"ask yourself one question how many husbands and fathers have you killed." that line was amazing

Glenn watching from above: 👁️ 👄 👁️

I love how Maggie completely ignores the question cause she knows he's right.

That line hit harder than Lucille hit Glenn

Negan was wrong for what he did to Gleen but Maggie isn’t innocent either.

negan: "how many husbands have you killed" maggie: "nuh-uh"

Every time negan has a good point Maggie plays the glenn card lol

He has a point. I think what Maggie needs, is a similar moment than Rick had back in season 8, when he found Gracie in the savior outpost and realized he had just made this baby an orphan.

Negan got tired of that shit of Maggie being mean to him no matter if he tries to help her or not, I mean yeah she will never forget the moment Gleen got killed by Negan...but fuck that, they have a kid to save, HER KID, WHO STILL ALIVE. And yeah, in this world, if you survived that far of course you were or actually are the bad guy from somebody else in some moment.

negan always spittin fax

This was the exact moment shane became heisenberg day 11

What I love about this scene and the episode is how they portray the moral ambiguity of both characters. Negan is long past atoning for what he did. He paid enough in his eyes and is willing to kill Maggie if it came down to it to survive. But he doesn’t hate her, in fact he respects and even admires her. On the other hand, Maggie hates Negan and because of that she clings to a moral high ground, struggling to accept that Negan has a point. They’re both killers and have killed to get what they wanted. The only difference is how they went about doing it and that’s where the debate is. It’s also the intelligence of the writing. To get people discussing the question of who is in the right or if neither of them are. Judging from the comments here. They’ve accomplished just that.

If you survived this far into an apocalypse, no one is the good guy anymore

You are eventually going to be the villain of someone else’s story. To someone out there, Maggie is their Negan.

Considering how many Saviors Abraham and Glen killed in their sleep at the satellite station or Saviors Carol and Maggie killed when they were taken captive, Ricks group only losing Glen and Abraham was definitely considered mercy.

Negan's too fucking wise

Can’t wait to see all the new shorts you’re gonna make with the fear midseason finale and dead city

I honestly expected him to say “I’m not the bad guy, I’m not one the who murdered people in their sleep” obviously referencing the satellite outpost massacre

“ask yourself one question how many husbands and fathers have you killed?” that hit deep

And later in the episode she can't bring herself to kill another husband and father. This show is going to be lit.

I love seeing Negan finally fight back.. He was the punching bag of everyone for too long.

I feel bad for Negan, he's broken, if Lucille didn't die, he wouldn't be the villian. But Negan is good now, which is a good thing.

"Hooked up"?! He really should have word it differently lol

god jeffery dean morgan is such an amazing actor 😭😭

I am not gonna debate the righteousness of Negan's words, or Maggie for that matter, Yes Negan killed Glenn and Abraham with a big smile on his face, which is quite different from what Rick and his group had ever done, Maggie will never forget that. However, Negan had many, many opportunities to kill Maggie over the years, or young Hershel, but he didn't, Maggie should think about that for a second, they will never be friends, but at least she should've recognized by now that Negan is indeed a changed man that is just trying to help and survive.

Negan and Maggie’s actors are absolutely killing it in the new Twd show

Negans changed so much 🧍‍♀️

And funniest part is Negan was being merciful when he killed Glenn and Abraham

'' No one every think they are the evil one'' Negan Smith said

Even though Negan has done evil things in his past, he does have a point in putting Maggie in her place where she isn’t a saint either. All the people she’s killed, she was probably seen as a monster in other people’s perspective of her. This is something I wish was addressed better in this franchise, like how The Last of Us handled it

maggie really be like : ''its only right when we do it'' xD

They forget the people with the governor were good people who were manipulated. And they still killed them nonetheless to protect themselves, negan killed Glen and Abraham for the lives of his people they took. In that aspect, negan was in the right.

The writers of this show won’t put this to bed

Negan speaking 💯% truth & facts😎🔥

Whether you kill someone with a cool ass bat or a rifle round, it makes no difference

"What you did, you don't ever put something like that to bed" 😮

Actually Negan has a point

This was an amazing episode. I'm already waiting for more.

Jeffrey D Morgan is such an amazing actor 💙

Negan speaking straight facts

I would've been better if at the end negan responded "neither what you did"

I don’t get how people justify/defend Negan. You make the bed you sleep in end of story. You go out your way to make enemies, don’t be surprised if years later they still see you as an enemy.

She avoided that question so hard and played the victim card lmao like they wouldn’t have killed Negan if he was outnumbered

Wow, no matter what happened, the old world is dead. negan well always be a teacher and he's right And hearing magie said reminds of my sister the only difference is my sister hates being wrong as magie I don't think she still hadn't moved on from what happened to Glen and instead accepting what negan said was right she tries ignore it or dodges he's qestion. which deep down we all know he's right

Guys in case your wondering how he’s watching dead city already even tho it didn’t come yet, you need amc+ and you get to watch first episode a week early

This is how Maggie and Negan argue Negan: the Saviors are dead, I have changed, I’m sorry for what I did, i did it 16 years ago, i helped you multiple times, you are no better than me because you’ve killed other people too, I saved your group and your son numerous times, i almost died saving you and all your friends, I left to raise my family and to leave you guys at peace Maggie: Glenn, Glenn, Glenn, Glenn, Glenn, Glenn, Glenn, and Glenn

Maggie never forgot, just let it slide for the time being.

The thing is, she has a hard time believing he has changed when really he had changed already when he met her in season 6. If only she knew that and that he just went back to who he originally was before she met him she would totally see him differently.

I've always loved the way he emphasizes the word "CLEARLY.."

Negan be looking lotzo bear from Toy Story 3

Both are killers yes, but I’ve never seen Maggie mocking someone while he’s dying the way Negan did with Glenn. That’s cold blood! I know he regrets it and said sorry and whatever, but.. it’s not the same.

She ignored the question just like every female does when they know there losing the argument lol

Bro killed him for fun tho, laughing and taunting them, he did not have to. Big difference

Negan has a point

Negan was right

Maggie is like that crazy gf that never lets go of your mistake even if years passed by lmao 😂 ( I know what negan did is hard to forgive but let it go, it wont bring glenn back)

Alternate scene: Lemme ask you sumthing how many husband's and fathers have you killed

negan: how many husbands and fathers have you killed? maggie: no you

What i dont see acknowledged from the series and the fans is how negan loved the pain he caused. The main group tried to be fair and kind and was betrayed. They killed out of need or safety. I can't recall when Rick or Maggie genuinely killed someone in the same way Shane killed the farm hand or how Negan killed Glenn, Abraham, and tortured Daryl. Sure Rick and Maggie had their periods of being bloodthirsty and unforgiving to any enemy, but still, it was always towards people who did something bad or were a threat. But all I see is: oh Rick is JUST like shane!!! Maggie is so unjustified for how Negan killed her Husband and would have robbed other families for years. Negan has obviously changed and we're all glad for it, but the only thing she owes Negan is indifference. If Negan did what he did with sadness and guilt rather than sadistic pleasure, he would be a massively different character from the beginning. But that didn't happen.

Hes kinda right u know but never forget Glenn ❤rip

What you did you don't ever put something like that to bed best line ever

She ducked that question like it was a hook punch

Maggie didn’t answer the damn question like she’s some angel.

Hey negan has a point tho

😀 They're chemistry is amazing and the writers are doing a good job making the audience debate over their character's perspectives can't wait to see more of it!

I mean Negan has a point but i don't think we can judge Maggie, cuz as long as we're not affected we coud never imagine how it feels to witness such a horrible death especially when its your partners

This was an amazing episode

Let's be honest... shit happens.

I'm bed and i can confirm their argument.

She avoided the question 😂

“Ask yourself one question: How many husbands and fathers have you killed?” This line really goes to show how much of Negan’s point makes sense. Everyone has done whatever they have to keep going, especially Maggie. I also find it odd how she still doesn’t trust him, despite bringing him to NYC with her.

Wait that already came out? Negan talking back now.

I have a deep dark feeling that they're going to hook up at some point

Negan, logical. Maggie, emotional. Makes total sense

Bro Maggie just can’t leave negan alone for 1 second

Negan was better off as a Villain

Negan has lost a spouse too

Negan has a point though

Hooked up 💀💀💀

Neegans kill count is probably one of the highest in the world, canonically. Not to mention other acts he committed and turned a blind eye to. He is the worst of the worst, so no, he is not all right.

Mike Ehrmantraut feeling just a little bit

Btw on imdb strand and luciana are depicted as credits only, while alycia isn’t

reminder that glenn and abraham (probably) wouldn’t have gotten bashed by lucille if the group hadn’t taken on that outpost

The follow up should of been "that goes both ways, maggie." With a disappointed pittied look.

Everyone is the bad guy to anyone who dont know eachother in the apocalypse.

Maggie: What you did, you don't ever put something like that to bed... But you, on the other hand 😏 Negan: 😳 Glenn in heaven: 😶

Glenn wasn’t even that good of a character it was more sad when Abraham died. Get over it.

Negen"how many fathers and husbands have you killed" Maggie"I can ask you the same question"

For real though, if the story was told from anyone else’s perspective it all shifts to them being the bad guys

Finally someone calling out Maggie’s hypocrisy. Negan could have easily brought up how she let that kid get eaten which in my opinion is way worse than being bashed in with a bat.

Everyone is the hero in their own story

Listen maggie, let it go…. -Darth Vader

Maggie acts like they didn’t raid negans hideout and murder his crew in their sleep.

Maggie has a habit of ignoring good points that Negan makes 😂

I think this is going to be the only twd spin off thats good from the start to the end

I like how she always avoids the questions he asks.

Negan pulled the uno reverse on her and her only defense is glenn

"I guess it's everyone, then..."

If you told me maggie and Negan was gonna have their own spin-off in 2016 I never woulda thought

Negan was completely right here