NFL Analyst Doesn't Think Caleb Williams Should be The #1 Pick!

Рет қаралды 372

Film Study For Rookies

5 ай бұрын

Today we're breaking down what Merril Hoge said about USC QB Caleb Williams!

Пікірлер: 6

@elsalsero417 5 ай бұрын

Good breakdown. And I agree, you can't teach anticipation. I saw his entire career at USC, and while the offense he played, could have hindered his progression. Caleb has excelled. Hoge, did get manzel and clowney correct. But has he seen the atrocious protection he had at USC. He was consistently under pressure and the highlight hudini acts he pulled out was insane. Maybe he doesn't like Caleb bcuz of the off field stuff. You deserve more subscribers.

@FilmStudyForRookies 5 ай бұрын

Appreciate the love man, I've got some Caleb highlights against Notre Damn... That line looked rough, but I wouldn't put the blame on him for that. Plan to do a video over that game that later in the month.. But to me he's a bit quicker than Mahomes and has a better arm than Lamar. How's that not a generational talent lol...

@ryanlynn3138 5 ай бұрын

I wonder what Merrill Hoge thinks about JJ McCarthy

@eduardosalinas7563 5 ай бұрын

I don’t see how anyone could have been high on Johnny manziel it was evident that he was going to be a bust so I don’t give him props for “predicting” that outcome

@choosecarefully408 3 ай бұрын

Human nature, or Social Psychology 101: when someone is presented in any positive way, everyone measures them against their Subconscious image of what they want their positive figure to look like. Sorry to say, too many people can't accept saviors in Black skin. I am not saying that that's what's happening with this guy. But *something* rubs him the wrong way. It can be anything. The painted nails I do not care to find out The Specific Reason(s) this one guy is saying this. You know why? I guarantee you that _YOU_ do this sometimes & never realize it. Politicians _openly accept_ lobbying $ from corporations that they then can not regulate because of a conflict of interest. We retain our prejudice that "no, _OUR_ politicians would never allow harms to come to us." That's the exact same mindset, prejudging based on the sake of prejudging. People's brains produce endorphins when they put others down. They also produce endorphins when we blindly defend anyone we perceive of as Our Group. This infantile pleasure loop resets itself every few seconds. How many examples do you want?

@choosecarefully408 3 ай бұрын

The QB he's replacing is a _perfect example._ Everyone is 100% certain Fields "can't read defenses." what's their evidence? They heard it. So it Must Be True, right? Brett Kollmann did a video disproving this when he was still in college. The stats proved he not only looked at his 2nd & 3rd reads, his passing #s to them were the best of all college QBs. Literally people looked at him & said "replace My Idol Tom Brady the Second Coming Himself with _HIM?!?_ I don't think so." Then people just say something to justify their predetermined POV. This doesn't have to be race-related. Aaron Rodgers is a _WAY_ better QB than Brady but is nowhere near as attractive. So what do people do? Take something unrelated to QB performance (team wins) & use that as proof of individual greatness. Barry McCockiner (yes, he got away with using that as his Yt handle) made 2 or 3 great videos putting up their individual stats then placed them in the context of what the rest of their teams did. In 9 playoff games, the Packers under Rodgers gave up More Points than any single year that the Patriots did in all their playoff & regular season games combined. So Rodgers literally had to overcome twice as many points than Brady Every Single Game. & he almost did so.