Who else is still enjoying this hit in 2024❤

its almost 2022 and I'm still in love with this song

i need this type of song again in 2024

Who’s still listening to this song in 2019 🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️

Starship needs to learn some management skills, this song is great. I just found out about Jooyoung, and I guess Im in love with him already, his voice is so ovaries exploder. Now that starship is cooking up with survival show for new boy group, like SERIOUSLY??? Starship needs to focus firsts on their current rosters of talents.. theyre great really, give them time to shine and theyll do big. NOT ANOTHER boy group..goshhh, they have BOYFRIEND already..should they focus first on BOYFRIEND. STARSHIP !!! DONT BE TOO GREEDY. It takes time to be successful! --- YGstan here and Im starting to like starship.

6 years after : still can't get tired of this song

2020?? Still love this song😍

This song is so timeless, still so in love with it till this day😭no Collab has ever sounded THIS good

Bartender is FINE

i keep repeating the bartender hello scene at the beginning i can't get that scene out of my head !!

my girl Hyolyn just released her new comeback "Layin Low" featuring Jooyoung again! go check it out the official mv everyone~ killing the game as always!

RIP to Iron.. Come here again after receiving the news about iron😔😔

It can't be helped people are instantly reminded of Trouble Maker every time there's a collab between a female & male idol like this one. Trouble Maker IS the first EVER unit to have a female & male idol and it's undeniable that after their success one after another female+male idol unit keeps appearing. Anyway, I was expecting a powerful duet. I mean, Hyorin has a POWERFUL singing. This kind of singing reminds me of Soyu's style more. Nevertheless, it's a good song for the season. This is my opinion alright. Peace!

This song is a true masterpiece. There are lots of Kpop songs I like, I‘ll listen for a long time. But I will never get tired of this song. It has something jazzy and soothing, that calms me down when I listen to it.😊

2024년에도 자주듣습니다 ㅎㅎ

imo, he 2nd hyolyn that comes later in the bar is the past version. she has the bangs, the style of when she was in a relationship with jooyoung. she represents both hyolyn's and jooyoung's longing for each other. for jooyoung, he is still stuck with the past memories of her and their relationship. he misses her even tho he says, "he could get any woman". in iron's part, he says "I'm dirty behind you. i drink all night with another girl." which i think the 2nd hyolyn also represents. she is also some random woman who he drinks with at night. but for new version of hyolyn who is now in a relationship with the bartender/takuya, the 2nd hyolyn represents her past version of herself when she was with jooyoung. 2nd hyolyn represents her longing for jooyoung. and how the distance makes her miss him even more. that is why i think she is crying behind takuya's back. she shows him she's happy with him but secretly misses jooyoung, therefore crying behind "his back" so that he doesn't know that she ain't moved on fully yet. but they can't be together cuz they'll go back to that toxic relationship. thus, they just stay in the sidelines, eyeing and longing for each other while trying to but not really moving on. also, notice how her new relationship with takuya is always shown in a brighter/whiter light, with white and soft colored outfits. it might mean that she is finally in a relationship where she is treated well, respected and loved. she is happy, and is most of the time but she still misses jooyoung. on the other hand, both hyolyn and jooyoung are always shown in darker lights, darker setting with bold and dark colored outfits which might mean that their relationship was passionate, but very toxic as well.

Top 2 mistakes Women makes in life; No. 1 - Choosing the bad boy No. 2 - Thinking that bad boy would change

I was expecting a bit more..... but this is really good. I mean hyorin has one of the most powerful voices I've heard in sistar, so I was expecting something stronger, but I guess a calm song is good for the soul

it's already 2024 but i still coming back here

Rest in peace, Iron.

my take on the story line: if u notice, hyorin always has bangs when she's with jooyoung, but with takuya, she has no bangs. and since irl, she took her bangs away, i guess her with bangs represents the past?? HAHA IDK OK but i think that the scenes with hyorin x jooyoung are the past and she is currently with takuya, but they are still both trying to "erase" each other, hence the second hyorin. she comes in because jooyoung still yearns for her and thats what she looked like when she was with him. but idk this is just my take on it.... if it even makes sense lol BUT HONESTLY THIS SONG IS SLAYING MY LIFE AND I LOVE U HYORIN OMFG SLAY

They're more perfect than Troublemaker. Thumbs up

bruh i was 16 when i first heard this and now I'm 23 with love experience. This song really ages like fine wine

This song deserves more attention

Since 14 till 20 I'm still obsessed with this song 👁️💧👄💧👁️

Am I the only one who has been putting this song on repeat ever since it has released? This calm song gets to showcase Hyorin's vocal amazingly, and she doesnt overshadow JooYoung's voice and both of their voices just blend so well together ~~

Doesn’t this song kinda remind you of that feeling that….you want to break up with your true love…. But you just don’t?

pov it's been 8 years and you still love this song

This song should've been a hit. *Replay Button*

omg i loved that part when hyorin said " i erase how i once loved you you" Best part of this song :')

Hyolyn comeback Jan 12 with jooyoung again.

2024 and this song still gives me chills

This video could of have been them sitting in a box wearing sweat pants and I would of have still loved it, The emotional delivery of Hyorin was perfect. Her way of releasing her notes with an airy breath made you connect to the song without the video. It is what SYJ of 4Men does. Jooyoung smooth sound which was a pitch above Hyorin and very clear gave the song a balance to the emotional singing from Hyorin. To say the least I love the song, The video as some as you are saying is like troublemaker and it is not. What is similar is the appeal trouble maker had. It is just in an lower does of sex appeal but it is still just as sexy with more class.

So...hearing this song halfway through, I thought I wasn't going to like it. But it's so deep and catchy with that slow vibe, so I fell in love with the song

Y'all it's 2023 and I"m here enjoying the song as it's the first time and the nostalgia is hitting me :)

Only legends know this song.

I really really want to see a collaboration with Hyorin and Tori Kelly. They have similar voices and I just know they'd kill it.

Takuya, I'll admit that you look absolutely good with Hyorin but... Joon Jae is waiting for you!!!

Yes, they collaborate again in 2022 Jan !!

This song is so underrated

Takuya, stop playing around and go to your apartment, Joon Jae's waiting for you.

I thought I got the storyline until we got a second Hyorin XD

Immediately came here to confirm that Iron is singing here. Omg rip 💔😭

I don't listen to kpop that much anymore..but I still come back to this masterpiece sometimes 💖

The rap parts are just amazing, it came out at the right timing.

hyolyn sings like an angel

Wish Kpop artists made these bangers again

These lyrics are so chillingly powerful that it's... scary actually. I swear songs about love, pain, and betrayal all hit differently once you've been in love/emotionally invested

TAKUYAAAAAAAAAA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I remember when people used to tease hyorin cause people said that she had a big forehead and that's why she had bangs... boy were they wrong she looks really pretty with or without bangs

Almost 2024 I'm still here

this song makes me feel sad about a love story that I've never experienced

My Mum and I both agree that if we had Takuya from Cross Gene serving us drinks in a bar then we would be there every night without fail. They don't call him "gorgeous gene" for nothing!

'Still listening to this ... and... damn... i'm still in love with this song.

so, this is how a simple reunion can brings back the memories

I miss this kind of kpop song

Everybody knows that Hyorin has a powerful voice. Literally, EVERYBODY. That's why it's good that she doesn't allow herself to be pigeon-holed and did something different, something that she personally liked as opposed to what's constantly expected of her. Artists need to be allowed to grow, experiment and expand their repertoire, otherwise it gets stale and boring for them and when it gets boring for them, it comes across in their music and who wants that honestly?

Ok, in my opinion, the story is about breaking up and erasing memories. In the beginning, Hyolyn/ Hyorin smiles and flirts (kinda) with the bartender. JooYoung sits there and they share some eyecontacts which seems like they have some sort of realtionship. Then, their memories keep rushing through their (or her) mind(s). In the last scene, another Hyolyn comes in, so the whole thing may be Hyolyn's memories about JooYoung. She keeps smiling at the bartender in hopes of forgetting her ex...

OMG THIS SO IS REALLY GOOD WHO LISTENING IN 2019?

2021?

Woah after almost 4 years, I still am listening to this and I still know the lyrics. Woah, learning the song by heart really does go far.

300.000 views? Are you kidding me? This mv need more views!! This song very classic and sexy.

9 years? its 2023 and i still love ....soon 2024 and lovee

Almost end of 2023 and this song just keeps on hitting like the first time it came out. 😱🥺🥺😭😭😭😭😭

I think if you do NOT have anything nice to say or even the fact that YOU know that people will not like what negative comments you will be posting (EVEN IF IT'S YOUR OPINION) expect that people will say something to you because YOU are bashing someone else's love/interest for these two or this song. Co-ed will never belong to anyone, so please stop with the whole Hyunseung and Hyuna "were first". Just appreciate the fact that this was made so well, people felt different kinds of positive emotions and how YOU can listen to this music. Love the damn song and be positive. If not, go to your favorite group/duo/singer and not hate here.

I think that the story is about how Hyorin is currently in a relationship with Takuya(bartender) but still misses JooYoung a lot. All the light scenes are with Takuya, showing how she's having a better time but because she still misses her ex, Takuya can sense it too. She's torn but she knows she can't go back, she's trying to "erase" him but in the end she still sees (Quite literally LOL) herself with JooYoung, hence the second hyorin. In the end, awkward moment for everyone XD Love this song

2020? July? come on i can be the only one

1. Hyolyn's voice is so soothing. 2. JooYoung's voice is also very soothing. 3. I am gay now. Thanks Takuya! ^_^

Bet troublemaker fans are gonna say something :/ Btw I love it♡

I love this duo Hyorin & Jooyoung. Their voices are complemented very well and are beautiful. They also make a beautiful couple together. I want to see them again in a duet together. I want a comeback :'( :'(

The most underrated song..

2024 y me sigue encantando esta canción ❤

WHOOOO! Man, I love Hyorin BUT DAMN JOOYOUNG--WHO R U?! (Seriously messing me up...xP) The R&B, the vocals, everyone was looking good too! (Especially Takuya...^^) ~~ THIS is the kind of song U need every once-in-a-while. Hyorin, great job as usual; Jooyoung, I'm DEFINITELY going to be following U now... BTW: Did anyone else get thrown off by the pocket watch? It kinda messed me up...xP #SISTAR #씨스타 #HYORIN #HYOLYN #효린 #JOOYOUNG #주영 #ERASE #지워#STARSHIPENT #STARSHIPX #CROSSGENE #크로스진 #TAKUYA #IMNOTABOYNOTYETAMAN #어려도남자야

Who else comehere for Jooyoung?!! I'm waiting for your re-debut under starship as a solo singer tho. Fighting babe

you're legend if you still here in 2020.

The vocals on this song!

This song exceeded my expectations, its just so beautiful and sweet and its just perfect.. Holy crap Takuya!??

B.E.S.T. song ever! Like their voices are perfect together. I didn't see that coming at first and i was like my feels.. they're too much. It's just too perfect T.T Dance and the mv is perfect too. I had to watch the mv again and again to finally understand(maybe i didn't understand it xD) but here's my theory: Hyorin and Jooyoung sitting in a bar represents that they're close yet far away from each other. Past Hyorin has bangs and the present one doesn't. So Hyorin is with Takuyo now but still trying to forget Jooyoung. While she was in bed upside down, she thought for a second that Takuya is Jooyoung. When the rap part ends the lyrics says '' You will fall in love with another guy'' then Takuya's in the screen. When Hyorin was in the telephone booth she was ending things with Jooyoung but she still remembers him. after that Takuya is looking the clock, he sees that the Jooyoung's time is over and Hyorin is changed now. He smiles because of that.Then the old Hyorin comes in because Jooyoung still didn't forget the old Hyorin and she's still with him. I don't know if this make sense to you tho :D

RIP. IRON ︶︿︶

uda mau 10 taun ni lagu, tapi aku masi suka dengerin 😭

This was just pure perfection. People were asking for a powerful song but who cares. Just because Hyorin has a powerful voice doesn't mean every single one of her songs need to be powerful, that would just mess up her voice. Their voice just go so well together! Can't wait for another song from them if there is one!

OMO the feels! Since I've heard their vocals I can't resist of smiling due to happiness because from the starting point, I really felt the emotions in their voices and I know this is another a masterpiece- a song that depicts class and decency even though romance is the theme. So happy Starship did not overdo the craft since both have strong vocals especially Hyorin. Joo Young's voice really suits in hiphop-ish RnB like this. It was very cool and light for a masculine voice. The story of the mv was also poetic, making it a plus to the overall product. Good job Starship! HyorinXJooYoung Fighting!

2021 everyone? My fav song ever💘💘

It’s already 2022 but I can’t still move on from this song🥺

it is so hot how he looks at the camera when he has his arm around her 1:21

I'm still listening. This is a masterpiece. All these years, for a duet song, I always say this is my favorite.

I have been obsessed with this song for YEARS. Not me just now realizing Takuya was in this mv.

Came back after 7 years well now Layin low is out once again Collab

so starship is where this beautiful duets came from

it's in 2023 and still my favorite 😍😍😍

its almost 2023 and I'm still in love with this song

This song >>>

damn takuya is so fine hyoyn and jooyoung vocals are on point as always

dat lip swipe though

jooyoung is the hottest man in kpop🤤

6 years ago and i still can't move on

Cross Gene's Takuya = cutest bartender to ever live

I jUst realized that the bartender played Takuya in The lovers

The nicest korean song I've ever listened to

This got stuck in my head after all those years. Hyolyn's really got the best R'n'B songs