If you fail the quest, but tell Byron the truth after, he’ll leave his shovel and catrin’s pendant in manse of the hallowed brothers on a rocky path near where you can find the stigma of him and catrin. I don’t have a video of it yet, but I’ll update this comment when I get a chance to record it.
@Dijito9 ай бұрын
Can you please show a video of the spot? It will be greatly appreciate it. Byron is just standing at upper calroth and doesn’t move from there. I want to start new game plus but want to get pendant first.
@NightScares.9 ай бұрын
so i fucked up becouse i tell it was evil and he disappear from my world no way to find it again ?
@FFFFPPPP9 ай бұрын
@@Dijitosame here. Byron doesnt leave anything behind and just stands there like a doofus. The only other diff is when you find Winterberry’s backpack, you obtain the strange coins item which is the same icon next to the pendent when you allow her to live.
@gabrielveridiano69372 ай бұрын
any1 have the video of this shovel ?
@hugosanchez3471Ай бұрын
That's really stupid I took the elevator without knowing
@plasma946610 ай бұрын
Guessing we all went up that lift ….
@kizmo231710 ай бұрын
What an absolutely ridiculous amount of steps, ladders, and just plain distance running to get to Winterberry. Great guide. Subbed.
@PsychoBoyTyler10 ай бұрын
The area also leads to an important boss so there's more down there than just Winterberry. I personally loved the tense exploration of the Revelation Depths, to find a massive hidden area underneath the mines and sewers reminded me so much of Dark Souls 1. It also made me finally use the Seeds I had been saving.
@EnoBuddy10 ай бұрын
It's so dumb that using the elevator cuts the quest. Wish i would knew this earlier. Thank you for this :)
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
It is a bit silly considering there’s no way to know to avoid it after killing the boss. Maybe if Byron has dialogue like “take the elevator and meet me at upper calrath after you’ve investigated the monster” then I’d understand lol.
@omenjesus110 ай бұрын
yep. i'm pretty pissed off about that. logically i wanted to go up first to see if there was a vestige to finish exploring the bottom, fuck me for being smart >.>
@mrBytemare10 ай бұрын
yeah same here I messed it up. Winterberry is also gone and the Byron is standing up at the top with the elevator, and seems pretty happy. Did I miss major items? @@NinjaPups
@Madxmanix10 ай бұрын
That’s how these types of games go! The devs gotta have their trolling too! It’s up to you to do your homework beforehand!
@EnoBuddy10 ай бұрын
@@Madxmanix yea got that but common, that has nothing to do with homework. I don't say they should make this obvious or easy or something like that but putting an elevator behind a boss to cut the quest it's dumb. Everyone would take that as you want to progress further. Not Tracking back or being forced to run, lets say, the umbral ending with no vestiges. Those kinda things are nothing else then a dumb design.
@elliotoverbeek589010 ай бұрын
I'm really bummed out taking the elevator fails the quest. I was trying to do a semi completionist playthrough but now I don't even feel like playing. :(
@ChaoticElegy10 ай бұрын
the longer it took you to get to that girl with all the different possible paths the further my jaw got to the floor, holy crap that is a long run without an in-place vestige
@kurinaki10 ай бұрын
Some tip for trophy hunters or someone who want 100%, you actually need to complete this quest in both ways, but you can fail it in both ways too (mb bug) if u got to Upper Carlath and didn't talk to Biron before going in depth, even after taking coins from Winterberry's camp there was no option to say truth to him. Recommendation: do it properly (saving Winterberry) at first time, because there is no Vestiges at ng+ and then you can tell him truth to get Rememberens and Catrin's pendant
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
That’s really good to know as I was thinking about going for 100%. Thank you.
@kurinaki10 ай бұрын
@@NinjaPups you welcome and thanks for the guides
@Rolandhinho10 ай бұрын
Too late for me...
@ruuwrl10 ай бұрын
maybe a bug cuz i talked to him before and still didnt get the option
@davidmcwhirter796010 ай бұрын
These quests remind me of my first play through of elden ring. I missed 90% of them because of how little explanation there is. I guess I’ll just have to play through it again.
@sandboy588010 ай бұрын
Fuck this quest I used the elevator without knowing.
@CNSninja8 ай бұрын
FYI, Skinstealer is super easy to beat if you equip the Bloodbane Ring (inflicting poison damage also simultaneously inflicts bleed damage,) and use Forsaken Grenades to keep the area full or poison gas. Skin-o is weak to both poison and bleed, so you get a quadruple-whammy, positively melting his HP away. He's also relatively easy to parry if you're used to parrying and have good reflexes for that sort of thing.
@glaucoruzzetti96307 ай бұрын
Anothe easy strat is just side step on right to avoid him and punish a bit
@Morellen10 ай бұрын
Dude, this video is great. Concise, explains everything, no bs. Good stuff man
@slicksilver94415 ай бұрын
This vid was a big help. Thanks!
@samisaariaho6689 ай бұрын
So I did every step like shown in this video, BUT i'm on new game +0 so naturally I killed the lightreaper at the tutorial part of the game. I think because of this Byron won't show up at the Upper Calrath vestige, but luckily I checked underneath the skyrest bridge and they both were there. Got the achievement.
@NinjaPups9 ай бұрын
Good to hear you were still able to get it
@Deathvalley8379 ай бұрын
lol, I accidentally did this quest. I do enjoy her as a vendor with the enhanced rabbit footS
@rejiIncognito10 ай бұрын
second playthrough inbound appreciate the extra deats
@davidsotoserrano483610 ай бұрын
You are the man.!! Thx dude..
@lane725110 ай бұрын
Worth it all just for the respec item. Very nice.
@Unfoldable10 ай бұрын
Hold this sub bro. Great guide,
@jorgeluizjr.06 ай бұрын
It's impossible to do most of the quests without googling. I hate that! 😠 I love your voice, by the way. 🙂👍🏽
@NinjaPups6 ай бұрын
True. Also thanks 😌
@Questizon10 ай бұрын
So can you obtain the pendant that she want to keep ……
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
Not if you complete the quest successfully. If you fail it, and tell Byron the truth, he’ll leave his shovel and catrin’s pendant in manse of the hallowed brothers on a rocky path near where you can find the stigma of him and catrin. But I don't know if that pendant will be an actual pendant or if it'll be a collectible item you can just look at.
@ShamanicShepard10 ай бұрын
You lost me at 43seconds. Im cannot find the path from Byron to the skinstealer. I missed a ladder or something but I have been running around in circles for too long.
@rillebanck8 ай бұрын
How do open the door Byron if you failed the quest by going with the elevator up before meeting the witch?
@zaneroberts381310 ай бұрын
My game had full inventory the drainage control key isn’t in my inventory now bevayse I didn’t realise key items were counted with armour weapons etc why do they add key items to your inventory total so stupid
@shadowofthesupremo78989 ай бұрын
And where is his stigma? I've read the wiki but can't actually find the place
@MissBlazinAsian10 ай бұрын
Do you have to avoid the optional bosses??? Does anyone know what they drop?
@0utragedOzm1lk10 ай бұрын
Left handed stillness blade
@MissBlazinAsian9 ай бұрын
Does anyone know what happens if you “fail” and then lie to him?
@mickey-mous9576 ай бұрын
So is there a way to actually get her pendant
@faulker434010 ай бұрын
I can't find her remains. Are they at the bottom?
@NFtheend9 ай бұрын
They’re not there at all
@timefliesby-jleo4745 ай бұрын
How do you buy the pendant though? What is that symbol underneath it?
@0utragedOzm1lk10 ай бұрын
What if I’m tryna do no beacons lit until the end quest line can I finalize this after meeting winterberry then come back once I’ve lit them…
@suspicioussalad55789 ай бұрын
Ironically Im trying to figure out how to complete the failure state because I found the backpack and the coin but cannot tell byron he murdered a child
@NinjaPups9 ай бұрын
Out of curiosity, did you find the coin and backpack before taking the elevator up to Byron?
@suspicioussalad55789 ай бұрын
@@NinjaPups no I went up because I forgot the elevator was the trigger and i was wanting an item from there, then saw byron and went back to get the coin, idk if I'm supposed to be able to interact with the backpack or something cuz he just stands there proud of himself for killing berry no matter what I've tried
@marcusohlsson313010 ай бұрын
You need to post videos faster! I missed it by one day, used the elevator yesterday. Now poor Winterberry is dead...
@MelkovSebristas9 ай бұрын
i cant find winterberry in depths?
@TVNorway10 ай бұрын
Where is that last location you hand in quest?
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
It says in the description, it’s underneath skyrest
@MattBooneUSA10 ай бұрын
Wow what kind of sword is that
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
if you mean the glowing lightsaber looking one, that's Pieta's boss sword. You can buy it from Molhu by clicking "Offer Remembrance" after soul-flaying Pieta's stigma in Umbral where you killed her. If you don't have access to the Remembrance tab in Molhu, you can unlock it with this guide: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/g8x4rdB70tnahJ8.htmlsi=-fe0H-ScncTvthNt if you mean the other swords, those are lightreaper's swords. You can get them the same way as pieta's, except you'll have to defeat him and soul-flay his stigma.
@LovingGameGirl10 ай бұрын
Can you not get catrin’s pendant
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
If you complete the quest successfully, then no. Winterberry will hold onto it forever. If you fail the quest, but tell Byron the truth after, he’ll leave his shovel and catrin’s pendant in manse of the hallowed brothers on a rocky path near where you can find the stigma of him and catrin. I don’t have a video of it yet, but I’ll update this comment when I get a chance to record it.
@mitchelverbiest478410 ай бұрын
so is there actually a way to get that pendant i really dont get how you are suppose to tell the truth?!?! to byron?!? i did fail this quest before and got those weird coins or whatever they were called but i never could do anything after that he always said something about moving on so i dont get it at all how i can get that pendant
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
If you tell him the truth, he’ll leave his shovel and Catrin’s pendant on this rocky path in manse of the hallowed brothers. It’s nearby where the stigma is of him and Catrin. I don’t have a video of it currently, unfortunately
@mitchelverbiest478410 ай бұрын
@@NinjaPups oh i actually found it now! thank you good sir! im just confused as to why the pendant isnt an actual pendant and what i can even do with it now
@wDeathw9 ай бұрын
I only way to actually get her pendant is killing her right?
@WorkedSix28zerozero15 ай бұрын
No. Once you see she has the pendant, go back and tell Byron and then you'll get the pendant upon quest completion
@TheKotragBG10 ай бұрын
I take trophy byt winterberry do not sell pendant to me
@NinjaPups10 ай бұрын
She will not sell the pendant ever
@FullCaber9 ай бұрын
well fug she fuggin got clubberd i found her bloodypack x(
@ems22playbook9 ай бұрын
Thanks, but the game is taking the piss, i played darks soul s till elden ring and i always enjoy hard fights, but this is so ridiculous trash, they make the game just op and you don't have any chance lvl up /fast or even normal now because it's a grinding for nothing and they patch all good farms now you can't progress in the next are because you get one shot
@Mad_Peasant_King10 ай бұрын
The quests in this are so dumb with the amount of backtracking you need to do for one thing
@therealmarce44010 ай бұрын
Mimimi don’t do it then
@Mad_Peasant_King10 ай бұрын
Or they could just give a better hint than showing you an elevator to the next area that fails thd quest if you go up
@supersayian19310 ай бұрын
Maybe like a quest tracker or something to show you kinda like lies of p would have the face of the character you should go talk too
@metalhev398910 ай бұрын
@@therealmarce440 I assume you haven't gone to ng+ if you think that's just whining.
@therealmarce44010 ай бұрын
@@metalhev3989Hahah. I did the umbral ending and some Sidequests in NG+. Never had to backtrack longer than 5min, because if you have some brain, you can use your seeds and shortcuts smart to get around;)
@sempi83238 ай бұрын
The lighting in this game is so dog shit
@mep145510 ай бұрын
Great... another thing I can't just reload a save for... So many ass things in the game...