This may not be the most "forgotten" game, but I think the players on both teams are fun to look back on, and this one was definitely a classic!

as an indians fan this year was so hard to get over. we were the #1 team in the AL just for us to lose to a wild card team

I’m a Yankees fan and I don’t know how we cameback after this game. Being down 2-0 and blowing a 8-3 lead in Game 2.

LINDOR WITH A SWING AND A DRIVE🔥🔥🔥

Yan Gomes legend. As a Brazilian, I'm proud of him for having achieved a solid career in the MLB

Both defensively and offensively, yan Gomes was the player of the game

I remember being on my way to watch the Dodgers and Diamondbacks NLDS and was watching this on my phone. I went ballistic after that Lindor homer!

Gomes representing Brazil and making us proud. Glad he got the ring in 19, the second Brazilian ever, but he was an actual important player, the other one was just on the bench. Yan also caught the last ball

This was the last time in the 2017 postseason that the Yankees lost to a team that wasn’t caught cheating

Even though this may not be a forgotten classic, This is a great classic game. I was hoping the Indians would win it all that year.

3:57 6 year olds when mom doesn’t get the dino nuggets

still can't figure out how that 2016/2017 indians roster didn't win it all

I can only imagine how mad Gary Sanchez is at 7:45. A missed opportunity to review a call he was right on turns into a huge momentum shift.

I thought we were cooked after this. I still can’t believe that we came back after that, The guys rallying behind Girardi was one of my favorite moments in all my years following the Yanks

As a Yankees fan, we won this series, so I can look back at this with happiness.

Game 4 of 2003 World Series is a good one for this series. Gonzalez walk off in extras and I think Miggy took Clemens deep that game as well

I wish I was more into baseball and the playoffs back in the early 2010’s. I would’ve been going ballistic for games like this.

this was my favorite mlb game all the way up until the Rays 7-1 comeback in boston this past labor day

This series was something else

Yet we still managed to comeback and win the series

This game is one could be forgotten about it

Might be a stretch, but 2013 NLDS Game 2 ATL vs. LAD was a pretty good game!

Man CC was such a gutsy pitcher. Loved his fire.

Still trying to figure out why Urshela was in that lineup. Also Kipnis in CF? How many weaker bats is the manager trying to put in that lineup?

At least we cameback and won the series

legend

The night to forget

7:48, I wish we can get this kind of enthusiasm in MLB: The Show.

All that just for Cleveland to blow a 2-0 ALDS lead again 😂

I still cannot believe we won this series after blowing this game

The last Indians playoff win

EXE i’m a HUGE cubs fan can the next game you do be 2016 NLDS game 1?

The Yankees not choosing to challenge the knob ricochet was a mistake to bring up Lindor.

It'd be nice if more of these classics weren't post season games. Cleveland coming back to extend the second longest winning streak, maybe the As game from moneyball, a nohitter, the Angels losing while pitching a sort of no hitter. Something completely separate from the post season can still be classic.

I was at this game 🔥🔥🔥

Can't say Cleveland doesn't like baseball, listen to that crowd, holy shit

3:57 you won’t be let down

I wanted Cleveland to win this series so bad man.

Almost forgot Kipnis played CF for a bit😂

LETS GO 1 WIN FROM THE ALCS😈😈

You should do the story of the 2021 red sox

I WAS AT GAME 3 OF THIS SERIES

Game 2 Alds royals vs Astros 2015 or game 2 alds tor vs Tex 2015

The best team ever to not win it all.

As a Cleveland fan idk how they didn’t win a title in 16 and 17. Complete meltdowns both years. Wasted a 22 game streak and a 3-1 lead.

7:57 S A N T A M A R I A

Post game 5

And then the Yankees got the reverse 3-0

When Lindor was good :(

Seriously though why do you think every classic is forgotten?

Not reviewing that play definitely factored into girardi’s departure

Somehow the Yankees still won this series being down 2-0

Cleveland guardians are better now I'm shocked

You need too make the 2017 ALDS game 2 Yankees vs Astros

does anyone fall asleep to these videos??

too bad this game meant absolutely nothing

I miss this Yankees team, so dangerous and resilient. Too bad we didn’t win it all because we got cheated out. We slapped the smile off of the Indians fans when we won the series.

Yet another example and reason why people don’t like baseball. Look I hate the Yankees but that’s not a HBP. It hit the bat and was caught. Strike 3 you’re out. The Yankees shouldn’t have to challenge, they got it wrong, that should be an AUTOMATIC review and umpires and EVERYONE should want to get ALL of the calls CORRECT. Insanity. Baseball is the hardest sport to watch and it’s not actually because it’s long or boring, it’s because u can succeed and the ump just gets to say nope. INSANITY

Stankees cheated and still couldn’t win a WS🤣

Joe Giradi was a terrible manager. He had the most talented roster year after year and couldn’t win but one championship