Squeaky Reed. I know Tom Selleck is an excellent actor and plays great cowboy roles such as Quigley Down Under. To me Monte Walsh was meant for Lee Marvin. Never should’ve remain this film. The clip was enjoyable to watch but the original will be my favorite.

dwsan1tx I love em both as well, just sumthin about this scene tho, epitomizes a REAL cowboy....and those are getn harder and harder to find!

squeaky Reed I did enjoy it and thanks. I'm an old cowboy myself. Worked cattle on divide creek out of Silt Colo. Worked for a man named Leonard Christianson, salt of the earth, and his wife Wilma cooked a hell of a ranch house lunch every day. I was foreman of the ranch and lived in a house across from the barns where we moved the cows who were ready to calve. At about midnight last of march in co. temp 15 below, Raymond our latest hire a kid out of New York wanting to get back to nature, came and woke me....a cow was in distress. I went over and pulled that calf (reached inside and grabbed the hooves and put my feet on her ass and pulled the calf out before it and she died). She then proceeded to prolapse. So I pushed her back together and yelled at Raymond (who was throwing up) to go get the Big needle and shoelaces we kept in the barn. I then proceeded to sow that cow together while being shoulder deep holding her internal parts. So long story short I, as a bartender I once told a couple of would be cowboys...…"if you've never laid shoulder deep in below zero temps. in the blood and afterbirth of calving, and sowing a cow up with one hand while your holding her prolapsed insides in with the other"......Maybe your just a guy who can ride a horse! lol

jim bishop Been there brother, even before I was considered a legal adult. I love everything about the cowboy life, even being shoulder deep in a prolapsed momma cow. I appreciate your kind words and the story, ain't many of us left!

Thanks man. Reminds me of a funny story. I was just turned 18 and we were feeding cows, and we knew we had an about year month old calf with scours. Well I spotted him and went to grab him by top of the back leg and throw him, I missed and all I got was tail. Off we went him dragging me through the mud and cow shit, with Ronny Hayes and old Leonard running behind yelling "hang on Geno". Well they finally caught up and we gave him some azimiacin. From then on I was considered a "hand"!!

You got to like Tom thou. What the movie. Makers doesn't know always comes thru the TV. Guns, horses, cows and rope, its funny . They did pretty good on LONESOME DOVE

#Scoot I'm not saying Monty Walsh (both versions) are Must See movies....no That is what I'm saying.

First thing I thought: too clean. He should be totally dusty.

I wonder where he finds a dry cleaner out on the range?

That's Hollywood, out of touch with reality.

I use that line every week lol

I definitely agree, thanks for watching

I agree, it takes a person with real cowboy experience to truly play a cowboy onscreen.

I should have, too late baby. Can still handle a little amusement on a cold morning but not like this scene.

ONLY A HANDFUL IS A LOW ESTIMATE. EASTWOOD WAYNE BEN JOHNSON TOMMY LEE DUVALL Jack Elam Lee van Cleef Gary Cooper Henry Fonda Glen Ford Walter Brennan Strother Martin Lee Marvin Jack parlance. Just to name a few

@@letsgobrandon6281 Even Brando in One Eyed Jacks and Kevin Costner in Open Range with Duvall...👍

@@njgl2010 Russell Crowe can. He does all his own stunt riding

Coincidentally, he never had more children after this wild ride...

Said I never had much use for one. Never said I didn't know how to use it.

Hombre - one of the best westerns. The final gunfight is THE best gunfight in a western - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/j7CEqbCe2tKso4E.html

I do like Quigley and I particularly like the introduction where he's proving his skills.

Thank God Baldwin wasn't on the scene.

@@billweg1463 bahahahaha

AMEN! That's what it's all about! I tell ppl all the time that I personally feel like I was born 200 yrs too late. I honestly feel that way.....so did ole Monty. That's why I love this movie!

You aint kidding. Grew up on Marty Robbins and he could paint a picture in your mind. Music, like westerns, is dead. Not much good of either coming out these days!

Strawberry Roan = one of the first songs my husband sang to me !

@@carolmartin2503 out in the horse around standing alone, was an old Caballo the strawberry roan. Spivin bowlegs and long pigeon toes, pair of pig eyes and a long Roman nose. Little pin ears that were split at the tip, a big 44 brand was on his left hip.

I'm thinking "A white sports coat......." might be appropriate here.

Marty Robbins is still one of my favorite singers of all time. I might be a young’en, but I grew up listening to him on both the vinyl and 8 deck tapes. I’ve ridden my fair share of horses from dressage horses on the east coast, with Navajos chasing cattle in New Mexico, ranch horses in Montana, and several in between and enjoyed every ride and every experience: but nothing could truly compare to the life Mr. Robbins depicted in his songs. I salute Mr. Robbins, the days gone by, and all the honorable horseman of today!

Here here, same to ya!

Same Here

I concur. Thanks for sharing

The no saddle blanket is how they started them back in the day and even today with broncy horses or even in saddle bronc or ranch bronc, the starting with a halter is right cus they started them with a bosal or halter i use both depends if they let me mess with their head, and a buck strap is used from time to time with horses even in rodeo they use them, some guys still do for the first fight so if the horse flips out and goes over you ain't in the hot seat

This was as usual another great tom seleck moment but Lee Marvin owns this part and this same scene is all lee Marvin.

Not that great to me.

Sure did. I love riding an honest bucker. Edit. I should say that I USED TO love riding an honest bucker, too old for that now. My brain still says I can, but my bones know better!

Never read the book but I think will now. Thanks.

I read the book 50 years back. One of my all time favorites. I like the actors from both movies, neither movie does the book justice but what’s new. :)

Thanks. Glad u enjoyed it

it was in the earlier version. (1970) Still one of the saddest movies ever made.

@michael boultinghouse Isn't it strange how stranger will tell you how you feel about things. I never said it was the saddest, "Brian's Song" or "Old Yeller" come to mind, and as you mentioned, there are others but nostalgia is not the same as sadness and this movie is sad. Suggest you watch "Ballad of Cable Hough".

@michael boultinghouse My my my what an erudite comment. I did say sadness about a single scene and the way the movie made me feel. I'm sorry that all you seem to be able to feel is a longing for a dirty, brutal period in our history. The overall plot for both versions is indeed nostalgic but it is not a happy movie. I suppose that you think that "Ballad of Cable Hogue" is only nostalgia.

@michael boultinghouse This was about a simple comment on a movie until you decided that, because I don't completely agree with your point of view, you attacked my character. Voted for the orange slug did you? Who the fuck are you to tell me I don't deserve to live here? My DD-214 carries a citation for a CIB with a ranger company, I might not survive the future but your sorry ass won't have anything to say about it.

kidstuff4455 you wasn't supposed to see that.

And now he's helping Banks steal old people's homes ) :

You need to watch this version if you never have. Both are great movies, Lee Marvin is LEGEND....but Selleck does a great job as well!

I've watched both,lee Marvin is 100% better is this that Tom is.i do love Tom in western but lee Marvin was better suited to play this ruff and tuff guy and not tom!!!!!

Ain't much genuine and wholesome left in this ole world! Thanks for watching and commenting.

And government

Amen brother, those kind of men are hard to find anymore.

@@njgl2010 :- There just ain't room for them kind of men anymore in this old world.

No sir, never quit.

Had one that every time he would go for the gate, open or closed ,didn't matter

Crossfire Trail

@@mikevaluska7313 thank you

The ending to "The Professionals" was even better! The line delivered by the late Lee Marvin is one of my all-time favorites. When called "You Bastard" by the wealthy villain, he replies "In my case, an accident of bi8th. But you, sir...you are a self-made man!" Same era, I like Peckinpah, but prefer ""The Professional" by an eyelash.

Yeah. The old way, is the old way for a reason. Got 2 broke myself. No way I'd ever try that s%$@. I enjoy all my body parts working.

@@jacobcastro1885 age made me do it different, not the "way". I dont bounce like I used to, damb sure dont move as good the next morning either.

Lana that’s how my sister did it. She was a horse whisperer., if there ever was one.

@Tim Mentzer I'm now of the opinion: if you want something done right you do it yourself. I get arab yearlings, untouched (uncorrupted). Apply some Clinton Anderson methods, and in a few years you can bring em in your house... well not quite. Lol

This country is so fucked up because we ain't got anymore cowboys to look up to and ride with and learn from

Dan Dickerson I agree got me to after I watched it I was how in the hell was that the best scene ever

Tommy Lee Jones tearing a Union Captain to shreds with a branding iron in Lonesome Dove comes to mind. Eastwood being Clint in Pale Rider or Unforgiven also. Bob Duvall with arrows in his leg fending off the Native American warriors is another. Bet I could give a hundred more examples. Selleck is good but he learned from the Masters.

Sam elliot

Lol hes last in line.

And you Know That HOW ??

Made me chuckle out loud thanks

That's fine, but this version is way better.

@@porflepopnecker4376 Nah, this one feels like a Hallmark movie. The Lee Marvin version is off the chain.

Pure fantasy But it looks good if you don't know anything about horses

Everything was new back then. Give it time it will get old.

@@terryderush7066 Same thing happened to me...lol

NattyBumppo48 LOL ! Me too

They had new saddles and ropes back then too ya know.I am a saddle and tree maker I can say that the saddle is a Modified Association which did not exist in this era.

Hahahaha, agree!

LOVE IT!

Which one?

I thought so as well. Just a dang good movie!

He's punchy for sure!