Thanks!

@@TrevortheTrainFan NP

And I meant I not o in the sentence if you notice that anyone

@@TrevortheTrainFan Aren't you forgetting the fact Charlie at least got redeemed by Season 17 when Andrew Brenner took over? That's part of the potential of being good and he did actually get better right?

@@randomnessetc5600 To be fair, I think Not Now Charlie is a slight improvement over Ho Ho Snowman, but still not the best of the Brenaissance era. But yeah, you're right. I should've mentioned that here. I'll put Not Now Charlie in the honorable mentions of my Top 25 Best Andrew Brenner Episodes video in the future.

How disrespectful of Mattel 😤😤🤬🤬. They will PAY.

And I can imagine Willbert Awdry coming back as a Ghost just to haunt Ace by doing things like those ghost horror movies do

That is actually how I portray them. Only as a bonus, Bash sometimes has a stutter.

@@donevangarrison1760 Like Theo.

@@JonathanAsiamah Yes

I have them as a Duke, Stewart and falcon kind of dynamic with a couple of differences

As in focus on their traits in the spotlight?

Wow. I like these ideas and agree on Dennis.

@@margogoralski6294 Or Charlie and Billie being hard working, comedian engines duo with better jokes and doing them to the trucks during their work and to the engines during their sparetime.

I admire those three

Like how Rosie is the Amy equivalent at the beginning

I like Nia and Rebecca too

I think Rebecca Is okay. Damn really Trevor? Charlie Is a really funny character.

I bet the Brenner era would give them good treatment.

Scooby Doo Mystery Incorporated Scrappy reference.

And that’s totally fine! 😉

@@TrevortheTrainFan And not to mention the Misty Island location,That's Underrated as well.

Good job being civil to him. If you said something harsh, he would beat you up for sure!

Especially for more story potential in Brenner era style with good writing on them such as helping out at Henry's Forest part time.

Sounds like an interesting idea! 💡

@@TrevortheTrainFan Thank you. Always open your mind to the possibilities, even with characters you're not fond of.

Maybe.

@@TrevortheTrainFan in my head-canon for Billy he used to work on the W&S, back then, his name was William William/Billy arrived with his brother Charles/Charlie in 1913, and they were troublemakers to the other engines and would always play tricks on the engines even the other W&S engines, Sir Topham Hatt would always tell them off, but William and Charles didn't care, however in 1926, they were sent away they were bought by another railway where they were repainted different colors and given new names, William was repainted orange and renamed Billy and Charles was repainted purple and renamed Charlie, they worked on the line for 46 years until it closed down but then they were bought by the NWR in 1972, and became official members of the NWR Billy became the NWR's 13 and Charlie became the NWR's 14

No, it's not bad. I think it's okay to have different opinions as long as you have good reasons for it.

Fully agreed, especially about the Cars stuff.

I like Dennis

@@trainguy2007 I also like Dennis as well, to bad he never made it into the CGI era. Oh well at least we have fan content.

@@victorgaminglounge3967 yeah he's in my series

@@victorgaminglounge3967 Yes, but do worry, in the future, I promise you that I will get hold of official thomas, scrap BWBA and other trash, and bring back characters, fix issues like bouncing and Nia and Rebecca and stuff, adapt awdry stories, follow up on previously show ideas, etc. And I wouldn't do it alone. So have hope my friends.

@Joshua W56 eh just take out nia and rebekah and then add molly and another female engine and then im good 😆

@Joshua W56 lol but yea it might be cool only if rebekah wasn't acting like a 2 year old lol

I'm not the only one who thought about Molly as a good replacement. James A. Williams also mentioned her in his History of Thomas & Friends video.

I like Nia and Rebecca, Nia is feisty, clever, stands no nonsense and fun loving, Which makes her my favorite foreign character from BWBA. As for the Logging Locos, I like them, mostly Bash and Dash

Thanks!

It’s supposed to be a mad face.

Because Trevor’s mad face is never shown in the model series

Sure thing! I used to like Doug Walker until that Not-So-Awesome document showed up back in April of 2018. And after watching a few videos about it at the time, I've decided to unsubscribe from Channel Awesome because I thought it was the right thing to do, and I don't want to support a company that treats its employees like trash.

@@TrevortheTrainFan Agreed. I more so stopped watching after discovering the video flaws after watching Shinobi-03's series on NC's Jurassic Park reviews.

@@margogoralski6294 I may not be a Jurassic Park fan because I don't know too much about dinosaurs, but I enjoy watching Shinobi-03's Jurassic Park videos (esp. his commentaries on the Nostalgia Critic).

@@TrevortheTrainFan Wow. Cool! I love them, too!

No one was replaced stupid

The fuck are you talking about?

@@iceeblueburst03, I didn't have a problem with Edward leaving the cast, he chose to move as he stated himself it is closer to his branchline and when Nia first came to Sodor, he was kind to let her have his berth, Because the shed that she used to live in was demolished and couldn't be rebuild again and she didn't have a home.

I think Mattel should stop bringing in new female characters to replace the old one

Yeah, a little bit, but if you like them, that's fine.

I think that would be redundant because I've just uploaded this video.

@@TrevortheTrainFan ok

Yes, he should've apologized to Thomas in the end. That would've made it a more satisfying conclusion to the episode.

I agree.

Yeah Me too I'm surprised Thomas never got mad at him

I knew that! lol

Well, because her character wasn't really established or built-up in the show. That's why I consider her a Mary Sue. If you want more information on that, look at the Unlucky Tug's video on Big World Big Adventures.

And that’s perfectly fine.

team zug also likes Billy, so you're not alone.

@@TrevortheTrainFan i do too. He's actually my favorite character

I do

Thanks, and I respect your opinion.

And that's totally fine!

@@TrevortheTrainFan, Yes Indeed

Speaking of, I should've added Philip in the honorable mentions earlier.

@@TrevortheTrainFan if you go to my channel and see my least favorite character video I think you can understand why I hate him so much

@@donevangarrison1760 Sure, I can go check it out.

That's cool! 😀

Ashima didn't replaced Henry, that was Rebecca

Along with Dennis with realistic flaws, learning his lesson fully and Norman being the kinder, hard working twin brother who is the straight engine who helps and keeps Dennis in order.

I knew that.

Thank you for respecting my opinion. But still, I don't like Dennis that much.

What is it?

@@TrevortheTrainFan Twilight Sparkle or Sci Twi - Thomas Sunset Shimmer - Edward Fluttershy - Henry Rainbow Dash - Gordon Rarity - James Pinkie Pie - Percy Applejack - Toby Starlight Glimmer - Duck Kiwi Lollipop - Donald Supernova Zap - Douglas Trixie - Oliver Juiluis Oppeheimer Jr ( From TAWOG ) - Diesel Snips - Bill Snails - Ben Wallflower Blush - Boco Vignette Valenica - Daisy Juniper Montage - Mavis Gumball Watterson ( From TAWOG ) - Stepney Dora Marquez ( From DAFITC ) - Emily or Lady Spike - Bertie Spongebob Squarepants ( From the same name ) - Salty Grizzly Bear ( From WBB ) - Harvey Brittany Biskt ( From LPS ) or Danno Wofle ( CG2FTM ) - Arry Whittany Biskt ( From LPS ) or Agent Trout ( From WBBTM ) - Bert Darwin Watterson ( From TAWOG ) - Fergus Sour Sweet - Skarloey Sunny Flare - Rheneas Sugarcoat - Sir Handel Lemon Zest - Peter Sam Indigo Zap - Rusty Babs Seed or Eric Cartman ( From SP ) - Duncan Granny Smith - Duke Stewie Griffin ( From FG ) - Bertram Daniel Tiger ( From DTN ) - Ivo Hugh La Sirena Mala ( From DAFITC ) - Smudger Mariana the Mermaid ( From DAFITC ) - Freddie Terence and Philip ( From SP ) - Mighty Mac Pearlie ( From the same name ) - Protues Dottie Mcstuffins ( From DM ) - Victor Annie ( From BP ) - Luke Nancy Clancy ( From FN ) - Millie Penny Fitzgerald ( From TAWOG ) - Arthur Rob ( From TAWOG ) - Diesel 10 Chi ( From TAWOG ) - Splatter Ribbit ( From TAWOG ) - Dodge Principal Celestia - Sir Topham Hatt Timber Spruce - Terence Franklin ( From same name ) - Trevor Princess Thunder Guts or Backpack ( From DAFITC ) - Toad Gloriosa Daisy or Zephyr Breeze - Derek Scott Tenorman ( From SP ) - Bugly Nicole Watterson ( From TAWOG ) - Elizbeth Miss Smian ( From TAWOG ) - George Wordgirl/Becky Botsfod ( From WordGirl ) - Murdoch Nom Nom ( From WBB ) - Spencer Carrie Krueger ( From TAWOG ) - Caroline Benson ( From RS ) or Larry Needlemeyer ( From TAWOG ) - Cranky Evil Trurtle ( From TAWOG ) - S.C. Ruffey Vice Princpial Luna - Mr Pervical Discord ( From MLPFIM ) - Harold Star Butterfly ( From SVTFOE ) - Rosie Evil Trurtle Babies ( From TAWOG ) - Troublesome Trucks Marina Del Rey ( From TLM3 ) or Classic Caillou ( From Vyond ) or Mickey Mouse ( From SP ) - Stanley the mid sodor engine Princpial Brown ( from TAWOG ) or somelse - Bulstrode Kirby ( From the same name ) or Blythe Baxter ( From LPS ) or someone else - Stanley Prinpical Cinch - The Spikeful Van Idk - Jank, Afile, Oliver, Max and Monty, Kelly, Byron, Ned, Isobella, Paatrick, Buster, Nelson, Nigel, Dcray and Brendam Adaigo Dazzle - Lorry 1 Aria Bazzle - Lorry 2 Sonata Dusk - Lorry 3 Raffish Rahlp ( From TBB ) or Supereme Dog ( From A) - Bowler, D261, The Diesel Arthur Read ( From A ) or someone else - Whiff DW Read ( From A ) or someone else - Scruff Richard Watterson ( From TAWOG ) - Dennis Stellauna ( From the same name ) - Jeremy Princess Sofia ( From STF ) - Molly Tobias Wilson ( From TAWOG ) - Billy What do you think?

@@isaiahrodriguez896 Interesting.

@@TrevortheTrainFan What do think?

@@isaiahrodriguez896 I think it's interesting that you cast MLP characters as Thomas ones.

Do you actually hate Vinny

They look similar but with different placed domes. That’s why I made that mistake.

Fair enough.

@@TrevortheTrainFan Can I ask a question. Are you aware of these fan made characters: Timothy (Ghost) and Alfred, if so, why didn’t you include them in the villains video, not trying to sound specific or anything, just wanna know

@@reptisaurusking8494 I don't include fan characters because they're non-canon. I only focus on the more official Thomas stuff.

@@TrevortheTrainFan Okay, that’s a fair point, but still it would’ve been really cool if you included them, no offense

That's fine if you like Billy.

I like Billy too