David Ben-Sun me too

I just can’t wrap my mind around it. But on the opposite side of the spectrum, I’m 7 years old listening to mostly 1920’s - the - was 1950’s music. Imagine that you old bastard

Be my dad

I LOVE imagining that!

@@tipsygypsy1064 Obviously you're not 7 years old with your grammar you delusional shitter.

Lighting And Production Designer: Mr. LeRoy Benet.

Yes. Do you do that sort of work?

​@@gianfrancodivitto4962 Who is that?

it's just amazing. and to realize that this concert is already 11 years old is even more crazier... just imagine what's coming next from these guys...

seen it live back in the day, one of the most amazing shows i've seen live

What a setlist... Sanctified, Big Come Down, Even Deeper

Tusen takk, det er veldig hjelpfull :)

Thanks.

Thanks a lot

Rob Sheridan

Trent and Rob both collaborated with Moment Factory for visuals, same as the Lights In The Sky tour.

yes

The addition of the ladies and everything else he did for the Big Come Down during this performance gives goose bumps every time.

The harmonies they each add to Trent's vocals and layering is just otherworldly.

One of them is Lisa Fischer, one of the greatest voices to ever live. Check her bio, she is the ultimate backup singer.

@@SNAFU78 Pulse. 50 yrs of the almighty Guitar God ... David Gilmore .. Roger won't be happy ... lol . Anniversary. THINK PINK

@@SNAFU78 HI fellow toaster . Nice to come across a mind that I'm able or one that's wiling to converse. My gratitude should be a good thing . My intentions are. Yes... yesterday was thier 50th anniversary. I read Nick Mason is sponsoring.. something that interests fans to compete for a prize?? I was to evolved with over 10HRS ( almost ) straight NIN .. my buddy from my pre season kept shooting me clips of the Gods.... hahaha That stuff is just way too tantalizing to not let it play out. Then I scrambled back in a hurry to continue with my own concert in my head. You know what I'm saying, feeling, goosebumps on top of goosebumps. Hahahaha. I'm going to get back into the Nails again. I'm trying to OD on them. Well enjoy your day, Rock on!

“Come on bass! March!” Some of the best bass ever!

Pino is the G.O.A.T. on bass.

Totally dude. I am loving that bass

I was suprised of seeing him in this lineup. One of my favourite bass players.

@@fernandoreis1518 can you provide a brief bio on him?

Those that know, know :). Trent knows how to pick em

8:28 he stands up to go to the piano, plays it perfectly and then comes running back at 9:10 to keep hitting the drumms like theres no tomorrow

ILAN RUBIN SAY HIS NAME ILAN RUBIN

@@AlexisMorales-ww3kl How did I not notice that lmao

+UntitledKirk if you weren't gonna do it, I was. Thanks man

UntitledKirk So glad they didn't play "Closer" but why don't they play "Heresy" anymore?

oscar godinez What?

Nowimsomething Exactly

For future reference guys and gals, the set list is usually in the description of the vid. Maybe check it first?

It's interesting that he used to be depressed and use drugs but ultimately has come out on top and a lot of similar artists during the 90's either committed suicide or over-dose.

Mr. TRENT has maintained his APPEARANCE to the ARTISTRY: EDGEY

I like to think about Manson, who never really evolved musically. I think it's about the people you surround yourself with and realizing sometimes you've outgrown them and bad habits.

@@arturotorres6437 #1 Pearl Jam #2 NIN #3 Tool

Simply put, even at 60 and enjoyed NIN in their prime, it's the best f#$% music ever

Ilan Rubin is great!

He is great in Angels and Airwaves too. Different style.

I bet he was exhausted after the show!! That's some heavy drumming!

Amazing. Unique WOW!!!!

As if u dont know him! He has his own side project too 👌👌👌

I still think that the Lights in the Sky Tour is "the one" for me with the motion tracking + live depth processing. Have you seen videos of it? (Still, I do agree _all_ of their tours have perfect light shows.)

agree - check out a Cult Of Luna concert for a bad ass metal light show

It's amazing!

The company behind the lighting is Moment Factory and they worked with NIN in the LITS tour too. They're god tier in the industry.

seriously, it's mind-blowing

and right after the camera pans to another guy off to the right who has about 3 keyboards, WTF? The drummer lose a bet?

Maybe two seconds, and in the dark, too. Coulda gone badly

Are you a musician?

@@ollielaw Will do, thanks for the info! Cheers!

drummer is a legend dude

the drummer is a huge part of this overall amazing af vibe. hands down one of the best live shows on here. Im a 40 yr old metal drummer from cnda and this show is tbh on another level of perfection.

@ᴇʀᴇɴ ᴊᴀᴇɢᴇʀ Is that his name?

@@markusaurelius777 this was Ian Ruben here

Thank you.

peter lustig You’re awesome, man.

I was in the process of doing this same thing, when I saw yours. Good job. I don't know why it's not like this in the song list under the video.

Nice detail with the albums Peter

With the albums. Good on ya

@@jamesmotter1221 Tool's drummer is insanely good yeah ^^ even though prefer Mastodon's one ! I love the way this drulmer plays anyway, the energy of his drumstyle outscales the majority of drummer imo. I don't get the purpose of your comment by the way

@@PowDJoke he is good and tight. Pino is just a absolute beast on bass. Danny Carey from tool is a octopus and is just awesome.

@@jamesmotter1221 it s a top crew, all of them,not even a. Nin guy , only know the guitsr😑🐷

@@jamesmotter1221 bruh you're trippin! That's Ilan Rubin. Kid Phenom and one of the most talented hired guns in the industry.

@@schullyschullyschull no bro you trippin...who else he plays with who is even worth Mentioning? Exactly just nine inch nails! Google him..

Thank you so much

Really appreciate the extra effort to state the album each song came from.

Youre the goat men 😎🤙

I’m an audio engineer and this documentation is incredibl.

The hero we need, ladies and gents. Much love.

+Alistair Coulson Ilan Rubin

Youngest drummer to ever play at Woodstock.

If you ever get the chance.... GO!!!!

yeah all the drummers they've ever had have been good as

Vrenna was better :P *sits back with popcorn* x

It's a different thing when you listen to NIN from a CD as opposed to watching them play live. I mean, the live version is an experience, not just a concert.

Trent definitely puts a good deal of planning to his shows. He really wants people to have a good live experience, not just see people play his songs. It's a show after all. I just saw him a couple weekends ago and he had carefully planned a different light show for each song that was played. It was amazing!

Literally me this week. I've been listening to their music for about a year now as I discovered/decided to start listening to them during June 2013. Decided to watch some live videos out of curiosity. I am completely AMAZED and cannot stop watching!!!

The best ever live !!

22suprstar22 same here man.

Me too! Ages like pearls around a Madonna.

Conveniently he scored Quake, so it fits.

@@Itiswhatitisitiswhatitiswhatit yup. As if the NiN on each box of nails wasnt enough of a giveaway. Although i have to admit, despite Reznor coursing through my veins i have to choose quake 2's soundtrack vs the ambience dreamboat that Q1 had. I wonder what ever happened to Sonic Mayhem. .

@Don Wright I know! Yeah!! People need to know wtf. QUAKE is the f#ck!ng $#¡+ in gaming and simulation. And if people started to hear NIN they would be less idiot.

Nice to see alike minds...

Be part of the Hall of Fame of Rock and Roll. CHECK

He's the Elon Musk of the alternative music world.

@@asdrofllmao Did Musk start a band with Grimes? :O

does a song for the Twin Peaks: The Return show CHECK

@@thenormanconquest No, that was the totally unrelated "The" Nine Inch Nails. ;P

Same thing

I'm on about 10 times myself, every angle of this show from lighting to recording through the board...fricken flawless

NIN is the best show I've ever seen live, and I've seen a few. Just mindblowing.

Same

Ditto!

love PINO PALLADINO ! ...you´re right Herman: ...remembering his work with GARY NUMAN -- "Dance" . -

TONY LEVIN - PINO PALLADINO - MICK KARN

@@MrThomas1958 RIP mick karn :(

Herman Melville no relation to Moby Dick? Pino? Touring with The Who?

Saw him first with John Mayer and loved what he did to that group... never imagined what he could do when paired with Reznor. Now I know. And I can die happy.

They add Soul.

Affirmative action hires

@@akshayde What the hell?

Did you really mean that?

I remember seeing this show in Colorado and was like “wow! It’s like a Pink Floyd, David Bowie, and Nine Inch Nails concert all in one!”

Neoliberalism?

@@negrungo Big time, money never sleeps...

@@negrungo I'm confused

Classic 90s, Current, Contemporary, [angry @Sebastian Garcia] Neoliberalism - suck it....whatever dude, label it what you want. The first time I heard it on the radio in high school, I was hooked. My appreciation has only exploded, especially since he sorted himself out.

@@yveltalsea Forget Garcia, he's a dredger.

I wish the guys sang too, with that growly singing on top.

Where are they both from...one sang with the Stones

all time low was so good with their vocals added! they added so much depth i wouldn't have been able to previously imagine! they're super solid vocalists, amazing talent!

Totally agree. Had the same reaction to Noel Gallagher adding female vocalists to his lineup, except he uses them on the albums too and it's extraordinary.

@@freudsghost It's like it's another song and for the better, honestly

Bless

Happy 61st! Or not. Getting there is half the fun.

NIN has helped me with that for years. Trent's music is so honest, it's hard to think of another artist who can translate their emotions into music, and have his lyrics be vague enough to be relatable. Maybe Radiohead with a song like Creep.

You young lady are awesome!

Just saw your comment...... hang in there young fella... 😁

yes definitely!

Does he have kids?

@@lnfreeman Yes, 4 kids!

I saw this tour in Toronto in early October 2013 and it is literally the best show I have ever seen and I have been to 3000-4000 shows in my lifetime (I also used to do smaller scale concert lighting and starting working in the Buffalo Music scene when I was a teenager.)

same

i know instead ill be going to thr fbi field office

i speeling error

I watched NIN in 2007 on Sziget Festival in Budapest.... It was insane!! They had nearly the same LED wall in front of the stage, only smaller... and you only could see the shadows of the band...it was mystic and blowed my mind

Hi

I watched this thinking that bass player is the best musician on the stage and looks exactly like Pino.... I never even considered that it was actually Pino in Nine Inch Nails.

1:04:19 Trent says “Pino Palladino”.

That version ranks up there with my all-time favorite NIN songs, wish they'd lay it down in a recording studio.

I prefer the album version. Slapping bass riff is just too damn good and live version lacks it.

Lovely comment.

Trent did sell his soul…but don’t u dare call him a whore.

He's a pure artist

That’s very cool. Yes, Trent is quite the Poet and is wonderful at writing music that evokes feeling. His embracement of the dark side of being alive is insurmountable. Oh and just because you had a tear does t mean you’re a gay, or weak at all. It just means that you can really explore pain. Best, oh and to the degree you dug the vocals and the chicks contribution and I happened to dislike it. It seems like it takes away from the dark.

I had to scroll way too long to find this

Thanks a lot!!!

51:53 Head like a hole.

you're a real 1

Or broad shoulders for that matter

+Mathiue David Personal opinion... Im 31 just like you but I started listening to NIN when they released "closer" and there is no band you can compare them to!! Agreed with you they are timeless but there is only one other band that makes me feel this way... Radiohead!!... Apologies for the english and cheers from Costa Rica!

+Andres Lobo NIN isn't really a band. It's just trent.

NIN isn’t a band nor is it just Trent... NIN is an emotion

bruh

@@PublicEnemyMinusOne smh

That video should go into the Music Hall of Fame. And the Woodstock show Video.

thank you!

Thank you!!!

thank you... goddamn vevo

I clicked this video randomly and found I'm checking my own comment for the timestamps. lolwut.

well done

By whom?

@@SandraLovesRoses Zoomers maybe?

If they never played another show after Woodstock 94, they would be in the rock n roll hall of Fame. I think I understand what you mean though. I think it is more under-appreciated by people afraid to listen. Genre labels and all. They don't even know they have been listening to them for years through movies, tv, etc... Not to mention Johnny Cash.

I wish I could have been at this concert. It’s so well done for live music

Good bass.. good drummer too

Agreed. Wonderful mix. In all fairness, every musician in this equation had a job to do and they did it very well.

Jason Morgan Oh, I know but I first noticed the drums. The entire set was perfect and the best quality I have heard on KZfaq and the songs off of the new album sound so much fuller and better live.

Let's not forget Sharlotte Gibson.

Pino Palladino

Wow didn't even notice Lisa Fischer - she is an absolute legend! The only one that could out do Merry Clayton on Shot Away

Ah, so she has as many Grammy Awards (2) as NIN.

@@MrArchie800 it’s called Gimme Shelter…..

been best live act for 25 yrs ;))) benchmark

@@davidsykes1281 I believe so. But I saw a bad one early 2000s.

@@davidsykes1281 Rammstein are right there

Don’t bogart that joint my friend.

Glitching Queen your not a fan than

Saw NIN back in the day with Marilyn Mason as the opening act. Now that was a concert! This concert seems a little tame.

Wouldn't have imagined seeing you around these parts, Queen!

I saw that tour twice. Then saw NIN on the same tour with Pop With Eat Itself instead of Manson. Then like a year or two later saw NIN with David Bowie

Try a Primus pit and then we'll talk.

Yes, I meant Maynard one in 2001 I believe right after the fragile tour and it was a perfect circle and he gave me Japanese candies because he was touring with APC! Puscifer and now it’s on Yellowstone and I’m like these are all listening to old Puscifer songs and I’m glad people are getting into them but to me it’s like a lifetime ago of songs that some of them make me sad and they’re just amazing but Nin and has definitely transformed into another band. I did I am just wow his vocals are great. He is one of the best he’s a genius and also Rick Rubin. He’s right up there and Dr.Dre and Rubin. Great production you know in a bit he’s one of the biggest producers, and I don’t know why natural born killers that’s what pisses me off didn’t get an award that had excellent music everything from Patsy Cline to Bob Dylan to Dr. Dre to NWA I mean like it’s amazing and then Leonard Cohen and he wins for fucking the social network really that’s why I don’t like the NRP the people that do the do you know practices and standards because they’re the ones that tell you all this is acceptable and this is not they should be canceled because nobody’s going to tell me what’s good and what’s not I’ve been on this earth a long time and I can tell you what sounds good and what sounds like shit sorry a lot of days are just fucking shit! I love I still love Manson because he puts on a good show. I don’t wanna get politically whatever with him. Why can’t he play even know who you know I don’t it’s like separating art from the artist people forget to do that.

Out of curiosity, which "famous single" do you mean? I can think of 2 or 3 songs you might be referring to.

EXACTLY what I was like for a looong time. For me it was ''Closer'' and ''Hurt'', discovering it from Johnny Cash's version. Probably was yours two too. Now I literally cannot get enough of this fucking band lmao. I love that they're played with ''real'' instruments live, while it sounds more ''computer-like'' in the studio version which I never said I disliked, I just like when ''real'' instruments are used more. Amazing bad and GORGEOUS concert!!

Band*

​@@fallen6060I was exactly the same but now I can't get enough of Trent's work either movies or NIN stuff. One of the best live performances on KZfaq this concert

@@rickybaillie4222 Exactly!

Pino Palladino

tsssss

That’s because it’s Pino Palladino there. Probably one of the top 3 session bass players in the world.

I got goosebumps

There bass is always good my friend hahaha. Got on scall candy atm woop its niceeeeeeeeeee lol enjoy 🤘💀🤘

Try Lights in the Sky. Search "this one is on us". Most amazing light show I have ever seen.

Its very good yes. but what about Tool?

@@beyer66 Not as good.

definitely up there. 2nd to only Tool imho as far as lighting and trippy visuals but even that is an unfair comparison because of the difference in styles as this is a far more intense stage presence and as such, the light show is used to greater effect here whereas Tool takes much relaxed and,nuanced approach as well as utilizing the,greatest visual effects possibly ever and the lighting is used more to enhance said visuals. They both sound pitch perfect live which is incredible considering how tight the original compositions are. 2 of the greatest bands to ever do it live. The 2 best actually imo... and they are still doing it as good now as they were 2 decades ago. breath takingly incredible

How about Meshuggah

Have you seen Gojira? They're the fuckin best

I agree with you 100% ✊🏽

The current Queens of the Stone Age tour is fire.

He is a true artist, and a genius.

Timeless is the word.

I’m a nin fanboy but he doesn’t sound like pretty hate machine. Trent can’t scream properly anymore. He stays in the safe zone.

I have loved NIN/ Trent since 1989. Been there since the beginning ...I was 19 now I am 51. NIN has been tattooed on the back of my neck for about 12 years now. It's why i chopped all my hair off. lol . I am probably the only person left that just cannot accept Atticus as an OFFICIAL member because to me it will always be just Trent.

I am exactly like that.

Washington Caires i can't get over how masterful sanctified is. the "back up" singers are amazing.. this performance is literally the future

I started listening to them around May time, and I've become more and more gripped by Reznor's work since. I've still only listened to half of their albums as I can't help but listen to their stuff over and over, finding new little things to love about their songs. Trent is a true genius, and I feel like NIN is one of the most important bands in the last 20 years.

not them, him

astorothcr Trent writes the songs, but even he's said that a lot of help comes from the other members he tours and records with.

I don't think you can compare them live and in the studio, Nine Inch nails has one of the Best production i've ever listened to, but live they are Just energetic as fuck!!

Ha ha ha!!! If you've never REALLY been in a mosh pit so close to the band you can get a high five while getting a broken rib from the crowd surge...Well...Sorry,reliving a moment... I think you get the gist of it though...🤘☢️🤘

Lol. True 😊

@@ralphnewcomejr oh, yeah I get the gist alright which is why I stopped attending rock concerts after 1990. Mosh pits were not for me ‼️😳

finish your drink if the song didn't originally have a "HEY!" in it

Take a shot every time Robin headbangs

Also works with New Order concerts

i tried and now im dead

RIP

Trent threw down a masterclass here... its glaringly obvious how much of his energy is devoted to Art now he's faced his demons. A joy to witness a talent this fierce back and stronger than ever. An inspiration to other strugglers...

Don't forget the Sunspots synth part near the end.

lol i just commented this before scrolling down the comment section!

I fucking love this version of Sanctified with that arpeggio going on

Because he's a musical God

+Zach Oberlander he is amazing live, I've "tested it" 6 times

Hes been playing live since he was 3 as a pianist and since 1988 live in a band. i.e. he has had time to practice.

because he's a perfectionist ;)

he has an amazing ear for pitch and tone, add that with being a workaholic perfectionist that only hires cream of the crop musicians and stage crew and voila!

We're all on the same boat 😂

Only thing missing is Wish. Cause that trully is my favourite live song, and it always makes me sad when I see a live recording and wish is not there...

I've seen Reznor and co. live 6 times? And every time, there are a few tracks that he seems to have dusted the cobwebs off of, that's a personal favorite, and that I feel was put on the setlist specifically for me. Crazy thing though... If I look at the setlists for the shows I miss when he comes to Chicago... I could say the same thing on those days too lol. Such a massive discography with so many incredible tracks... and he varies the setlist from one night to the next, even! Its really fucking impressive lmao

CDP?

me too. :) so happy i dont have to choose. :)

I wish he could give NIN more of those sexy bass.

That's just what he does

This collection was especially strong.

NICE!

Who is Top 1? Curious?

+Dennis Alvey Looks like you haven't seen other drummers at all if you think that Rubin is the best.

+yrussq Is that what it looks like....? I'm so glad you took the time to bring that to my attention...

Dennis Alvey Just out of curiosity - do you have any arguments to claim that Rubin is the best? I mean everyone can have their own opinion for sure but it usually based on something.. Maybe you're gay and love Rubin from the highschool or maybe you like his haircut so much that he became the best for you?

yrussq Dude I'm 43 and been going to concerts since I was 15. I'm really too busy to argue on the internet about drummers.... Sure, I'm gay and like his haircut... Haha. I just enjoy his playing, man. Find something useful to do.

Dennis Alvey I'm 43 and i've been going to gigs since 15 - that's a hell of an argument :))) I'm thrilled)) Honestly my first comment wasn't that serious even to answer on it but you decided to take your time and when i asked seriously about if there's more than personal sympathy - you started your boring blah blah blah. Wtf with you? You're most illogical dude i saw for last year. And it's aside from your gaylove with Rubin certainly...))

@Kevin Tate Dan K. Brown from The Fixx never moves either. He was out of the band for a while, but the point is he's always been a veritable statue.

Wash your filthy mouth after talking like that about Pino Palladino!!!!

33:30 But it’s the WAY he stands there! Pino is a bass legend!

Once in a very long while you come across epic comment poetry. If you only knew how very little shit makes me laugh. Feel good at this moment dude. You are a comment master. You didn’t mean to do it. But you did it. And that’s the best kind. But Palladino is one of the best.

@@foodog777 Sanctified is so Smooth with Pino

me too.

You got that right. I've seen hundreds of concerts over the years. We'll two shows I regret never seeing Pink Floyd & NIN. I'm 62 and this video of NiN is the sbit. Better than I ever thought.

Rock on!

couldn't have put it better myself. absolute genius! perfect from start to finish!

a very pleasant surprise indeed

you fan on NIN then phil? Watched you for like 3 years and i still have no idea what music you like.

I didn't know you were a NIN fan. This just makes me like you more.

Seen them in Belfast a little while ago, was great.. gonna go see them in May as they're coming to Nottingham!! yeeah

Grandi

+Dennis Alvey Also because Rob Sheridan is genius too

Roxie Marquez He really is... This whole production is completely out of this world.

+Dennis Alvey Have you seen The Wall live? I think Floyd is easily on this level when it comes to theatrics. The wall Waters builds during the show is like three stories tall and it looks amazing.

zs23100 Do you mean from the early 80's?! I was in jr high and grade school. But I have seen enough video to know what they were doing. Yes, they were definitely at this level in theatrics, but if they were to do it now with this technology... I love Floyd, so I wish I could see them do a live show with this at their disposal. There are few live shows I know of that are this amazing, even now, though.

Dennis Alvey You should check out a video of Comfortably Numb live from 2011. Gilmour and Waters played together again for one show. The video is amazing.

Yeah its got 2 b the best live performance I've ever seen and I've seen alot

It's a good song for fucking imo.

@@groxx715 Like any NIN song.

Agreed! I have seen some amazing shows in my life, but I still cannot get enough of this one.

Totally agreed! I've seen lots of different acts/genres/venues... But this one in particular won the breadwinner

It's visually stunning and impeccably done

​@@mellymel3292have you seen Tool live? They're something else

​@NooDLES411911 over month ago accidentally meet in restaurant Adam Jones, Sarasota, Florida. On the way listened to Invincible and then OMG!!

Did you listen to “Locusts” or “Together” yet? They both came out last year. They were good.

save me. I have to watch this on my laptop I need NIN yes so true

It’s why drug overdoses are up. You have got to be high as giraffe balls to enjoy today’s music

listen to his earlier music, and attach to the last 4 years of hell in america to it.

@@sylviacarmichael7525 hahahahaha nice...... so true

No one expresses pain as well as Trent does. He is the Richard Wagner of our day, pure genius.

Oh, dear. I just typed for a half an hour and the screen changed. Basically, I keep turning back to this 1. I am in utter awe with the language of sens required to run this show, and it's execution. What a peaceful thing for him to say. What a totally utouchable way to say it. I am floored every time I listen to or watch aand....this. This is what I needed. In a lot of ways. Enjoy, on many levels...

NIN's meaning really allows me to experience more potent and truer gratitude. And an overall awareness that I like and want to view life through, or with, or whatnot...I like the betterment these guys have brought on through their expressions and music. It's impressive, and it has a voice. I tend to admire the meaning of that voice, at the very least...but I am just the Admirer Of Clouds..

I wasn’t expecting to see Pino here. It was a pleasant surprise!

My favorite cyberpunk of all time. Well, in a close tie with Robin Finck.

To see him playing that synth part in the beginning of March of the Pigs, I knew immediately this was gonna be a different kind of show. And he immediately became one of my favorite bassists of all time.

i saw this tour , with Queens stoneage ! they blow Queens away big time

Totally 🔥🔥🔥🔥

For any age, really!

Because he got off drugs and started working out

No shit, I'll be proud if I look half that good at 74,

@ɮօʊռċɛ օʄʄ You don't know that for certain.

@@elliotville1742 Exactly, really wans't old. But sorting his life out early really helps. No hard drugs and staying fit and healthy does wonders. The guy is still as fresh now as we was in his prime.