"i've overplayed it" means it's an S-tier.

Great channel, keep the Dylan album reviews coming

Cool way to rank the albums. You are very harsh imo lol. My S tier (does that mean super?) would be very crowded- all 60s albums except debut and NS, then BotTs, Desire, Basement Tapes, Oh Mercy, TooM, L&T, Modern Times and R&RWs. So thats 15. Im a lost cause really lol. But the more rock music I listen to the more I realise how unique and great Dylan is. My other rows would differ greatly too, of course. But fun watch thanks! Stuart.

World Gone Wrong should be in the S tier. It has Dylan's best singing and contains genuine gems like Two Soldiers and Delia. Good as I been to You should be up there as well. Dylan's performance of Arthur McBride is very compelling. Canadee-I-O and Jim Jones are incredible too. I agree with you about the Sinatra stuff, though I do love Melancholy Mood. Good list overall, MDR. The video was a fun watch.

Thanks man for very good ranking of Bob Dylan albuma. I think thatThe Self Portret album is very underated album and underated on your list too.

I agree with your S tier rankings. It's hard to argue against BOTT and the mid-60s trio albums as being Dylan's very best work. The first thing I disagree with is your ranking of Street-Legal... It's a solid album and it easily makes high B. I don't like the words underrated and overrated, but I will make an exception in this case - Street-Legal is an underrated album and always has been. Saved goes in the B tier, too. I enjoy that album, even as a non-religious person. I am almost tempted to put it in A because I have such a soft spot for it - Pressing On, Saving Grace, Covenant Woman, and In the Garden are all fantastic tracks. Also, I would put Time out of Mind in A tier based on how often I listen to it, which is regularly. I am pleased that you mentioned Highlands in particular. I love that song! Further, I would drop Empire Burlesque to F. I can't stand that album, mainly due to the OTT cheesy 80s production. When the Night Comes Falling from the Sky makes me want to vomit... The album's only redeemable song, for me, is Dark Eyes, and even that is not vintage Dylan. Empire Burlesque's successor, Knocked Out Loaded, is probably even worse in the production department, but at least that album contains Brownsville Girl, which is a Dylan classic. Finally, I think putting Love & Theft in C tier is astonishing. It's a classic late-period Dylan album and it goes in high B or low A, for me.

This is a great overview of Bob Dylan's discography, thanks for the video.👍

I also agree with the other commenter about “World Gone Wrong” even though it’s a covers album, I think it’s really well done, interesting collection of songs, particularly “Love Henry”.. I would put “John Wesley Harding” in the highest tier, Good list though, and nice video.

Nice List! Oh Mercy is an S for me. And for some reason i really really like Street Legal, never get tired of it - would place it in B.

Good vid. I’d personally have TOOM & times they are a changin’ in at least the A tier. Street legal, Love & Theft & Modern times definitely would be higher than C too. R&R Ways is at least an ‘A’ for me. Some of his strongest songwriting ever. Key west is lyrically insane.

Loved the video. Imo, The Times They Are A Changin is S Tier and most days my favorite Dylan album

My favorites are Blonde on Blonde, Highway 61 followed closely by Bringing It All Back Home, then The Basement Tapes, and Freewheelin,' Blood on the Tracks First pressing (New York Sessions), Another Side of Bob Dylan, John Wesley Harding, Desire, Love and Theft or Oh Mercy

As a huge Dylan fan, I find this is the best rating of Dylan's albums I've seen, though we are miles apart in generation. I even agree with your selections when you debated which tier to put albums on.

I've just come across your channel while searching for deep dylan cuts on yt. So I'm interested in your thoughts on the best live versions of his songs. For example, my favorite version of "Don't Think Twice, It's Alright" is from the Carnegie 63 show. I think it's the first version I heard and now every version, including the studio version, all pale in comparison. What are some favorite live versions of songs do you enjoy and what do you think of my take on the Don't think twice versions?

Calling Planet Waves one of his most underrated records and putting it in C-tier is a bit odd, if I may say so.

Thanks for the rankings ,i like Planet Waves a lot so woud be in my top 10.😊 Mick.

Being a Dylan fan for 50 years Your choice is very close to mine Apart from Planet waves that IMO should be a A listing

Being totally in love with early Bob, I’d put the times they are a changing, the freewheeling and another side in s tier, but I agree with almost every other pick 👍🏻

Rough and Rowdy Ways and Time Out of Mind belong in the A tier, Modern Times and Street Legal should be bumped up to B.

Great list! Agree with most of it. Freewheelin’ though …. I think Saved came before Shot of Love.

Time out of Mind and Another side need to be A tier.

“Saved” was BEFORE “Shot Of Love” and it’s one of my top 5 Dylan albums. But the other 4 is all top s.. But all that aside, I kinda wish you would’ve added the Traveling Wilburys albums. Why did you skip letter “E”?

Great list, only quibbles, I'd put Another Side in the C tier, New Morning B tier, Infidels -B, Oh Mercy A tier, Out of Mind A+, Modern Times A, Tempest is a C and Rowdy is a S for me.

Hello! is it a " class list" of album ? in order of merit ? what is the principle ? your good taste ? each letter ( S, A,B;;;) correspond to a better or lower rank? ( S is the first, ad F the last ?)! perhaps it would be more precise to draw up a more long list, for differentiate more the albums! why not twenty ranks ?

Fellow Alex, where would you put Shadow Kingdom? Bottom C?

If JWH were called "All along the watchtower" it would make everybody's S. Now it has that silly outlaw name and people tend to forget that it has easily 8 of his best songs ever on it.

Interesting ranking list. The classics are beyond doubt and the 'dogs' are obvious. I'd bump up a few more of his '60s albums and consign the Xmas album to F. I think you probably could have given his 'renaissance' albums (TIME OUT OF MIND, etc.) another listen before starting. Those albums are much stronger than B or C tier with strong writing and a distinctive production style. I would agree about the American songwriter albums as well as the over-rated R&R WAYS. One note: the infamous DYLAN album was not put out by him but by his label, Columbia, after he jumped to Geffin's Asylum Label (BEFORE THE FLOOD and PLANET WAVES). The album is made up of cast-offs, mostly from the SELF TITLED sessions.

that "Dylan" album is shockingly listenable considering its reputation. I wouldn't put it in F tier personally

Man, I'm happy to see that Logic is getting into Dylan

I was so angry (and confused) at your Street Legal placement that I listened to it three more times the next day. Modern Times is at least an 'A' for me as well. On the positive side you have re-aroused my interest in Bringing it All Back Home and Planet Waves. The former has always been a tough listen but I've learned to skip Subterranean Homesick Blues and it is much improved now. That and Rainey Day Woman # 12 & 35 are the only two Dylan songs I need to skip every time.

2:14 for a second I thought he was breaking wind🤣🤣🤣🤣 Good list though

basement tapes is not all from that summer of 67.

times is the absolute best of acoustic dylan and an easy s tier

Interesting list. For most people there are more A's and B's. (Time's, Skyline usually get A for example. Street Legal is a solid B with an S opening and closing songs) For me Basement Tapes is an A a lot of the bootlegs are A or S. "Albert Hall (really Manchester Free Trade Hall is a definite S.

planet waves definitely B maybe A tier

World Gone Wrong and Good as I Been To You are B-TIER at least.

I know its about opinions and all but love and theft, rnrw are S tier records and until you see that you are unenlightened Oh mercy, toom, 60s records all A tier except highway S tier

That 1973 Dylan album was put out by columbia because they were pissed at him for going to record at Asylum. He had no input on it.

New Morning, World Gone Wrong, and Good as I Been To You, should be higher. Nashville Skyline should be lower. I do agree that R&RW was overhyped, C is probably fair.

Nashville Skyline is better than John Wesley Harding. Fight me lol

Freewheeling, Desire, Oh Mercy and Love and Theft are all S and I think there is a consensus among fans and crictics alike there... many others should be F lol

Rough & Rowdy, Love & Theft are way too lowly rated.... Time Out of Mind is too low.... Shot of Love and Street Legal also too low...

Totally disagree with whole list. Oh mercy is an A.

Tedious, he sounds bored.

You should probably refamiliarize yourself with an artists catalogue before doing another ranking video. Things really fell apart for you after the '60s (classic albums which my dog could have ranked). Your B and C levels contain albums most other artists can only dream about. Also, maybe you should hydrate yourself before shooting your videos. Just a thought.