Bro it's good when they let each member shine in different eras. Next should be Jiwoo

Yeah true but what I like about Nmixx is that they all got to shine at some point. Sullyoon in roller coaster and Lmlt, Jiwoo in young dumb stupid and party O’clock, Lily in O.O and Dice, Bae in party o’clock and here Dash, Kyujin in Soñar and Dice, Haewon in Kiss and Dash era too So Sullyoon will get more lines in future comebacks :)

@Kpop_Xavierit’s because in twice, most of them are underdeveloped vocalists, all members in nmixx are around average vocalists tbh bae, jiwoo and sullyoon’s vocal techniques are quite close, it’s comparable

@@ERROR-rr9gnWhat?? This was Jiwoo’s era!! Totally!! She owned Soñar and Dash!!

@@haewonsdog I personally consider Sullyoon to be a better vocalist than Bae and Jiwoo, which is totally fine considering both of them are better at dance & rap. But she has stronger support, a good mixed register and is even a comparably good belter, which already puts her above almost all of 4th gen. Just because the entirety of Nmixx on average outsings every other 4th gen gg, doesn't mean there aren't any differences between the Nmixx members. But that doesn't mean that line distribution should only be based on vocal skills, because there's rap parts too and the song has to fit the vocal color aswell. Just saying that Sullyoon comparably is one of the best vocalists in 4th gen and the only ones where I can see arguments of getting ranked higher are Lily, Haweon and Ningning while Liz, Goeun and Winter are on a similar level to Sullyoon. But obviously, when we're talking about vocals it's impossible to stay completely objective. I love her vocal color a lot too.

Lily is the main vocalist. Haewon is a lead vocalist!

@@Cheshireless No, she is definitely the main vocalist. In the vocal tier, B- along with Lily

its wrong pasonfruit and kyujin have 50 sec and haewon 30 so haewon is still 3 and kyujinn2

​@@user-wh4oo5ne6iHaewon Low AA Lily High AA

Yes right

What is "soo much better" for you? She's only 35seconds away from Bae so shes just needs 35 seconds more than Bae to satisfy you?

@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 no, but she deserves more lines in general. Like way more, maybe more than Bae, maybe more than Sullyoon, but the point is she needs way more lines Since she is best rapper, and a good vocalist. Her vocals aren't too far behind from bae.

@ValentinaFlowers but their songs doesn't necessarily have rap that's why she doesn't have more than them but when she have raps its being replaced with her vocal lines that's totally normal

​@@ValentinaFlowers shes actually a better vocalist than bae lmao

​@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211jiwoo should have more lines than bae at the very least, she's a far better rapper, dancer and even vocalist

yea! i think nmixx is actually pretty good at that, but obviously lily will have a lot of time bc high notes + main vocal. haewon is starting to get most and kyujin is center / maknace. jiwoo is a rapper, getting less lines but sometimes an average amount of lines, while bae their “least talented” apparently is getting either low average or a lot. and she gets the most iconic lines

bae also does lots of adlibs

@@njmsjmdctsea1043 Yeah, even their weakest vocalist can sing better than some lead vocalists out there

Kyujin lead vocal

@@Kep1er_OT8 They wrote Thee not three

Isn't Sullyoon is 3rd?

haewon is 3rd the distribution are wrong

Sadly

at least she’s second place overall!

JYP should to gave part for haewon

​@ecl1ps3vfx yeah I'm so happy for that! but its just that i was looking forward to highnotes and stuff XD

She got lots of high notes during expergo.

Im waiting for thisss soooooo longg

Kyujin should be 2nd imo

​@@etc-entertainment9847no

@@rjiejlk me tooo 😭

​@@etc-entertainment9847Haewon is a main vocalist, around the same level as Lily, in a vocal heavy group. She should definitely be 2nd

And boom

Sullyoon pretty much got rekt in this last cb... I guess it was the sacrifice member for this era this time

The line distribution is wrong, haewon is 3rd not 2nd

But Jiwoo already shined in the "lmlt" era, all members have their moment to shine and this time it was Bae's turn.

​@@KYU_XXjiwoo shined in young dumb stupid and lmlt, honestly her raps❤

JYPE*

Nah I think she suits more Dice

i think she fits the least

Dude she’s not going to have the most lines every comeback she shined in other songs plus the lines are fair it’s ok she’s not first

@@Kep1lieo_ im not saying that she need the most lines but I think she could have a little bit more

Key Gold (Very Fair): 0%-10% Green (Fair): 10.1%-29.9% Yellow (Normal): 30%-59.9% Orange (Unfair): 60%-94.9% Red (Very Unfair): 95%+

How do you make the average percentage per song? Pls tell me

@@Milki.... First, for each member, you have to calculate the number of seconds divided by the number of songs they participated. Then, you put in all of the inputs inside a circle graph. That’s how you get the percentages for the average line distribution. If you want to know about the variation, you find a standard deviation calculator and input all of their percentages. Afterwards you divide the standard deviation given to you divided by the mean, which is all of the percentages combined divided by the number of members there are.

@@Milki.... I’m sorry if this took so long to reply to you. When I try to explain this to someone, my reply becomes hidden (Sometimes, until the viewer look at all the comments form newest first).

@@philip0w0hoang its ok, tysm for replying 💗💗💗💗💗💗

Up

That theory makes no sense

She needs to rest for a while

​@@rolling8407 what you trying to say???

​@@sapphicxswiftslet Lily rest a bit for being constantly belting into the upper 5th octave lol

Lily didn't get the last part in the boom, she got the second most lines. Creator using the wrong line distribution

She's left

Sullyoon shined a lot in the debut and the first 3 comebacks (Dice, LMLT and Rollercoaster/Party O'clock), she only got less lines in the last comeback were Haewon, Bae and Jiwoo received more lines than before. It's pretty equal.

​@@stanbtsforaclearskin Actually Sullyoon deserves 3rd place she needs More lines she is the 3rd best vocalist with Lily 1 best vocalist and Haewon 2 second best vocalist Also Jiwoo, Bae And Kyujin are actually sub vocalist She really fits some songs like passionfruit and xoxo of the albums more than Kyujin or Bae

@@Nayeonmy178 so? being 3d best vocalist doesn't mean she should be third, Kyujin is center, 2nd best rapper and 4th best vocalist with a minimal difference with Sullyoon. Considering NMIXX has a good combination of both vocal and rap Kyujin being 3rd makes completely sense.

@@stanbtsforaclearskin Sullyoon and Kyujin are 80/90 seconds apart of difference , that's bad even Sullyoon and Kyujin are like the same Level vocal (not hate i love Kyujin)

@@Nayeonmy178 Kyujin is also a rapper and the center of the group while Sullyoon is only a vocalist, it makes sense she has a bigger difference, she still 4th.

Main rapper in a non-rap based group

@@iskreniliev3679 yet the lead rapper is in 3rd, weird

@@soyeonvsveggies lead rapper,who also happens to be lead vocalist as well as the center(aka gets a lot of focus)

@@iskreniliev3679 the lead vocalist is sullyoon and center doesnt mean “get a lot of lines”. ryujin is the center of itzy yet she’s 2nd to last in their distributions

@@soyeonvsveggies Kyujin AND Sullyoon are lead vocalists, also centers are Nayeon,Jennie(tho unofficial) and the face of the group/center/however you want to call it will get a lot of lines as their voice and image represents the group

Pero ha tenido muy buenas líneas antes, las líneas de Haewon y Bae mejoraron y por eso las de ella disminuyeron. Están dejando que todas brillen por era.

​​@@stanbtsforaclearskin Kyujin? She not gets never a last place and lily Who is the best vocalist had her first time as the last but why not Kyujin? (Not Hate Kyujin is my bias)

@@Nayeonmy178 Because she's the center probably, she's also the most allrounder member.

​@@stanbtsforaclearskin She deserves her lines but why songs that fits with Sullyoon like Passionfruit and xoxo she not have lines only little rap parts

I also agree (No hate) but they give a lot of fonts to Kyogen even with songs that do not fit the voice of the rest of the members I hope they make the rest of the members shine They focus on her voice although the rest of the members have a more beautiful voice in my opinion ​@@Nayeonmy178

In "boom"

​@@Gaons.hair_ she's 2nd in boom

@@illegaluser69 at 3:14 for the boom section she moves down to 6th.

@@Gaons.hair_ well this video is very incorrect

nah this video is incorrect

I hope she would be 5th in the next era & getting more lines like Haewon this era

Vocal tone has a lot to do with the lines you get. Also, Bae has a more stylistic approach that producers might prefer over other members. She also has a lower voice than the rest of the group that allows her to get a ton of lines in songs like run for roses.

It’s understandable since she is the main rapper and this group mainly focuses in vocals. Another factor is vocal tones, some like Bae which has a very versatile voice might get higher lines than Jiwoo.

@@Starymixx It’s not understandable to OT8 stan of 9 members group lol. Just read his(or her) nickname, it’s useless to try explain him(or her) because this person is always hate one member of the group(Bae, Nayeon, Eunchae and one of Kep1er’s members).

@@hollyglimmer3486 I didn’t even notice lol

shes the centre, lead vocal and lead rapper (supposedly) and she only has a massive lead due to tank tbh

😂😂😂😂 i also think so They distinguish her a lot from the rest of the members With clothes, singing and even slaveryThey never let Jiu dance dance break even though she's a more skilled dancer than kyujin In addition to singing, it takes a lot of lines, although Hywon has a better voice. And clothes also distinguish And clothes also distinguish it And they usually give it the most prominent thing

​​@@rawanackraman1578Kyujin is better than Jiwoo in dance

@@rawanackraman1578 kyujin is better than jiwoo at dancing, and theyve only had 1 dance break to date so its hard to say. and haewon getting barely any lines is a seperate issue and shouldnt be blamed on kyujin tbh

Boom is right, most adlibs in chorus are bgv while the outro is paternally all members got each parts

@@SoCool7987 in boom Kyujin is first, not haewon

@@illegaluser69 And Lily last not second

​@@illegaluser69wavemoonk was incorrect, you were cheated

@@MuhammadHafizfadilah it's correct

Pretty sure it’s Jiwoo

​@@hyejusbbynope lily is last

@@Kep1er_OT8she isnt

@@generationkpop9267 she is

@@Kep1er_OT8 nah

Yes she should get more idk why Jiwoo gets least lines Jiwoo 😍

@@Cryforme- jyp needs to start treating jiwoo better and stop giving all her lines to big forehead girl 😡

​@@soyeonvsveggies forehead- 😭 but haewon actually deserve what she got this comeback 😍 Coz she is 2nd best vocalist but she always used to be 4th which was low Jiwoo should get Kyujin's or BAE lines

because she’s a rapper? they are a more vocal focus group so ofc she should be last

​@@roslay211 she is a nice vocalist as well

Lily is literally last in their newest album song Boom

Jennie and winter have been last before as well

Winter is last in Don't blink Jennie is last in Boombayah, Yeah Yeah Yeah and Tally

​@@savy1563lisa is last in yeah yeah yeah, random_k is wrong

@@radioactivevolt i didn't said that i got from random_k, a lot of line distributions shows that Jennie is last

For me it's party o' clock, but yeah run for roses should really be the TT or atleast an MV for it.

Run for roses is kinda boring

I think Run For Roses is an excellent song but it has never given me vibes of being a title track, Dash deserves it, it is a song that deserves to be a title track, JYPE knows what he's doing and if he put Dash as the title track and not Run For Roses it's because that's how it should be, imo

@@delusi0nal.xdx8 real, besides Run for roses were already leaked months before its release. So it's not going to be exciting or a surprise if you already knew it's going to be the TT for this album.

And why are you mad ? LILY is still in first place with a big difference between her and HAEWON anyway