I SEA what you did there

asukigi / AAAAAAA XD

I didn't liked these symbolism, y'know...

and don't forget kyoko's father committing suicide with her family was the cause of kyoko abandoning mami and being hostile towards sayaka

There's something fishy about this

same

And it would be cool to see kyoko's witch animated.

I couldn't agree more.

So OVA?

​@Jay T AKA Jeremiah Tisdale honestly seeing Ophelia and Canderloro was something I wish happened whether in a spin-off or even in the movie as a montage of Homura going through different timelines all ending with Madoka becoming Gretchen but we could've at least got slight glimpses of the other two witches

지금 집에 가고 싶다

it was a magical adventure they just didn't specify that it was going to turn out well.

Kyoko Sakura what do you mean?

KYOKO HOW I THOUGHT YOU WERE!?!?

It's a horse

It opens a new route, as if it's *fate*

Well, since the game shows the multiple timelines that Homura went through, this is how things would've turned out if Homura just killed Oktavia instead of letting Kyoko sacrifice herself

really wish that this was what Homulilly's gimmick was along with every time a magical girl almost defeats her the labyrinth goes back in time , causing an entire restart

Maybe it is in a different timeline. It’s a bit fuzzy considering both the Homura tamura manga and magia record had multiple versions of Homura from different timelines, but I believe it’s possible because of the weird nature of time travel itself. If there’s multiple Homuras, they made different choices. Every potential choice you make in a universe has a different outcome, and each outcome has different outcomes as well. It acts as a branching timeline thing, like the TVA or other multiversal systems have portrayed. Like Octavia in timeline III, where she had a different barrier and slightly different way of attacking, I feel like one witched out Homura had that power when she realized she wanted to stay with Madoka forever. Perhaps she was already having a murky soul gem trying to prevent the others from contracting/dying/convince Madoka to not do it and succeeded, saw Madoka and her witch nature hatched out of that obbesive desire.

Damien Cuvrette Ophelia's illusion power would be massive pain in the ass

+JKM2468 I know about that timeline, but is it made clear that Sayaka knows she will turn into a witch if she doesn't use grief seeds to purify her soul gem? That was what killed her in the original series. She kept passing on grief seeds without knowing what happens if your gem goes dark.

@@TheDevNell yeah mami told her if it gets too dark you die

Or rather having to roll persuasive checks with an excessively low charisma point.

Blick Winkel are you sure about that?

Even when they are witches,no matter what I still love them

Yours are my favourite characters too! ^^/

So is the one of the first shot of Ophelia, no other letters.

Nico Niko I fucking know right

Sakura ga shinda!

Calm down??? Seriously?! o.o' ....

+Lunos Ouroboros Ophelia only shows up in this route if Kyoko's soul gem is corrupted. Otherwise she gets over this incident and the game loads a different scene after Kyoko namedrops the title of the route. And even in the anime, she still had the faintest sliver of hope that Sayaka could be saved, which was why she was exerting herself to keep Sayaka's body magically fresh. Remember, Kyubey told her that there was no way he knew that witches could be saved from magical girls, which was what gave Kyoko the idea that there could be a way that Kyubey didn't know of. The callback to the food chain analogy is a great way to show how Kyoko would fall into despair. Her compassion for Sayaka in the anime showed she was wavering in her survival of the fittest mentality and she was beginning to embrace hope again, but after that hope died, she went back to the survival of the fittest mentality, except this time, she no longer saw herself as fit.

Blick Winkel Well.. yeah.. But she can't just blame Homura for killing a Witch by using as an excuse a flat possibility which could more than likely be plain wrong, can she? :/

***** I know that and still maintain my point, she wasn't thinking rationally at all. Once a Mahou Shoujo turns into a Witch, there's no turning back as far as we know and they too, so she surrended to a flat possibility of saving her which was obviously kinda impossible, unless you're Godoka ofc.

***** ... Fair enough.

That's true but you have to remember that by this point, Kyouko has began showing her soft side way more often and remembering her past that she always tried not to think about, since she told her story to Sayaka. And the whole reason she remembered is because she saw her old self in Sayaka and slowly began caring about her. She probably unconsciously believed that if Sayaka could be saved then so could she accept her past and move on. She once believed in stuff like miracles and justice and all. She may have become much colder and put on a tough exterior but she still has feelings and she doesn't believe in dry facts and logic as much as Homura. So finding out that she has indeed been fighting in vain (because of the witch system) and seeing that Sayaka couldn't be saved (which she knew was impossible but had one last glimmer of hope that there may be some good in the world) was like telling her everything she once believed is false. At this point of the timeline she's lost way too many people and her faith in life is pretty much lost. She can't hope for anything anymore. So she despairs. And this is also pretty interesting, because, as far as we know, this is the only condition in which Kyouko can become a witch (she almost became one in TDS and was saved by Mami but this was before Homu started messing with the timelines so we know it she never actually turned into one then) so yeah, she is pretty damn emotionally strong and Homura encountering Ophelia is waaay more rare than say, Oktavia, Gretchen and Candeloro, who appear in every other timeline. You have to begin the route with your sole purpose being to reach Ophelia. When she sacrifices herself in other routes she realises saving Sayaka is impossible but doesn't really have time to think about the food-chain system and still believes Sayaka is somewhere in there so, since she has nothing left, she decides to at least keep her company in their afterlife, since they are both hopeless and alone at this point (yaay similarities). And obviously she can't do that with Oktavia not there lol. I think it's pretty logical and in character if you think of it that way. Sorry for the rant lol

+KiwiDrawsStuff Homulilly was indeed Homura's witch

Okay thank you!

If Homura became witch, it would be GAME OVER because she cannot leap back in time anymore.

It says Ophelia

Yes. But this is happening because Kyoko's soul meter is above 400 and fall into despair. If her soul meter was below 350, she would've begrudgingly accepted that witches must be slain and forgave Homura.

@@HonestFarmerLigue1Fan I don’t believe they’re talking game stats wise, rather in the world of Madoka Magica Homura is right.

of course not she is homulily

+justice tyner Walpurgisnacht is the combination of an amount of differente witches. Nobody knows what witches specifically make Walpurgisnacht tho. +Fiona Chen Nothing says that Homulilly couldn't be one of them or even it's core tho.

NO

This whole comment is a whole ass mess.