That businessman just wants money. He has no nationalism.

Excellent answer from Jaishanker ji No amount of praise is sufficient for Jaishankeji It is common sense Life can't be usual where national security is threatened Pak is bankrupt surprising some business men still want to do business China is most untrustworthy past experience has shown Common sense dictates avoid and look for alternatives

EAM & foreign affairs dealings are at diamond era😊

Excellent reply!!

Dr Jaishankar is the best EAM the country has produced. He is crystal clear in thoughts and exceptional in expression

Excellent.... Always. I hope others learn from him.

German Shepherd: Namashkar Dosto! Do we need manufacturing in India? Dimag par jor daalke dekhiye.

“If the Indian option is available, it is good for our national security…and even to our business in the long run”…who can put it in a better way 🙏🏼

I'm wondering why these businesses can't work to find alternate destinations for sourcing their input materials or markets. But they constantly complain about something more to do with these two hostile neighbours, who've shown no intention to change.

Make jaishankar PM and India will travel the distance between a literate nation and a Educated nation.

APART FROM BEING AN EXCELLENT FOREIGN AFFAIRS MINISTER, HE IS ALSO A VERY GREAT STATESMAN.

Dr jaishankar is the master in his craft 🙏

Manufacturing needs 3-4 things Land Law - easy to get land for factories Labour law - easy to hire and fire people Judiciary law - to quickly fix the court cases arising from above two

Such meaningful debates and clarity of thought from our EAM Sri Jai Shankar gives us lot of hope and optimism about the future of this Nation Bharat in reaching greater heights.

India thinks of China day and night. China thinks who's India.

Is india accumulating adversaries in the neighbourhood as well as elsewhere in the world? Are we erring on the wrong side? Can inflammatory diplomacy delivered in bold and decisive style be helpful? Yes, it is already helping in escalating tensions. World has been taking the cues emanating from India in the past 10 years with regard to external affairs. Now, perhaps the processing of the same has begun. India - China border piece, Qatar appeasement, India out from Maldives, US threatening to sanction etc. We may witness increase in the outputs directed against India more often, in not so friendly ways, from various quarters. That would only be fair.

No business is the best business with pakistan😂😂

He is a trader more than a business man.

The businessman in India are gaining with the business with China because their less expensive goods are sold in India for a higher price.

Excellent answer as always

Unless regulated, indian industry is all about sourcing and selling with very little low tech product development. What if war in the next few years prevents sourcing of materials, components, kits and sub-assemblies from various countries? Can you survive?

Shamelessly Indian Businesses want all resources but no national interest

But in today's interdependence world one can't sustain alone. China's raw materials can't be boycotted, not even the US can do it. Why not India, China and Russia collaborate on business and security??? Why bear doubts and suspicion on each other and slow down the potential for development of infrastructure in the region???

"Aman ki Asha ka tamaasha" gang is enemy of Bharat in every way.

AmaraRaja Group which makes Amaron batteries recently stepped up into Lithium battery production amd also acquired the Bengaluru based battery R&D start up called Log9. Most of the world's lithium comes from china, hence he's worried. Also the Chairman Jayadev Galla is Loksabha MP from TDP.

HE REFLECTED THE MOOD OF THE COUNTRY , THE DIRECTION , RESPECTED THE IDEA OF STABILTY 4 FOR FIRMS..ECONMIC MASTERCLASS

It is Line of Control , Line of Actual Control & Working Boundary.

very well explained.

My one question to this businessman : If your neighbor slaps you then he will say lets do some business and have peaceful talks, would you do business ?

Meanwhile Indian businessman to china 🤩💵 💵 💵

The country of C poses a significant security threat to India and its population. It is crucial for businessmen to grasp the common sense notion that if C threatens the well-being of Indian citizens, it ultimately jeopardizes the customer base of Indian companies and their purchasing power for goods and services. This, in turn, will have a ripple effect on these businesses and ultimately impact the Indian economy, creating a negative spiral within the circular economy. It is essential for businessmen to consider the potential long-term consequences that may arise from prioritizing short-term gains in raw material prices, as it could lead to severe repercussions such as economic downturns and business closures. Therefore, businessmen should carefully weigh their decisions. So, I fully agree with the minister's comment to apply security filters.

Our business enterprises has to stop being an assembling unit to become a manufacturing unit. Assembling things imported from China will never make our businesses self-sustainable in the long run because there's definitely a big war coming and probably its going to be with China. The recent defense purchases and speed of manufacturing defense products and imports suggest that our Govt is well aware of the threat which we might have to face in recent future. So self reliance is the key.

opinions of Bharatiyas were always clear about paxtan, only the elites of this country forced this "aman ki aasha ka tamashaa" on us for 70 years. We never wanted any kind of relations with bhikari nation, we love to keep paxtan in their current state.

Commercial Pacifism and Strategic empathy for neighbours should be part of a gentler and kinder India .

I think india should go hand to hand with other super power for that decision of government yield power and also cooperation and collaboration and team work etc is important

Few of our businessmen and lots of traders prefer to do business with China, whether it is in India's interest or counter to our interest. It is these people who make a killing by choosing to import cheap stuff from China and are the ones doing the most damage to our economy and contribute to thr lopsided trade imbalance in China's favour. We still import a lot of cheap consumer goods & consumer durables from China, despite the fact that we have adequate manufacturing capacities. China has a strategy to dump these goods at prohibitively low costs which will for ever bar us from manufacturing them at home. They even use our neighbours like Bangladesh for these nefarious practices. Unless we have a clear policy to ban these imports, situation will not improve.

Because of him and his master, today none of our neighbors are friends with us. Even tiny maldives has shown us two fingers!

In awe of this man.... golden era for EAM

Don't we have the resources to start raw materials manufacturing companies in india? Or we still have to import from china for next 10 years? If government is supporting to make in so obviously there will be no issues in factory setup and permissions grants for land and loans ... what is that india is lacking that we need to import?.. little bit confused over here.. ( i am not businessman, just saw Jaishankar Sir speaking and decided to watch😊)

China had border issue with Russia and war with each other. But they are now strategic partner. I believe India and China can resolve the border issue. India, Russia and China together would have huge economic potential. 🇮🇳🇨🇳🇷🇺🙏❤️

Very good answer. The business world if not careful and patriotic then has the potential to act like Jai Chands (traitors in economy) which will allow foreign interference that can be detrimental in the mid-long term! Jai Hind 🙏🏽🙏🏽

Excellent

Still Bharat is trading in billions with China

वाह मोदी जी वाह, Invest in India से Start-up India Start-up India से Make in India, Make in India से Jobs in India, Jobs in India से कम गरीबी, कम गरीबी से कम महंगाई, कमाल करते हो मोदी जी, सबका साथ सबका विकास करते हो मोदी जी

The border high up in the Himalayan mountains frozen stiff is not exactly our living room.

Namaskar.. I just love the way you explain things... धन्यवाद।

As a whole, India brags a lot. There is one success, but they enlarge it to 5 or to 10. It is always that way.

Robust Self defining , Crystal Clear response from our one & Only EAM SRI ShivShankar. 3 Cheers

The industry houses in india including psu sector run after cheaper cheaper L1 criterion and dilute the strength of Make in India companies and keep importing from Chinese companies

This Tamil is brilliant. He should take care of tamil nadu in future.

If BJP wins they should appoint Chandra Babu Naidu, the only one and capable visionary leader across India, to oversee Make-in-India program. He can turn tables in our favor with in 5 yrs. Just request him to help out and give him a free hand.

These questions of dealing with china and pakistan from business communities should be asked to themselves, introspection is needed 😢

It's not the business man it's the customers who care only about money. If people really cared about make in India and had any national pride they would buy only made India products. But most just talk big big talks and post comments on social media. Don't blame business men, they are the ones creating jobs, taking risks with their own money and helping the nation grow. It's the useless public or customers who just talk about national security and pride but when it comes to actually buying made in India products that's when their true face can be seen. If you truly love your country then support your local businesses, no use making big big statements on social media.

No no no, Jai Shankar, THE BALL IS IN INDIA'S COURT. NOT IN PAKISTAN AND CHINA.

Makes sense.

What kind of idiotic question is that? Is he even fit to be a businessman?

" regarding the business with china,Japan- korea and Russia- Germany belt make them force to maintain a willynilly relationship with India and the same is applicable for USA because of geopolitical belt with Israel "

Economic dependence is a matter of national security. Indian industry needs to realise this truth, the early the better .

QUALITY PRODUCTIVITY & FAITHFULNESS ON SERVICES WITH EACH CONSUMERS???*** IF, ANY NATION ***

The first thing for India is to clean up the overbulging corruptions in every bureaucratic department and govt agencies including the police force. Second is providing free mandatory education to all. Third is basic health care especially for the children and underclass. Fourth is provision of basic amenities and means of livelihood for all classes of society. India problem is not external but within its own border.

WHAAAAT, CHINESE TECHNOLOGY ?????????????????????? WHAT A SICK JOKE!

Honey-tongue politician don't mean what they says. Their actions speaks louder than words.

*We have for the first time ever after independence, got THE RIGHT PEOPLE at THE RIGHT place and at THE RIGHT juncture of time; at the helm of affairs! M/s. Modi Shah Doval Jaishankar & Asso. They truly have put in action THE RIGHT policy and taking THE RIGHT decisions! Pak is already deflated. China will follow suit. Partly thru our efforts and the rest thru its own domestic turmoil and economic mess!*

印度朋友们，忘掉中国吧，不要总讨论中国，专注自己发展。 中国发展的好，不一定对你们有害， 中国发展的不好，也不一定对你们有利。

Agar india ke business man ne nationalism hota china ke logo ki trah toh yha bhi manufacturing hoti har ek chiz ki lekin dukh ki baat hai indai me businessman buss pesa kamane ki sochta hai desh ke dushmanon se usse ghanta fark nhi padta 😢😢😢😢

India - China Trade : India exports goods worth US$ 16 billion to China. India imports from China goods worth US$ 110+ billion. (Those are figures of 2023). There is NO NEED to export goods to China. The US$ 110+ billion worth of goods coming from China SHOULD BE produced in India by Indian companies. MADE IN INDIA. TO STOP the out-flow of money to China , the Government of India should increase the import tarifs for goods from China to 100%. IN that way (i.e. 100% import tarif increase) businesses in India will be able to produce those kind of goods in India. BUSINESSES in India should be able to accomplish that in max 12 months. One should NOT CRY that a US$ 16 billion market (i.e. China) is lost. One should BE HAPPY that jobs are created in India to produce goods worth US$ 110+ billion. MADE IN INDIA.

lolJai reply is not to the point he is confused 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣i dont know how people are commenting excellent reply🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭

Make In India is the policy.

Best EAM of India.

jaydev wants only money but not bothered about relentless exporting terrorism.

Jai Bharat

How our honourable FM can expect we can ever do it unless we correct our basics. Our state machine was handed over by Brits to its collaborators still it is unchanged. Our laws, judiciary, policing, education and beurocracy same colonial. One can not win a race with a rickety old obsolete car .Commpn people are never mobilized and trained to be skilled. It has become a republic of Gujratis and Marwaris.

How is it possible to import product from china at a cheaper price than the same product made in India? To make a product with a cost and profit, transport it, sell it to the Indian trader who has make a profit, still the Indian manufacturer cannot match, something is very wrong.

India should suggest UAE to let go of its free tax policies by reminding them of their dying oil reserves...that way it will no longer be a safe haven for insolvent businessmen of our country who take refuge in gulf, europeon or south-east asian countries taking the wealth along with them that was supposed to stay and promote innovation, education and manufacturing in India...other countries will gradually follow suit..and if they try to foil Indian intentions then they will have to do it at the cost of their own economy...only then instead of looking for petty shortcuts, Indian businessmen will think for long-term impacts and invest accordingly...fully money driven businessmen will then automatically start to grow some sense of nationalism in themselves...and by that they dont make life easy only for themselves but also for their and the whole countries future generations to come

Just like Govt. of India wants us businesses to be patriotic & source within India , we also expect Govt. of India to be generous in support & end its idiotic & illogical 28% GST slab . Otherwise , you have no right to preach us . We source from wherever its cheaper.

Right time india moved away from importing readymade and sold. Mfg in India multiple jobs creation. Modiji vision of viksit bharat.

He will definitely get back Kachatheevu from srilanka🎉

if talent and skills are using for wrong purpose, and for fabrication of power or wrong ideology..

tax to kam karenge nahi aur bolenge make in india.

India has lost UN membership confirm and please send a reply.

Evm criminals😢😢😢😢

Thesse are bussiness men Is feeling lost..

Evm culprits😢😢😢😢

CONT ..FROM BELOW TOTALLY STEELY, MORAL ,PERSPECTIVE..CORE POLITICAL WILL RUNNING THRO GOV...FANTASTIC..!!

With out next 40 years what to do in all mps hands india doez not go to next level

India has many manufacturing and trading giants like tata , birla, reliance, bajaj, mahindra and what not long before china open its economy to foreign investors in 1980s. But the indian companies only focused on indian market which is quite closed to foreign competition for long time. There was little competition from foreign companies thus leading to little R&D on new products . For many years these companies were enjoying closed economy environments in india and consumers in india has little choice but forced to by out dated technology and prrofucts

I will encourage my friends to not buy Hero automobiles.

Sometime i think that Indian guy Nehru's name is everywhere at a selling security n land of Country India. Of you really read and listen last decade.. all falls on 71' n Nehru. What the heck you guys did to your own country. Or dont say Indian people didn't knew if both were born in India or abroad or child of foreigner?

These business guys are looking for buying cheap raw materials from china and looking to selling their products to Pakistan.. They doesn't care about India's security just want to expand their business and make more profitable, Dealing countries like Pakistan and China is nightmare, diplomats those who are involved in the negotiation table only can understand how difficult it is..

Cities must be repeinted in city extension to make ease for police mamagement and new plans will make mess only

Did you notice something. China has an open door policy for entrepreneurs from any country, including India. Ask Tulsi Tanti of Suzlon who made a packet selling wind mills to Chinese when China did not have a wind power industry. Chinese never preach, which Indian ministers like EAM and PM do a lot. Chinese quietly did the hard work and made the country an economic super power. Now the West and India are threatened by its progress. But still Chinese are not reacting. China is the true Viswa Guru. India has a lot to learn from China and it is learning belatedly.

Manki bat suna rahe ye😆😆😆

Do not agree with Jaishankar. Indian government must actively ban import of all those items from China (or from any other country, since Chinese manufactured goods are cleverly repackaged in Thailand, Bangladesh, Vietnam etc and exported to India in billions also), which are being manufactured in India or can be manufactured in India relatively easily and quickly. Example. What is the logic of Indian government allowing mass import into India of Chinese manufactured floor and wall tiles, kitchen utensils and crockery, shoes, building material and hardware fittings, tyres, toys, picture frames and art decorations, even Hindu idols, lights, rakhi, Diwali crackers and decoration, balloons, colours, paints, steel, mobile phones, computers, laptops, refrigerator, AC, air purifier, water purifier..... and millions of other items that have flooded Indian markets. Why hasn't Indian government banned all online stores like Amazon, Flipkart etc from selling Chinese manufactured goods, and infact there should be law that online sellers should only be allowed to sell goods manufactured inside India. Presently what is happening is that every day, Amazon, Flipkart and other online sellers in India are selling every day billions of dollars of goods manufactured outside India, and in this way destroying Indian industries. Why isn't Indian government doing such basic thing like directing online sellers to only sell made in India products.

Want money for what and where to invest will it return from malaysiavor singapore side no may be answer as i invested 1400000 cr rs all gone to multi ftory and their bank accounts to live people peace full there and few only gone to make industriez of small scale

He thinks as usual… send him at front .. such so called seculars and greedy business minds are dangerously acting against the interests of Bharat .. He wants to sit at table .. what a joke and hypocrite

F1 race track in bangladesh may be good and in pojk

Eventually Jaishankar is going to realize that it's not really wise to keep intimidating and hostilizing neighboring countries. Don't know where he got this kind of diplomatic attitude from but this is not worthy of the great civilization of India. This is a sad imitation of Western thugism. There's no competition here between China and India, at least not a close one, start cooperating instead.

Despite getting good beating from China in 2020, the indians continues to buy billions dollars worth chinese goods every year😂

Sirf Great you tell the tt tryout We are what people can do any think give apportunity to the people to produce and supply Govt has to think on this paint

Munjal has always been a traitor .