Correction: I meant to say thank you for over 3.41K Subscribers, NOT 34,000 Subscribers. I'm so, SO SORRY, I don't know how I miscalculated that! I'm usually not very good at math, you know! Maybe I will reach 34K eventually, but I'm never going to promise that!

Forever and Ever’s alternative title should’ve been: Mattel making fun of everyone who criticises their changes: the episode.

With Rebecca, they should say that she's strong, fast and powerful enough to pull the Express just like Gordon, something that no other engine has the speed or strength to do. That's something special about Rebecca. But saying that she sees the best in everyone, we've had characters with that type of personality, specifically Porter, Stephen, even Thomas and Percy see the positive side of things sometimes. And she did this once at the end of What Rebecca Does when Marion points out that she made Daisy feel good about herself for being a diesel railcar. But that's what Daisy is anyway - highly sprung, up-to-date and thoroughly modern.

The irony to it all is that Rebecca was planned to be introduced in Season 21 and would have been a proper character, before Mattel cut the season short. As for Thomas’s Animal Friends, it is pretty bad, but it’s message is relatable to the fandom, with the whole “like what you want regardless of what others think” idea.

I have a couple problems to pick at the double length Episode known as Steam Team to the Rescue; First one, Sir Topham Hatt told Thomas that “We don’t have enough engines, Thomas!” Well… what about all the other engines besides the Steam Team! Surely it’s been a while since we saw any of them including Donald and Douglas, or heck even borrow some engines from Mainland UK like Stepney! Second problem, at the end, Sir Topham Hatt congratulated the team for their hard work in clearing up the chaos at Brendam Docks yet he forgot about the Diesels still trapped in the Dieselworks!

My Top 10 worst BWBA Episodes: 10.) Thomas and the Dragon 9.) Chucklesome Trucks 8.) Ace's Brave Jump 7.) Thomas in the Wild 6.) Gordon Gets the Giggles 5.) Panicky Percy 4.) Apology Impossible 3.) Rosie is Red 2.) Forever and Ever 1.) Thomas' Animal Friends

Here’s an idea: when James crashes into Tidmouth shed, have the shed be completely destroyed and needs to rebuilt from the ground up, the reconstruction could be an over arching plot in the BWABA era, while building the shed, sir Topham Hatt might decide to add more berths to the shed. During the BWABA movie, Thomas could’ve saved Nia’s life. Nia would then feel in debt with Thomas and decides to help on the NWR but feel out of her league. We could maybe see her getting frustrated with herself but refusing to go until the debt is paid, and maybe have Edward step in and help her. In the last season, if they wanted to write edward out of the show, they could show him struggling with his old age, he’s slowing down and can’t take heavy trains anymore, he struggles to bank engines and wearing down. They could build this up to a finale where Edward has to decide whether he should retire or not. In the end he decides it’s best if he goes into preservation kind of like what happens to Gordon in the original books. It is now time for Thomas or Gordon to step up and be the mentor like Edward was. Gordon could find this change jarring along with the arrival of Rebecca to help take the express with Gordon. Gordon now has to mentor Rebecca, Rebecca wants to please Gordon to a fault. More Thomas mentoring Philip coupled with flashbacks to when Edward was mentoring him as a parallel And finally, if they really need to write Henry out, they could just have him run longer trains to the mainland giving him a reason to stay at vicarstown. Just some ideas on what I would’ve done if I were in charge of this era…. And I write Thomas fanfiction…

I just hate the whole BWBA Era of Thomas in general.

For me, the BWBA series was okay, although there are some episodes that I found completely horrendous. Great list Trevor, and congrats for 3.41K subs!

My least favourite episodes from this era would be: 1) Apology Impossible. Because James was being a complete and utter dick to Philip for no bloody reason! And..... 2) Panicky Percy. Because Percy was just panicking about Thomas throughout all the episode! Sure. Thomas Makes a Mistake is my least favourite international episode. But it's more tolerable and not as awful as the previous two!

Also, my theory for why Pinchy was featured in the fantasy sequence of What Rebecca Does despite not being featured in the episode is because maybe Rebecca met Diesel 10 offscreen.

Speaking of Forever and Ever, here's a theory of explanation.: Henry needs to move to Vicarstown because he takes the Flying Kipper at most nights and after delivering the Flying Kipper, he arrived back in Tidmouth Sheds at late night or at dawn and he'll be tired when he works in a daytime. When he arrives back in Vicarstown, he'll be on time to sleep again like near midnight. Rosie got repainted for a change and another change is she moved to work in Vicarstown.

“Forever & Ever” is the worst episode in my opinion.

"Thomas Makes a Mistake" is NOT a good episode. But you know, I realized that the main problem this whole time was that the idea of Thomas not needing help and then needing it later was already a concept done before many times. It's not a bad concept, but it could have been a different character for that role than just Thomas learning the same thing again and again. It's not a horrendous episode (okay, it is NOT THAT horrendous), but it's certainly mediocre. Only for the overused trope of Thomas not needing help becoming a cliched plot point at this point. I understand that Thomas is new to a country that he has never been new at working there before, but he has a driver and fireman for Lord's sake! They could just help him out solve his own problems instead of letting him do that himself! But you know what? The mistakes Thomas makes in that episode are easily forgiven because all what Thomas was doing was try to fix the mistake he made, and not do nothing about it until the last minute. Isn't that something we should all consider ourselves grateful for? It's not like in Seasons 12-16 (the dark ages) where in most of the episodes Thomas is the lead role in, Thomas causes all these mistakes to happen mostly on purpose and does nothing about solving them until the last two minutes. Can you really blame him there unlike the former? Oh, and had this episode been set back on Sodor, I would have hated this so much more just like everyone else.

The only BWBA episodes that I genuinely enjoy are Michael White’s episodes.

Interesting list. My least favourite BWBA episode is Apology Impossible, Because of the way James treated Philip. Especially since in season 19, Philip saved James from falling. Plus James knows better. I know he’s vain, boastful and full of himself. But that is too far.

It's been long since we've waited. Also, congrats on reaching 3.4K subs, Trevor!

Congratulations on more subscribers. And I will have to admit on Thomas makes a mistake it's kinda average because Thomas makes every mistake over and over and over again and for episodes such as too loud Thomas I think it's good but now when I think about it it's a little average and a little harmless although I absolutely laughed at that one harmless gag. Runaway Truck or Runaway Car in the US I honestly enjoy the episode because on that dynamic between Thomas and Yong Bao and for Lei he's fine even though that he is a Chinese Goods van and I know it is unrealistic that he is literally tipped over every time that he gets bumped by Thomas try to learn t'ai Chi honestly it's kind of growing on me. Forever and ever and what Rebecca does, I think one of those episodes are good and I will respect your opinion on the dream sequence where the engines are literally bouncing if they're listening to hip-hop but that's for me the music in the background is so hip hop in pretty cool and Rebecca is cool with the shades although it could have been better if Diesel 10 was in this episode and as for forever and ever a pretty good episode for me and I do understand that it doesn't make much sense about Henry leaving at Tidmouth Sheds and going to vicarstown sheds for now on and I personally don't mind it but it could have been a little bit executed and the moral I know that some people think that knee has reason for leaving Kenya ruins it but as for me I quite like that moral even the life lesson segments. Thomas's animal friends the final episode of Thomas and Friends unless if you count Thomas and the Royal engine I think it was pretty good and I do understand that people hate it because it exists just to sell merchandise trust me I had got the motorized items and even the monkey Adventure set but personally I don't blame it. The Water Wheel I think it's a good episode because it explains what a Waterwheel can absolutely do in China and it is pretty interesting that things could be made from bamboo even though pandas do eat bamboo. Overall opinions are highly respected on the worst episodes of Big World Big Adventures.

I agree that “Thomas makes a mistake” is one of the worst BWBA episodes ever. How many times has Thomas made a mistake in the show? FAR TOO MANY TIMES! This era gets worse and worse to the point where I just stopped watching these episodes all together, and the messages were poorly executed. Nia and Rebecca could be good characters if executed better. Or just bring in old female characters like Rosie and Molly into Tidmouth Sheds. What’s the point of creating new characters if they just look the same as the rest?

Hey there! I've watched a few of your videos, and they're not that bad I wish I could make videos about Thomas but I don't know what videos to make Anyways, congrats on 3.4k subscribers!

I liked and agree with the results also congrats on getting 3.41k subscribers

According to the online video "Still the Best of Friends", the official reason Henry relocated to Vicarstown was to be closer to his work, referring to his taking trains to the Mainland in Tale of the Brave and Journey Beyond Sodor. Also, according to Ian McCue, Henry was not originally going to be removed from the Steam Team and would have been present alongside Rebecca at Tidmouth Sheds, whereas it was always planned to remove Edward.

congrats for reaching 34,000 subs!

Love this video so much

Happy 3.41K subs, Trevor.

They could’ve made Rebecca be like a golden retriever type character personality wise, but with having her feel like she has to please everyone. That’s a flaw

Congratulations on 3.41K Subscribers Trevor Davis!

Very informative video. I agree with every point in this video.

In my headcanon tidmonth sheds will have extra berths this takes after the fastest red engine after james was sent to the steamworks and after the fat controller fix the berth that james crash into the fat controller decided to add two more berths to the sheds because he has purchased another engine this being rebecca to work on the mainline and help gordon with the express. In this version rebecca will be introduced in season 21 and she will have flaws and troubles while pulling express and soon after gordon respect rebecca now after saving him from a accident the fat controller will say that rebecca will be staying in tidmonth after redemming herself from her past incidents. And after big world big adventures nia will have problems like she dislikes snow and adding counting in nia but rewrite it better and soon after she will be later on staying at tidmonth sheds now. And that is my version of how nia and rebecca will introduced in a properway.

I hated the BWBA Era as a Whole and the one thing that I've hated about this Era is the way how they treated Edward and Henry also the BWBA Era as a whole is Fucking Boring,Excuse my language.

Congratulations Bro!

I can't wait for the best ones

Its a shame that Rebecca never got the chance to encounter Diesel 10, because the creators thought Diesel 10 was scary as hell, so they have no choice but to kill him off and gave Molly 2.0 just Pinchy along with Harvey's crane arm, Marion's shovel, and Belle's water cannons

6:20 4th wall break😂😂

Congrats on reaching 3.4K subs. Also, when will you make your Top 10 movies that you like but everyone else doesn't because I really want to see it, but here's mine: 10-The Angry Birds Movie (though I'm not into Angry Birds anymore) 9-Thor: The Dark World 8-Diary of a Wimpy Kid (2010) 7-Open Season 2 (Not as good as the first but has funny moments here and there) 6-Thomas and the Magic Railroad 5-Alvin and the Chipmunks (2007) 4-Speed Racer (2008) (It actually stayed faithful to the anime series, why do people hate it?) 3-Fantastic Four (2005) 2-Godzilla (1998) (Sure, it doesn't feel like Godzilla but it does have funny moments like "wrong floor" Honorable Mentions Cars 2, Spider-Man 3 and Home (2015) 1-Captain Marvel (2019) (My parents liked it, what's with all the hate?)

When Trevor swears i got reminded of that cussing Spongbob animation But good job on getting 3 thousand subcribers Trevor

4:20 IDK why, but this moment made me chuckle.

My problem with Chucklesome Trucks, Rebecca learns how to deal with trucks too quickly, like how Nia learned how to count too quickly. Surely even Edward had trouble with trucks when he first used them. I also didn’t like how they treated James, Thomas, and Percy in that episode.

Molly is a merchandise character and I'm surprised that she got a lot of cameos in season 9 to 11 and great discovery

WHAT DO YOU MEAN THOMAS’ ANIMAL FRIENDS IS THE LAST EPISODE OF THE ORIGINAL SERIES?! Oh my god nothing makes sense anymore.😫

I agree with some of them also how about the episode "Panicky Percy"?

Thomas Makes A Mistake alternate title: Thomas doing a HiT Entertainment formula even after HiT Entertainment quit the show: The episode.

9:43 Rebecca dogg 😂😂

I don't try to be unfriendly, but at the No. 4, I actually laughed loudly. The dreaming sequence makes it bad, but overall it could have been a moral decent episode. The solution in the end actually helped me parcially curing from my depressions!😑 Sorry... But I had to get this off my chest. Kinda hurt me when this appeared.😔

Imagine if the search and rescue team had the same situation the steam team had from forever and ever in another episode.

I would say that my least favorite Big World Big Adventures episode would be Diesel Glows Away. That episode made me very annoyed. And I would say that Thomas Makes a Mistake would be my second least favorite episode.

Top 10 t&f characters

Fun fact: Thomas's Animal Friends is a last episode according to google. before it was cancelled and maks it a SHITTY AND CRAPPY ALL ENGINES GO SERIES.

The Image On The Thumb Nail Is LOL XD 😂

I thought number 1 was going to be Apology Impossible.

Finally, someone agrees with me on Too Loud Thomas

I don't mind the fantasy sequence because they are in the imagination and for comedy and remember that imagination scene in a grand day out, no one complained about that and it was funny.

11:43 Paramount Plus also listed Thomas and the Royal Engine as the series finale as well.

They should have had more with Gordan's brother and maybe an episode with Gordan coming in terms of being the little brother.

No hate towards Rebecca because I love her 🥰😊

You May Notice In Thomas's Animal Friends, At Crovan"s Gate, Skarloey Is There, Facing In The Same Direction As James And Percy, So Can't He Tell them How Thomas Feels Being Made Fun Of, Would that Be Better Than Him Just filling The Background.

Hey there Trevor buddy. Your week is starting off well for you so far I hope.

Al The Time In BWBA, I Was Like, Add More Births At Tidmouth Sheds

As someone who enjoys Sesame Street (currently it's my favorite show period), "Counting on Nia" is horrendous. At least Sesame Street teaches about numbers in a way that doesn't dumb down the audience, and the characters are not Mary Sue's and actually have flaws. "Counting on Nia", on the other hand, dumbs down the child audience, and Nia is a Mary Sue whose only flaw is not being able to read English numbers.

Tbh I like forever and ever because of Gordon WHAAATT and his dream sequence

It really upsets me that Mattel added two new female characters that in my opinion could’ve had so much potential, but Mattel said screw it, let’s tick off the fans instead and give girls a bad name amongst the Thomas community. I swear if I owned the series instead of Mattel, I’d expand Tidmouth sheds and ad Nia and Rebecca instead of replacing two very popular characters that have been their since the beginning, also I’d give these characters a far better character arc than what Mattel made. Ex: freight traffic increases in Tidmouth and Knapford, so they need a new shunting tank engine, Nia. Express trains get longer and heavier, so they need a new engine to help Gordon, Rebecca. SEE MATTEL, ITS NOT THAT HARD TO MAKE GOOD CHARACTERS AND EPISODES, OR EVEN KEEP OLD CHARACTERS AND BRING IN NEW ONES TO JOIN THE ORIGINAL TEAM. GO SCREW YOURSELF MATTEL!!!

Thomas and friends season 22 Bad episode 2 forever and ever

Counting on Nia would have been better if it went something like this, Fat Controller: Nia, I need you to go to platform 4 Nia: okay *Nia goes to Knapford platform 1 Annie’s what are we doing here? Nia: this is platform 4, isn’t it. Clarabel: no, Annie: this is platform 1 Nia: oh, I’m sorry, In Kenya, we call one, moja, and I thought this was 4 because it rhymed

4:18 Thank you!!!!!

2:47 At least ThomasFan2002 has fixed this problem in his series.

Could you do a review on the detailed thomas and friends series 23 and 24

3:11 huh... put Forever and Ever on 9 and not at least 2? I am surprised. Does ANYONE think this one is the WORST Thomas episode ever?

My list: 10. Lorenzo's Solo 9. Runaway Truck 8. Forever and Ever 7. Thomas' Animal Friends 6. Panicky Percy 5. Counting On Nia 4. Number One Engine 3. Thomas Makes a Mistake 2. Thomas and the Monkey Palace 1. Apology Impossible

Hey Trevor! Do you think you can make a Top 10 or 5 Worst All Engines Go! episodes video?

I think the worst episode of the BWBA era for me personally is Panicky Percy. I can't stand that episode and Percy is really annoying in it.

At first, I thought your number 1 worse episode would be Forever and Ever.

Uh Trevor I think you have a few trolls and bots in the comments section. Try to ignore them if possible.

Thomas's Animal Friends is that cringe and ended the show as a sour note

I want to see if I can adapt some bwuba episodes for my series tttedaf (edit) 13:43 no no that episode shouldn’t exist

I do know how to read numbers but sometimes it can be a little difficult reading the really big numbers I mean really big numbers but the only thing I'm not going to that reading is the actual words that's not what I'm good at even though I'm still practicing but that's why I'm not that good of reading even though I'm getting well learn how to read but it still taking a while for me learn how to read

I think The Water Wheel just literally ripped off Steady Eddie.

And the number one worst BWBA episode is… Me: is it Thomas makes a Mistake? Thomas makes a Mistake Me: Called it.

I agreed with your este roies is Red is a 10/7

I wanted more seasons to be like the railway series!!!!!

Well I have my top 10 favorites from BWBA : 10# Characters (for Exsample : Shankar, Rajiv and Lorenzo) , 9# all Sodor Episodes, 8# season 24, 7# The new main Cast Roll Call (with out Edward and Henry), 6# Croatian Voice Actors, 5# Australian Episodes, 4# Songs, 3# ending of Hiro in CGI series with great ending on that Episode, 2# Animation and 1# The new main Cast (that also Includes All engines go characters)

Bwba is plagued with problems

What about Trusty Trunky, Apology Impossible, Chucklesome Trucks, and Gordon Gets the Giggles? Those episodes are just as bad as the ones you listed. I’m also sorry to disappoint you, but “Rosie is Red” is given an article on Terrible TV Shows Wiki

Me: Said to Batucada episode. YOU'RE GOING TO BRAZIL!!!

Hey trevor davis in the episode rosie is red the episode teaches kids and adults that you can have a relationship with someone of your oppsite gender.

My top 10 worst big world big adventures episodes are 10 Rosie is red 9 an engine of many colours 8 thomas makes a mistake 7 forever and ever 6 Emily's best friend 5 panicky percy 4 Thomas's not so lucky day 3 counting on nia 2 the other big engine 1 crowning around And that's it

MOHAMMED GEEDI: If I want more girl power into the steam team, I would choose Rosie and Molly instead of Nia and Rebecca.

4:04 you and me both buddy I have dealt with that kind of stuff multiple times before believe me I know

13:53 not to mention I'm also that

13:08 Never thought you would mention a DreamWorks movie in a worst Thomas episodes video. 13:50 So am I. In fact, in my headcanon, I made Thomas and Ashima boyfriend and girlfriend. Oh. And THANK GOD you didn't put Trusty Trunky in the worst episodes because I consider that episode as my all time favourite episode in this era (and the entire show as a whole).

Also Thomas and Friends have always had diversity and other girl characters long before Nia and Rebecca. Everyone from the classic liked Elizabeth and wished that she got more screentime.

The Water Wheel is basically a ripoff of Steady Eddie from Season 12

Since Rebecca is my fave Charakter, my question is: What's your overall opinion about her? (Pls. reply on this.)

I Actually Like Some of These Episodes. But I Have To Agree On Forever and Ever, Too Loud Thomas, The Water Wheel, and Thomas Makes a Mistake. But My Worst BWBA Episode Is Too Loud Thomas. And I Agree On Thomas' Animal Friends Not Being Number 1, Because It Would Be Cliche, Kind of Like How You Didn't Add Wonky Whistle As Number 1 In You're Top 10 Worst Sharon Miller Episodes Videos Because You Said It Would Be Too Cliche As Number 1.

I think Batucada might be one of the most forgettable episodes in the entire show

Hey man you're not the only one I put all my anger out for stupid things on a Thomas the Tank Engine show especially all engines go I always release all my anger on that show a lot and Big World Big Adventures that's why I end up hating those three other seasons I always like the CGI series through season 13 through 21 I thought those seasons were okay but I don't know anymore

Thomas the tank engine was supposed to be like the railway series but instead it becomes clichéd

2:53 Actually, a Mary Sue is an overpowered female character. Most people think Rey’s a Mary Sue, yet Rey DOES have a character flaw. She constantly dwells on her parents. If most people are dumb enough to think that didn’t even exist or it not being a flaw, then I’ve officially lost all hope in humanity.

Thank you why not give more spots in the sheds

You know When I See A Video On A Top 10 Worst BWBA Episodes, They Would Put Panicky Percy And And Apology Impossible On Their List, So I’m Just Wondering Why You Didn’t Put Those 2 Episodes On The List.

You forgot to put Emily in the dream scene with belle, Harvey, marion and Percy.