Рет қаралды 9,557
//
Stream or purchase my huge piano solo album collection (new high quality recordings;
10 volumes at all and an extra album with movie love songs!; also many exclusive recordings which you can't find here on KZfaq!) here:
Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/1IFo7...
Apple/iTunes: / steven-bear
Amazon: www.amazon.com/music/player/a...
Sheet music of my own recordings:
www.lulu.com/shop/-pianomusic...
//
/
/ What's your favorite piano and what do you think is the most realistic one? Please vote/comment!
Here's a comparison of an excerpt from "The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter" theme by Dave Grusin, played with different virtual pianos I own. Everyone is a new recording, no MIDI File used (these kind of comparisons are senseless).
00:00 Piano 1
01:22 Piano 2
02:43 Piano 3
04:04 Piano 4
The complete recording of this beautiful theme comes later played with the piano you voted as first place!
SPOILER!
Ok here are now the pianos I used and my opinions:
1: "Pearl Concert Grand" by Impact Soundworks (a Yamaha concert grand)
Pros:
- very realistic (especially for a Yamaha, which is more brilliant in sound);
- strong and realistic "internal" resonance/reverb like in a typical grand piano playing live on stage (more than in any other library I know) (the samples were recorded directly with natural stage reverb)
- different mic positions (combinable)
- nice pp and p samples
Cons:
- many detuned and unclean samples, especially in the lower keys which is really a big problem (the sampled piano seemed to be pretty old)
- hard to control dynamics (playability not good)
- needs pretty long to load in your memory, especially if you use more than 1 mic position (because of so many samples)
2: "Addictive Keys" by XLN Audio (a Steinway grand piano)
Pros:
- good especially for pop songs and accompaniment
- different mic positions (combinable)
- very clean samples (nothing detuned)
- pretty good playability
- pretty fast to load
Cons:
- unrealistic and unnatural software reverb (although I used the best setting)
- not really very fine (p and pp) samples (just reduced in volume)
3: "Ivory II American D" by Synthogy (a Steinway grand)
Pros:
- good for intimate recordings like jazz pieces, partly also classical pieces
- mostly clean samples (except two or three keys)
Cons:
- a bit unrealistic reverb (it is only software reverb, piano was recorded dry and that you can here unfortunately)
- only one real mic position (just a software algorithm for changing between audience and player position I think)
- very low "internal" resonance (it seems that the fade out of a key sound is very quick and short)
4: "Black Grand" by SampleTekk (a Steinway grand)
Pros:
- in some way pretty realistic but also a bit "special" reverb
- pretty good playability
- very clean samples
- very fast to load (needs low performance)
Cons:
- the best version (with convolution reverb) only for GigaStudio which is not longer developed
- in my version only for Windows XP working (so I can't use this much longer in future)
Conclusions:
At the end it depends on the piece you want to record. I think I will use every of these pianos also in future. I just test for every piece which sounds the best before I decide.