I have watched every PMJ Creep reaction on KZfaq. I must admit, a couple of good ones. But your s take it to another level. You actually managed to recognize the nuances that makes Haley a masterful performer.

Haley now owns this song forever, nobody can top it EVER!

To assess the singing voice of someone of a different language than your own cannot be an easy task. Having done as well as you have here is nothing less than brilliant. I've seen several react video's to Creep by Haley and yours has proven more insightful and informative than any I've watched. Thank you. Well done.

Fantastic analysis of this iconic performance by Hailey ! She absolutely killed this song from beginning to end ! She is so natural and organic in her delivery ! Her growls and raspy voice are so mesmerising and demand your antention completely ! She is a true performance artist .Your breakdown of her vocal performance is absolutely the very best I have ever heard ! Your ear has the ability to pick up all the nuances immediately ! You're a pleasure to listen to ! Thank you so much and keep posting 🤗👍🇨🇦🇨🇦❤️❤️❤️

Hi Anna, I couldn't hardly wait for this one 👍. Haley Elizabeth Reinhart, smooth as well as raspy jazz touch, like it even more than the Radiohead version.

I have followed Haley for over 10 years sad she is one of my all itime favorite singers . She has many songs on her channel that are not PMJ that are good but this one is special . Really a fun reaction, thumbs up to you 👍

Superb analysis! This was PMJ and Hayle's first and only take too!

One second, before I watch the video I have to turn on the subtitles. Ok, hello Anna I'm ready for another great video, this is one of my favourite Radiohead songs :-)

Great reaction and interpretation of this video! I've seen most of the so-called musical experts reactions and this was one of the best by far. Great job!

Great reaction Anna, all the songs Hailey does with PMJ are a real treat as well as her solo projects. I’m also looking forward to your reaction of Floor next week.

And her style, voice, control and tone, everything that’s literal perfection to me, for this song, and especially the style, of it were made back in the day, to me, voice and physically, style, all pure perfection, how she moves, etc. can’t get better for this.

Anna, thanks for pointing out the arrangement, some do some do not, but Scott Bradlee deserves all sorts of admiration and compliments on his incredible ability to hear the vintage/jazz in all the tracks they remix and provide these incredible arrangements for each. The band delivers every time too, providing a true flashback of music evolution. I don't think I could ever say enough about how unbelievably talented Hailey is, so I'll just leave it at that, LOL! Great reaction!

anna... nice reaction and excellent breakdown... this maybe one of the best covers ever done, bar none. haley reinhart especially with postmodern jukebox is incredible. . all the other haley/pmj ones are great also: "all about the bass", "habits", "black hole sun", "mad world", "seven nations army", "oops i did it again", "lovefool" and the very recent "don't speak". i think what is so phenomenal about haley is not just her amazing silk to sandpaper voice but also her character and soul that she puts into the performances. even when she uses very little acrobats, her pure raw soft voice is amazing like in the intro of "creep". you see this even more in her solo platinum cover of "can't help falling in love" for the extra gum commercial which is truly stunning and frequently described as what love sounds like. you can find it here: (kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ldt-o6iT2Z3bj6M.html)

I never get sick of listening to Haley sing this song. Great Reaction Anna

Great reaction Anna, I've never thought that a jazz version of creep could be soooo goooood!!! 🙂🙂

This was wonderful, Anna. Beautiful reaction to a beautiful song. Hailey can really sing. I actually grew up listening to all the jazz greats of the Big Band Era. When I started playing drums, Gene Krupa was my idol. I cant tell you how many times I listened to the live recording of Benny Goodman's Sing Sing Sing! And you are right, she reminds me of Billy Holiday, with a little bit of Beth Hart thrown in! Love from Chicago xxxx

I can’t get enough of this virtuoso performance by Haley. The reaction and analysis was outstanding. I need to see some more of your reactions ❤️

This is as close to a perfect performance (that is this complex) as I have ever heard before. This woman is a complete professional, with total control of her voice and every note she sings is designed and planned. She is truly great.

As always, you have brought us an exceptional singer, with an outstanding performance, and the most beautiful thing of all is having you tell us about it, you are magnificent and I will never get tired of watching your videos over and over again. Kisses

This is my favorite Haley/PMJ cover, although they are all fantastic. Haley never disappoints. Your analysis was spot on, and I enjoyed watching your reaction and listening to your input and perspective. Thank you Anna, great job!

Anna...Awesome reaction from beginning to end. Personally, I like Haley's vocal intensity with all those growls, cries, bends, and other "creepy" techniques because she takes it up a notch at the end, as she does so well and the suddenly drops us down right where we started. Out of the many covers of "Creep" I like Haley's best.

Haley's been on my radar for years, but this makes the hair on my arms stand up every single time I listen. I enjoyed the way you caught the nuances of her style choices...

Very nice job. I thoroughly enjoyed this. As you said, her time to shine with this. 🌸

PMJ with Morgan James is a must after this one. Either Dream On (Aerosmith cover) or Take Me To Church (Hozier cover). Her vocal power is on a level few can claim.

Oh, I like it, Anya. Haley is perfect, now I'm going to check her other performances) This is my first time I listened PMJ. I'm not a jazzy man, you know. But this was cool. Thank you!)

This is a professional and awesome reaction of this wonderful mucic. Congratulations Anna.

Think I loved how you reacted right at the beginning as the first note hit. You dived right in. Love the break down you did afterwards too!

Loved your reaction, very insightful and complete. I loved the original, but I love this version even more!!

Post modern juke box seven nation army featuring haley reinhardt she will blow your mind

I most prefer this rendition of creep than any other I've heard.

I get all misty eyed every time i hear her sing.

Not sure if it was mentioned previously, but this was the very first take of the videotaping. Amazing.

I love Hayley. My two favorite female singers are hayley and Nora Jones. I play guitar for a very talented singer and we do Creep. I enjoy your analysis. Much better than just a pure reaction video.

I love her performance. Her body movements complemented her vocals very well. You made a great clip even better. Thank you, moi-moi.

I do believe that she was sick with a cold this very day and really didn't want to perform 🤔She gave in despite this and did it in one take 👌 beyond impressive in every conceivable way... Absolutely love your channel ❤️

I really enjoy your reactions! You allow yourself to enjoy, not just critique...

I'm a year late to the party, but what a mother vibing vibe of a reaction! 😍Such a good song, but an even better reaction/analysis! The reaction part of this video was so nice! Keep rocking ❤🤙

Damn...Now I know how women feel; "Done already"?! That was to quick...The anticipation, the wait, so excited then Blam! it's already over?! Oh well...Looking forward to the next one; It may have been quick but it was sooo Good! Thanks Anna. Haley can sing. I wish singers like her, in this genre, were more mainstream. I will have to listen again to catch what you were talking about with the constanants; I always learn something new with your videos.

Love your reactions and Haley too.2 beautiful ladies.

I’ve listened to this performance least 100 times and have a fresh emotional response each time. Haley has a way of getting into the the emotions of her listeners, not just pulling for them, but somehow getting inside the mindbody and comingling her soul stuff with ours. This can be unnerving and confusing, otherworldly, but if you just go with it the emotional musical hoodoo is joyfully transcendent and unforgettable. Such is her power on stage.I’ve seen so many reactions to this performance that leave the listener sometimes in tears, so emotionally moved that they can hardly articulate a coherent thought. You impressed me by your ability to maintain calm and focused thinking as you responded emotionally. Your analysis was astute and documents Haley’s impressive vocal and performance abilities. I consider this cover iconic, it stands on its own under Haley’s strewardship. I experience Radiohead’s performance as existing in a separate musical world where I can go and fully enjoy a listen to their original version. But the performances defy comparison, so that’s where I settle the question for myself. Thank you for pointing out the arranging and the performance skills of the band. Scott Bradlee is the musical force that drives PMJ. All featured artists and band members are sharp performers, no less so Scott himself. The result is the high level of arranging and production that bring to us this collection of rare music. No small part of the success of this piece is the quality of the band playing so well this excellent arrangement that showcases Haley at her best. I’d like to hear your thoughts on her performance of I Can’t Help Falling In Love (With You). Thanks for this thoughtful review.

Anna...a super reaction (first time hearing you). If you haven't heard her rendition of "Seven Nation Army" by PMJ, you'll love it !! Personally, I think she's the best female singer on the planet. BTW, have you ever heard of and/or reacted to Pentatonix videos...would love to hear your take on their videos...they are intergalactically talented !!

must admit this was interesting, jazz was something I really never cared for, probably because I never really fully listened too, your break down and analysis certainly helps, keep up the great work

So glad to happen upon you and the detailed analysis. I might add that it was reported she wanted to do this in one take because she wasn 't feeling good. I hope you continue with Hale,y especially her newest Don't Speak.

You did such an excellent job analyzing this!! This is my favorite version of Creep. Haley did this in ONE take and was sick at the time. They were out of the Country on tour and had rented the studio. They also had recorded another video before this one. I know I couldn’t sing like that while sick… or well 😂 Than again I’m an alto so there’s that.

Thoroughly enjoyed this arrangement, better than the original. Loved your breakdown of the performance. I look forward to more from you.

Her pure talent, and mannerisms, and yes body, is perfection, can’t find anyone better for this song/role, performance. She is perfection for this, pure and simple. And a lot like you!

A great analysis of a great singer and performer....I find her holding on to the consonants a style choice I see in jazz vocalists a lot...and I love the way she plays with her voice....your analysis was spot on....you pointed out many of the nuances of her performance...well done.

Haley has one Hell of a voice❤. Glad to see more people being able to find out about her

Hello once again, hope all is well with you and yours. PMJ, fantastic arrangement and instrumentation, meaningful lyrics and a captivating vocal performance from Haley. I enjoyed their rendition of this song and enjoyed your reactions. When my instrumental instructors are moved emotionally by a performance.......I feel privileged to experience those emotions also. I have much respect for your musicality and vocal knowledge. That is why I subscribed to your channel. I like your content. Farewell for now, stay healthy and safe as always.

Haley's voice is like silk drawn across the skin, followed immediately by a full-force punch in the mouth. She really draws on her effects, and she uses them liberally. She's sultry and sexy one moment, and firey attitude the next. So. Damn. Good. I love both versions of the song. I won't even stand them next to one anther, nor compare them, for each suits a different mood through the arrangement and interpretation. Super impressive to have a cover that stands on its own. I can think of few examples off the top of my head. There aren't many who can pull off a cover with as much style as PMJ. Marilyn Manson's covers, perhaps...

Loved your reaction…you’ve got a new sub

Hailey is one of my favorite singers. The songs on PMJ have been on my playlist for a long time. Of the many songs that PMJ plays, only when Hailey is the vocalist is the right one for me. 😊

Never get tired of this one!

The ultimate version of Creep as far as I'm concerned. Purely stunning.

She was perfect and so were you. I liked her movements a lot because they followed the lyrics very well. I always hear about word painting, here she did body painting. At first she represented a flower opening up and then she became a creep. Jazz artist don't usually move very much so she was right on point. Just enough. I could see you were feeling her too. If you weren't recording you would've been standing up and moving along with her. Enjoyed your reaction as always. moi-moi

Love it!

Pmj has excellent covers. Morgan is my favorite singer, her voice is insane. Try 'dream on" or 'maps' Love from the Netherlands ❤

Love your review. I think she is very talented. I like all her songs. She is a real artist.

Thanks Anna! You covered already a ton of stuff in this beautiful piece, and probably you have still left something, e.g. that Hailey managed to do even a little scat. I listened to several PMJ covers and often they are just fantastic, and often (IMHO) better than the original, like this one. If you plan more PMJ on your channel, I'd suggest Morgan James and 'Take Me To Church', she sings with only Scott at the piano.

Ooh, niin herkkua luvassa! 😍

Blows me away--this IS THE primo version of this song for me. None come even close to comparing. Haley Reinhart and PMJ are just amazing. Love them! I first heard them about 1.5 years ago and I can't enough of either. Also love Morgan james singing with PMJ. Try listening to "Dream On" with PMJ and Morgan James if you haven't done so!!! Love your channel---I learn so much from your analysis. And you are so lovely to watch!!!

Как всегда,прекрасна))) и я не про исполнителя)))

I couldn't understand most of what you said, but your reactions were enough 💓💓

Speaking of PMJ - Miche Braden doing Sweet Child O' Mine is definitely worth a listen.

This was the first time I'd heard this cover by PMJ and I was trying to figure out why it sounded vaguely unsettling underneath all the more conventional smoky/sensual sound... and then when you pointed out how she was singing the consonants in strange way it all made much more sense, haha If you are ever looking for more extreme distortion to analyze, I'd want to recommend the band Slaughter to Prevail and their song Demolisher that illustrates a wide range of false chord manipulation. They also have a newer song, Baba Yaga, that utilizes a wider range of base techniques too. Plus the videos for both are so over the top that it's impossible not to have a good time watching them, haha

As a boy who grew up in a working class Chicago suburb controlled by the mafia, I am so happy for Haley. Haley is Chicago blues at heart. The video of her dad and her performing at Chicago-based Chess records confirms her roots. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pdOkpqt22JjLYKs.html From the the Naperville (a Chicago suburb) RibFest shown here: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pbahoNuDy8WtnJs.html to seeing Haley on you channel - it is with great satisfaction that her talent is being appreciated. Obviously, Post Modern Jukebox is a great venue to showcase her talent. Thank you Anna for your reaction video.

I read that Haley had a bit of a head cold & had just finished an entire concert right before recording this! Amazing....

Wahou....Did not know anything about her. Thank foR this discovery ! Impressive.

Sweet!

I love this version of Creep. This song is what made me start watching reaction videos like yours. I generally only watch reaction to this one or Haley's new one with PMJ Don't Speak. PMJ is generally really good and creative. Allison Young is another one that joined PMJ is a few videos that I love like Mr. Blue Sky.

WONDERFUL reaction...will subscribe to hear more reactions. For Haley, check out Seven Nation Army; Habits; Don't Speak; Don't Know How To Love You; and Better (many more). Have you ever reacted to Pentatonix...if not, you would be in for a treat !!

I just love listening to the Finnish language being spoken ❤

I discovered you through your reaction to Angelina Jordan, and followed you over to Dimash. I have liked their music for quite a while now 😊 I like your analysis a lot. You pick up a lot of interesting details on a more complete level than most, both on vocal and on posture. I like that a lot 😊 I would love you to react to Pentatonix 😊 They are an acapella group of 5 who do amazing harmonies. I’d recommend that you start with either Hallelujah or Sound of silence. 😊 I just want to point out that Hallelujah has the original group setup, while in Sound of silence their bass singer has left the group for personal reasons, and been replaced with another one, which is the guy with the white jacket to the very left in the lineup. And in case you wonder… they don’t do much studio work on their songs, because their philosophy is that they should be able to do the same performance in concert.

Great reaction.

Can..not..wait!

I don't believe there is anyone, including the original artist, who doesn't think that this is exactly what this song is supposed to be. Anyone, regardless how homely or comely, who ever became helplessly infatuated with another person has had these feelings of inadequacy. While the writer has brilliantly described it, the composer (Scott Bradly) has detailed it with striking precision and Haley, with her richness of talent and beauty, has displayed just how powerful that emotion truly is. That someone can give us this or any other emotion without having to endure the experience, is a gift to anyone who will have it.

Postmodern Jukebox All About The Bass 😁

She make songs better than the originals, like; (can't help falling in love)

I love your diction!

Just wandered in and subscribed via your Pentatonix reaction, but I saw this & it's one of my favorites. I think my favorite thing about this song in particular for Haley is that she *sounds* out of control, but she never actually is

For a very emotional cover of this, I recommend The Warning covering this (actually a Pau solo).

I mentioned 'Leana ( Lena) Horn' the other day and had another singer that I could not remember her name at the time. I remembered ,,, 'Billy Holiday'. Same kind of style. Thanks from Arizona.

Hailey and Diana Ankudinova are my two favorite singers in the world today. Very different sounds but both beautiful.

People love your assessments and I’m on the other side of the fence as an empath. I like seeing your reactions as it shows your sentiment in the moment.

Supposedly, she was not feeling well on the day of this shoot and wanted to cancel, but Scot convinced her to try it. Good call. haha. I love your analysis. Spoken Finnish is soothing to my ears even though I don't speak Finnish. My Grandparents immigrated to the States from Finland, so it must be knocking around in my gene pool. ;-)

Haley is the most impressive singer working today IMO. There's nothing she can't do, and she is like a cartoon character...like Bettey Boop and Jessica Rabbit in one. I would love to see what you think of her (also with PMJ) cover of Tove Lo's "Habits". It's a such a dark and pitiful song, and she makes is fun and 30's jazzy. It's a total transformation, and it's quintessential Haley Rinehart

woohoo!

Hello beautiful Anna!She's gorgeous!Thank you!)))🌹😲🇷🇺

I've been watching reactions to this song for about 2 hours straight now. I'm obsessed. I'm gonna suggest 2 Christina Aguilera performances. At Last at Etta James' memorial service, and It's a Man's World at the James Brown tribute. Both dynamite performances

This version of Creep spent 58 straight weeks on the Billboard Jazz Digital Chart. It is by far the most successful song ever performed by PMJ and Haley is by far the best of the best vocalist to have ever performed with PMJ. Two other covers that Haley did with PMJ, "Seven Nation Army" and "Oops, I Did It Again", are almost as good as "Creep" and should definitely be reacted to by you for your subscribers enjoyment. As each cover is uniquely different vocally and I might add mind blowing. As really, all of Haley's covers she did with PMJ are very excellent. Her own music written and performed by Haley, is quite eclectic and is also spectacular as well.

"She runs" 'Run" And her run on the third, "RUN"

Great reaction, I really love the attention to detail you put in this. If you want to react to another great female vocalist I would love to see you react to Nightwish / Ghost Love Score (Live at Wacken) with Floor Jansen, if you haven't already. (But be aware that it'll bring the Nightwish-army to your channel, it's one of the most reacted clips here on youtube XD) But I'd be very curios about your analysis.

Haley did this in ONE take, WHILE SICK!

Nie znam fińskiego ale twoja mowa ciała wystarczyła mi za tłumacza. Dzięki

Just a note about the video, Haley was not feeling very good the day this was taped and it was taped in one take on the first try. This shows how tight the band is and just how good they are. Love the reaction Where are you from btw? I can see how much you really love music in your reaction. I bet you would love to hear ( sound of silence )a cover by disturbed taped on the Conan obrien show I think they will blow you away, some of the greatest vocals with no enhancements

I love Haley interpretation of this song. I actually never felt this way when someone had sung this song. BUT this woman.. Jesus.. I felt like my eyes were blowing out of my head. How can one person sing like this? Like you want to rip something out. I'm a creep, I'm a weirdo, yea... It felt like pain.. Again, Jesús.. I love her interpretation.

You may enjoy Postmodern Jukebok's - All about the bass.

I have always liked this song, but I may actually enjoy PMJ's version more than the original! (I suppose it depends on my mood) I loved how Anna says "you ARE special" in response to the line in the lyrics... And immediately, I found myself echoing back to Anna that SHE is very special as well...

I enjoyed your insightful observations, Anna! I never heard this song before I heard PMJ's and Haley's version. After listening to this several times, I decided to listen to Radiohead's original. I couldn't believe how the original is TOTALLY different from PMJ's version! I actually had a difficult time listening to the original all the way to the end! And that's okay - it's simply not my style of music. My introduction to PMJ was last year when I stumbled across "All About That Bass - PMJ European Tour Version" with Haley Reinhart, Morgan James, Ariana Savalas and Casey Abrams. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/l7KejZR_ttOWpZ8.html

My favourite Artists. Lara Fabian, Angelina Jordan, Mamamoo, Haley Reinhart. there are more but these are kinda special.