Tuff Golem when

@@PhoenixSCitem frames

Please make a texturepack someone

​@@fulookin6701they dont move

@@Adrian-kb4rg you can break them and pick them up to put somewhere else

It'll take several more before the fletching table has its own interface and use

ok seriously why is all of your comments "...... lmfao"

Now we need the actual villages.

​@@PGDreemurrlmfao

@@PGDreemurr ok seriously why is all of your comments "...... lmfao" lmfao

that'd be cool but wouldn't solve the main issue of the distance you'd have to travel

@connortg5 traveling should be enjoying in of it shelf, seing cool new sights and gathering resources

Makes sense, too, since wandering traders are constantly "wandering" and have been to many places

@@connortg5 at least it does solve the problem of finding them

I mean wandering traders are rare too

100% agreed, and since i never touched the whole villager trapping thing i am 100% on board with these changes, prooving the point further, just some refining and additional changes will help with the balancing

Or increasing costs.

Agreed. Anvil is so expensive to keep replacing as is without a cheeky iron farm. Let us upgrade our enchantments for cheap and have no cap!

I think that rather than removing the level cap, I think that enchant and repair costs should cap out at a max of 40. I don't want to have to start paying 128 levels worth of EXP because I used an Anvil 12 times. That and capping enchant costs to 40 means we will be slipping just under the "too expensive" limit.

I think it should cost 0 levels to repair gear, plus 1 for every level of enchantment the resulting item would have.

But mojang is proud of people haveing to farm, or lets face it grind.

people will find a way to farm the boss lol

people will intentionally minmax the fun out of their games and then complain it is "grindy", if they add a boss or a cool challange people will make a farm for it, then call it boring and grindy i guess that happens when people need "the most optimal path" for stuff instead of playing more casually

A good part of the major updates for the last few years has introduced new boss type enemies yet people still want more, they will always want more. The ravager, the piglin brute, the warden

@@jenv.7995 do not call piglin brute a boss enemy. They are a pushover. It's usually crossbow piglins who give me a challenge to traverse a bastion. Brute is easily countered by knockback(basic one, not even enchantment.)

The swamp villagers will be sacred now though

@@simplyNKHThe funny thing is, there's no such thing as swap villages

Flint and Steel + Lava Bucket go brrrrr

​@@buszka695people will have to make them for them xd

"Safe" Proceeds to feed the villager to a zombie five times and gaslight them into worse deals

Mojang: nah man, this sounds too fun. How about extra 10 hours of grinding for this?

Although them selling low level books is too much, It was nerfed because you aren't supposed to get endgame enchantments so easily. It's really not that bad to get good enchantments if you make a good xp farm like an enderman farm

​@@hhff8534but its tedious. And you have to build an xp farm. Thats not intended game design. Instead mojang wants you to spend 3 hours smacking mobs in caves to get an efficiency 1 book

@@SomeCowguy 3 hours? More like 3 minutes to get bunch of enchanted books or items using an enderman farm(which isn't tedious to build). Mojang doesn't want you to have easy access to endgame enchantments before actually beating the game. The concept with villagers isn't that bad, it just needs a few tweaks and changes to become fun and not tedious. Swamp villages and easier villager moving would make people happy. Building xp farms now became a part of the game so it's not really unintended

I'd rather Have Less Books.

Agree except that Frost Walker isn't entirely useless. It's good for mining/walking around on magma blocks (e.g. esp. useful when building a gold farm), also good if you are riding a horse around exploring or whatever--makes it easy to cross bodies of water, just dismount and lead the horse across the ice.

mojang nerfs villagers, but they refuse to fix anvils, they refuse to deal with the lottery in enchanting tables, and they refuse to fix the tedious ass grind of enchanting a book at an enchanting table over and over again until you get lucky enough for the 1% enchant.

sitting at an enderman farm and enchanting books for an hour is no more gameplay than sitting with a librarian and swapping trades for half an hour

They’re just inflating the playtime instead of adding content

we need more ancient city type gameplay, risky, rewarding, and fun as hell.

i dont know why its the only good way to enchant

@@woobgamer5210 It's because it's not the intended way to do that, the intended way is enchanting.

Ah... 'the intended way'... In an open sandbox game. Haha 😂

​@@xbit2011minecraft is partially a survival game and there needs to be balance. If you want fully sandbox, you can just turn on commands and have things the way you want

@@hhff8534 Or you can decide to not use the mechanic you deam OP. That would avoid hours of Mojang induced mindless grinding and everybody would be happy.

Truly a change i can get behind. It requires you to find a book, but at least it requires you to find it once. Swift sneak is a pain to seek.

​@@eternal4081XD I spawned in a new world right near a deep dark

i like this because then you have to actually get an enchant first

that a very good idea!

Holy shit he cracked the code

Oh by the goat's horns, 3000 blocks isn't far. If you don't have time to play 15 minutes to get to somewhere in Minecraft why are you even playing a sandbox game. Play something that is just distilled version of whatever you are looking for. For instance creative mode in minecraft or whatever other game. Seriously, you are just whining here. If you just want to chill, then do so, you don't need villagers for that at all.

@@Limrassoni’ve literally traveled more than 4 thousand blocks before finding a desert, plus there is no way 3k blocks is 15 minutes on land, also i would rather spend that time doing something productive, i love exploring but not everyone does, be compassionate

@@Almaeeni0 No. 3k blocks is neightbourhood in Minecraft. The largest map is 2048×2048 I tend to make multiple ones to create a bigger one. "jumping while sprinting allows the player to move with an average speed of 7.127 m/s" 1 block is 1×1×1 Meaning to move 3k blocks you need 7 minutes. So you can dodge trees, climb mountains, avoid enemies and go around pits and still make it in 15. And if you have a known route, then you can go there and come back in 15. Even casual exploring is larger than 3k and I would say early game exploring on a not too hot server is 10-20k if you find base location before you did good.

@@Limrasson not everyone likes exploring, ao you saying “if you dont like exploring play a different game” is stupid, minecraft isnt an exploration gamem it has many different aspects which is why it appeals to a larger variety of people plus this change was mainly made to accommodate for the villager nerf, sure it would be quick for you to reach there but transporting a villager is painful

@@Limrasson also you sayif someone doesnt like exploring they should play creative which is dumb, what if someone likes grinding,survival,challenges or literally any different aspect of the game minecraft might be a sandbox game but its also a survival game

We would have been PERFECTLY HAPPY if the only change was no more trade discount stacking. Would have been a slight annoyance (as now we can't get eff 5 for 1 emerald), but understandable.

@shangex4795 it actually does

​@shangex4795it actually does

@shangex4795Firstly, yes, it does (speaking as a player of Bethesda games), secondly, it allows you to skip the boring and frustrating grind and get to the fun parts faster.

​@shangex4795then don't abuse it? The option has always been there for you to willingly make the game harder for yourself

Too op

​@timohara7717 did you watch the video?

@@shloinguslover68 they spawn every hour

@@timohara7717 yes and they do not resupply their books, you can get a few every hour

mending is just outright badly designed due to how base anviling/enchantments work im fine with replacing tools now and then, but diamonds arent that... renewable unless you trade for diamond tools *with villagers* excluding the needance of highly more levels when you repair more and *outright ban* if you meddle with too much makes those diamond/netherite tools just bad without actually having mending. even iron too, unless you, A. like to kill lots of zombies for flesh and occasional iron ingot(this goes same for cooper and... drowned? i think?) or B. *enslave villagers* great design. im fine with non-renewable tools but way to obtain said tools is waaay to complicated and headache worthy for people to just mending everything

Are you saying they want mending to be nerfed tho? I think Mojang are more concerned with players getting everything they need in one place. Minecraft is one of the only games that gives the player so much freedom that you can pretty much farm and mass produce anything. This is the real balancing issue Mojang keep trying to address by pushing updates towards exploration and non-renewable items. You can tell from how they talk in Minecraft Live. Here's how I think they want you to play: 1. Grind for diamonds, iron & XP 2. Use tools until they break. 3. Repair/upgrade with said resources OR return to step 1 This forces you to play the SURVIVAL element of the game rather than getting too comfortable. If you know the tricks, Villager trading gets you basically whatever you want. Even emeralds are essentially free if you trade back and forth. The villager economy is so broken that is puts all your time into cycling trades rather than playing the game. I think they realize it's hard to make new additions now that are valuable enough for players to want to leave the village.

@@TheAwesomeAccount What they want is stupid. They should build the game around how players want to play, not their stupid idea of survival gameplay that wasn't even relevant ten years ago. If they want to make the game harder, add more mobs, more bosses, more dangerous structures. Taking petty passive aggressive swings at players building huge bases to provide them with their tools is the opposite of good game design.

@@CPU9incarnate what you want is stupid. it's their game, what they want is the most important thing. If you want to make the game easier, play with datapacks and commands and creative mode.

@@elmok What the players want is always more important than what the devs want, especially when the devs are morons like Mojang who can't even make a chair.

@@MrTomyCJ i get that it can be done, but you shouldnt have to research a specific order to combine them, its not very rewarding to those who dont uderstand what order to enchant in

@@MrTomyCJ Nope it cant be done anymore if they push with this update. Its literally impossible even if you try the most optimized combination.

@@MrTomyCJ Not anymore, it was barely possible before and now the costs are roughly tripled.

You mean it's looking like it is going to be impossible if you only use villagers, since you can still enchant helmets and boots at the etable and just disenchant it at a grindstone until you have 3 or more enchantments and then combine them

Buff grindstone, make it able to choose what to do for the enchantments. turn enchantments from items into a book or turn it into xp That's only my idea because somehow I accidentally get a lot of enchantment in my golden helmet (I enchantmentt.1 times but get ,3)

Chilliger

Gigaillager

Yeah

Bro's down bad for the chad villager

Yeah we do need more of the daddy villagers

what

What

That's actually a cool idea

yes

Yessss! I love terraria's methods for biomes! They probably won't do this, because it would take an enormous toll on the speed Minecraft runs at, and it would require making an entire system for it, but it is a fun thought.

Or bring villagers to a swamp and breed them there

Well, just create one from zombie villager.

Or find a zombie villager spawning there and cure it. I usually find zombie villagers rather than finding villages because zombie villagers will follow you and are easy to trap and all you have to do is cure them and you get cost effective trades.

@@NicholasFlamy Oh simple just wander around for 4 hours until one happens to spawn

@@toastr1255 that would be pain in the ass because moving villager in big distance is very painfull

I mean trading was never fun in the first place. It was just stupidly easy, accessible, and efficient to a broken degree

​@@Thund3rDrag0n12 They're basically slaves to the full extent of the word, they can't even complain about the stuff people do to them cuz it is beyond their code People already had easy ways to bypass them getting angry by you hitting them by killing them anyways, I don't really have a problem with this change aside from the odd decisions of the books levels Although I guess that is more because it is just absurdly easy to exploit the trades

The problem is that they can't just add features in to fix it. That's also bad game design. And it has to be somewhat clear and intuitive while using features that already exist in the game. Connecting it to the biometype of the villager is super good in terms of a game design decision. It has other bonuses too such as being easy to identify the villager you want to trade with in a trading hall instead of 20 identical librarians with the enchantement written in a sign hanging over their head. Overall, very good game design decision, so what they need to do is add some form of rebalance or a counter strategy that allows you to skip the RNG of exploring but that is a more tedious, but consistent method of getting the right villagers. The suggestion i keep posting everywhere i can is for zombie villagers to have a low rate of being from a different biome than they are supposed to be. Something like 1/8 zombie villagers or lower. It allows players, wherever they are in a world, no matter which biome(unless it's mushroom biome or deep dark), to set up a zombie farm to try to get zombie villagers out of it. You may think this is too easy, but when you consider that this is a mob farm where you cannot just kill the mobs, and where you try to keep the Z-villagers alive(which cannot be auto-separated from zombies) and you get a weird mob farm that you have to try to run both quickly and slowly at the same time, to get as many mobs as possible, yet not so fast that you cannot keep track of Z-villagers inside. It's a cool interaction with a farm, it's probably the most tedious farm to manage as afk-ing doesn't help in any way, but it's a way to get villagers that are all going to get the curing bonus AND you get a xp farm at the same time. So you get the choice of either trying to make and manage that farm, or go out in the world to just get the villagers yourself. And btw, with 1\8 odds + the rate of spawning a Z-villager from another biome is 0.5% per zombie spawn. And the chance per zombie spawn to get the exact villager you want is 0.09% which is lower in chance than mending, but zombies spawn multiple times per second and rerolling trades takes 3-5 seconds per roll. So overall, i think this could be a balanced way.

@@Thund3rDrag0n12 true, but would you rather have that or have to haul your villagers halfway across your world to a swamp or snow biome and then all the way back? i’ll take easy but broken over stupidly difficult and tedious.

I’d prefer it if they added new enchantments to the masters in each biome or even added another villager tier for them, I’m not leveling up a villager fully for unbreaking 2 lmao

that would require there being enough content to have different gamestages in the first place.

@@weisslerren go to nether go to end beat dragon beat warden reach level 30 xp be in world for 30 hours just some off the top of my head that could be vanilla game stages

Yeah, like the other guy said, what in Minecraft would even constitute a different game state? Entering the nether, entering the end, killing the dragon, killing the Wither? Becuase if they use that it's just as easily exploitable as it is now.

But unlike something like terraria, there really isnt progress. You can get to the dragon and do most overworlf achievements in like an hour with some speedrun elements

Actually we’ve got things to work with : 1- Achievements 2- Local difficulty 3- Stats 4- Current location 5- Stuff crafted (material used for armor / max level enchants made) 6- surely other things

Cool idea, nice to see your suggesting some changes, even If I hate it when people compare Terraria to Minecraft since they're nothing alike.

That would give an incentive to upgrade villages/build for progression. Building. The essence of Minecraft. Great idea.

@@SkyTheGuy8 Honestly, i cant help but imagine people would bitch that you have to waste time/grind just to get the trades, rather than just... getting them, the repeated "Tedium" thing :V

Just put a limit to how many books a day and call it a day

Maybe villagers can have tiredness, if they haven't slept for more than a day they wouldn't go to work

That’s something I was thinking of, too. Like, if you put kelp in water at y:63 - y:50, it could make an ocean biome, coral could make a lukewarm ocean, and the full coral blocks could make it warm ocean. Ice would cool it to cold or frozen ocean if there’s no other determining blocks. Same could be done with trees. Like the biome post-generation could be determined by the leaves on newly grown trees. Perhaps the chunk would be checked every number of ticks and have a 50% chance of changing a few blocks to the new biome, to allow for some blending.

but it doesn't work that way so it doesn't make sense. The "biome" is determined by the air patterns and clouds above a certain area of land, not the land itself so terraforming shouldn't change a biome.

It would probably be a lot harder in a 3D game compared to a 2D game.

What if I want to build with certain blocks without changing what biome I’m in? Better to add a block that acts like a beacon, that changes the current biome’s behavior as long as it’s active

Maybe take a page from starbounds book and make special terraformer blocks/items and make them need a special fuel. That way it would be late game and satisfying to the player, but also allowed to ignore physics like jasonshrock said.

Never got people doing that. Enchantment table is always a go to first since for me since you can accrew a solid baseline of enchantments for 3 levels with you being able to cycle enchants for what you want and come back later and any enchants you want/need after that are also cheaper since you don't need more books.

Get an enchantment table and a grindstone. Enchant the sword with the table until you get some solid base enchants. Then use books for everything else

I tried doing that with max-level books on boots, I couldn't get all enchants without going over the level cap. I had everything except soul speed

It will be possible through use of an enchanting table.

​@@Spiffyobecause enchantment tables are dogshit, people just want to get their good gear faster so they start doing things that are actually fun like building their megaprojects and shit

This is why I hate this update aswell

its literally just an experimental update that nerfed the most overpowered mechanic in the game

What do you mean afk fishing is nerfed? Works like a charm for me.

@robertmaske2030 The old machine was super simple, and easy to make in early game. The post-nerf machines were ultra-complex and not something a lot of people wanted to put effort into.

Ah okay, so an ingame build. Never looked something like this up, because i made my own solution based on something totally different

@@robertmaske2030 What does your machine look like?

​@@mustacheman529probably an external script/macro, first thing that came to my mind

True. I am not casual but i still don't like this. I see many people praise the update for making things less accessible, forgetting that fishing exists and that you can actually disable villages and play the way you like. Instead people who are burnt out quickly(like me), are now unable to get things at satisfying pace. Yeah you can counter this update by nether highways but building it requires knowledge, a full inventory of ice, buttons and blocks for walls of the highway.

Yeah I hate that this update is just gonna make things more tedious

It's simple, Ask Alex.

​@@YourNormalProgramhis pet cat too.

@@Homer_Noobsonhuh???

I mean it's not like you're required to trade with villagers

Grindy implies there are long parts that are not fun. Which part is not fun? You don’t have to transport villagers. Just cure a zombie and leave it in its biome

​@@FuzzyJeffTheorygoing 4000 blocks just to to get to that biome is not fun

do you not realise how rare a zombie villager is? also it requires either going to the nether for blazes, finding an igloo with a basement, or going to a village anyway to have a chance for a breweing stand@@FuzzyJeffTheory

@@FuzzyJeffTheory ok, let's check. Firstly you need to build 7 villager breeders (one for each village biome). Then you need to connect all these breeders to transportation system of your choice (presumably blue ice road in the Nether). Then you need to traid villagers that your got from breaders to the max level and hope that it will open a traid to enchantment you need. If it's not you need to utilize this villager in your preferred way. I suggest burning in soul campfire as the most humane method. Then you need to transport villager with needed enchantment in your base using your transportation system.

So then don't make a trading hall if it's too much effort for you? It is absolutely not required to do stuff in the game. If you want the convenience of a trading hall, put in the effort.

Agreed, my friend went afk fishing for like 6 hours, i checked the chests and there was 1 mending book. ONE

This would also bring value to all that gear you can find or get from drops, which sometimes has decent enchants but you can basically just toss it away, because it's made of gold and breaks if you stare at it too hard.

real @@Sercil00

I know I like to go for a fallen kingdom like playstyle where my duty is to protect the villagers as there King

I kinda just bully the villagers like i never trade with them just steal their chests bully them and thats it

Afk fishing is not practical tbh.

I feel like the majority of the people saying they're "OP" or are "too easy to exploit" haven't tried working with them before either

Im getting terraria ptsd@@MrWeird-mu5ul

I'm also hoping they use it as an excuse to add more banner patterns for shepherds! Or potentially possibly maybe some rare dyes because right now it's hard to build in certain ways because not many blocks have certain colours.

biome specific trades seem neat, but changing some of the more important and often used trades to be biome locked makes the game even more grindy. buying biome blocks is a pretty good idea though

or the much more likely outcome is taking hours to get any good books, took 6 hours of afk fishing to get one mending book…

honestly this'd be cool imo, as long as they still don't make the books villagers give us come at lower levels

Is there any hope for ships if they are technically possible in this game? I always enjoyed building age of sail ships in my worlds, especially in creative, and to have them be actually functional would be amazing. Part of me says even if it was possible it wouldn't fit into Minecraft though

@@connortg5 Either make the final reward a max level book, or make anvils better. Either works, just not the system they have now

@@-cet honestly yeah, personally i would prefer the former but removing the anvil limit would be nice too

@@user-bv7zo6vd4m There are mods where you can build airships or trains as so called "multiblock structures". Meaning you can build whatever structure you want (maybe with some size limitations) and add some sort of "control block" (e.g. a steering wheel) that basically glues the whole thing together and lets you drive it somewhat like a regular boat. I could see something similar, but for "water ships". So yes, it would be possible. But these things can be a bit clunky (especially on servers) and as you already mentioned, this stuff doesn't really feel like like it would fit in regular Minecraft. Though maybe there could be something like the existing boats, but bigger. Some fixed/ "premade" thing that you can craft, place on water and drive like an existing boat. Maybe with like 3-4 slots for players/ mobs and an inventory like on a horse or something. I'm sure this could work as well and would feel more "minecrafty".

But then Mending would be too easy to get! Disclaimer: This is Mojang’s logic, not mine. I don’t want to see a bunch of angry replies.

@@HungryWarden i think they're doing the right thing, while the community says that minecraft is so easy, they added stuff like this to make it difficult

@@Redcon0 yeah. They’re trying to anyway but it could be executed better.

Honestly this all just makes me agree even more that Mojang's idea of "difficulty" isn't adding more fun bosses and enemies but just making the game grindier, this is why Terraria beats Minecraft btw

I feel like it would be best for the genre if we let Minecraft die and other games try to fill the void it will leave

@@SemiHypercube This is why I'm interested in the upcoming game hytale, it has the sandbox elements of minecraft with a progression system that is similar to terraria

@Blue-dg8vt I heavily disagree, think whatever you want but most people aren’t going to let Minecraft die unless Microsoft pulls another “chat reporting”

but then people would actually have to like... build a proper village and like... play the game Idk maybe tie it to difficulty as well, if you want to get maxed out everything really easily then play on easy but on hard you have to put more effort in.

@@childish4487 Yeah, people would lose their shit at the involved "Tedium" :V

They literally just said fuck bedrock players entirely, and Java players will now need an iron farm and an XP farm in addition to the trading hall, while using the nether roof to safely transport villagers. A 2 person team could make nether portals on the roof quickly and easily in no time and have a trading hall in the spawn area of a server in a day or 2 tops, likely even less knowing some players or with a little luck. Im not sure why they thought this fixes anything, and I fully agree that adding more grind isnt how you incentivize players to engage with the game the way you want. Even with this added grind its still way more effective, easier, and more quickly available than base enchanting will ever be

Maybe Mending *SHOULDN'T* be considered necessary whatsoever?

Which just bring us back to the anvil thing that other people have said. Repaing fully enchanted tools/ netherite tools is WAY too expensive, and you can only do it like 4 times before "too expensive" shows up. Also, if you think villagers/mending is too overpowered, you can just not use them.

@pokerusfreak8194 As a bedrock player, I think you are sorely mistaken. In Bedrock, you can use a Lead on a boat. This allows you to pull villagers in a boat.

@@HungryWarden good luck with hills, though. And actually having the boat follow you. It's really easier to dig a tunnel, fill it with water, and boat them across.

Yep

sandbox is when you turn on creative. it is survival and they are correcting the mechanic to better match the design they intended. mod the game if you want otherwise

@@neekk040motherfucker it’s a sandbox game there are no rules

​@@neekk040 I have seen many a dumb take in my life, but saying taht only creative is a sandbox and survival isn't/shouldn't be a sandbox is amongst the highest of them very easily

@@TheAuthorStudios apologies i really was mistaken with my definition if sandbox. I somehow mistook it to mean what is essentially creative mode. Still look at albion or sea of thieves, both sandbox games, things like fixes for cooldowns after dismount or silent boarding are exploits or mechanics that were deemed to not match the intended design that changed over time. The same applies here. Sandbox doesnt mean anything goes either. Mojang is giving back use to the enchanting table and anvil eliminating the broken shortcut that appeared after many years of different systems being added to the game.

@@TheAuthorStudios thinking back my response was addressing the very notion that "microsoft dictating gamplay in a sandbox" is exactly as nonsensical. Any sandbox has established rules. Ships in sea of thieves have set speeds. Swords set attack range. And those can be tweaked or changed. In this case mojang is giving use to more tools and people are just angry their shortcuts dont work anymore.

Notch 🤝 JK Rowling Tweeting weird information no one asked for

​@@husky0098the people on reddit asked

@slicepie410 I'm honestly not surprised

But normal in minecraft terms (square), or in IRL terms? CRITICAL INFORMATION

@@MrTomyCJ irl 😳

how is it fun

@@herbnfizz4113 lol literally

@@herbnfizz4113 when you can get from level 27 to 30 in a few seconds using an enderman farm it can be pretty fun

​@@herbnfizz4113Casino

going back and forth a dozen times to do one thing or another isn't my idea of a fun time, neither is the system we currently have for villagers either, but mojang isn't going to make a more creative solution to the issue, instead they'll just nerf shit into the group and call it a day, making everything MORE tedious to do isn't fun either as for your xp farm? how long until they nerf it too? idk "standing still for long periods of time reduces or eliminates mob xp gained/dropped, or, endermen drop less or no xp inside the end" something like that all because someone's opinion on the issue forums changes the game for everyone

Yeah

Fr fr

I, an average viewer, have contributed to the female phoenix sc's. I actually made him use phoenix sc chan longer. I'm so proud

@@MrBrineplays_ nah

@@MrBrineplays_ bro liked his own comment💀

brilliant idea, though i dont think thats what they want, since any tree can be brought back to base with sapplings, since this update clearly wants you to adventure about more still a brilliant idea though

Well, the wandering trader would be more useful because it sells saplings.

I just find disappointing the fact that they introduced this updates without first playing with what was more easily available like : 1- Traded quantities before the villager blocks the trade (in 1.14+ you can acquire 12 enchanted books with 1 trade, was chocked when I read that, wished they put it to 1) 2- Time before restock. Even tho I believe this is hardcoded and is not meant to accept dynamic values, I do believe that villagers should take more time to restock rare/expensive items. 3- Limited restocks. Maybe the villager can only provide you with 15 mending before completely running out, or maybe replace the trade with another interesting book. 4- bonus, would have been nice if you could somewhat specialize your villagers to lower previously mention stats on a/some trade(s) to augment the ones of another more desired item.

I’m probably the only person to carry around a Ban of Arthropods 5 Netherite Sword. BUUUUUT I have a good reason; I don’t want to get another 30 levels to re-enchant it, and I don’t want to build farms because they just suck the fun and challenge out of gameplay.

I’m keeping it because it has other enchantments on it too.

The thing is this screws over bedrock players, we don’t have access to autoclickers so we just have to sit, fishing for hours on end. And in my experience it’s not even that good, it took almost 6 hours for a mending book

is it? I find the biome thing better because it encourages you to set up infrastructure in your world. Let's be real, having a nice village in each biome connected via nether rail is wayyy cooler than having them in a single corridor. If you say that building all that takes too much effort then well... you might need to play a different game. At the end of the day I could die and loose all my enchanted gear but I won't loose all the cool builds I made, I find the excuse to go to different parts of the world and build stuff more interesting than placing a single block or spamming lecterns for an hour. Also adds for the possibility of other cool trades for villagers in different biomes, this is minecraft after all you gotta think about what mechanics can be built off of for future features. Even currently I can imagine them adding a secret dark oak villager that sells totems and the curse books. Maybe the Shepard could sell diferent banner paterns depending on biome perhaps the armorer could sell a unique amour trim.etc

@@childish4487 everyone does that anyways. And if you want to encourage exploration, just use logs instead for the blocks for the lectern.

​@@childish4487 if by making it more tedious and contrived sounds "cool" to you then sure. the problem is that the book options are chosen for balance reasons and not that it fits the biome. I admit that fire prot for desert and frost walker for snow biome makes sense, but can you explain logically why the swamp villager sells the mending books, or why taiga villagers sells the fortune books? the whole mechanic feels contrived and illogical

@@darren8608 so you have a problem with balancing?? It's a game, I wonder why they're doing game design. Of course it's arbitrary and contrived, the entire game is. Every piece of media is contrived lmao. Idk if you really want a reason roleplay/headcannon one. The idea that it's more tedious is silly considering the current "gameplay" is spamming a lectern or just getting good RNG, which is far more tedious and immersion breaking than exploring. Most people explore their worlds anyway, it's like a significant part of the game or something.

You are still on KZfaq.

This comment makes me feel like im reading a benevolent political ruler's diary from the 1800's

what

lets play "find the god complex" i think i won

Nice ideology, Friedrich Wilhelm

so you're a dictator

I like that mending is frkm swamp villagers, makes it feel a bit more earned when you finally get mending

Ah yes, having to spend half an hour attempting to get one enchanted book with the right enchantment is so fun! You know… the enchanting table could acutally be made much more useful… if they remove the 40xp limit.

Nerfing enchanted book trading won't really make the enchanting table better, it just makes both ways a chore This isn't a win-loose situation when both sides are terrible. At least, that's my merit on things

​@@FakeDogsThere is no a fun reward for wasting countless hours to cure, breed, level up, and transport a swamp villager especially when the nearest swamp biome is extremely far away from your main base, only masochists or ret*rded people like this change. Sure the old system is broken but at least is not boring, tedious, and frustrating like the new one.

@@azlanadil3646 Old method (breaking lecterns) takes super long time. I reached a point where i made a script to do it for me becuse it was taking so long to get it each time. now you just need a rail way i nether and 2 portals. travel might be 100-500 blocks in the nether. but that just asking you to either dupe rails or build iron farm so not much of a problem there.

Because they are completely irrelevant and this does not change that.

Some of those are OP and break the spirit of the game (MINEcraft). But shhhh!

​@@CPU9incarnateYou can obtain enchanted diamond tools from them.

@@ConcavePgons the enchants are usually bad. You can disenchant for cheap base diamond gear of ccourse, but it's not like diamonds are hard to come by. But if people stock piling loads of diamond gear is the concern, making armorsmiths, weaponsmiths, and tool smiths no longer offer diamond equipment would be a better solution than nerfing villager trading in general

@@CPU9incarnate I wonder if they nerfed the Librarian trades assuming that the enchanted books from them can be combined with the pre-enchaned tools and armor from the other villagers.

^^^^^^^^ you are so smart please go add this to the feedback page for this snapshot

Iron farm ? And I might have agreed if fortune didn’t work on iron ores but now I’m curious to know what you think makes the anvil expensive.

@@lygencore i meant with xp, not the iron used to make the block

Oh my bad. Yeah I agree about the enchanted book use penalty system being the worst implementation of a great game design idea.

I thought about that and was like... what if villagers climbed onto camels when they are sitting and get off the same way. It'd add a way to move villagers, and it would sorta be like the villager wants to go on a journey.

Yeah. They could be like boats on land. I've had this idea since before 1.19 but I haven't had a place to suggest it until now.@@WhatIsMyPorpoise

Or have them follow you if you hold out emeralds or an item they want to trade for. Like how a cow follows you when you're holding wheat. So you don't have to build massive railways and try to nudge them into a minecart for 5 minutes, or row a boat across land and scream every time you have to go up 1 block

That's so true@@Sercil00

But then again Minecraft is a childrens game and they don't want to promote slavery or brirbery. The camel would have been such a good fix to this problem.

*pulls out shotgun*

100% agree with ya, villagers are were way too OP

@@cringeproductions5817 *pulls out another shotgun.*

fitting name@@just-a-fnf-fan

@@just-a-fnf-fan ah yes, the average north American, with more guns than people

Regarding villager trading, the system was too broken. While needing more to balance it, this change was a step in the right direction.

@@Doythedino agreed. Although by making it so much more annoying to get trades there should be something to make it worth your while

@@F1nn1810 I mean, if you look at it from the perspective that it's just how things are, it kinda is worthwhile...

​@@F1nn1810Getting unlimited access to powerful enchants seems pretty worth the while

​​​@@Doythedinomore like a step in tbe wrong direction, there is no fun in wasting a lot of time just to get a mending book from the most rare villager type instead of utilizing that time on building structures I want and you know how dumb is anvil repairing, I am sorry but I feel this change is a braindead one.

yeah, this point is another sign that the anvil mechanics need a rework, I think the cost shouldn't increase with how many times it's been through the anvil but by what enchantment your putting on it, make mending cost a lot so it's more an investment.

How about using boots that aren't maxed?