When Tyrell was in hiding and the most wanted person on earth. How could he be running around as elliot???

Here are two of the many concrete reasons why this is impossible: 1. Ep 108 - Gideon goes to see Tyrell at E Corp, then immediately travels to the AllSafe offices, sees Elliot, and doesn't recognize them as the same person. 2. Ep 110 - Tyrell's assistant at E Corp meets Elliot and does not recognize him. If this is supposed to be true, this show is a lot more poorly made than I gave it credit for. As for the evidence in this video, Joanna starts the mysterious scene by saying to the Mastermind, "Can I help you?" which is an odd thing for a wife to say to the alter in her husband's body without hearing him speak, even if he is wearing a hoodie. Tyrell is indeed in the inner world hallucinations the Mastermind is having, but so are Angela and Qwerty, and we're not saying they're alters. The deleted scene can be explained by the fact he's making a joke about Elliot's DID, but it also might have been deleted to avoid this confusion not just keep it a mystery. What this video is saying is that the original Elliot left New Jersey, moved to Sweden, learned Swedish to the level of a native, married a wealthy heiress, moved back to New York, and rose up the executive ranks at E Corp to become high enough to be interim CTO. At the same time, the mastermind is getting a job at AllSafe, feeding a fish in Chinatown, doing a lot of morphine, and somehow never being recognized by people who knew both Wellick and Alderson.

I just finished the show, and immediately have to rewatch it now.

When Philip went to Tyrell's house to offer him the job of CTO, Tyrell was beating mr Robot. Then Phillip talked to mr Robot (as Elliot) and Tyrell at the same time. How's that?

But this whole point was disproven by the Season 2 finale. Sam Esmail knew people were suspecting Tyrell and Elliot were one person, but when Tyrell really shot Elliot and later talks to Irving and Angela as Elliot bleeds out on the floor, they could not be the same person

I respect the effort, but this theory is completely outside the boundaries of possibilities and makes no sense. I'm actually upset at the fact that other people believe this theory, as I feel believing it takes away a lot from how well crafted this show truly is.

This is the only show when I watched the finale I cried and then immediately decided to rewatch the entire series from the beginning. That’s why this show will always be a masterpiece to me. Also no Tyrell is not Elliott, I don’t agree with this theory at all.

How could Elliot work at Alsafe by the time Wellick was at Ecorp??

This is completely insane. They are referenced as two different people by too many others for it to ever be possible that it makes any sense. For example, the FBI has both of their pictures on the wall, and it’s not like they could have been blanks that are filled in for us. They know who Tyrell is and know who Elliot is.

by far THE most rewatchable show ever. not just the type where u get a realization at the end of the series but in a way where u WANT to rewatch season after season

Interesting theory, but as many have pointed out, there are too many things that contradict it to make this theory viable. 1. When Tyrell is first introduced, he is talking with E Corp execs. Other coworkers would have noticed if he was talking to himself. You managed to write off one scene with the other executives at the round table as a delusion - which is a stretch within itself - but you would also have to do that with *every* other interaction between Tyrell and Elliot that is front of a third-party. There are too many to be able to feasibly disclaim. 2. On that note, there are so many instances where Tyrell and Elliot interact in front of a third-party. The two of them arguing while in a cab. The Dark Army soldier shooting in both directions from the crashed van. We would have to suspend disbelief that those onlookers would just ignore the distinction every time. 3. Elliot would not have been able to hold two full-time jobs, one as an exec at E Corp and the other as a security engineer at Allsafe (all while routinely on morphine, no less). Moreover, it would be impossible for Elliot to have made any progress on the fsociety mischief if he were in prison. 4. Gideon Goddard meets with Tyrell at his E Corp office. If he were one and the same as Elliot, he would have commented. 5. Moreover, for an entire season, Tyrell Wellick was the most wanted man in the world. And yet, at the same time, Elliot walked in the city openly, interacting with many people. Fernando Vera, Krista, Ray Henworth, and so many other characters didn't notice that they were talking to Tyrell????? 5. When Joanna's fixer, Mr. Sutherland, goes with Elliot to his apartment to help him "find Tyrell", he doesn't at all question that Tyrell is right there. Also, when at his apartment, he talks to Elliot about "the Wellicks" as his favorite clientele. 6. Tyrell mentions that the only English his dad knew was the Red Wheelbarrow poem. Obviously, Mr. Robot knew more than that. There is also no evidence that Mr. Robot was ever an immigrant. 7. On that note, where did Elliot grow up? Suburban New Jersey, or Sweden? If it's Sweden, why doesn't Darlene know a different language? Did Angela grow up in Sweden too, and if so, does she know Swedish? Why doesn't Joanna ever talk to Angela or Darlene, or vice-versa??? 8.. Detective Pierro shows Darlene the FBI board filled with photos and lines. Tyrell Wellick and Elliot Alderson are two separate photos on the board. Because Elliot is not part of that scene, there is no reason to suggest that this was a delusion. 9. It would be difficult to explain the phone conversations had between Elliot and Tyrell. Did Elliot have two phones on his person at all times...and he never noticed? 10. The Blue Screen of Death theory in the 404 episode would have made the story stop at Tyrell's death...and yet, he continues to interact with Darlene, Whiterose, and many others after that episode. Explaining this point away with a "time travel" theory goes beyond suspension of disbelief and jumps the shark. 11. If Elliot shot himself to prevent himself from stopping Stage 2, then who called 911 to save him? To be clear: Elliot was, in fact, shocked, since afterwards a surgical team is there working on a body, overseen by Irving who saw the blood on the floor. And if Irving knew that Elliot/Tyrell had DID, he would've stayed there or had a dark army soldier supervise him, instead of handing an unstable guy a gun for protection. 12. Giving credence to a deleted scene is backwards logic. It was deleted *because* it does not fit into the canonical story. Also, it appeared that all three actors laughed at the line, suggesting that it was not a real line and instead a joke between the actors and outside the story itself. Valiant attempt at stirring up controversy, but in the end, I have to conclude that this theory is utter trash. Sorry for the reality check.

Maybe the real Elliot is “You.” It’s the only person of acknowledgement we never physically see and unlike Elliot, who has gaps in his knowledge every time Mr. Robot takes over, we’re entirely omniscient to every alter he has.

So many scenes contradict this theory but you chose not to address them because it would obviously ruin it! Nice try!

4:25 - Holy shit, she spoke Danish because the alter could also speak Danish. So by speaking Danish and recognizing that Elliot didn't understand her, it was a further confirmation of the alter. Mind Blown.

Most of these points are lousy with confirmation bias.

I just watched the last episode and when Elliot hands over his license she says "this looks nothing like you?'' meaning she could have been looking at a pic of Tyrell

this theory doesn’t completely work because of how we see Tyrell interact with others outside of Elliots perception. (How dark army deals with Tyrell when Elliot is in prison, how we see Whiterose talk about Elliot being in jail (at the same time as Tyrell is in Uosate NY post 5/9). this means either that bit in upstate NY didn’t happen or Elliot was never in jail(which seems more unlikely than the former). Also how was Tyrell CTO in S4 while Elliot wasn’t?

While I reaaaaally like how this could come together, Tyrell has blue eyes and the eye being depicted as "waking up" is certainly Elliot's

Also, the scene where police woman (Dom) looks at Elliot's ID and tells him that he looks nothing like him (Although it was inside the dream/thought, yet and still this shows that the Mastermind is subconsciously aware that his appearance was different than the original host).

Then what about the scene at the gas station, when Tyrell and Elliot want to pay for gas, and the lady behind the counter recognizes Tyrell and asks for a picture, but refers to Elliot as being “rude”? This is an awesome theory, but it really has a load of flaws...

THIS THEORY IS SO WRONG

So how does Romero arguing with Elliot when he mentions working with Tyrell make any sense?

There is a huge problem with this theory. In season 1, Gideon speaks directly to Tyrell

WATCH ANOTHER ONE OF OUR AMAZING VIDEOS HERE!! - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/b9GKitmT1q2rj2w.html Let us know what you think of it in the comments

There's definitely something about the relationship between Tyrell and Elliot that has yet to be uncovered. There does seem to be a lot more evidence that disproves this theory, but I do suspect there is a hidden meaning behind all these weird coincidences between them that fans have yet to figure out fully.

Wait, I thought I was Elliot.

this video is a prime example of why removing the count of dislikes is a disservice to users.

But how is he working at both allsafe and ecorp at the same time

the theory for tyrell being one of elliott’s alters is a big big big stretch. there are so many scenes throughout the series that would make no sense if that was true, plus Joanna definitely would not kill her husband just because one of his alters became more predominant lmao

Few things that have me doubting this theory. The speed camera picture is a picture of Elliott and Darlene. Also on the FBIs board of suspect's, there's pictures of both Elliott and Tyrell

Jeus Christ, that is the worst theory every. They only make Tyrel history similar so they have both some connections, but it doesnt mean Eliot is Tyrel. Deleted scenes proves he said that for a joke only and it has to be deleted not because to hide mystery but to keep the story go, that mr.robot (father) doesnt exist there, there was only eliot and tyrel. End of Story. Tyrel was not ELIOT .

There's a lot of holes here but one thing that makes me think this might be right is when Elliott has killed himself in the loop reality, and the red-headed FBI cop lady sees his ID she looks at him and says you don't look anything like Elliot alderson. Could that be because Elliot alderson looks like who we know is Tyrell wellick and he's well known?

This show is brilliant a modern masterpiece

I do like the idea of this theory. However when Tyrell was forced to live in the house in the woods with the Dark Army, Elliot was in JAIL at the same time and It's hardly to believe that this was all in his head... We need an explanation from the Director :D

They made the plot more complicated than needed. I liked the overall fight against evil corporations and greed. That felt more at home.

I'm all for any theory that explains the blue light in the woods. However unfortunately as many others have stated there are multiple scenes that are problematic for this theory.

Mr Robot(Christian Slater) and Mastermind(Rami Malek) are the only alternate personalities. Notice how no character mentions the name “Mr.Robot” except the host, mastermind, his therapist, and Vera when he forces it out of Krista. The only character who mentions the name “Mastermind” is Mr Robot(manifested in the form of Krista) and Angela in Eliot’s subconscious because she’s the only one aside from Darlene(still many questions for Esmail about her character) who can tell when Elliot switches between alts. Tyrell Wellick is a household name in the show and many aspects of this would make absolutely no sense. I will admit their are a few scenes seem to suggest Tyrell and Elliot are the same person like the taxi scene at the end of 2x11 but I believe that was just meant to hype up the Tyrelliot theorists before the rug gets pulled out from underneath them in the next episode where Tyrell shoots Elliot, putting the theory to rest. Esmail does have some explaining to do about that blue light though. And Darlene. I find the theory that Sam Esmail himself is the host more believable than this and I’m pretty sure that one has been debunked too because of the eye color in the final scene. Still, the scene with Sam injecting Elliot with Fentanyl and causing him to overdose and have to be resuscitated by Price in 4x1? While the guy in the lobby is eating fruity pebbles, you can clearly see on the security camera there’s only 2 men in black trenchcoats restraining Elliot and in the elevator. Neither of them are Esmail. Then once they’re back in “John Garcin’s” apartment, Sam Esmail magically appears in a black trenchcoat alongside the other 2 men, with a fatal dose of opiates, which we know is an addiction host Elliot struggled with. Those sketches of Fsociety on Flliots computer in episode 4x12 and the interaction with Dom in 4x13 are very sus too.

This show blows my mind Highly recommanded 💯

God man "Where is my mind" no vocals x piano hits hard to anything with a soul. Put that with anything meaningful and itll hit home a lil harder everytime.

Here I am, 5 seconds after finishing the last ep. I NEED TO BE EXPLAINED.

This theory, while interesting, surely collapses entirely when you see that the FBI investigation board has Elliot and Tyrell as separate individuals.

Actually during the show I always suspected Tyrell to also be a persona. I watched the Finale today and it is not conclusive if the real Elliot was in fact Tyrell but you bring really convincing arguments and brought for really interesting clues....great hypothesis!

Eliott sees his own reflection in the mirror when he breaks it. He sees it again when he puts up the new mirror. Tyrell looks nothing like Eliott's mother and father. Elliot has the skin tone and height, whereas Tyrell is big, blonde, and Scandinavian. That said, Tyrell could be how Elliott wants to see his host because deep down he believes he (and his physical appearance) is not worthy of being loved. Both of them hate their selves, that is definitely a common trait for both.

Most emotional episode that touched me: Elliott and Trenton's brother. Heaviest episode that just leaves me empty inside: Vera+Krista and finding the truth about his father.

The point of Tyrell is: Elliot and Tyrell are in some sense the same. They were connected through their experiences on a deep level. For this reason the lines between their identities are kept intentionally unclear. It doesn‘t matter. They both share pain and love. That‘s what matters.

Last episode almost makes me cry. The truth, the visuals, the music… the whole thing was the most beautiful thing I ever saw in a tv show. Definitely this show was a masterpiece.

There are too many holes that can be poked in this argument. They leave out convenient details

If the final evidence for being an alter is that you have to be an alter to talk directly to more than one alter at a time, Angela would have to be an alter too, and so would Price, and that makes zero sense. There's a scene where Mr. Robot loses control in front of both Angela and Tyrell and MM takes over. Angela has to knock out Elliot's body, and Tyrell instantly loses faith in Elliot after that. When Price comes to Tyrell's house and offers him CTO, he speaks directly to Mr. Robot, who he refers to as "Mr. Alderson." Irving would have to be an alter, White Rose would have to be an alter considering that in all her plans she treats Elliot and Tyrell as two different people. The FBI would have to all be alters, they have pictures of both of them, and Darlene is shown them, and she's asking about Tyrell in the restaurant because she's WORKING FOR THE FBI. If Tyrell is an alter because he can talk directly to alters in a deleted scene that means any character who was ever in a room with both Tyrell and Elliot also has to be an alter. Why the hell would Tyrell's wife be so distraught, and believe the fake phone calls gambit so hard, and then track down Elliot and make him trace the call when she knows he's just Tyrell? Why would she still need proof he's alive so bad? Tyrell being an alter breaks the whole show.

Its amazing how not one person understood the true ending of Mr robot and how white roses machine actually worked! They go on rants about the show being more about mental illness then the machine but missed the whole point. Just before the machine goes off white rose gives Elliot the choice to choose what happens. He then finds a book with ressurection and exit clues attached that lead him to a computer game. The computer game is his choosing of how the machine will work and recreate the parallel world. Remember he plays the game twice which is very important. The first time he plays he leaves his weak friend (Darlene) behind in the dungeon and eacapes to a beach (ocean of time) and a boat takes him to a new world. The 2nd time he chooses to stay in the dungeon with his friend. So there ends up being two elliots. One that escapes to the new world and leaves behind his best friend (as he calls her in his own words when describing her to the other elliot when talking about fantasizing about the hacker Elliott and his hacker friend Darlene). The other elliot experiences digital glitches (showing the machine is working behind the scenes) and experiences a different reality (the one he chose where he would stay in the dungeon or old reality with his friend darlene) therefor he undergoes a different perception of what's happening. He experiences glitches that reveal the machine is working in the background altering his perception. So that he (the 2nd elliot from the 2nd game played) is told he's in a created loop in which he's made for the real elliot while actually being in a comma from the explosion which then allows the 2nd elliots perception to remain in the dungeon (old world) with his friend Darlene as she sits beside him on the hospital bed. He couldve had the new parallel perfect life (which was real for the other elliot due to the 1st game played) but chose to stay in the dungeon of the old world (which was also real for him at the same time due to the way the computer programmed his perception of what was happening) where he then developed an identity crisis because of the split realities trying to both make since at the same time from him deciding to play twice which programmed the machine to create two elliots and two different events that would both happen simultaneously. And the only way for the machine to make since of this to the 2nd elliot was to create a way for him to believe he's in a comma and that hes having an identity crises.. The key to the final show is the computer game he played that programmed the machine which created the reality that came afterwards. I cant believe no one got this. It's really deep and mindblowing. All that work to create such a deep ending for not one person to get! Not one person understood the ending.

Unfortunately this astonishing theory can easily be shattered by a very small detail: a picture of Elliot on the FBI wall.

Intriguing but can’t actually work, if you watch the show carefully there are many reasons why this theory can’t work: Gideon calls who we think is Elliot by “Elliot” and not “Tyrell”, yet he didn’t know Elliot before so this doesn’t aligns with the “changing identity after trauma theory” FBI has both Tyrell’s and Elliot’s pictures on the wall as different pictures. FBI uses a phone call between Elliot and Tyrell as a proof to Darlene that her brother is not telling her the entire truth. The cashier at the gas station says “GuyS” to Mr robot Elliot and Tyrell. Since we already know Mr Robot isn’t actually there she must be talking to Tyrell and Elliot as two different individuals The scene where Price shows up at Tyrell’s house and speak with both Elliot and Tyrell, he says “Mr Alderson you should join us” Season 1 : fsociety meet and Elliot mentions Tyrell, Romero asks him in disbelief “Tyrell? Like Tyrell Wellik? Since when you and E corp CTO have become friends?” Also, there’s a “theory” that we see Elliot always dressing up the same because he’s actually an alter so he doesn’t change (as Mr robot for example) but this isn’t true! We see him changing clothes and Darlene actually points it out! My personal thought is that we see Elliot’s real appearance the whole time but with a different “personality” and this could be explained also by the fact that when Mr Robot takes over the other characters continue to see Elliot’s appearance. And for Dom telling the Mastermind he doesn’t look like Elliot can’t be taken as proof to say that the real Elliot doesn’t have that physical appearance because , if so, everybody else in the “fake world” shouldn’t recognize him as Elliot

Wait. Wait wait wait. So Tyreliott did all this because he loved his son so much and wanted to protects him, then did absolutely nothing when his wife got killed and son taken away? Darlene, which should be his aunt, didn't mind at all? No other mention of the baby or any attempt to raise him? This is a very weird outcome for the original goal.

This theory is pretty bad, the editing was pretty well done though. I gotta give you credit though, its rare to find an interesting theory that would actually cheapen the show if it was true.

This theory is ridiculous. Tyrell feels him and Elliot share a connection because of the trauma they both experienced at the hands of their fathers, hence the scene at the farmhouse where Tyrell is being interrogated.

I usually hate unanswered shit from a movie or show, but if it's done to this extreme I am a sucker for it.. I'm pretty glad I got into Mr. Robot so late, cuz I would've been around 14 when it came out and gave up immediately lmao.

3:52 this is a fair and interesting point however, the way I took it when Elliot says that he feels like she sees through him, is that a while before we see Tyrell tell her about Elliot and about how he thought he was just some tech but how he thinks he’s trying to get revenge or something. THIS is what it’s means when he says “she sees me”. because she does see him, she sees the mastermind.

This is very interesting to think about. When in season 4, the mother personality told young Elliot personality, "No the other one" my mind did go to Tyrell being involved in some way and I did question for a second if he was another personality.

Great theory... I enjoyed pressing volume up and down throughout this vid.

Eliott and Tyrell have similar computer styles. They are quite similar in the way they approach computing.

a lot of things doesnt add up here, but i remember watching that eisode in the snowy forest and felt like this doesnt make any sense. Three of them just walking felt bizarre. And then, the protective alter just stands next to Tyrell and refuses to walk away with the 1st alter

It's impossible , how can people not recognise the same person ?

How do you explain Elliot and Tyrell sitting in the same room, when Elliot frames Colby and the other people referring to them differently.

Just when you get comfortable and accept how crazy this show was…🤯

The numerous characters they both interacted with independently disprove this theory every time. Dom Darlene Irving Mr Price But most obviously is White Rose. She uses Tyrell for CTO and then CEO. They would not have put Elliot in that position where he would have been even CLOSER to the inside. The theory just doesn't make any sense at all....

One more scece confirms that. In season 4, when Mastermind alter is trying to pack the body of himself into the car and Dominique as officer is asking him for ID she says: "This is Mr. Elliot Anderson's ID... he looks nothing like you sir." And that's because on the ID was photo of Tyrell Wellick. Tyrell == TRuELLiot.

My only other thing is what was up with all the multiverse stuff? That was mostly fan theories, but they were pretty convincing too.

When the maker of the movie said the original host has always been there he did not mean Tyrell. What he meant was whenever the mastermind spoked in inner Monologe and it looked like he broke the fourth wall and talked to us, he did not but talked to the original aliot. We get confirmation of that when aliot is in his illusion where the original aliot lives and hears him inner Monologing. There was never a fourth wall break.

A lot of this isn’t definitive, it’s subjective. And grasping tbh.

Many people talked to both of them at the same time. The real Elliott was the happy innocent optimistic from the dream. ¿?

tyrel told him to park the car there and gave him the keys. Its in the show

Cool theory but it is wrong. Number 5 is actually against your theory because if you remember after shooting the mastermind/Eliot Tyrell calls Irving in a panic and Irving and in the following scene Irving recognizes Eliot and Tyrell and tells Tyrell to stop pushing on Eliot because "that's not helping" and calls doctors to work on Eliot. Irving also talks to them both in other scenes. Also, in the first season (episode 1 or 2 I think) Eliot is in a meeting at All Safe where the executives and Angela interact with him and with Tyrell separately. There are other Scenes with the FBI talking about them as separate people.

Ugh I loathe this theory. It makes no sense. Really don't understand why people still keep considering it when there are so many scenes/situations that would make no fucking sense whatsoever if Elliot and Tyrell were the same person (i.e., when Elliot was walking around New York whilst the FBI was trying to track down Tyrell).

Sorry, but this theory is paper-thin. You can't give some examples to prove a theory and call it a day - you have to try to disprove it. And if you can't, then it is a valid theory. A very easy way to disprove this is that Tyrell is wanted by the FBI, yet Elliot can walk around in public just fine. Edit: this isn't even the best evidence against the theory - there is countless more once you think about it for more than two seconds.

There are some scenes that really backs this theory, and watching this would really make it believable. But also many more that breaks it apart, that I hope it's not true because otherwise it makes the show worse not better. One possibility I can think of is, Sam Esmail was entertaining the idea of Tyrell and Elliot being same person, so he planted some scenes and hints, but eventually decided to go a different route, with some breadcrumb trails still there. Or maybe that alternative timeline actually works?

I don't know... That cut scene confirming everything, I kinda wish they'd left that in there. Why? Cuz I watched this entire show and Tyrell being the real main character went all kinds of over my head. Great breakdown!!

This theory sucks. Phillip Price went to Tyrell's house to hire appoint him as CTO and Mr. Robot was there. He greeted them both separately and told Elliot to join them as well since he was part of five/nine. How could he have seen them both?

This theory is really difficult to reconcile with a lot of scenes from the show, just for example if Elliot is Tyrell how come his own wife have Elliot search for himself by tracking the phone call, and Tyrell own security guard tells Elliot that part of him wishes is not him etc, how come it’s own security guard is not recognizing Tyrell in Elliot, and even is stress out for the fact that maybe Elliot track Tyrell. And It’s not only that scene, it’s too many like that to think or the whole show it’s been lying to the viewers (in that case we’ll need a new show to explain all the loopholes this theory leaves), or this theory is not possible at all.

Well in the first episode both Elliot and Tyrell are at the meeting room of Allsafe discussing the hack. If they are the same person how did they have different interactions within the same space?

theory is completely wrong for reasons such as; Tyrell became a wanted man and recognizable by everyone in new york. So how was Elliot (Tyrell) able to go anywhere and sneak around and interact with anyone if he was actually in Tyrrell's body? Everyone would be like "hey aren't you that Tyrell guy?" I think the comparison of them having abusive fathers is just another parallel between the two seperate characters Tyrell doesn't look like Darlene or the parents and speaks Danish. If he grew up in new York he'd have to have a danish speaking parent right? Also doesnt seem like a guy who grew up poor like Elliot did Angela doesnt treat Tyrell like they grew up together as best friends If Tyrell is our main character than it means the hero of this show beats the shit out of homeless people to get out his rage. Theres your protagonist folks. Dumb theory for dumb click bait video

How about when Elliot and Tyrell meet at the an Ecorp building then when he goes to the restaurant and they are served 2 plates of food.

Also Tyrell says to Elliot he is a complete opposite of him, someone who he wants to be like. Very similar to the explanation the real Elliot gives when he thinks he is in a parallel universe to the created Elliot, where he says I created u bc u were the opposite of me, a rebel and etc.

You actually see Vera in the Intro (part that tells you what's happened previously) of the episode where Darlene reveals that Vera had spoken to Elliot, which makes me think that the persona that saw Vera was actually you (the audience) and not the real Elliot (or Tyrel). Just some food for thought.

you lose all credibility when you use a deleted scene as part of your theory. theres a reason why it was deleted.

When they show Darlene the evidence board, why are both Eliott AND Tyrell on the board?

What about the scene when Phillip Price comes to Tyrell Wellick home and interrupts Tyrell from killing Mr Robot(Elliot). Phillip calls Mr Robot Elliot and Tyrell Tyrell. Also if the mastermind is the person created to carry Elliot's rage why does Tyrell have more rage than the mastermind? How could Eliot be hired by E corp in season 3 while Tyrell was the most wanted man on the planet? Also Phillip always spoke down to Tyrell he never spoke down to Elliot. What about Vera why didn't he recognize Elliot as Tyrell?

OH MY GOD I LOVE THIS THANK YOU FOR MAKING IT

This theory doesn't match at all. Elliot was in jail when Tyrell worked for dark army. The car at the parking was a task from Irving, but not Elliot but is alter Mr robot drove the car and Elliot came back in his own head after at the parking. This entire theory doesn't make any sense. I watched the show 8 times in 2 years and can every line out of my head, I know what I'm talking about.

I really like this theory, and you had me for a few weeks. Your deleted scene seems to nail it. But then two things happened. 1. The FBI whiteboard that Dom shows to Darlene shows two different pictures for Elliot and Tyrell. The only way for that to be possible is if the whole scene was in Elliot's mind. If Tyrell really was the original personality, Elliot and Tyrell would look the same to both the FBI and Darlene. Here you see both Elliot and Tyrell -- they look different to both Darlene and Dom. Note that Mister Robot is NOT on the whiteboard, as you'd expect. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/gZuFds5j07Wpg40.html 2. Your deleted scene seems to nail it, however, this can be explained away pretty easily. It's not a deleted scene -- it's a blooper. You can tell it's a blooper for a few reasons. First, Martin Wallström is basically goofing. Look how wooden / stilted he delivers that line "And you too". He's trying to be funny. It's an impromptu line, not scripted. Second, that is genuine laughter. It's the actors that are genuinely laughing, not their characters. Martin was getting a laugh out of his fellow actors. So this clip was not put into the series because Sam Esmail thought it was too explicit; it was not put into the series because it's a blooper. I really like your theory, but I think my reason #1 is hard evidence why it can't be true, and my reason #2 explains why your deleted scene, which seems irrefutable, can be refuted.

Guys another thing that maybe proves a common point of Tyrel with Elliot is that in episode 1 when AllSafe has the meeting with Ecorp executives Tyrel goes to Elliot desk for a small talk and the Tyrel says that he is also running Linux on his desktop exactly like Eliot does. In that moment Eliot is astonished about that fact .

How can there be so much that proves this theory is true and so much that proves this theory can't be true.. It's like it's the only explication possible and yet it doesn't quiet work.

tyrell was a famous person,since he was on fbi's wanted list obviously people would have noticed him and if they do then fbi would have captured him so your theory doesnt make any sense

I always had this strange explainable feeling about how Tyrell fit within the universe of Mr. Robot that I could never really quite place. Everything about him in this universe really didn't fit. And it may be because of this is a universe that he is creating for himself to escape his own trauma. Great video.

wouldn’t elliot’s boss at allsafe recognize tyrell in the times they meet? not to mention in season 1 when evil corp, allsafe and the fbi are all in the same room they all see tyrell and elliot together and terry even tells tyrell to have angela leave the room after elliot clarifies something she says

It’s a fun theory and tbh helps explain tyrell sudden blue light weird death but to many times in the show they had them interact with others at the same time in a way that doesn’t make sense

wait but why the fbi search for Elliot and Tyrell at the same time

Then why would the “real Elliot” have scenes with tyrel?

People saying this theory cant be true because of parts where elliot and tyrel met different people are forgetting something, people with DID can have strong hallucinations and imagine things, a whole scene couldve been different from the truth. When tyrel "shot" elliot, it couldve been all elliot's hallucinations, remember when his father personality kept shooting him in the head? What proves that elliot didnt imagine all the things that happened after he was shot like the surgery? his sister?

I believe we are never suppose to know his true identity. I would think it was less about his look and more about his true personality.

I like to think that Elliot just has a fictional version of Tyrell in his head rather than the real Elliot being Tyrell.

The most believable thing about this theory to me is that Tyrell's involvement in the story seemed too vague. His character was so heavily built up...went missing for ages...then just kinda died. There had to be more to him and this might be it!