everybody remember where they were when the mic drop performance happened. lip sync accusations going strong, the number of haters growing every day... yoongi saw a chance and boy did he take it. such an iconic moment

we love vocalists flexing their vocals but my favourite live moments are the unserious ones, like seokjin going "popping popping popping popping popping woo" while performing cns. i also LOVE when the singer starts giggling/laughing while singing

It's not a coincidence that we don't have so many iconic live singing moments with 4th and 5th gens like we used to with 2nd and 3rd gens. Now you don't have to be able to sing well to become a popular idol and go viral. I really miss top tier singers in kpop 😢

THE SISTAR CLIP 🤣🤣🤣 how dare you 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

King Taeyeon'a fine is so iconic 🩷

MAMAMOO BACKWOODS SO FUCKEN TRUEEEE but also just any breath mamamoo took on the immortal songs stage. u have to see their perf of 'love' if you haven't yet

I was about to write a whole paragraph when i did not see mamamoo here until the last clip

My favorite is Wheein's part in Mamamoo's queendom I Miss You performance, it's so delicate and perfected and just sounds so so good.

Soobin's face like he saw his life flash before his eyes😅😭 tbh that must have been so scary when they were just rookies that time. BTS omitting some lyrics just to prove they are singing live will always be iconic! Mamamoo the vocal queens! Deserved!

4:33 first day on the job too chenbaek the legends yall are

THE THINGS I FEEL WHENEVER I HEAR JONGHO'S GOODBYE BABY GOODBYE

Tayeon's voice singing FINE always makes me shiver

MAMAMOO are LiveVocal Queens indeed, every performance is iconic❤ I miss them soooooooooo much😢 MAMAMOO OT4 are forever for me❤

ateez’s performances always give me chills

i legit watch the RV vocal line immortal song performance every other day! Specifically for the moments in this video

that chen baekhyun moment lives rent free in my head ngl lol but I also like that you included the sistar moment bc I love those moments too. Or strangely I also don't mind idols voice cracking bc its endearing

ace's someone you loved cover genuinely one of my top emotional comfort songs so deserved

one of my fave live moments was 2014 Kpop world festival, BAP was performing One Shot and poor Daehyun, he'd been pulled out of the hospital to perform but the festival staff thought he'd just lipsync cuz he was sick, they had his backing audio so loud you couldn't hear him all song until his big high note in the bridge, when they cut it but also didn't turn his mic on, AND YOU CAN STILL HEAR HIM LIKE BOI WAS SINGING WITH HIS WHOLE SOUL

blackpinks 2019 coachella performances are just so toe curling 😭 i get goosebumps everytime

For me the 1st group come to my mind is BTOB. They're king of live performance with amazing voices. No matter how people keep sleep on them but that's the fact.

soyeon is such a queen. gidle performed in my country last year during a kpop festival. there were some issues with mics in general, they changed soyeons mic like two times. it still didnt work but you could hear her. shes tiny but so powerful

i love all of the moments mentioned in this video but the vocals with no backtrack or instrumental moment of fine by taeyeon actually breaks me each time i hear it

I was absolutely expecting SHINee to be included, but then I was pleasantly surprised to see A.C.E here. Hoping for a part 2 now

Beautiful! My favorite moment will always be Kihyun singing the "Lost In The Dream" highnote from MX's comeback showcase. I didn't know anything about MX back than and just randomly found that clip. But that moment I knew, I was going to stan that group and his man would be my bias and favorite voice of all time. I also love Jooheon's and I.M's "SAMBAKLA" live stage.

THANK YOU for reminding me of that last Mamamoo performance, can't believe I haven't been listening to it every day like a day job

dk's aju nice high note... he's so comical about it but lord if that note isn't insane

It might be recency bias but I'm right after The Rose concert and the way they slapped me across the face with their vocals is an unforgetable experience. Woosung and Dojoon popped of with the highnotes.

The Sistar one 😭 I AM a fan of the ones that are still impressive for the circumstances. My fav example is probably when Yoohyeon in one of Dreamcatcher's Bon Voyage encore performances (i think for show champ) just completely improvises a key change despite holding back tears.

okay you got me to click on thumbnail alone

the crown one is so iconic

I have two: the Mayfly performance of Love Poem in Kingdom, particularly Eunkwang at the end; Seungsik of Victon doing the See You Again cover in concert, especially that a capella part and the ending.

LOVELYZ MENTIONED

bpchella will always be legendary

if you do a part two you should definetly add nmixx!!

One moment that I think doesn't get talked about enough (prolly because of the decade of time since it has happened) is the Leo (Vixx), Eunkwang (BToB), Daehyun (BAP) and Youngjae (Got7) collab cover of Mirotic for the 2014 Hallyu Dream Concert. The adlibs at the end!!! 😲😮😮

thank you for including mamamoo 🫶

I love love love Bolero live from tvxq. It's giving me chills. Also Bada's Ave Maria was wonderful but I can't recall if it was live or not

the iconic ones that come to mind for me are Hweseung covering that queen song, Ailee and Youngji’s immortal songs bang bang performance, and pretty much any Mamamoo immortal songs performance. Also, Lucy!!! pretty much any Lucy performance. I don’t necessarily think you’re looking for these, but in terms of music show performances - ONF’s Love Effect (and their recent immortal songs performance) on inkigayo in green outfits. &Team on Music Bank during Firework era where you can hear Jo singing during a stunt. I think they’re wearing blue blazers. there’s a pretty epic Rolling Quartz mcountdown performance from Blaze era where Jayoung is demolishing the vocals. I’ll edit this if I can think of any more.

Gosh thank you for including this beautiful cover by A.C.E😭❤️ And Ateez slaying as usual with THE best main vocal💜👏

For me it's SHINee's encore stages especially during dream girl era. They were wild on encores during dream girl era. In one or two encore stages they were doing push-ups while serving us with their powerful vocals

one word ICONIC 🙌🏻

ateez’s live singing is fr no joke their coachella performance is gonna be one for the history books

my favorite is this performance from Ryeowook, Kyuhyun, Sungmin, and Zhoumi performing How am I supposed to live without you, but the music cuts out around 2:20. They laugh, and look to Ryeowook for the pitch and continue the song acapella. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Y9Soe5Smnq7Seac.htmlsi=GcagEnXWPm9qB5k5

THANKS FOR INCLUDING LOVELYZ

three of my all time faves are lily’s triple note in dice, the last ~45 seconds of skz’s i’ll be your man cover and jongho’s wonderland high note on kingdom

mamamoo are really incredible !!

mine will always be seungkwan on maskered singer

your intro is stellar

Ning ning, always remember us this way

I don't know a lot of these groups but I thoroughly enjoyed watching everyone. So talented! I personally love JHope's performance of Outro: Tear at Wembley. Its the emotion while he's rapping the verse.

i would love to see kingdom's love poem cover...seungmin, jongho and eunkwang's voices are so magical together...they complement each others so well

Where there’s live singing compilation, Imma be there no matter what. I couldn’t think of anything (as of rn) but somehow TY singing Into The Unknown kept popping in my mind while typing this comment (the one where she wore blue dress). So do check it out (if you haven’t already) ❤

@1:35 OMG THX FOR INCLUDING A.C.E

OMG A.C.E IT’S BEEN SO LONG SINCE I LAST SAW SOMEONE MENTION THEM 😭😭😭

GREAT COMPILATION ... AGREE WITH THEM ALL. Can we get a part 2?

THE TXT CLIP IM CTFUUU

mamamoo gives me goosbump

My excitement seeing the thumbnail thinking you'll include Wendys live performance from any of her solo live performance like song stealer, lee mujin or even slow life slow live dying down at the end of the video

Son la esperanza de los vocales de esta industria 😔✋🏽✋🏽✋🏽

More please

my personal favorite is in the final chorus of district nine kcon 2023 it’s so good!! the high notes, the passion, the arrangement, everything

A recent live moment that comes to mind on the funny side of things is that concert clip of San nailing his part, miming a flute as he turns to the side, only to get nAILED by a giant balloon and goin’ “oOMPH” audibly into his mic 🤣🤣🤣🤣

pt2 please!

ATEEZ MAMA WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

My favorite is the kingdom cover of I’ll be your man when Han and Seungmin are hitting those high notes and changbin is rapping 🤭

Sm cargando con los vocales de la industria desde siempre 😝💅🏽💅🏽💥

I want you to include SNSD-Goodbye LIVE the concept of the song is so rare nowadays. Also SNSD(TTS)-Holler and Cater2U performance.(All at Yuhiyeol). And lastly,SNSD-Into the new world ballad because it's show vocal ability of every members.

Yea lovelyz 🥹💕

Silently deleting paragraph after seeing booseok

mine would def be piwon's live intuition busking cover!!! or legit just any keeho + theo + jiung live where they r going off lol

Thank you so much for this video ❤. Suggestion for part two. TTS Cater 2 U

That Mic Drop moment I just aggressively mouthed the words he didn’t sing on the couch. 🤣🤣 I wasn’t a fan yet, just a passive listener not into all the drama, but in my extensive research since I’ve been an Army, that moment is sO iconic and I’m so proud of Yoongi for it 🥹💜😂

jongho would have been such a slay if he hadn't strained so much lol I was suffering for his throat the whole perf, it was awesome nonetheless

I miss 2019 BP so much. 🤧 Another one of my fave live moments was a live of Dice where the music stopped and Haewon and Lily started belting the note. Unbelievable. It was so good. 😭💞

Chen and Baekhyun doing that as rookies is crazyyy. They really don't debut idols like that anymore

If you do a part two please add BTOB!

I came here knowing some of my favourite moments were going to be included (exo and red velvet), but I got introduced to some really dope performances, like I didn't know Lovelyz could do THAT, and also A.C.E???? I'm in love. I'd love to see some BTOB or NCT 127 on the next one if you make a part 2! :)

I just read the title and thought of FINE by taeyeon, SOOO CLEAN

yes to immortal songs! basically catapulted mamamoo, exo, ailee, so hyang and so many more to be considered singing icons of kpop 🤩❤️

Not all kpop idols are not good singers but unfortunately most (if not almost all) kpop songs do not showcase their talents. Kpop is more about the overall performance than musicality. So some idols get ridiculous hate (not that any kind of hate is justifiable. If you think someone can not sing to your expectations, simply stop listening to them. If they are truly lacking talent and people stop listening, they won't survive. You don't have to mess with people's psyche. The world is difficult enough as it is). That's why sometimes covers become more popular than their own songs.

I remember the Taeyeon moment, I cried. And that is the Mamamoo performance I ALWAYS cry when I watch lol. Well along with “Saraghae”

4:32 this duo is criminals for two things. First of all they sound like THIS (illegally beautiful) together, second of all this was their last time singing as a duo wtf guys c'mon

lovelyz mention in 2024!!! i'm gonna cry 😭😭😭😭

If you're still looking for candidates for future parts to this, I HIGHLY recommend including my favourite silly but impressive SHINee live performance of Like A Fire. Them not taking things too seriously throughout, only having easy choreo during the chorus of the song and playing around on stage... but then suddenly you get the sheer vocal skills showcased especially at the last minute with the bridge and around when Onew and Jonghyun are singing "baby baby baby baby" at each other and then key out-of-nowhere (literally this part isn't in the original mp3 version, as if he just did it unprompted lol) does that AMAZING high note and goes back to dancing as if nothing happened haha!! It's sooo funny and good!

if kpop was more about vocals than just being pretty, Lovelyz would have been way more popular. the girls were both pretty and talented but people didnt give them enough attention

2:24 TOO REALLL BRO

TXT sang live since debut!

🎶yeoreobun🎶

I'd add more EXO, and also Ailee because her cover of I will always love you was (and still is) iconic!

BROO YOU FORGOT SOMETHING: sWeEt DrEaMs I mAkE👹🎶

ITS NOT FINEEEEEEEEEEAAHHHHHHHHH AAAAAAAAAHHHHH

I need the one where chuu sings hart attac and makes beonce cry plsss

oh my god yes not to be too boomer but i miss old immortal songs and sketchbook so much. every mamamoo immortal songs stage is pure gold and snsd tts cater 2 u on sketchbook slays fr. i feel like award show live singing also used to go so much harder, like niche but shinee sherlock at kmf 2012 is insane. not to say that new gen stuff isn't good, i love stuff like leemujin service, award shows are still fun, and concert footage is always great, but damn i miss the old stuff

It doesn't matter how many times I've watched it, Backwoods still makes me cry 😭

4:32 that's why they are exo 🤣 from exoplanet and I love Red Velvet and they slayed that Immortal song performance, but you could not talk about Immortal Songs without talking about Mamamoo, and I was glad at the end 😅You could easily pick any part of any of their performances and it would make the point... Also, Seulgi was just proving they were singing live 😂 There's that 1 time they were performing ICC at sports court and Irene forgot her mic, but they were lip syncing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣#neverforget

Mamamoo amen

3:07 Hyolyn's face always make me laugh 😂😂😂😂

I'd add CRAVITY's immortal songs performance and dear name cover here. They gave us LIVE VOCALS and stage presence

BRO YOU NEED TO ADD ATEEZ'S LIVE PERFORMANCE FOR WONDERLAND FRFRFRFRFRR

Pls bring txt 20cm live!!! Theyre so good AAAAAA