You're Welcome! Figuring out the base inlet holes area is beyond my math expertise.

@@WhipCityWrencher Not sure if you can measure the oil holes but if you post the dimensions, I will do the math and post back here the results. The Mahle should be simple, just the diameter of the holes. For the Mann I need the width and length of the slots.

@@advrider9143 Sure, the Mahle oil filter inlet holes are Approx. .25" and the Mann oil filter inlet holes are Approx. .26" x .32"

@@WhipCityWrencher Correction. I made a simple math error. The correct oil flow areas are as follows: Mahle 0.3927 square inches. Mann 0.3036 square inches.

@@advrider9143 Thanks! You should delete the post with the wrong numbers.

Most Ttuck and Taxi services in Germany use MAN filters they are good!

That is so sweet ! Thank you for sharing :)

Mann filters are a big reason why my 1986 Mercedes Benz 560 SEL has lasted over 38 trouble free years.

BLABLABLA, facilities like that are also around Stuttgart and they build proucts for Mahle as well, my brother works in one of those.

@@merylpelosi8485 While the first filters which were build in in the factory have been Mahle filters, lmao. Like the Pistons in your car and 50% of all cars on this planet! But it's ok to think the Mann filters are the reason the Mahle products inside your engine are not breaking. Mercedes, Porsche and Mahle are located in Stuttgart, like Behr, the company which build the radiator of your car and parts of the ac. Behr is mostly owned by Mahle for almost 15 years now. So there are even more Mahle products in never Mercedes' and Porsche's and BMW's and Audi's and VW's, also in some French cars, a lot of Japanese brands and so on.

100 % CORRECT.

Amen.

It does show two well made products. At least you know it's not cardboard and glue filter.

​@@davidwickboldt712honestly don't care what it's made of, with or like. Does it work well? Does it last? 👍

Yeah, he's wasting ten minutes of the viewers time.

if you look closely at the packaging of the Mann filter, the bottom line shows an icon (maybe for "compatibility?) and "Mahle OC 54" !!!

​@@Anson_AKB That's a thing MANN FILTER does sometimes: they write on the package the equivalent filters from other manufacturers.

Many filters have cross references to other brands. It is especially common on filters sold in bulk to auto repair shops.

Ferrari F1 uses Mahle pistons

In 1984 when Harley Davidson introduced the Evo engine one of the improvements in it over previous engine's were it's low expansion pistons, they were made by Mahle for HD.

Most of your engine original parts probabky where mahle. I know all the PSA engines were all mahler parts.. pistons, rings, bearings etc etc etc

Totally agree mate good stuff is available for china but a lot people just want cheap so they make more selling on

I also agree and mostly it is just made in China or so but by the German standard/ design. Than they better put designed in Germany, Switzerland and so on the item. Czechoslovakia made very good tools, machines and cars before ww2. I still think that German, our own Dutch and American tools and machines have the best quality.

@@gerhard6105 I bought some cordless stuff couple of years back, the firm that sells them is in my city but they get them made in china which is different to just buying in china to then sell on, there man goes out 3 or4 times a year and the quality is great

@@johngibson3837 yes, exactly.

It looks like the MANN has been cost engineered a bit more, possibly to keep it competitive price wise whilst retaining expensive German manufacturing/labour. The Mahle on the other hand is built with cheaper labour but perhaps to what would be a more costly design. The really important bit though is whether the designs meet/exceed the required performance for their intended service life and I think the answer is yes for both brands.

Have used random manufacturer filters for more than 20 years, never had an issue too.

@@robertolaggo9141same here

I like the Mann filters and had been using them in my Suzuki Grand Vitara. Where the filter is located you really need to use a cup socket for removal. Unfortunately the flats at the end of the Mann filters seem to differ from the likes of Bosch, Fram and Blueprint and genuine Suzuki filters and the cup socket slips on the flats where as it's a good fit on the other makes. It makes removal a bit of a pain due to the filter location. I have tried three different cup sockets and none fit the Mann filter properly.

i only use Mann for my car too :)

Good Luck having an issue with a filter tho 😂😂😂

Thanks for sharing👍

But you can not say wich one is better without a particle scan of the oil ;)

@@Tsripper69 Oil filter efficiency is overrated. Some of my first cars didn't even have one and did alright.

I would say, pick any well known brand filter, and oil. Much more critically is change often, whatever brand, like once a year or every 6000 miles/10.000 km no matter the instructuons says you can go x2 - x3 the distance.

@@Rimrock300 This is my angle on oil changes after 40 years of driving: Change your oil only according to mileage. Every year is BS and a waste of good oil and money. If the manufacturer specifies 10 000 Ks, you can stretch that to 15 or eve 20 000. Sure, that might mean slightly more engine wear, but do you really want to one day bring your car to the scrap yard with a still perfectly good engine? Let your engine get old and worn at the same pace as the rest of your car.

You're Welcome👍

It's not where it's made, it's whose quality standards it's made to. I explain to people all the time that there's a big difference between "Bob's oil filters" that are made in China and Mahle filters that are made in China. In the case of Bob's oil filters some guy named Bob who wanted to start an oil filter company went to China and sought out an oil filter manufacturer and made a contract with them to make his filters, which are essentially what they already produce, but print Bob's name and company logo on them and package them in a box printed with Bob's name and logo. In the case of Mahle it was Mahle themselves that built the plant in China full of their spec production equipment along with everything being made to their standards, so essentially the filters are identical to the one's made in Germany. Any large corporation whose products in the past 30 years started showing up with made in China written on the box are all essentially selling you the same exact product they were when their plant was located in Germany or the US or wherever it is they oriented from, they simply moved their plant to China along with enough management to oversee production to make sure the standards are held to the same level as before. All that said I still try buying products made in countries that have free societies, I try my very best not to support communist systems.

@@dukecraig2402 Yep, expanded on my comment perfectly, I'm 100% in agreement.

Glad it was helpful, Thanks👍

This

In this instance the MANN doesn't come close to the MAHLE, and you can litterally see it.

@@dirkfolscher3001 Hardly. This is not a test, but a series of personal and subjective preferences. MANN is the manufacturer of OEM Porsche oil filters. These oil filters are manufactured precisely according to Porsche specifications and with MANN development experience. All components of the oil circuit are matched to each other. In the case of oil filters, it is not about which oil filter has the most pleats, the thickest filter paper or the finest pores. It is about whether the filter mass remains dimensionally stable, whether the flow rate meets the OEM's specifications or whether the pressure gradient between the inlet and outlet is correct ... for example.

Mähle isn’t generic as someone posted (general automotive parts manufacture) they actually supply OE Daimler Benz, ZF as well as many others for OE fitment , they’re suppliers to Audi with OE BEHR coolers… General..? Not really, manufacturer of OEM ? pretty much…

Mahle ist Top! 25 Jahre Erfahrung mit Mahle! Preis Leistung Überragend.

I used all the time MANN products on my Volvo D5 till two years ago, I needed quick and oil filter but couldn’t get one so I used a Mahle and I have to say, the engine runs a wee bit smoother. Didn’t expect that outcome but I can even notice a more balanced oil pressure with the Mahle.

Running a Mann interior Air filter, works a hell of a lot better than the Hyundai OE.

Thanks for Sharing👍

Thank You👍

You're Welcome, Thanks👍

Thank You, Cheers👍

You're Welcome Jim, Thanks for Sharing👍

@@WhipCityWrencher anytime, Pete!

dry sump system

Thank You👍

Thank You👍

Thank You, Merri Have a Great Weekend👍

@@WhipCityWrencher You 2

You're Welcome👍

You're Welcome, Thanks!

Mann-Hummel makes filters for many brands of vehicles and OEM and on the shelf filters in the States of brand such as Purolator Boss family, Denso, Mobil1, Wix and Mamy more OEM filters. Mahle are made in China and are made for most foreign and Euro vehicles. They really both vary in design depending on model of vehicle. There is a whole myriad of designs that I have looked over.

Typed on your China made smartphone?

Thank You👍Glad you liked the video. Thanks for Sharing👍

You're Welcome👍

Thank You😊👍

Plus far better filtering medium.

@@user-sf7kl9uh7k how could you come to this conclusion? You have not filtered anything

@@will-ever I've watched the video, have you?

Thank You! Cheers!😊

For me it used to be the decider for me as well, it still is for some things. I never would buy a Mercedes bult in the USA for example, like the M-Class was, the GLE, GLS are. But conerning filters it doesn't make a difference, cause they are developed in here in germany. And i know chineese can build those as good as the germans, turks, italians, greeks, people from former Yugoslavia or all kind of asians who work on their production here in Germany!

@@escariol I'm a recently retired factory worker, we spent decades struggling against other countries' lower pay and production costs to the point we took a pay cut and it was ten years before we got back to the original wage ignoring inflation. I will always gladly pay a bit more to support European workers.

@@skinnytinny9023 You don't make sence at all! A Bulgarian worker earns about 10% of what a Danish worker earns. So which European worker exactly do you support if you buy products made in the EU but in some of the low wage countries?

@@Bretware904 possible, but Mahle isn't chinese even if it's build there. Or is the Iphone or any other Apple product chinese?

@@escariol Alright then, I'll buy made in the UK from now and on and f*ck everyone else, is that better?

Thank You👍

Why? How can you tell it works better ?😲

Yes.every western bigger company has factories in China 😂.cheap work force

Yea, other countries like Germany have very different disclosure laws when it comes to where a product is made, in the US the package must show the country of origin, in other countries they're allowed to put the company's home country on the package and then the country of origin where the product was made on the product itself, by doing it that way you don't know where it was actually made until you get it home and open the box. There's been companies caught here in the US advertising "Made in Germany/UK/France etc etc" who had people in those countries unboxing products and removing the Made in China stickers from the product then shipping them to the US distributors, by doing this they had people in the US buying products they thought were made in those countries and paying highly elevated prices for what they thought was "European craftsmanship". I remember about 10 years back there was a new line of motorcycle helmets on the market that people were paying ridiculous prices for thinking they were made in Germany, turns out the helmets didn't pass European or American DOT safety standards, the shell's broke much easier than they should have once an agency started testing them even the padding on the inside wasn't up to the claimed standards, as soon as the trouble started and it became public knowledge that the helmets were actually made in China from normal plastics and other substandard materials the company's website went dead and nobody could get a hold of their offices which turned out to be an apartment or something like that where they were unboxing them and removing the labels then taking the reboxed helmets around the corner to a shipper and shipping them to the US.

Do Hyundaia i30 1,5 DPI 2021 rok kupiłem dwa filtry Hyundaia i Mann - jeden niebieski drugi Mann czarny- oba made in Korea a puszki metalowe taki sam kształt i rozmiar - różnią się kolorem i nadrukiem. Przypuszczam że są z jednej fabryki.

China can and does build good stuff, if just whether the companies they build for keep on top of the quality control

@@Thecrazyvaclav ^ this

Mahle is OEM for many car-brands. I always buy my filter for my BMW from Mahle, but those filters are made in Austria.

But you cant tell by watching, the filter paper might be crappy!

@@SuperMegaImbaLord MAN also good, as German Knecht and Hengst brand.

Mahle filters are developed in Germany, the manufacture of it specified and controlled by Mahle Germany. Does not matter where the factory is located

@@Rimrock300 It does matter when bean counters at Mahle outsource production to China to boost shareholder profits, destroy jobs here in Europe and the price tag for consumer ends up cheaper by pennies only.

Thank You👍

Thanks for sharing

You're Welcome👍 and Thanks!

Thanks for Sharing

Thanks for sharing

Thank you! 😃

Χαιρετισμούς από Γρεβενά

You're Welcome

Thanks for sharing

You're Welcome Dan, Have a Good weekend also.👍

Thanks 🙂

You're Welcome👍

Yes, Porsche, Mercedes, BMW and VW built solid cars then and mostly built in Germany.

Thank You 404👍

I used to have a BMW E46 M3. The OEM filter is made by Mahle. It was a very well made filter compared with others.

You're Welcome, Thanks👍

Thank You

Thanks, WrenchingMafia👍

You're Welcome👍

Mann were all I ever used in the multiple W124 Mercedes I owned

Wow - impressive.

You don't know much about cars then...................

Thank You, I Appreciate it.😊👍