Andrew sir, i noticed that everytime you paint your brushes are new, no old pigments or whatsoever that pigment that is left, brushes really is the key to good brush strokes, regarding your painting is really amazing salute you sir i learn a lot from your demo.

I love the new one - the mnt was separated from the front before, now you can see the connection.

The only thing I can think of to make this painting perfect…. Location! It needs to be hanging in my home! Love your work pal!

You are one of the youtubers who have inspired me to stop "hoarding" art supplies and start using them. I have to say, I really enjoy painting and thank you.

The first painting was definitely claustrophobic with the two trees on either side. The new one just makes me feel so much more free and the brighter colours make the scene so much more alive. Definitely a good choice when removing the tree on the right.

Andrew, watching you paint is so mesmerising. I learnt so much from this video, both during the critique session and the painting session.( I must admit, I was thinking it was a test for us.) I just love the changes you did to this image and it is refreshing to know and to assure all of us, that even you, who I have put right up there on the highest pedestal, is humble enough to allow us to critique your work and you took it on the chin and went with the flow. Thank you so much. I just love watching you create your magic and all the comedy is a bonus. Keep on doing what you are doing

AWESOME ANDREW. YOU'RE A YOUNG MASTER, AND VERY WISE AND YET NOT WHITE OF HAIR YET. ANYONE WHO WILL EVER MET YOU WILL WALK AWAY A MUCH RICHER PERSON. MUCH LOVE TO YOU DEAR BROTHER. GOD BLESS ALWAYS, YOU ARE A BLESSING TO ALL OF US. THANK YOU FOREVER. LOVE LIGHT & PEACE BE WITH YOU AT ALL TIMES. Bruce Bissell in Southwest Utah,

Taking the tree out was a brilliant idea. The glazier and top of the waterfall are no longer fighting for dominance. It's beautiful Andrew.

I really like the composition you came up with finally, I could see your episodes forever. Stunning landscape, it's really eerie to think it's imaginary

Who else in the world would have done what you just did, invited whoever's to critique your work.? You are an exceptional person with the exceptional Talent an exceptional paintings. Love your videos. Thank you.

This picturesque is a continual flow of water, a good scene connected from where it is, then to our sight, so nice.. Awesome.

You have entered the realm of "The Hoff". Now all that's left is the "Dimension of the Shat". Good luck and Godspeed.

Wow,! Amazing video sharing. It's really helpful for beginners. Very interesting and informative tips. Keep continue Stay healthy and happy always 😊👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Great job! My art instructor said to me,”One must always be teachable to reach the simplest of sophistication.”

You are a top painter. one can only admire you, sometimes call you a machine or a program, but that is all one can. I admire your world ... there will be a lot and a lot of work behind it all, I would say almost your whole life. Magician with brushes ...

Amazing, I loved watching your thought process and design. Thank you!

Looking great!Good to see you're leaving the water pouring off the canvas gives the painting an exciting dynamic.

I would shift the angle of perspective on the last waterfall as to keep the details in the right bank. Push the left bank more into the mid-ground by changing the tones & reducing the details. Extend the width of the canvas & lower the horizon line to include more sky. I 💛 the flow lines of the waters.

A great insight to Tish process, thank you Andrew. I love both before and after

Your block-in stage is far better and detailed than my finnished paintings :(

I cannot tell when you posted this, but I know I am late to the party. However, I have to say that there was only ONE part of your original painting that really, really stuck out for me, and here's why. I live in the extreme southeast region of Virginia, otherwise known as Tidewater. So as you might imagine, I am not very familiar with the geography of New Zealand. As a consequence, when I first saw this painting, I thought the glacier was WATER, so to me it seemed to be defying gravity, floating somehow.. I was puzzled that no one mentioned it until you began to comment on glaciers. THEN the lights went on, and I had to laugh at myself. I just thought you might want to know that the particular portion where the glacier originally sat may not "read" as ice for a lot of people. THANK YOU SO MUCH for posting this. You are one of those rare people: an artist who is not afraid of criticism, who is "real," along with being (I think) one of THE most talented artists I have seen these days. Thanks again....Susanne

I really liked this video. Thank you for sharing your amazing job!!

Hello Andrew, you are doing fine and this video is giving anserws to many good questions. Your painting is efortless and brave. Your presentation is a genius show. Thank you very much.

Great thought process. Will revisit some of my older paintings with your comments in mind.

Thank you very much for the wonderful video. Thank you very much and very interesting thanks ..For ..sharing videos .. thanks for sharing . 💯..💓.💓 ...💯...

Wonderful. I really like how it's opened up, shows more mountain, and the continuity of the water flowing really opens the dynamic

Itis magnificent how the color gradually takes on life and form. Beautiful, i really love it

You are amazing. I stopped painting years ago but you are giving the drive to start again. Thank you 💞

Seriously i am 60 years old and i love your step by step tutorials : you will always find someone slanderous to criticize.... Let say you are at the top. To say you teach me to me an old !!! Thank you for tutorials. A old fan

I enjoyed hearing your thinking process on this! I am finishing a small painting of a scene with white water rapids and this was helpful!

YOU are a giant of the painting world!

I like both. I like the more light and openness in the 2nd one. The second one "invites me in" as you are famous for teaching us. Thank you for this. I enjoyed it all. I am learning a lot from you that I apply to my acrylics and colored pencil pieces. I am still afraid to do oils with my solvent sensitivity. I may copy your studio ventilation and begin doing oils.

If you a german, this whole Tischler being tisched makes even more fun and sense in a way. Thats because and I think you already know this, Tischler is the german word for the guy who builds Tables (german Tisch) chairs and all the other furniture one may need. But here it gets a bit deeper. If you put someone or something to the test, in german it meens you bring it to the table (Tisch) The Tischler gets tisched is the literally expression of what you guys and gals have done in this video. Greetings from Germany.

Love your tutorials Andrew ! Very very informative for artist’s perspective like myself… my inspiration on landscape subjects was in my heart again! More Blessings Maestro!!

I so like the detailed painting process letting me “see how.” Also have been enjoying the critiquing videos and the What Itf? You are so fun to listen to and I appreciate you sharing your knowledge with us.

This is absolutely amazing ! Too beautiful for words. You are a star Andrew.

You put in all of the work...planning, critiques fresh ideas and views points! Love the finished painting!

Simply: beautiful!

This was so cool, I like the updated version way better. I always learned so much from critiques…felt like I was back in painting class. Big ups, thanks for posting!!

IT is such a pleasure and honor to watch your content! You bless all aspiring artist!

I love this painting!!! It looks stunning and better than the first one, although the first one was great as well. Thank you for your inspiration, I'm happy for watching this video! I'm impressed with technic and color matching, and composition 🤩

You know what I think….as someone who also paints? I think there isn’t a painting anywhere that can’t be changed if you pick at it long enough. I love your work….I like how YOU see a scene and wouldn’t change one single thing. The 2 d painting is nice. It just doesn’t draw me in and have the “ forest feel” that I got with the first one. In the end,it’s just a matter of opinion is ‘nt it and there are as many as there are viewers. Bottom line…..paint it as YOU see and feel it and I’m going to love it!

Excellent! I loved all of it! Hi from South Africa! Cannot wait for the next one!

@Andrew Tischler I think you are incredibly talented and so very generous with your Patreon fee, unlike so many artists on YT who ask so much more but have far less talent. I love watching your videos and hearing what you have to say. Your presentation is brilliant. Unfortunately, the last time I tried oil was in the Caribbean, and I got home one day and my rubbish painting had slid off the canvas onto the floor with the heat. Yep. I think it looked better on the floor. My real love is watercolour (I'm also rubbish at that). Watercolour. Colour. I like bright colours. When I returned to the UK from the Caribbean, landed at the airport, I said, "Who turned the lights off?" All the colour had gone. Colour, which is so magical. Now when I looked at the painting at 6:57 my eyes lit up. Pop. Colour. Have you even seen the art by Alfredo Rodriguez? I think you know what I am saying. I will shut up now and get back in my amateur corner. 🤐

Great stuff thanks for sharing

Thank you. I’ve just discovered you and have been watching some of you videos and I’ve learned so much. I can not say thank you enough.

beautiful! Thumbs up! 👍👍👍

I was looking for a video on painting rocks and this is top of the world quality, thank you and thank you for sharing the process of transferring the image.

Loving how it shows no one is above critique. All that feedback really took this piece to the next level. The warm light and breathing room in the composition really draws me in. Thank you for sharing!

Thank you Andrew enjoyed watching. Love to watch you paint you're a great guy! Great attitude! Good sport! Looks as if you had fun. And I did too. Thank you. Paint your paintings, love it. On occasion I tried to oil paint myself. I started out with the familiar things of landscape. A lot more simple than your work. I can tell you that for sure. LOL now I'm trying what I never used to care for it still life a lot more challenging than I thought. Same as if everything has got to be propped. And most of it is not natural looking. It looks prompt! Landscape is so natural for the most part! Would love it if you would help people like me with painting still life appreciate it much . God bless your little heart!

🤣🤣🤣 love it.! So cute. Love love your humor.

That original is stunning! Put that tree back in on the right and don't change a thing! 😁... You drew me into this life changing, breathtaking view, captured the essence of it's beauy, then want to take it away? I don't think so... 😉 I really liked your openness and willingness to have some fun with being "Critiqued" but all those changes were hard to take!.. Thank you for all your amazing video's!

I am totally in awe! I liked the first version however the second version was that step further into a master piece. Looking forward to seeing the next stage and heading over to join your Patreon. I was interested too, in you having a love of Alaska. I too have that. It steals a part of your soul. Thank you for all you do.

This video is so good with the content that I wanted and you're the only artist Andrew who I really look up to and the number of paintings are going on in your studio ...it really pushes me to do more and more work 🙌🏻 looking forward to part 2😄

Love your painting just the way it is… not busily cluttered with animals.

On the original one, the glacier just seemed like it was just sitting there, as in a cup, not having a route where it came from to get there. So I like you expanding the glacier and giving it a home path because before, my eye kept going to that and ignoring the rest. Eliminating the right-hand tree really brought the two halves together and allowed my eye to roam down the mountain, from the glacier to the rocky slope, into the top of the river and follow it down to the bottom of the painting. I think that one tree just blocked the flow. Great job, loved it.

I am loving your videos, you are a total inspiration to all begginners and professionals! I have personally learned so much from your videos. KEEP UP THE FANTASTIC WORK! Cheers from Australia

Awesome Andrew, love the new update composition. Impressive mate..

Wow! it was worth the critic! it makes sense, it has the "S" shape water flow..I get it. I have to share a true experience I had several years ago in L.A. Museum of Art I'm pretty sure it was there. They had a John Singer Sargent exhibit (also one of my favorite artists) in which one of his paintings/watercolors was a scene of closeup rocks with rushing water.. I don't know what it was about that painting that every time I saw it I had to go and get a drink of water as I became very thirsty. I just couldn't get my eyes off that painting/watercolor. I would leave that area gawked at other of his paintings and had to go back to see that one particular water scene, and again I had to go and drink some more water. After I saw your painting and at mid-waterfall and following it down, I got thirsty and took me back to those particular paintings (watercolor)? of Sargent's. I believe they're "Mountain Torrent, Mountain Stream, Glacier stream and Mountain waterfall) I believe these were in the exhibit. So, if your painting got me to go get a drink of water, Sargent better move aside a little, The Tisch has arrived. Thank you very much for a great and very educational video. Take care!

I really enjoy your videos. They are informative and edited well. I tried painting with acrylics many years ago. Watching your videos is helping me build up confidence to try oil.

I love the re-make!

Amazing work you have inspired me to get back to painting

At first I was like it looks great just the way it is... but after he removed the right tree.. WOW I didn't know it would make that of a drastic difference. So much better

My only change was making the tree on right smaller or into a bush. So happy to see yoù are changing it!

awesome video. So happy I discovered your work :)

I have a theory based on a comment by an old art teacher who said one doesn't commission a painting of oneself from Rembrandt, one gets a improvisation of oneself as Rembrandt. He meant that Rembrandt invariably inserted his own likeness into the portrait. Through 40 years of my own art practice in landscape/portraiture and still life, my curiosity about my teachers comment led me to believe ( and it bears peer reviewing of this theory) that almost all painters inject a kind of likeness into their works (most obvious in landscape) of themselves. ie: bald head=clear open sky.....asymmetric face=asymmetric landscape......dark complexion[hair/skin=low key painting [alternatively light complexion=high key painting], elemental weights and their placement according to facial build (eg: close set eyes/long nose/high or low cheek bones) etc. This is to say that personal preference when choosing and designing a composition and key seem more the personal discrimination of the artist based on their own physical appearance and individual ego. Also, their seems to be a consistency in the choice of composition, particularly when it comes to directional flow eg: water or road leading off the right corner/edge or the left. This is a working theory and I'd be interested to know what others think of this concept and if it has any logical or even legitimate weight. I might add that a recognizable image in painting or photo of an artist and comparing them to their catalogs of works helped me in determining my theory. It has helped me when I am commissioned to do works for clients who have entirely different complexions/facial structures to myself. Ordinarily, darker complexion featured clients prefer darker keyed paintings etc. If you lasted this long in my wordy essay, well done you and thanks.

I love this .. Its really amazing

Love the constructive critique format of this video. Also love your paintings and look forward to seeing the modeling/detail stages!

I truly like the idea of letting others critique my work with questions; "what's working"..."what's not working"...and "what IF."

Wow! You took it to the next level!

I preferred the wider waterfall in the lower half...more interesting. The change made that waterfall look more typical of other paintings I've seen. All the other changes are spot on, except please put that bit of sky back at the top to make for some great water reflections and for a few more highlights on the lower rocks. Beautiful painting!

That was a fantastic video! Thank you

Awesome Change. Loved it.

Wow! Your videos have improved a lot, it's so much more entertaining now❤

You are a true master! I personally loved both versions. ❤❤❤

Both paintings where good I like the second one with the more open look with water .. fantastic work Andrew

that fire explosion made me hit the like button

I like Rachael's comment. That painting held it's own and this is just another separate painting so you can't loose Andrew. You now have two gorgeous paintings. Thanks for the peek at other infamous artistic works as well. They just really opened the view of what all we we're looking at and it sparks all our imaginations. They definitely look like places we'd like to be spending time in. Well done Andrew and it's good to see how you take those "What if's." Let's face it the possibilities are endless. What matters is you keep your mind's eye open to broadening the view without taking it as a rejection of your concept. Creators create and seeing even more ways to do that is exciting. If I stand still gazing out a huge picture window at a mountain, all kinds of changes happen just with the passing of time. The light and color and nature are always happening around us. I like to think of it as watching God paint. We all know that if we move a few steps to the right or the left, the whole scene, perspective and meaning can change. It's exciting isn't it? Build on what you have and thank you for sharing and adding to our possibilities. Thanks.

Absolutely love this one, and for sure use projection, who has time to sketch, just get busy painting...love it!

Thanks again again again. Very interesting video. Since my painting teacher's health has failed her and she has quit teaching, I haven't got a built in critique group (our class). And I MISS it. It's so true that the artist becomes more or less blind to what's good/bad/ etc. Do we ever get to see Rachel? We already love her.

That intro 😂 Your videos have such quality!!

It’s amazing how just removing a tree changes the picture

I’ve missed you for a few months but so glad I have You(Tube) back ♥️

♥️ amazing artwork 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

I love your videos so much Andrew I love to paint and watch you is the best part in my week XD

I love critiques so much 😆 they always make you reconsider and think from a different perspective. The size of those trees on the right side mid ground hold similar size, that’s my primary critique. Maybe can still have two bigs and one medium, medium size tree in the mid ground, right to funnel eye towards the falls. Those epic paintings you mentioned before are primarily getting that atmosphere from the lighting, almost heavenly spot glow with a combination of sharpe planes of light and softer direct light. Brilliant work, absolutely fantastic to consistently be considering the geology and flora. You’re making me want to come back to painting and spend less time on work. Edit: You had the right idea about the whole glacier change, one medium skewed triangle shape to the waterfall, another larger skew triangle following to the right side of the picture plane following the top mountain’s ridge line. That would have been ooooooooosonoice. (medium skew triangle leads to waterfall cavity, large skew triangle following ridge line to the right side of picture plane, then medium tree size dip on the right mid ground trees to lead eye back towards the waterfall. You’re so good at textures !😖)

How good is this👍👍👍👍 I use Procreate, so I’m going to try the same approach. Your method is superb! I like your blocking in as it is, slightly looser feel really gives movement to the painting, brilliant!

I Love it looks so good

loved the process. it helps.

this brush is a good thing to happen , looks very willing to work

Andrew you are amazing. It felt so nice you did it twice. And thank you for your good humour. You can be a serious little rooster sometimes so it was fun to hear and see your reactions to your ex-friends.

Hi Andrew, You, are the best painter I have ever seen. Love it

Your painting is beautiful compositionally,,,,even that waterfall running off the canvas. Unless you are just wanting to be picky or find something simply for conversation it is unlikely that someone that isn’t an artist will find a thing “wrong” with it. If I went by first impression, the only thing “lacking” might be some warmer tones in there somewhere. It has a very cool look even though it’s a summer scene.

Andrew, this is awesome. One of your absolute very best in my opinion. Your artistry talent is amazing.

I'm speechless, Andrew!!

The one thing everybody’s missing is temperature. it lacks temperature . Bierstadt was huge temperature painter . This is what it needs if it even needs anything at all .

LMPAO thanks for the Saturday laugh totally needed this. (fabulous intro voice over lol) Love your work btw :D even though I work in wc or graphite but still picked up many many tricks and ways to think about the art creating process :D Thank you.

Wow. I really love it all. Though, definitely like the water falling off the bottom right corner...just makes the eye flow...and I especially like the more saturated colors. This was super helpful. Thank you

The result of your artwork is very interesting to me..Thank you for Sharing this.

Brilliant Andrew, the changes look great. I thought the initial design was fantastic, but what a difference now. The block in could be a finished work for most of us mere mortals out here. Love it. 👏👏👍