN. The GOAT. Simply MC

Mariah is very true and kind😍😘😘

Mariah is so down to earth and real. She was amazing on the show. So loving.

Mariah at the first minute 😂😂😂 And Nicki was like😒😒😒

Mariah really is a good coach!!

TV is not ready for a real singer/composer/producer with 19 #1 hits to give the best feedback possible

I loved when they said ‘happy birthday’ and we know Mariah doesn’t acknowledge age and time and birthdays so.. she just ignored

She is soooo good at this. So positive

The legendary.. The icon... The Queen Mariah

Nicki pressed asf 😂

Mariah is the definition of Diva

She looks super beautiful!

mariah was the only one who was vocal in the panel.

When Mariah does something, she puts her whole heart, soul and mind to it..even being a judge on this show (even though she hated doing AI). Legendary, Classy, Loveable.

Mariah is noy just a judge but also a coach

That is when a truly artist who can sing and knows music and be the judge.. perfecto. 🌺🌺

mariah carey is a kind sweet goddess.

I love mariah. And it was really funny when she was playing with that little wand😂

Her voice was so high and clear this episode

Mariah being a star as always, judging so classy and Nicki with that bad attitude the whole time, what's wrong with her?

Love mariah

It was mariah's birthday (anniversary) that day.

Just when you thought you couldn't hate NM any more.

Thank god atleast from the first place in this video the camera was only towards Mariah Carey from whom we can learn so much bcz she is a musical genius...and we love to hear her music .....she has so much knowledge, plus she never exaggerates about herself...she talks real sense...and I love it how nikki is pissed off here with jealous expressions...more power to you mariah ... .ur a genuine artist Mariah🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹!!!!!

I wish she'll do The Voice, she would be great as a coach

Mariah Carey is a legend, I love her. I don't even know why Nicki Minaj would beef her! They're worlds apart!

Miriah Carey is such a icon! They should introduce her in a better way!

Best judge and most competent judge ever on American idol!

Mariah made the show so much longer with those comments that go on for infinity everytime!

She's a good mentor

I can listen to her talk all day. Thank you @LegendaryMariah for sharing this. 💕🦋 You got Nicki from Queens and Mariah the Long Islander

Ryan being shady and letting she ppl know Nicki has on too muh perfume 😂

I love her omg

Minaji is a product of an American populism. Hard working is great but person needs a moral values and good virtues. She seems insecure and defensive which makes a very unpleasant experience. Mariah is obviously in a different class.. gentle and very graceful.

Love you MIMI

Mariah amazing love her from malaysia

It was a tour de force !!! ❤❤❤ love u Mariah !

BEST JUDGE ON IDOL - MARIAH CAREY !!! XXX

Mariah really and truly respects artists as free-minded individuals who have the right to picl and choose how they use their talents. Love that ❤

Mariah is just pretty as heaven 🥺

Thank you

The way she ignored the birthday comment

Mariah Looks like as if she is doing a TV Show guesting and promoting her Butterfly Single

omg me and Mariah have the fave Smokey song

Why does Nicki looks so put off and depressed throughout the entire video?

*She wished Mariah a happy birthday but Mariah doesn’t have birthdays, she has anniversaries. That’s why Mariah didn’t say thank you to her lol* 😂❤️

Nikki's look while Mariah is trying to express herself trying to say her point and implementing the contestants...is kind of disrespectful. It's like she doesn't like to listen to her. Hhmmmm, Nikki has attitude and I don't think it's nice. Mariah is a legend, she's one of the greatest female artist have collaborated with greatest female artists like Whitney Houston. Mariah knows what she is talking about she has been in the music business for a very long time and made hit songs and albums! But despite if her being a legend, she is still humble and trying to help the idol contestants. Nikki needs to be humble.

"Happy birthday from us by the way" Mariah: ... Dahlinggg, we don't count numbers

Mariah taught me tour de force.

Towards the end of the vid nicki looks agitated asf lol

3:09 Did anyone notice, she was wished a happy birthday, and never said thank you. Lol!

Mariah really loves Aretha Franklin!

QUEEN MARIAH CAREY ws perfectly beautiful the whole of her 'American Idol' Time. She's Soooo BeautifulbOn Every Episode And She Did A Great Job With Her Judging Also Because She Finds And Uses The Right And Politest Works Towards The Contestants. 🎤🎼❤🙏😇. The devil MonCki sitting 2nd from the left has all her horms raising the whole time on all of the episodes. 😏.

Omgg Mariah stole Sailor Moon's zepter(sp?) wand!

She should be a judge again regarding about singing competition.

4:32 mariah belting hahaha

Mariah should return this body, make up and Hairstyles.

Mariah at 1:34 be like Ahhehehhahhhh😂 i love you mariah

Nicki is so unprofessional.

Could you imagine Mariah Carey spends a long time giving you valuable advice and your response is "I just wanna have fun" 😳

She's like Alicia in The Voice but 10x as competent and with 10x less wishy-washy spiritual nonsense

nicki is always pissed in this video, And mariah as a SINGER can relate, And judge them accordingly,

Look at Nikki’s stank face… 👑 Mariah killed it on the feedback & always tried to lift someone up rather than tear em down & Nikki’s just mad that Mariah sold more records, got more money, probably looks better than she will at her age, got a better voice, been around a hell of a lot longer than she will, etc. etc. Nikki need to get herself some Jesus 🙏🏽💯

Wow Nicki definitely wasn't having a good day

For those who don't understand" Mariah is eternally 12 ok?! That's why she's mimiing sometimes 😂😂😂

Tour de force

𝙼𝙲!!!!!!!!!!!!

Look at nicki's attitude 🥴

I still don’t know why they did they chose Nicki to be judge so bazaar and weird

NICKI LOOKS BITTER