✨본 방송전 아이브(IVE)의 ELEVEN 라이브 선공개✨ 아이브(IVE)의 또 다른 이야기들이 듣고싶다면, 스페셜DJ 랄랄, 수현 OPPA, 요요미의 사랑의 컬센타가 궁금하다면! 12월 25일 SBS 파워FM 107.7MHz에서 2시에 만나요📻 (방송 후 유튜브에 보는 라디오 풀버전 업로드❣)

They're all talented but Liz and Yujin's vocals are so good and they're so STABLE.

who else here is impressed by liz's vocal?? her vocals sound exactly the same from the cd

liz's vibrato sounds so good. she's the best singer technically in this group.

I hope Gaeul has more part. Her voice is firm and clear just like she has no doubt to reach the tone, and Liz OMFG her voice is so beautiful

no one's talking abt rei's vocals here she's really stable and has a great voice, i hope more people would appreciate her

Liz really has a stable and good vocal technique. I hope company give her the refrain part to her for the next comeback to give more strong impact. Rei (the short hair cut is Rei right?) has nice voice tone. Love it!

I feel like people should appreciate Leeseo's vocal more. She's slaying live singing

about Yujin and Liz I already knew the vocals would be powerful. Now Leeseo, oh my God, with just 14 years old, the girl has a magnificent voice. the group is pure talent

I am confident to say that YUJIN, LIZ, REI and LEESEO have stable vocals in this group.

YUJIN'S VOCAL IS SO UNIQUE AND ATTRACTIVE OMFG, I'M NEW FAN AND VOCAL TEACHER I THINK THAT SHE'S SUCH MAIN VOCAL MATERIAL AND THE BLONDE HAIR TOO

I feel like nobody is talking about Lesseo's vocals?? For only 14 she is great.

와 .. 이서는 진짜 타고난거 같다 어떻게 저 어린나이에 저렇게 잘 할 수가 있지..

유진이 성량이며 음색이며 안정감이며,,, 미쳣다ㅠ 글구 아이브 애기들 다 너무 잘함

난 레이 보컬이 제일 맘에 드는듯. 제일 딴딴한 느낌이라 나중에 어떤 곡도 자기 스타일로 잘 소화할 것 같음.

Leeseo is so talented, I can see why they wanted to debut her so early (even though I think she’s too young). I just hope that because they did debut her they take care of her and keep her safe and healthy. She has so much raw talent and shines in this video.

1:26 Look at Rei's smile. You can tell she's proud of Liz nailing that part of the song.

리즈 레이 안유진이 갠적으로 너무 잘함 음색도 좋구 ㅠㅠ

Yujin's vocals are everything, she the main vocalist material I can tell

Yujin, Liz, and Rei are the most stable vocals. Yujin's high notes and stability are impressive, Liz's stability and the way she sounds the same way as in the mv shows that she deserves the main vocal position and Rei (even though she's a rapper) has a good vocal technique and it sounds clear and beautiful.

liz definitely the main vocalist. shes damn stable

THEY ARE ALL TALENTED. I was impressed by LIZ, REI, and LEESEo for their powerful and stable vocals!

as usual LIZ and REI are so stable and wow LEESEO did great too!

yujin really looks like suzy with her black hair. i can't unsee. she's so pretty

Yujin omg, she's so stable all the times and her highnotes just mind -blowing even vocal teacher say she can sing from low to high notes, definitely ace of IVE! 🔥🔥🔥

Liz,rei,leeseo sounds exactly like that of song..I am impressed with them..gaeul needs more lines, wonyoung is improving and yujin high notes are everything

Falling into Gaeul, Rei, Liz and Leeseo stable vocals, please they deserve more regconite

Liz and Leeseo's vocals, wow. They were very stable, and the tune, flawless.

Yujin is really something else. She stands out in the group not because she's the leader or she's the tallest but because she's so talented and charismatic. She has a natural way of captivating her audience. Everyone else in this group is also amazing.

I'm happy to see Yujin's loyal fans interact with Yujin's new fans at the comment section. It makes me proud of Yujin more now that she's getting more appreciation from other people.

레이 라이브 이렇게 잘하는 지 몰랐는데 너무 잘한다 🥺🥺 목소리 완전 탄탄하게 잘 들려!! 예쁘다❤️

All of them have amazing vocals but Liz, yujin and rei stands out the most

리즈 레이 유진 ㄹㅇ 속시원해 너무 잘부른다

why is nobody hyping gaeul vocals ?!? SHE'S INCREDIBLEEEEEEEE AND AWESOMEE

레이 라이브 왜캐 잘하냐 ㄷㄷ ㄷㄷ

Yujin's High Notes never disappoints! She's so good!

I hope they give my girl Gaeul more lines in the future, I would love to hear her voice more.

Liz and Rei stood out in this performance. Leeseo is doing great as well Gaeul too.

Rei is super strong, she sounds exactly like the og song! Liz too 😱💜

Yujin, Liz & Rei are great at projecting their voices! Another great live from the girls! They'll get better as soon as we know it

Wow Liz, Leeseo and Yujin’s vocals are so good

I like Yujin's voice very much.

Yujin's vocalization is amazing periodt. You can hear her voice clearly when she sings

Liz is so consistent with her vibrato. I love it.

안유진 목소리 나올때가 제일 안정감 딱 돈다 목소리도 중저음이라 그런지 듣기도 좋구

리즈는 진짜....노래 진짜 잘하고, 춤도 잘 추는데 표정도 잘 하고 개이쁘고, 키까지 크고 비율도 좋고....진짜 인생이 리즈다 정말......와우 대박이야😶

레이 개미쳣다 레이 사랑해 레이 ,,,,,,,,, 음색 개쩔어 성량 개쩌러,,,

I can see how Yujin is getting enjoyment singing eleven. It is Yujin's Era no doubt

Yujin highnote and Liz's stable vocal 😍

Wow! Their live vocals are so good. Rei sounds so good live and Yujin, Liz, Leeseo literally nailed their part. Never thought I would found another group whose live vocals are as good or better than studio recordings.

yujin and liz vocal👏👏👏

For me in this vid Liz stands out. The vocals is stable and not shaky.

Liz is solo material vocally. Her ability to move through registers..... 🤯

Haters everywhere trying to discrediting the fact that Yujin can passed to be main vocal material, She surely deserves with her experiences and Liz too, both of Yujin and Liz are main vocalists

레이,가을이 음색이 왜이렇게 좋아😍 막둥이 윙크가 자동이네😉🥰

Yujin, Rei, and Liz did the best.

라이브 논란에 정면돌파 하는 느낌이라 매우 좋네요 노래 자체적으로도 매력이 넘쳐서 하루에 한번은 듣는듯

Who else impressed by Yujin's vocal, she sounds heavenly and ate CD omg like she's adding soul to the song 💘💘

가을 코디 너무 예뻐요 ,,, 똥머리도 잘어울리고 ㅜㅜㅜ 무엇보다도 니트가 체형을 잡아줘서 팔이 길어보여서 이뻐요 ㅠㅠㅜ!!!

Rei's vocal so stable and unique❤ I love her so much❤❤❤

liz makes it sound like singing is as easy as breathing, her voice is really beautiful, woah.

Yujin's vocal really stable. Love her voice

Liz and Yujin vocals are the best!! Jjanggg!! 💕

Rei, Liz, Yujin sounds so stable Rei vocals also sound powerful her tone fits her very well the rest of the girls did so well Wonyoung i think she needs to improve alittle bit on her singing. Will they're all still young and rookies so they have plenty of time to improve i can't wait to see what the future holds for the girls~

Yujin's powerful vocals never dissapoints she's really so good and also Liz voice it's so unique

the girl with white hair's vocal blew me away... She sounds so stable I initially thought it was lipsync! Plus she has such a cute dimple 😍

giving yujin that high note was a great decision :) she makes it look effortless

Woonyong has the Visual but I think she can improve her singing and dancing💜, I’m rooting for all the girls💕💕

Rei slow down part is seriously that of a battle rap queen !!I hope she had more rap bits. I wish Gaeul gets more lines even in their second single she sounded great I wish it was longer.

Both Yujin and Liz did well and Yujin's highnote just makes me goosebumps everytimes, She's insane 😍 and Wonyoung improve so much of her voice, I'm proud to see ☺️

Oh my gosh. Please, Starship. Please give Liz and Rei more lines for their first comeback. They sound so great singing live! They are freaking talented give them justiceee! And anyone see how cute Leeseo is? Though her body movement still looks awkward compared to Yuujin or Won young, but Leeseo and Gaeul are so cute! I can even see now that Leeseo really is the maknae. And for Wonyoung - Yuujin, so proud for both of you for growing up and honing your skills to this extent!

Liz and Yujin so stable, and Rei sounds really like the CD omg

Rei Liz and Yujin is the trinity vocal

Yujin is so good with the transitions of voices, she's ain't playing!

Liz's vocals are consistent!!!

REI'S VOICE IS SO POWERFUL!!!!

Yujin is killing me with her high notes

Liz being so stable. She slay

이서는 음색도 이쁜데 라이브도 잘하네 기특해라 라디오에서도 윙크요정이야🌱

liz and yujin's voice sounds exactly like the recorded version imo.

why is no one talking about rei's vocals?? shes so good too 😭

tbh they all did well for me, considering they're fairly new. they still can improve in a few years. I believe they can.

Liz's vocal so amazing, good job lizz

Liz vocal is so stable..she's my fav vocalist on ive ❤️

why no one talk about Rei vocals, she sounds amazing too.

원영이 다리가 어디에있어 청바지에 니트 입었는데 비율넘사다ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ너무이쁘고 노래도잘해💖

OMG liz's vocal is perfect

i feel like rei is under appreciated as a vocalist... shes personally my fav voice in the group

Comeback here again for listening Yujin's highnotes.. She such main vocal material maybe just little more practices more breathing support, She will be more perfect

Yujin is the ace of IVE that's the fact!!!!

Rei and Liz's vocals. *Yujin* is ♥♥♥!

I'M SO IN LOVE WITH LIZ'S VOCALS😭😭❤❤ SHE SOUNDS SO GOOOD

Wow, Rei has a sharp ear. Her notes were very precise.

I’m always proud of Yujin😭💗

How can Yujin did everything so well? She must be works so hard 🥺 our ace leader indeed

Yujin is so beautiful and POWERFUL

있잖아..요즘 아이브 라이브 무대 찾아보는거에 재미들려서 계속 보다가 느낀건데.. 원영이랑 유진이가 아이브로 데뷔한다고 했을때 솔직히 아이브로 같이 데뷔하는 다른 멤버들이 좀 걱정이었음. 왜냐면 이미 인지도 있는 멤버들이 합류해서 데뷔하는 그룹은 확실히 초짜 얼굴도 모르는 신인에 비해서 주목받는 속도도 빠를거고 잘될 확률도 높긴 하지만 이미 알려져있는 멤버들만 주목받는 경우가 많았으니까 혹시 대중들에게 비교되진 않을까, 게다가 나이도 어린데 상처받거나 트라우마가 되어 긴장하진 않을까.. 근데 아이브 영상들 쭉 찾아보면서 신기하게 다른 멤버들에 비해서 유독 원영이랑 유진이가 더 긴장하는 모습들을 너무 많이 발견함. 한번 데뷔해봤으니까 그것도 한때 너무 주목받았던 그룹속에 있던 애들이니 그 짬이 다르겠지라는 생각으로, 마치 연차가 오래쌓여서 여유로워진 아이돌들처럼 여유롭겠지라고 생각했었는데 다른 멤버들은 이 연예계라는 사회에 이제 막 발담가서 그런가, 아니면 나이가 너무 어려서 그런지 겁없이 즐기고 신나하는 모습이 보이는데 원영이랑 유진이 특히 유진이는 리더도 맡고 여기저기 대중들의 반응을 확인한 사람처럼 라이브 무대에서 티내진 않지만 아이즈원때부터 봐왔던 사람으로서 긴장하는게 어쩔수 없이 보여서 너무 마음이 좀 이상함.. 긴장해서 더 끌어낼수있는 역량을 다 못 보여주고 있는 느낌... 언니들 속에서 의지하다가 팀의 중심에 서게되니까 그 부담이 엄청 크겠지.. 한번 겪어봐서 그걸 너무 잘 아는거겠지. 사실 유진이랑 원영이도 어린데.. 뭔가 잘못을 저질렀다던가 누군가를 아프게 했던가 이런게 아니고서 받는 쓴 조언이나 평가에 너무 힘들어하지 않았으면... 나이가 무기라는 말이 있듯이 앞으로 나아갈 길들이 너무나도 창창한데 넘어져도 다시 일어설수있는거니까.

ive be eating cds all day. they sound and look amazing. dam yujin. shes so beautiful.

Liz, Rei, and Yujin are so good. Everyone did great 💓

Liz's vocals are so magnificent, what a unique girl she is.