Which AT-AT is the best? (Rip polls)

I still can’t decide between the 2020 version and the 2007 version 2020: AMAZING design 2007: WHAT ON EARTH IS COOLER THAN A LEGO AT-AT WALKING ON ITS OWN?!?!?!?!

I like the 2020 version because it doesn't waste any space.

Can't wait until 2070 when you'll be comparing 37 AT-ATs. 😂

The 2003 one surprisingly up really well! However, the 2020 one's design and the 2007 one's function is just incredible.

11:01 “Mom you’re embarrassing me in front of the other AT-ATs!”

Searched and found this, I was wondering how the troops got off the AT-AT: "The funny part about this is that Lucasfilm had no clue what the answer to this was. They just put them in ESB and thought they were cool, without really thinking about the practicality. However, while preparing the toy lineup, Kenner called them up. Uh, guys? We're trying to design the new AT-AT toy, and we're not sure how the people get on and off. How's it supposed to work? Lucasfilm didn't have an answer. So, the older books like the Star Wars Source Book or the Star Wars Technical Journal will tell you that they got down onto their knees, lowered ramps, and had troops run down the ramps from the body. However, when the Incredible Cross Sections book came out, the authors derived a different theory. They suggested that rather than have the AT-AT kneel, they instead projected large booms from the body, and have troops rappel down zip lines to the ground. It's therefore possible that both are correct, and AT-ATs can do either one, but it's not really clear. The technical drawings of Cross Sections, Technical Journal, and Essential Guide all differ in their descriptions of AT-ATs. In other words, the authors just made them up. But usually, the way that canon gets around that is to say that there were many different varieties of AT-AT walkers. In fact, the old Source Book says that some AT-ATs could be configured to carry AT-ST walkers inside them! So it's definitely likely that they had different configurations." -David Eaton, on Quora

The 2003 version holds up incredibly well considering how old of a set it is

I'm proud to be the owner of the 2003. Very last set I've ever built before I became a high school student and moved on to other interests. One of my absolute favorite sets.

Been waiting for ages to see this comparison

I have a theory for the “squinting” view port slit on the new one. For one of the close up shots of the head in empire strikes back, they use a model with a noticeably thinner view port. I’m guessing they used that shot as reference when designing it.

The UCS AT-AT release has brought me back here and has confirmed what I have always thought. Apart from the original 4483 the other Walkers have way to skinny legs and this is a big deal in the overall look of the complete AT-AT.

I own the 2003 version, I got it as a birthday present when I was younger and still own it years later

Proud member of the 2% 2003 vote. I idolized that set too as a child and when I finally got it a couple years ago it didn’t disappoint at all. I don’t see outdated building techniques as a flaw if the set had its heart in the right place, and no one is gonna tell me the 2003 at at didn’t give its all for us Star Wars LEGO fans back in the day.

The shoulder and neck area on the motorized AT-AT is rough. Moving legs seemed to come at a severe cost to looks.

is nobody gonna talk about how the legs are too skinny on all but the oldest one....?

The 2007 one gets too much hate. I have it and it is literally one of the best sets ive ever owned. I MEAN COME ON! IT WALKS!!!!

I love how the side cannons were made of a wrench pick-axe and spades.

I was really confused as to why my AT-AT didn't look like any of these. Then I remembered that I got it for a discount but it was missing the box and one of the bags. So mine is apparently a VERY heavily modified 2014 one.

Legend has it, General Veer’s identical brother joined the rebellion and fought each other on Hoth.

I really still love the 2003 version. It's a little fragile as a play set, but I enjoy having it on display on a shelf. Plus the legs actually look thick enough

The 2003 one still holds up imo

I remember owning the 2014 one and when I was holding it at 7 years old, I had so much trouble building it and in the end I decided to just tear it apart and now looking back at it, I really regret it and I hope to get one to have as part of my collection

From 2018 onwards I've noticed Lego has become super dedicated to their new meta of focusing on accurate appearing kits and I think that has a lot to do with their shift in target audience with changes to their marketing. Now days they have fully embraced the older generation of Lego collectors who care more about accuracy and display model quality kits than kids do when it comes to their expensive show piece model kits with focusing on marketing their different ranges at specific target audiences within their customer base. And this also was forced on them with shifting customer trends. Lego seems to only really have two age group audiences now; Adults and Kids, that's it. As most teens are more interested in video games and sports currently.

Ryan: Newest, Latest, and Greatest! Me: Wow Ryan, SpOiLeRs

Capital ship comparison: 2006 ISD, 2009 Venator SD, 2014 ISD, 2017 FO SD.

I only ever had the 2014, so I felt disappointed when he ragged on it so hard

that moment when you realize a lego set has been on earth longer than you've been alive

I think the new one is totally the best, but that doesn’t mean I can afford it...

The builds are drastically different, but the figures imo even more so.

I still love the 2014, because to me it just looks the most pleasing to have on display. New ones just doesn’t have they look that the 2014 gives. I also remember that I bought the 2014 on like the last day it was going to be in stores. Since it was going to be discontinued. I had the option of the at-at which I bought or the other discontinued star destroyer.

I remember 2014 Christmas and the 2014 AT-AT was probably the best gift I've ever gotten on Christmas. Sadly, as the kid that I was, I absolutely destroyed this set into pieces, but I'm currently trying to rebuild it!!! Great video!

He has a true grand army of the empire!

The 2020 version looks fantastic I can’t wait to get it

The Mindstorm is a monstrosity because it actually walked.. which is what made it badass

0:00 The council of AT-ATs

Honestly i like the 2003 one the most. For the time it was very well done

When you’re so early seven different people are saying first

Love the comparison video Ryan! One suggestion - your new ratings system allots quite a few points to opinion relative to the other categories. Maybe you could average the opinion scores of the fans and yourself for the future comparison videos to fix that. Keep up the great work! Can we see a Jedi Interceptor comparison next?

This is by FAR my favorite upload you’ve done! I’ve seen it so many times

You’re like my favourite Star Wars reviewer, you have inspired me to create my own lego channel. I would love some support and feedback

The 2020 one is better scaled and has a better interior

I really love the contrast of dark grey and light grey on the 2003 version.

You have no idea how long I’ve waited for this

Isn’t this series just him flexing that he has all the Lego sets that he’s comparing

Hopefully you can remake this video in 2-3 years with the UCS at-at

I got the 2007 one for Christmas in 2007 and it was probably the best gift I have ever received. So many memories building and playing with it with my dad. it also had that handle on top for easy mobility. its fallen apart a bit since then but the skeletal technic remains still stand in my closet.

Seeing all the AT-ATs. Echo Base: Well... we're boned.

Has anyone else noticed that the port has a brick separator in its mouth in the background?

i like how the 2003 atat is really tall, and the dark grey goes well with the set. also its cool that 3 2000s sets had the same speeder bike build in different colors

I think the 2003 AT-AT had the best design from all of these models. He looks by far more like the "real" AT-AT than the others and the old grey just goes better with any set. But since this is my opinion based on the Lego Sets I had as child, im clearly biased there.

Damn the older Lego sets built with that gray really feel old. Like they're from a black n white movie

The notes at the bottom when he was looking at the boxes were hilarious😂😂

All of the AT-ATs just standing there reminds me of the boys

Man, I love your comparisons, they are really thorough :) 2014 AT-AT was very good, 2020 version seems perfect. I'm surprised the first one (2003) still looks pretty well, considering how bad first LEGO Star Wars sets were designed...

The first AT-AT has a genuinely impressive build and I feel like the following years were a pretty big let down. I mean they were better in a technical sense but they were kinda missing the allure of the first one. I mean that was up until 2020 which is such a huge improvement over every other build, they really utilized as much space as possible and the body looks so much better. It's the improvement upon 2014 is truly remarkable

1:24 ahh yes “Auctually”

Really good vid! One piece of constructive criticism: It would be better if you could make the overlap on the "basic info" section a little bit more opaque, so we can see the box better. Cool 👍

2020 has the best design, 2007 can literally walk, this is a hard choice

when the german engineers work on 2020 lego at at

I don't think the 2003 version gets enough credit. Sure the coloring is poor and the build could be improved, but it has most accurate proportions of all the other sets. Yes, I even think its proportions are better than the 2020 version.

Love the vids man. Never thought i'd get back into LEGO, Thanks man!!!

The choice between 2007 and 2020 is really tight for me. 2020 looks better but how can you not love an AT-AT that can walk on its own?

Thankyou so much for doing these reviews and ranking all together I am buying the 2020 At- At!

Imagine having 5 ATATs... if only...

if 2020 set had a one more SnowTrooper and a rebel trooper and a turret

I have 2003 version of the at at. And I personally love it. It's big and looks super cool. Also the speeder inside of it is super cool as well. It's a classic among Lego sets.

thanks for making this it really helped me to know which i want to get

The 2020 version looks amazing.. good use of space, accurate design and makes for an awesome display piece, but man.. seeing the 2007 walk is a thing of beauty! Great review, and I think ultimately the ranking in the end is correct

The 2010 and 2014 versions weren't long enough. I'm glad the 2020 version fixed that.

Just bought the 2020 walker I’ve been working way too much to relax and finish it but I’m pretty satisfied with my purchase. Also I love the fact you include inflation adjustments I just appreciate that a lot

Thank your I’ve been waiting for this

you know a Lego Star Wars set is amazing when they use shots form the underside of the build in the front of the box!

Me: has two dogs Ryan: has 5 dogs- i mean AT-ATs

amazing comparison videos!!!

Great comparison video, my favorite is the 2014 because it was the first over 1,000 piece LEGO I got but when I moved it got lost.

0:22 I forgot about that boyo, I feel like he should be included (even if it gets last place in every category).

A beautiful pack of Imperial dogs! I liked the 2020 set the most

I have the 2003 AT-AT, and I've ended up messing with the neck connection to keep it on. While I still love it, I eagerly await the 2020's release- maybe even going so far as to pick up a few of em ;D

I love the old grey and sand green that the old set used

Had no clue there was so much

I like the 2014 version because I remember wanting it when I was a lot younger. The new just feels smaller.

I love the AT-ATs because they are one of my favorite Star Wars vehicles. I only have the 2020 AT-AT and now got the huge UCS AT-AT and cant wait to build them soon :)

When I saw the head of the 2010 version the first thing I thought was, did they use a shovel as turret

I am a HUGE AT-AT fan. I love this vehicles so much. The 2020 version brings so much justice to this iconic vehicle that I thought previous iterations were missing. I can’t wait to get my hands on it.

Motorised version is brilliant. Even the Design while not being as accurate is still nice Great video👍

2:50 I got this one for 70 bucks on eBay out of the box but still in the bags with all the minifigures and I love it

By far the best comparison video

This, does put a smile on my face

The motorized AT-AT is coolest because it can walk (!), but the 2020 version is most acurate and looks best.

Ah I remember the one on the left side. I was so proud of it.

Me: Can I go to Bobby’s house to play with his atat? Mom: no we have atat at home Atat at home: 0:22

0:01 Me and the Boys about to attack the Rebel Base be like:

11:15 that at-at be doing the moon walk you know

Walmart has the AT-AT on clearance for $100. So glad I picked it up. Always wanted an AT-AT as a kid but the sets were always too expensive for me. Wanted to see how the others stacked up against it. 2007 looks pretty cool as well. There's something about that original that I love too. Probably just the nostalgia.

You said the 2020 is “squinting” cracked me up lol 😂

What set was the "monstrosity" I want to know more about it

There should be a UCS AT-AT

@1:37 Can we just take a second to acknowledge that the quotes in the info card are freaking hilarious! 🤣

Cool comparison dude! I started to look for a AT-AT to finish my Assault On Hoth Recreation Display, and you really help me. 2 questions for you: 1) If i can get 2 of the 2020 and 1 (just for fan) 10178, is the best choise you think? 2) I allready have all of this: 75098: Assault Of Hoth (2144 Pieces / Year: April 30, 2016 / Star Wars Ultimate Collector's Series) 7879: Hoth Echo Base (769 Pieces / Year: 2011) 8084: Snow Tropper Battle Pack (74 Pices / Year: 2010) x2 8089: Hoth Wampa Cave (297 Pieces / Year: 2010) 75138: Hoth Attack (232 Pieces / Year: 2016) With the 3 AT-AT is enoughor i need something else? Hope you can help me!