ctyetta1 She needs to shut the haters down. She had a bad luck streak. She’s fabulous in every way though, so she’ll do fine🖤

They're live of course

Mc fan robin hood exactly

The E5 would be on the word ME but no sound came out it was more like "You got __ feelin emotion"

Michael that’s ‘cause it quietly kinda cracked hahaha, but she slayed the “deeper than I ever dreamed of” part

"you got me feelin"

That was a voice crack but only she can make a voice crack sound AMAZING!!!

tfimperfectangel its definitly Not live !

MC_Fan forever yea I don’t think it’s live

it's LIVE!!!!!!!!!

蔡阿嘎 in your dreams

tfimperfectangel Mariah sing live 😀

Ya she was the QUEEN 🏆

André I KNOW!

It was liveeee

in 1:43 its the same she did in live melbourne 2014

JoyJoy111 yahhh it's so hard to believe now that her whistle is live maybe she need to do some whistles in Vision of love to prove that her whistles is still there. Or she need to do some acapella whistles to make the haters shook

Erwin Reyes She lots of live whistles in Love Hangover. :)

JoyJoy111 ohhh I've watched that before she's pretty amazing :) I hope that someday she will back again I want her new songs for 2018 will be #1 in billboard and her #AIWFCIY I hope that she will hit that number 1 spot

@@joyjoyforevershe lips them sometimes but you can tell they’re live here especially the last ones you can hear her breath and she does a little whistle at the end after she’s done it’s easy to tell when she’s lipping them she’s not here and even if she was her belts are strong and she sounds great

You know I thought the same but if it was reasonably priced, I'd go. She obviously can't sing like she did in the 90s but as long as she hit a couple of the whistle notes I think I'd be satisfied.

E7

she’s always done the ear thing ever since 1993

I don't know that first whistle note cracked.. it sounded live to me, but blended possibly with a track

not a crack, just an inflection

What the fuck, it's live. Don't listen to this hater. Dwight.

We all tell ourselves certain things, to get by in life. Mariah is my bitch there's no hate.. Just the TRUE LAMBS know... lol it's obvious you aren't one. Just cuz we point it out doesn't mean there's hate.. byeee

JR Taylor ill let you figure that out lol

Now how does her crew know when she's gonna use a "lipped whistle" only on the 2nd part ? Does your words even make sense to you ? Seriously ?!!

I screamed 😄

I was about to blame you when I understood the joke Nahh just kidding

shes been fully lipping all the whistles since 2010 but she did do the ending whistles live at billboard 2019

Memoirs Of Mimi's Imprefect Infinity Butterfly 90 I love Mariah but yes! At 3:12 it is the same exact whistle from NYE 2016, when she was squatting down asking for help from the audience

Johndave Laranja You Know she hasn't performed since New Years and this performance is from December 17, 2017 right?

World Of The Trailer which year does he lives in ? Ahhah

she sounds great-

Ariana Grant wtf

Ariana Grant No sorry Ariana is the most ridiculous vocalist ever. Mariah is the best singer songwriter ever with the best powerful vocals with 5 octaves vocal range so you can't say this. She's also the queen of whistle registers,Ariana Can't do them live and so she is the fake vocalist

Ariana Grant You know nothing about music.

Nobody asked for your opinion and I don't care if you were "just saying". If you feel the need to get things off your chest, go speak to all 0 of Ariana's number one songs or Grammy awards. Kindly fuck off.

adhil ramgoolam I say what I want. And if u didn't agree u could of kept scrolling