I kind of believe him. Wrong place, wrong time. If I was breaking into cars and came across a dead body, I don't know if I would call the cops either. It seems that all the state has against him is that he was near Samantha's house when her motion sensor was triggered, and he had some of her blood on him/ his clothes. That can all be explained by Samantha crawling outside her house at around the time the motion sensor was triggered and him touching her body, as he described. I just don't think that's enough to convict somebody. The biggest piece of reasonable doubt for me is the fact that nothing was taken from her house. The state's theory is that this was a robbery gone wrong. But where's the robbery? Yeah, he was breaking into cars. But somebody who's willing to break into cars isn't necessarily willing to murder. He was trying to stay under the radar and not get caught. So why would he murder someone and not take anything from their house? Doesn't make any sense.

I’m stuck on people having their doors UNLOCKED in DETROIT! 😭

It was the ex. This guy is NOT the one.

Mental note: dont check on a person laying in the ground, may be deceased and blamed.

I don't see 12 people finding this guy guilty. I've served on a 12 person jury on a rape case and this guy was guilty as $hit so it was really easy finding him guilty. This ain't that!

Whats baffling to me is wouldn't Samantha's family and friends want real justice for her murder if it was my friend or family member, I would want real justice so that I could rest better knowing the real killer is serving time not just charging anyone with her murder just to satisfy the people thats not real justice the Ex Boyfriend is clearly guily you would have to be insane not to see the ex is guilty high or not medicated or not if that was the case pretty much the whole entire united states would be running to the police departments beliving they commmited murders this is a bunch of bull crap the ex boyfriend received immunity because he done it. He probably has no criminal record his parents knows he could never handle prison and more then likely he would take his own life in prison, his family has a little money and connections with the jewish community the ex is a sick man with a lot of mental issues clearly lets stop being so bias and judgemental of other nationalities and be honest human beings, the ex could not except her rejecting so he took her life. he should not be a Dr. Of any kind, his license should be revoked indefinite, unfortunately! now if this man is found guilty, he will serve 20/30 years in prison, then found not guilty after serving all that time for a crime he did not commit, and then becomes a millionare with our tax paying dollars for wrongful conviction. now tell me, is this real justice? we have seen this throughout history in the United States. Also, im not saying this black man is an angel he is not innocent he should not have been out breaking into cars or anything but he did not commit this murder, we dont no what we would have done if we came across someone lying on the ground in the middle of the night we may try to shake them, speak to them to see if they are okay we may even reach down and touch them it was a cold winter night, yes he should have called the police but because he was out commiting auto crimes that he should not have been doing but that doesn't make him guilty of killing this young lady we need real justice for samantha not charging a random person because they were out commititng dumb senseless crimes lets pray that Samantha receives real justice from the real murderer so her family and friends will be able to rest better at night 🙏

Not guilty, everybody say not guilty

HE IS INNOCENT. EXCESSIVE AMOUNT OF BLOOD WOULD HAVE BEEN VISIBLE ON THE JACKET AND ALSO ON HIS SHOES.

This guy is guilty of making poor decisions. Not guilty of murder. Who is guilty for the horrible crime? The ex-boyfriend or the guy that was stalking Woll. I heard his phone was turned off during the hours where the murder occurred.

I believe he is gonna go free because he’s truly innocent in my opinion.

He didn't murder Samantha Woll. She got stab in the face and neck, that's a crime of passion, she knew her killer. Wrong place, wrong time. I hope the jury makes the right decision.

Him running away from "security" is not a sign of someone who wants a confrontation. Why would a killer try breaking into cars, dodge security before deciding to kill a woman. Makes no sense. The state was lazy on this case.

I believe him! I think the ex bf did it.

I've changed my mind...NOT GUILTY.

I believe the only thing he guilty of his breaking into cars. I believe the police and prosecutor did a rush job. Why wasn't the boyfriend vette more? Again, they wanted arrested someone because of the climate of crimes against the Jewish community. If this crime of passion and he no relationship to this lady. Some of this is not making sense. I hope they have right person but I don't believe the do. My heart feels for the victim family. I wonder do they believe the state has the right person.

I believe him he didn't kill that woman the ex boyfriend said he did it then he changed his story y'all got the wrong guy on stand the ex boyfriend supposed to be on stand

Not guilty. Evidence is very flimsy. And he comes across as very credible in his testimony. He's not shifty eyed, hesitant, or stumbling on his testimony.

It's easy to admit a lesser crime (grand theft auto) when your being accused of murder

The way that woman was killed, he would have had blood all over that jacket when he appeared back at "home". None can be seen on the camera footage

If I were a juror..not guilty

I absolutely believe this guy is innocent of murder. The meticulousness in him explaining every move he made. Even down to him explaining how blood feels when it's dry in the skin.... Like paint chipping. He even seemed to reform once he got out of jail... At least somewhat... Is enough evidence to absolve ... Then you can hear his gut when he realizes she doesn't believe him.. They trying to convince him to plea. Probably told him he getting 25 years ...

I believe him, the ex boyfriend already admitted to killing her and they let him go smh!

I’m watching the trial I believe him wrong place wrong time and if he gets acquitted, he should he better get his life together and start fresh and no more crimes because he has a second chance!!!

I believe him I don’t think he did it. I hope the jury makes the right decision

I don’t think he did it either petty criminal yes murderer no.

Wow, man, listening to his jail call with his fiance was very sad. Damn, man this hurts. It was all the telltale signs of an innocent man reaching out for justice.

If you think the evidence is lacking, request a bench trial. If you think you can win on emotion, request a jury trial. Judges weigh evidence, juries weigh feelings.

A grown man stealing candy 😳 now on trial for murder. This whole thing is just so crazy.

Here before the not guilty verdict ™️

It makes me sick that they 'decide' who did it and pin it all on them instead of getting who actually did. They just want it over with.... my sisters killer is still out there because they did the same in her case.

He’s innocent but I think this was a sign from god to change his life. He did choose petty crimes thinking the most he’d face is Leas than 10. But now I hope he sees that no matter how much time you think you don’t mind sitting, life of crime no matter how petty can possible end in life in prison. Just stay say from crimes period

The prosecution seems to be playing dirty

58:25 THE CRAZIEST PART OF THIS STORY IS THAT HE WAS A MANAGER AT A JUICE SHOP. This man had a job and was still compulsively stealing from strangers.

Yes they are working against him he is guilty until proven innocent and its not supposed to be that way 😢😢

While talking to police, Herbstman "THE EX BOY FRIEND" added that he had a motive to kill Woll because she had broken up with him in July after about a year of dating. He last saw Woll on October 7, 2023. Woll was murdered on Oct. 21. "I had a motive and an opportunity," he told police in the bodycam footage. Throughout the interaction, he kept repeating that he didn't remember anything. Herbstman testified that he started having irrational thoughts that he may have stabbed Woll to death after learning about her murder from the news. "I had no recollection of killing Sam," he said in court. "I convinced myself that I had done this act, but I could recall nothing of it." While testifying, Herbstman said he believed the medication he was taking for depression made him delusional. The night of his alleged psychotic break, he had doubled his medication and used marijuana. THIS GUY IS NOT GUILTY OF MURDER. Ex PLAYING "CRAZY" NOW.

He dint kill samantha,I beleive during the coarse of that night while he was out stealing cars,he came upon her body,and he touched her to see if she was breathing,when she wasn't he went into panic mode,African american men go into panic mode in instinces like these,because he knew once he touched her,he was number one suspects!!!😢

He read that WHOLE room ‼️

So sad to see Fred Sandord facing life

Yet Another good reason not to steal cars or even scout around for cars to steal. You never know what you might get yourself into. Sad 😢 situation.

He is telling the truth

I believe the man

The unemployed habitual offender is an expert on everyone else's job🤭👌

This case is interesting. His innocence sounds so convincing. But I have heard many men tells lies and sound so convincing that they are not guilty...I hate to see him go through this because he will be forever marked even if he is found not guilty 😢

Thanks!

I don't know if I believe him but I dk the evidence is spotty

Yea I def believe him. Nobody who steels cars or in the middle of steeling cars stabs or kills anyone. Their whom thing is not to be seen at all by anyone so they can be in and out. The dude knew he was on camera in the area walking around checking cars already so it be dumb so go and then killl somebody.

He most definitely read that whole courtroom!!

I hope he's not a smooth criminal

Can someone tell me which video it's in saying where she was ? Like she had ghb so I doubt she was chilling alone

He should distance himself from the person who suggested that suit was a good choice!!!

Avoiding confrontation stealing somebody's car😂

Play stupid games, win stupid prizes

I believe this guy is innocent not guilty at all.

I don't believe he did it not guilty I say

her admitting to washing the jacket is the most damning thing. him sending pics of challengers is such a new angle and criminals are always upgrading their "skills." feel for the guy. all i can do is internalize what i can do positive for myself and be glad im not him. on the jury id probably acquit. he will do something else in the future so he will definitely get his 5 to 10 years of incarceration but not by me.

1:38:26 sounds like the typical jail house in every state, I found that no matter what you're arrested for, a humble attitude and telling the truth is the only way, no matter how wrong the situation might be. A friend of mine was accused of murder and they put him through it at the jail and he was finally exonerated.

I can appreciate his honesty tho..

When you dress for Court like it's a minstrel show what more need be said?

What is the iq of this lawyer? Is the just a homie or some sort of affirmative action situation?

I think he's innocent of the murder. It's the crime of stealing from hard working, fellow Detroiters that he should face justice for.

How many believe GF thinks he is just “going for walk, innocent walk” that time of night?

You know you're f'd when your lawyer wants to "aks" you some questions😬

Who is Dr. Washington? Why texting him that time of morning after what happened?

His attitude, demeanor, posture & vocal tone has been exactly same & even throughout the whole trial especially the questioning by the wicked, crooked prosecution... *HE BEEN FLYEST DRESSER IN THE WHOLE TRIAL* 💯🙌💥 *but the jury is takin' too long* 😮 for Man who is being *FRAMED*

Absolutely not!

He had a knife on him when arrested? No reason to have knife when committing crime, breaking into cars, but had knife in him that day.

One tip Finger prints Goes through rubber gloves

His clothes would’ve been covered in blood. But my thing was her body seen on the cameras at all? Or seen alive right before. I’m late starting the trial so idk if there was video shown of her alive walking on camera. I wanna see all the video from right before he walks up to here when she is alive. I’m gonna have to start from the beginning lol

I knew he was guilty when he said he carries a seatbelt cutter bc he speeds a lot😂

I wonder if he ever considered getting a job.

This guy had a job, but yet, HE CHOSE to keep stealing. Seems to me he never learned his lesson. Well it looks like the law is about to teach him a lesson now

Innocent!!

*not, not guilty* *INNOCENT*

Wow!!!!

The thing that gets me is though, is that if you were seen crossing the road to avoid this guy approaching you, you could get into even more trouble nowadays for being racist and yer life destroyed anyway.

That sick ex

“I was breaking in cars…I mean not breaking in cars, but going into motor vehicles” 😄 Sir, that doesn’t change it or make it better. You could’ve been at home looking for a job.

This defense lawyer was the same lawyer used in the Zion case he was SSA af I hope he do better this time

He should have remained silent after hearing his testimony & his answers being so vague &’nothing like what he had told the police. He also made his gf look like part of the stolen car thief ring. She didn’t seem genuine on the stand & this man only made it appear that she right along with his stealing the cars & others property.

Someone says they have evidence of me connected to a crime and that makes me not want to tell the truth. Bro wtf?! That makes absolutely no sense. He might get off because of LSP.

Why would he approach a dark figure? There were no cars parked on street in front of condos only in parking lot. But, he’s story could be true so that’s reasonable doubt.

She choose to date a car thief says alot about tiera

He innocent, no one can commit the perfect crime in minutes, the video shows all his moves no way he killed her, he is freaking out, just looking around that no one sees him stealing from the cars, and placing items in different areas just in case some one sees him, how in the world you go from a dumb theif to a killer, who stole absolutely nothing from the victim.. he is innocent.. no way..

I initially thought the prosecutor just didn't prove their case but I think this dude is innocent. He appears to be a thief that got caught up. Let this be a lesson to all the petty thieves out there.; you could be implicated in something way more serious than what you were doing. Besides, her boyfriend admitted he did it.

And for the record, people in jail/prison get better medicine than those on the outside. And I see he already has lawsuit money in mind. Ready to drain the taxpayers.

Other nationalities? All from same nation. And are you referring to bias against Jews or blacks?

Well, one thing is weird.....he keeps calling his girl a bro. Maybe It's just me, but that's weird.

Putting on the surgical gloves was a big mistake - normal car thieves don't car about fingerprints

Being a manager at a job and braking in cars at ugly hours of the night don’t sit right with me he seems to me to be a person of strange mental work . Sense he wanted to avoid people and it was his 4th habitual maybe he panic and stabbed her by her car I’ll keep watching but being a manager and out at 3-4 am braking in cars is psychotic to me far fitch over the top and wired

Quit dating these losers.

😅 LOL who will have a boyfriend a thief😅

Not guilty

Not guilty.

Love from the 305❤

Still a predator.

guilty af! typical. will admit to lesser crime in order to get out of a murder! this is a career criminal but had to kill someone. hope he fries. "speak really low in court" listen to the jail calls. you see his true colors!

Guilty as f

He’s lying , come on people,, you don’t just happen upon a dead body and leave if you’re a decent person, a lot of thieves do stuff big would still report a dead woman.. he’s a liar.

His motive , habitual offender status.

He cute