Welcome to the Andy Here We Are Club how Andy Here We Are are ya? *note* part 3 & the finale is in this playlist kzfaq.info/sun/PLq7Wze90TsOrSNV7gD7SG-ikO6tBRJqPz

This isn't a toxic relationship, it's a nuclear waste dump relationship.

Imagine how boring this game would've been if Andrew just learned how to say no

"The mom's kinda... Appealing." Manly breaking the tension of the scene to let us all know he's a milf appreciator, legend behavior

Ashley just whispering in Andrew's ear the entire time while he's sleeping to gaslight him is the funniest plot point I've ever seen despite it being horrifying

Ashley despises Andrew, it's Andy she likes. Andy was the docile, submissive persona who went along with her every whim, but Andrew is the older, matured persona who will stand up to Ashley and her bullshit. Conversely, that's also why Andrew hates the Andy persona so much and wants to kill it, while Ashley and Leyley are pretty much the same. She's always been that deranged since she was a kid.

At this point, cannibalism feels like the least serious crime that they have committed

The parents were so neglectful and manipulative towards their children that they had to treat eachother as parental figures, which resulted in this fucked up relationship. Andrew was the "favored" child, meaning he had the more reasonable personality, but his presence in an abusive family meant he was submissive and clingy and believes that he doesn't deserve any form of real love or affection. Ashley was the "hated" child and clearly had some neuroatypical problems in the first place, meaning that all she ever learned about relationships was manipulation and that she cannot receive any form of attention or love without demanding it. They both grew up with a flawed understanding of love and affection, which was only compounded by the death of a child extremely early on forming a "callus" against any serious peer to peer relationships outside of their pair. This means that when puberty struck, their emotional isolation from the rest of the world and the peers and idols young teenagers would normally direct their burgeoning sexuality towards was instead restricted to eachother. This overcame the westermarck effect, so they were physically attracted to eachother. Andrew, as the more societally conscious of the pair, attempted to direct his sexuality towards other women, but was likely unable to maintain any kind of serious relationship and may not have ever actually progressed to actual sex (both due to a lack of genuine emotional connection and the rampant harrassment any girlfriend would take from Ashley). Ashley, as the one without any form of meaningful connection to anybody outside Andrew, focused her full attention on him, possibly without being initially aware of the what she wanted (after all, her understanding of relationships and sexuality is deeply flawed and underdeveloped), only to be repeatedly rejected due to social guidelines and Andrews' attempts to distract himself with other girls. Thus their deteriorating relationship up until the quarantine. That provided both a physical isolation from the rest of society that has forced them to confront the best and worst aspects of their relationship without interference and, in the form of the cannibalism, killing, and ensuing escape, a major enough shift in situation and relationship paradigm that the previous stand off could not be maintained, forcing a new relationship to be formed.

Ashley: we were TRAPPED in an apartment for MONTHS WITH NO FOOD, WE ALMOST STARVED TO DEATH mom: cry about it

Two loving siblings visit their parents and nothing bad happens

Never seen a toxic sibling relationship so depressing, funny, and disturbing at the same time

The deeper we dive into Ashley's past and evil deeds, the more you start to understand why the demons answered her call. Maybe it knew she won't have issues giving it what it want, compare to the rest of the characters, the cult included.

Everyone else: "Ashley is so hot!" ManlyBadassHero: "The mom's kinda... appealing." "God, I love souless eye characters." "The mom's got like a certain appeal, I'm sorry." This just had me cracking up!

Let's gooooooo, nothing better than watching the codependent relationship between a psychopath and a dude coping with PTSD, it's like watching coca cola and mints being mixed up over and over again

Never have i been so uncomfortable and so intrigued at the same time

hearing Manly explain in realistic detail how the investigation would go down if they found the kid's body is exactly what I expect from this channel

man the mom really said "Cry about it." that caught me off guard 💀15:17

can't wait for another episode with completely platonic sibling relationships

Ashley: Who has a fireplace? Manly: I do... Me: You rich bastard!

Shoutout to my parents for raising me well, call that a big win.

30:17 Had this pointed out to me; Andy’s hand looks like two of its fingers have been inserted into one of the belt loops on Ashley’s shorts. I’m guessing their mom wasn’t giving them the stink eye just for their suspicious whispering alone.

Andrew and Ashley’s relationship is definitely on the weird side if that isn’t obvious enough. There are subtle hints that the mom gets towards it, like Andrew having his finger in Ashley’s belt loop when she catches them talking ( 30:18 ), or when the mom sees the both of them at the end ( 1:05:15 )and Andrew holds a pillow over his lap while Ashley is on the ground…

1:01:01 if you notice Leyley’s hairpins look like eyes, and with two hairpins and her own eye, she has three eyes just like Lord Unknown

Manly being down bad for the mom is not something I expected but is very much welcome

and the line at 50:26 “they will take you away from me” just highlights the codependency really well, ashley is crazy but andrew really let her crazy grow cause he cuckoo himself

The way I got physically disgusted when Andrew told Julia to tie her hair up was absolutely insane. This game is really effective at make you feel uncomfortable as shit but you really can't get enough of it!

The story is disturbing and unsettling, but the art style is beautiful.

"The artwork is effective" Absolutely the right word. No matter how despicable the actions of the characters are, they're expressive, emotive and borderline primal at points. Much like Witch's Heart, Manly's delivery is something that makes this playthrough the way to watch. Thank you for your work on your videos as always, yo!

I find it funny everytime there is a questionable scene between the two, manly's responses with little noises like "ha.." or "hmm.." 😂

Wow, Andrew and Ashley’s relationship is really interesting. And I’m not talking about the incest part. Just how Ashley manipulates Andrew and stuff. Well written and inspiring (for writing). But VERY uncomfortable to watch haha ughhhh

Every time Manly says “you are Andrew” I say “yes I am” because that is my name lol

Ashley: we were starving to death! Mom: Ratio

Shame they didnt draw the dad, i would have liked to see the full set

I love how you just go "Mhmmm" at all the incest-innuendo in the game! It's... a perfect response.

Mom works so hard to keep her kids from giving her weird grandkids.

If people didn’t catch on from the last parts that Ashley is an objectively horrible person then here ya go lol

Ashley's a pretty tragic character. Neglected and abused by everyone because she was, well, utterly unlikable; and so she clung tightly to her brother, the only person in her life who didn't treat her badly. But she has such a deep-set insecurity, a feeling that no one could ever genuinely like her, that she felt the need to blackmail him into not abandoning her. She's completely callous, a real psychopath, but the only reason she became evil was because everyone treated her like garbage. That's just sad.

Old refrigerators were death traps for children - no way to open them from the inside. Modern refrigerators can be forced open from inside by children, it's why they're sealed magnetically. I think that's what you're remembering in this episode, when you're talking about children getting trapped in places and dying.

Oh yeah the kids could have easily gotten away with this, "Hey, we were playing hide and seek yesterday and we couldn't find her. We thought she went home after we called her name multiple times and she didn't respond."

the way hes audibly making a 😬 face every time the siblings get a little too "close" lmao

It REALLY worries me how much the Mom insists on the kids being separated Like, I know there was massive subtext before but holy fuck they’re basically saying it at this point

I like the “you’ve been behaving” at 27:49 and Manly just cackles like no you haven’t. Such an evil laugh too.

You know people have been kinda blaming all of this on Ashley. And don’t get me wrong, she deserves like 75% of the blame. But… Andrew is the one who’s actually committed every murder aside from the two the demon did, doesn’t actually feel remorseful about them, turned Ashley’s quick thought about the cultist being a lot of meat into Eating him, when prison was brought up he immediately was worried about being separated from Ashley, and as we can see by things like his finger going into Ashley’s belt loop, he is… very active in the less-than-wholesome sibling dynamic.

This shit is terrifying because I’ve lived it. To a much less severe degree in terms of the physical consequences, but I have a family member who is a lot like Ashley, and unfortunately, it wasn’t my sister, it was someone who had authority over me. I’ve never seen a piece of media more closely capture the hell of having a family member like this. It’s eerie

If Nemlei won't give us the mom route, the fanartists will provide.

Yeah I see why Ashley is crazy. Not excusing her actions but it's definitely nurture over nature here

ah yes. a 22 year old grown ass man suffering from trauma, while sticking together with his psycho sister. Very healthy relationship. They're just visiting their parents who left them alone to pay rent. Very good parenting. edit: now we be starting a whole debate fr

it's funny how sometimes manly is okay saying "fuck" and then other times you can tell he's trying really hard not to say "fuck"

dang. I'm realizing how nice and normal my siblings are.

I don't know why but when manly says bitch it's the funniest thing to me.

Honestly seeing the subreddit and all of the "Andrew being sus" videos made me more intrigued and just even more hooked in this game. Gonna have brainrot that's for sure.

Remember the choices: - Trust Andrew - Decline - Siblings above everything Brings best ending and start for chapter 3 (which is to come).

44:06 Seeing Andrew in a seemingly healthy relationship is so odd at this point

Ah yes, another episode of “How Far is Too Far,” with Manly!

Freud would have a field day with these two

The amount the artist manages with so little is crazy. I love the importance put on Color. Didn't know if this would be worth watching when I first saw the first vid, but now I'm excited to see more

So here's what I think. Ashley wasn't wanted by their parents, so they treated her poorly, while Andrew was treated nicely. Ashley lashes out against everyone, and they shun her for that. Andrew is the only person who is nice to her, so she latches on, and become totally dependent on him emotionally. Now her biggest fear is losing him, and she's do anything, murder, steal, gaslight and manipulate to get him to stay. "The child shunned by the village will burn it down to feel it's warmth"

When Andrew told Julia to put her hair up in a ponytail, I couldn't help but get the gitters. Then laughs it off and tells Julia that boys pull the hair of girls they like. Then those gitters turned into spine chills. I am on the tightrope of feelings. Heavy investment and gagging. 😂

WELL SHIT nvm i only caught a crumb of ep 2😭😭 this is why my autistic ass needs to pay more attention instead of putting vids on as bg noise im so sorry

Leyley: most people would be horrified to kill a child. Anakin: allow me to introduce myself

I absolutely LOVE this series, I don't think I've ever been so interested in two fictional characters like these. Honestly their behaviors are so authentic that it definitely comes from the creator's personal experience somehow. I love them in every way

It's like a trainwreck I can't stop being alarmingly invested in.

Tell me why, when Manly mentioned people dying because their back doors were unlocked, I immediately checked every lock in the house.

*"Wow, mom's kinda... appealing."* My man's got his priorities straight! 🔥🔥🔥

Ain't no way andy pulled a 10/10 just for her to break up with him because of his sister.💀💀💀💀💀

something about this just tells me there is going to be a certain community that... makes alot of "art" with these characters

1:01:35 Aaaaand poor Andrew got an eye infection from Ashley's blood getting in his eye. LOL Also the cultist in Andrew's dream has a point. If you didn't understand the thespian-style speech, he was basically saying that Ashley and Andrew were idiots for leaving his limbs in their freezer, in their apartment, because the fire likely didn't destroy them completely due to a freezer being insulated.. So there most likely _Is_ some sort of search or investigation going on about their disappearance. They'd know that Ashley and Andrew didn't die in the fire. No bodies.

Despite Andrew and Ashley being the textbook definition of toxic siblings, I'd reckon they still love each other more than most siblings.

1:05:15 The location of the pillow and all the buildup makes the mother have good reason to wonder if her family tree will end up as a ladder

manly's reaction when their mom appears... priceless

I love the subtle "HMMMMMM"s you do when shit gets incestual, gold

🎶Ashley's mom has got it goin' on... 🎶

I wonder if the parent's distaste with their kids' mere existence is because they were was always secretly aware of how unusually close they were, like closer than you'd expect your average siblings to be. Hence why the mom chastises them for still being around each other even to this day and absolutely insisting that they sleep separately. No incest in her house. I'm guessing that the parents were both happier at the thought of having dead kids, as opposed to incestuous kids, when they left them behind at that crummy apartment. That's all I can think of to explain the mom's utter indifference to seeing them alive. But then again, almost everyone in this world is a dickhead so I could be dead wrong And Ashley is still the worst

I love this game’s humor. “There is fuck-all under the flowerpot.”

All they really had to do was take the stick out of the chest and knock over a shelf onto it. Girl climbed in on her own. A small animal or something knocked over the shelf because it's an abandoned warehouse. The shelf was too heavy for her to push it off the chest. Perfect murder. If andrew and ashley get connected to the area at all, they were playing hide and seek, that's why she got in on her own. So far that's not even a lie. ley and andy just never found her and assumed she went home

Manly being thirsty for the mom’s style is definitely my favorite part of the video

Brah- I talked about it last video but this makes it even worse. The first thing the mom does when confronted by Ashely is lie and then shove her off onto Andrew. Like instantly "Shouldn't you be bugging Andrew by now." she needs a kick to the throat as well. It's also really interesting how quickly Andrew falls into the good son role for the mother. She doesn't question anything he says and believes him when he lies. Ashely is silent for a good chunk of the first half just because Andrew can talk. It's all bullshit of course, in the kitchen when he's trying to talk to Ashely. It seems to be implying the mom has always been cold and distant it just Andrew picked up how to fling it back in her face. What also gets me rolling around in anger is that the mom has the nerve to say. "Don't you two get tired of each other?" WHAT DO YOU MEAN!? They have no one but each other. Especially, Ashley, Andrew can at least fake it till you make but Ashley is a lost cause. Andrew out here having to say he Chose Ashely cause she has abandonment issues. An does what annoys me more than the fact she knows they (Andrew and Ashely) have a weird relationship. Like she catches them in the kitchen whispering and Andrew's fingers in Ashely's short loop. She emphasizes that they need to sleep in different areas like come on. At least have the extra pair to call your kids out for what you think they're doing. The fact she probably thinks it's not her fault. That the kids are just like that her parenting was fine. It is clear Andrew is spiraling too, seeing how he has the whole dream. Where he has to compartmentalize the whole fucked up situation. Also, Ashley is to blame for a good chunk of it too. Like Andrew isn't innocent not by a long shot. But got damn does he pale in comparison to his sister. Like- Andrew's whole dream had me screaming. He can't catch a break and Ashely is just the worst. It is also very interesting, how the eye and the mouth are part of the blood pact. I'm guessing Andrews gonna lose an eye and Ashely will lose her ability to speak. This would be fitting for her because she uses her words to fuck with Andrew. I hope so bad the mom finishes what she was saying. I wanna hear just the bullshit she's about to say. Like this whole game has me shaking my phone. There's so much to talk about honestly. But I can't wait for the next part. I do share the whole, I hope they don't die. I feel like that such the obvious way to go. Ashely dies goes to hell and Andrew stays alive or they both die and that's the end. Like I wouldn't be surprised but I would want something different.

People say that Ashley's the only psycho one here, but it's clear Andrew's pretty batshit too in his own way. Not caring about killing but rather getting caught, even when young, and seemingly not worried about losing personal attachments, despite being so desperate for them outside of Ashley. Seems to me they're both attention seeking psychos, and always have been to an extent.

It's weird how close they get, Andy passing his finger for the trouser loops of Ashley pants when they're in the kitchen with their parents in the bedroom knowing they can wake up and see them at any moment, andy covering with a pillow when the mom wake up and Ashley in her knees so weird moments of incest

something I noticed when the mom came in at 30:16: Andrew had his fingers through Ashley's belt loop on her shorts

Part 3 is gonna be craaazy

I think it's interesting in the story that so far a lot of people blame everything on Ashley and reach the conclusion that Andrew is a by-product of manipulation and abuse, but if you think about it, andrew never actually seems to feel guilt for any of his murders, he is only scared of the consequences. Like nina (girl in the box), i noticed when he finds out, he's only worried he'll go to prison and not the fact that the girl had a life and family and is now dead. Everytime he is shown as scared in the story is actually only the fear of being caught, not the fear of his actions. I definitely think that Ashley is the main driving force towards the siblings actions becoming increasingly worse, but i do think that as they are siblings they probably will have the same tendencies, i think andrew certainly isn't normal either, but as he says a suspicious amount in the video, he prefers to ''keep up appearences'' and act normal to blend in, where as ashley prefers to do whatever she wants no matter the consequence in order to have things her way regardless of what others think. Whether it's psycopathy who knows? And this is besides all the potential incest that appears to be happening. I guess we'll see next time though...

🗣: "You are Andrew" 🤖: "I am Andrew" 😂

Wow, this is just.. nice, a very interesting relationship between brother and sister

Mother: I hope it is not what it seems. Son: It is not. Daughter: It is worst.

I love the little touch of when Ashley is dreaming about the incident Nina's name is blank and you find out in Andrew's dream that Ashley said she'd forget her name.

"mom's kind of... appealing" -MBH, 2023

This game is so strange, so uncomfortable, it treats so many morbid completely fucked up topics, yet... i can't stop watching, it is so intriguing I wonder how all of this will end, tho the comments have me worried now...

the mom is such a baddie bro

It's been a long, very long time since I have seen a visual novel this engaging. The art-style, as you said, is extremely effective, and so is the storytelling!

3 parts in and we've already learned how much of an obsessive monster she is to andrew. Thwarting any attempt he took to try to have a normal life. Truly a monster

we reaching past the C O Z E Z O N E

The "toys", the lingerie, the second bed down in the basement. "I'm actually quite well liked". Yeah, I think we know what's happening here.

At 44:15 when he asks her to tie her hair up, literal chills up my back. You know what he's implying and it shows that's super weird, beyond weird. I think a lot of people like to blame LeyLey for every messed up thing in their relationship but really, Andrew has all too much skin in this. Imagine asking your gf to wear your sister's hairstyle, right after a hard conversation like that? I think he's definitely been wrong by LeyLey but as for his victimhood? I can't see him as one.

The more I see of this game, the more invested I get, in an unexplainable way. I have never been made so uncomfortable by a game before. It's like watching the best trainwreck ever, where everyone dies but no one gets hurt.

This is a very wholesome game. I'll go ahead and recommend this to my goth sister. Thanks man!

Bro I'm fiending for that third episode. This is one of the first let's plays in awhile where I've been so invested in the series.

Julia and Andrew were so cute together. Never thought I'd be so excited to see him with someone else other than whatever he got going on with his sister

Honestly can't wait for part 3. I've been really enjoying this series! The characters are really well written. They're outlandish enough to be interesting, but grounded enough to be believable

Wow, I can’t believe they went to the basement to do their laundry at this hour. How responsible of them! Surely nothing else could be foreshadowed with those two going into a basement.