If you’re staying some place five days a week, YOU LIVE THERE! Plus she didn’t have a job, so how was she maintaining a separate home??? BS

I disagree with the ruling on the utilities the girlfriend was home on bed rest when they were gone to work using the utilities more than both of them.

The pregnant girlfriend's portion should be the responsibility of the plaintiff! The defendant should not have to cover her portion. That is ridiculous that the plaintiff even tried that.

“She ended up getting pregnant” you mean you got her pregnant? Lol sheesh

I would have had defendant pay 1/3 only because the agreement was broken when he moved in his girlfriend....

The defendant seems pretty remorseful at the end. Hopefully they can move forward as friends.

The defendant seems like a sweetheart

Defendant walks in empty handed, all bad bro

The entire time she was there the rent should have been split three ways. Especially the utilities definitely 1/3 there The plaintiff should have been responsible for two-thirds of the rent because he brought her in

My favorite part is when the women come in with a designer bag posted right at the front of their body lol. It never fails

Harvey levin what a flatbread and silly boy he spoils the show

I so don't agree that he should have to pay for the other guys girlfriend living there and using utilities just because she was out of a job. If that's the case it's her BFs job to cover her part, not the roommate - what's he get out of paying her rent and utilities? Disappointed in this verdict big time

I think that verdict was crazy..why did the judge make him to pay utilities when he didn't use it.. and his girlfriend moved in too.. very unfair. There are times where the judges ruling is unreasonable.

Living with someone I work with is a no no for me. I just can’t do it and next thing stuff like this happens and then it gets hella awkward

He says “she got pregnant” as if he had nothing to do with it

I’ve been in situations where my roommate had a girlfriend or boyfriend who are there all the time but claims to just be “visiting “. The plaintiff excuse was she “got” pregnant or didn’t have a job. In the words of Judge Judy….who cares. You are eating the steak. You have to pay for it.

Mmmmm....now I want a sausage biscuit and some hash browns.

The defendant is dressed like he just coming from the gym. Lol

Judge is wrong this time!!! So the pregnant girlfriend gets a free ride on his "friend"... sad!

Glad they are showing cases on KZfaq.. full ones too.

The defendant looks perfect for the role of a goodlooking Lex Luthor.

Do people always think when they live in a roomate situation, it is okay to move in another person? This happens alot.

5:51 when the defendant and judge both say ‘ummmm’ at the same time lol

Idk about him paying half of the utility bills for months he didn’t live there

I never understand the “I paid cash, so there was no receipt” excuse. Have you ever bought an item at a store with cash? Did the cashier give you a receipt? 🤦‍♀️

There is no way that I would pay still pay half of the rent if my roommate moved in their significant other. The defendant was a nice guy to agree to that. The plaintiff should have paid two thirds of the rent on behalf of his girlfriend since she wasn’t working. I will never understand why people who chose to play house without the funds to do so decide to put that burden on other people. If you want to cohabitate that’s fine but the full cost of that should be on you.

I just don't agree with judge this time I think because of the girlfriend living there not just coming around he broke the agreement

She should have charged him only a third of the utilities the girlfriend was definitely living there the whole time

Everyone has a phone with a camera that records video, Record the exchange of money, I’ve done this and it protects you from people “forgetting” the exchange happened.

Between the ages of 21 and 23 I lived with different coworkers. Half of those living situations were absolute nightmares. When you have to live with the same person that you see at work all day they end up just tap dancing on your nerves. Even the ones you like can get on your nerves but thankfully my last roommate situation ended up being one of my best friend for 15 years as of now.

I attempted to coexist with a coworker in a 2 bedroom apt. She was looking for a place and my roommate was moving out. 2 years later, I now know that was a poor decision on my part. I barely knew the girl and if I would have paid more attention to her as far as how she carries herself, how she speaks to people, how she manages her life, Her standards (which I soon found were very low)...I would have known not to trust her or to allow her in my space. She was lazy, always had random men over (and then got mad when people started to notice in the building lol smh), always in competition, always needed to be gassed up because she had SUCH low self-esteem, and never held herself accountable for her bad decisions. Living with her was a lot, I became the person to help her get a HOME, a job, a man smfh ALL BECAUSE SHE DIDNT WANT TO DO THESE THINGS FOR HERSELF. Now I also know she used me because I have the drive, determination, and follow through to get what I want in life. Rather than adopted that mentality and gaining those skills she just used me. I learned from that time in my life and now I'm not pressed for friends who are dependent of everyone around them lol

So the guys were getting along until girlfriends got involved. The story of life.

Why does he pay half when the plaintiff admitted the rent being divided by three and why does the girl friend lives for free

So ummm the girlfriend just get off scott free because she didn’t have a job? If I lose my job I still have to pay my rent & bills period. The judge should have held her responsible for something

Wow that's awesome they both agree that everything will get taken care of but will remain friends. And the defendant was honest about it all.

Good for the defendant for being a nice guy.

I wonder if the landlord knew and/or allowed his tenant to sublease the apartment? Because if the plaintiff isn't allowed to sublease, but did so anyway, twice, the plaintiff didn't come to court with "clean hands".

So much for taking into account that he didn't mitigate his damages🤣

The Complainant is a Con Job. Why should the defendant pay for the gf ? 😤😤😤

the number of times "we were friends" was thrown around seemed odd. I would not consider someone I met in 2-3s of a job orientation a "friend". These must be lonely people. P. said the D. moved out because he got a gf but the D. said he left and went back to his parents' home. Sounds like he just wanted out since it became awkward with the P.'s gf/baby situation and 4-5 nights per week....I consider that moved in. Rent should have been split 3 ways with 3 people, you don't pony up for "your friend's" gf.

Sounds like a man crush.. lol

"When she's on bed rest, whose bed is she resting on?" LOLOL🤣

Plaintiff lied, at first he said she moved in after the guy left, his story changed quick.

While sausage egg mcmuffins are tasty I prefer a sausage egg mcgriddle personally 😋

Bad judgement...if a roommate moves in another person, he is not liable to pay the agreed amount as its a violation of lease agreement.

I disagree on this... He moved his GF in and nullified his own agreement and then to make the defendant pay half of utilities when there’s already another person living there after he left is crazy. The initial story sounds a little suspect to me. I mean, you want who you want but the buying him a sausage sandwich breakfast leading to him moving in........ We know what was REALLY served. 🤣 He didn’t want his gf (who’s really pretty, BTW) to find out.

I lived with the defendant prior to this guy. Pretty cool dude

Defendant seems so chill.

This verdict! 🙄Plaintiff says because they were friends, yet he is the one taking major advantage of charging him for half yet he is the one with his girlfriend, just because it was not originally agreed on for her to live there the fact was she did end up living there. Defendant should have put his foot down from the beginning and never agreed for such ridiculous thing. His girlfriend, his responsibility.

Verdict was fair... only 1/3rd of the rent, because he was 1/3rd of the occupancy. Too bad he agreed to 1/2 the utilities, because he was only owed 1/3rd of those bills, too.

Living with someone that you work with would absolutely be ridiculous and awkward. 🤣 It's like seeing the person 24/7. 😵😳

WTH he moves in his girlfriend but the other guy still pays half?

They keep talking about this woman being unemployed and pregnant, yet she has no shame clutching that Chanel bag 😅. Priorities 🤷‍♀️

He should have just moved in some jobless women too. See how sexist the judge can be.

Don't know if all or ANY do this but, if you have someone stay or let someone stay 4 days or more that is most of a week being weeks are 7 days. Therefore 4 days should be recognized as living in that place even if you have your mail or a lease somewhere else. That is more than half of a week so that person should be paying half of the rent for those weeks.

The defendants eyes were constantly half closed and drifting , I think I know why he never had any money.

Very generous of the plaintiff of the move his girlfriend in and have his roommate Help pay for it.

If your roommate moves their lover into the house..... move. Right now. Don't wait, don't agree to split costs 3 ways. It's no longer your home when that "partner" moves in. It becomes their home and you're a "guest" paying their bills. In this particular case, it's a disaster. She "needs bedrest" because she got casually pollinated? Bollocks. I've been through this. Shared a house with a longtime buddy, everything was great until he suddenly moved HER (and her illegitimate daughter) in. It immediately because "House Of Susan". Her tantrums ruled the house, everything had to be HER way, however minor, and he was too whipped to set her straight, so I quickly moved into a place by myself. Then she was furious that my rent money disappeared, and raged at him more. I lost a once-great friend over this. Never be a single person roommating with a couple.

Wow 5 days a week. She should pay too

This case is a prime example of why someone should never ever do roommates. The moment the defended saw the plaintiffs girlfriend was sleeping there 4/5 times a week he should had said something about it right there especially when she don't have a job. Then gets pregnant, again no jo due to bed rest. That rent should have been split 3 ways from the moment he saw that, job or no job, let the plaintiff pay his girlfriends half. 1 or 2 nights sleeping over I would understand but not 4/5.

If he is getting kicked out of his place....Maybe juuuuussstttt MAYBEEEE he shouldnt move in with you..hmmm ya think!!!??!!🤔🤔🤔🤔🤑🤑🤑🤑🤗🤗🤗🤗🤣🤣🤣🤣🤭🤭🤭😏😏😏😒😒😒🙄🙄🙄🤥🤥🤥🤥🤢🤮🤧🥵🥶🥴😵🤯🤠🥳😎🧐😳😕😓😢😫🥱😤😤😤😤😤😡😡😡😡😠😠😠😠🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠

Plaintiff's girlfriend is so beautiful and has an equally beautiful and infectious smile.😍

i like the judge but this ruling sucks. both parties agree they had an agreement then changed it when the girlfriend moved in. she never moved out so why would the defendant pay half? Judge says "I changed my mind" because he should have had the money to pay but still the bills don't add up. In my opinion, he owed march and april 1/3 rent and bills anything else is hormonal not objective lol.

Another comment. The plaintiff doesn’t realize how cool the housemate he had. Some housemates will teach you the meaning of the word “drama”.

I feel sorry for the defendant

People who do not love each other and are not committed to each other (i.e. committed to work things out when times are tough) should not attempt to live together, especially if they are friends.

Hey! It's One Punch Man!👍(for my anime fans😏)

Wow I can't believe the judge made that decision. Poor defendant get a backbone please

Wow these guys responded so good and mature!.. Wonder if girls in same situation would behave like this 😂

Defendant looks like a random NPC in GTA!

The girlfriend is lazy and a freeloader, should have been 333 from the get go

He shouldn’t have to pay may if he got his stuff in April lol

That's why you couldn't pay me enough to have a roomie - can't stand living with frauds

Think they work in IT?

So they were hook ups that decided to move together, he got jealous he got back with his ex and sued, got it

Hmmmm, seems to me that these two dudes fell in love at first sight, as they nibbled on their sausage McMuffins together, so they moved in together, to share in sweet man love, hehehe. Then, the plaintiff moves his "girlfriend," in and his lover got jealous, and moved out and back to mommy and daddy's, hehehe!!!

What condition does she have that she's on bedrest in the first trimester? Did she still have that baby, because that sounds like an EXTREMELY DANGEROUS pregnancy. It also sounds, to the rest of us who worked (sometimes manual labor) up until the day before we gave birth, like BS. And it doesn't matter anyway. If there are three roommates, things are divided in thirds. Two thirds are the plaintiff and his gf, one third is the defendant. If his girlfriend can't work because he got her pregnant, that's not the roommate's problem. 2/3 rent utilities etc are the plaintiff's problem.

Defendant is paperless! Oh, boy! 🍿🍿🍿😂😂🇺🇸

I let a coworker move in cause his girlfriend was cheating, she kicked him out and tore up his I.D which made things hard for him because he didn't have money saved to get a place and winter was coming he literally hanged out at work. So he moved in always paid the rent on time, was respectful and clean the only thing was he played on his X box with other players and would cuzz once in while but it's wasn't a problem, he was a nice guy. The funny part was he told me it's only going to be temporary, 3 years later he moved out and got his own place LOLOLOL We still see each other at work, he's over nights and I work during the day. I told him if something ever happens and needs a place he will always be welcomed back. I lucked out

I'm over here paying over 1k a month on my own for my rent and my 3 vehicles all by myself and he can't come up with 333, I don't know how much he gets paid but it has to be low or he is waisting all his money and that's why he had to move in with his parents. I have not lived with my parents for 12 years and I want to NEVER go back but if I have to I'll just go to a shelter instead 😅

They'd make a cute couple.

He DOES owe but plaintiffs girlfriend should pay too. I hate when they do that.

Judge Judy would never allow a defendant to stand before her with his hands in his pockets

It’s kinda of dicey but the original agreement was only between them the girlfriend only came into the picture later. Plus he was the one on the lease.

I think the girlfriend should pay a 3rd of utilities because more is used, but as far as rent, if she is in the plaintiff's room she isn't taking up any more space. Now if she has her own room then yeah a 3rd of the rent as well.

Plaintiff was hot for the defendant.

I see everyone keep saying don't be housemates with your coworker. But for me, I feel more secure having a coworker as a housemate cause then I can keep track of the person at work haha. It's safer (for me) that way than having a random person as housemate that might steal your stuff or disappear and not paying rent. Lucky me I have been with the same housemate/coworker since 2015 and she is the most trustworthy no drama friend ever.

Coworkers in my opinion should not date ,fool around, move in ,hang out etc. 99% of the time it goes bad

The defendant was nearly homeless and then complains the place is too small and in the end moves back in with his parents, so his sob story of having nowhere to go was false, he played on the plaintiff's good nature and then tried to screw him...

My advice: It’s okay to roommate or date someone at your job, ONLY if you are willing/prepared to quit if it doesn’t work out. It may not come to that, but one should be prepared.

At least the defendant owns not being good with money. So many people screw their roommates/land lords and then blame THEM for not paying their rent.

I dont think u r supposed to wear that kind of t-shirt w those kind of dress pants. Red flag!!!!

“She got pregnant,” as if he didn’t have anything to do with it. 🙄

she was laying around the house unemployed getting screwed and prego

The people in the background are funny in this show. lol

does anyone else have a problem with the plaintiff bumping uglies with the girlfriend WHILE LIVING WITH THE DEFENDANT???

I moved in with a co worker when I was 21. Everything was great for s few months but then she kept having her bf there all the time...Including times she wasn't home. It ended badly but ended pretty good for her. She ended up marrying my then bf at the time and lived happily ever after 😄

Why can she not get a job from home....🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Why have Harvey on?

The defendant looks like a slow Channing Tatum 🤣🤣