Super fun video. I definitely see Oscar and Andrea holding on to their titles for a while, as Jeff and production seem quite committed to new player only seasons for the foreseeable future.

The messiest/worst players often don't get many votes at all, because everyone wants to sit next to them at the end.

Shoutout to Karishma for racking up 22 votes against in only ONE season

Wait your telling me it took SEVERAL votes to get ozzy to redemption island on the SEVERALTH episode?!?!

Both Ciera and her mom (who she voted out) being here is the perfect irony I need for this video.

You know, i think people misunderstand players like joe. When you're good at the outplay portion, everyone becomes scared of an immunity run. They aren't allowed to play the social or strategic portion of the game because they have become the universal target from everyone.

I'm not trying to hate, but I really don't think votes received and messy gameplay are correlated at all. Half this list is good players who were targets. Thats not messy. As someone else said, messy players usually don't get a lot of votes because they're either voted off quickly or taken to the end.

Survivor was my grandma’s favorite show. I love your channel, and I know that if she were still alive, she would too. Thanks for your hard work.

Thank you for making this video! I love survivor KZfaq but never knew Ciera voted out her mom! I can’t believe no one has ever talked about it before!

Wentworth and Andrea in the same video is iconic

Started laughing when i saw the premise of the video because I just knew Andrea wold be here😂 It must be so scary stanning Andrea during a live season and she looks like she’s getting voted out for 75% of the episodes lol

I'm shocked Russell Hantz isn't on this list, but I suppose the numbers don't lie.

I wouldn’t necessarily consider Joe a bad player, he was just too much of a physical threat. People knew if he went on an immunity run and made it to the finals that he would win the game. And obviously that’s going to make people want to vote you out. But to me, that’s having a high threat level not being a bad player.

Did you know that Kelley failed math in Elementary school? Her teacher said "Wentworth will not count."

Banger video! 🔥

Jelinsky would be #1 if the title of this video was the opposite

I miss the gradual rise of amount of votes Survivor contestants would collect in seasons. With the new era I doubt anyone would get close to this top 10.

I wonder if there’s a messy winner video coming up.

9:06 "This counts as 4 votes" excellent editing choice

Joe at #9 shows him being the 9th person voted out during Episode 9.

My boi, Boston Rob, is the goat at landing himself TV gigs. You have to admit, the mess he brings to the game is super fun. He's a gambling man, too, so Deal or No Deal Island is 🔥with Mariano there, poker face locked.

I always thought Ciera voting her mom out made perfect sense and wasn't that cutthroat, since she told her! There was no way she or Laura would have made it far as a duo, so the only way to break free of it was to vote with the group, so she could have a chance to win (and even share with her mom if she wanted). Then Jeff went on and on about it, because that's exactly the dramatic scenario they wanted when they came up with the blood vs water concept: for a contestant to vote for a loved one. As a mom, I'm sure Laura was fine with it too, because she wanted her daughter to have a chance.

Redemption Island will never not feel like Jeff’s attempt to get BR a survivor win

No Hanz in top 10? He neutralized at least like 15 votes against him

I will never get over Jerri not winning HvV

Heheh, I am only 1/3rd into the video and I already know who the "winner" is, and looking at the stats...damn. My girl DOMINATES this category.

Savage getting voted out in that epic council is an all time favorite satisfying moment.

I feel like someone has definitely already topped Ozzy 😈

Curious could you do a list with contestants who have gotten the most votes in history like Boston Rob or Abi Maria?

Messy to me would be flippers and stumblers. The likes of Chase from Nicaragua, Julie from Redemption Island and even Tony Vlachos I would describe as messy players. Their moves are less calculated compared to others and can be completely unpredictable (making for better TV mind you) Players getting the most votes are just players who have a higher threat level to either win, or be brought along to the end.

An honourable mention should be abi maria who got 23 voted across 21 tribal and was voted out twice

I disagree with Joe: he was voted out because of his strength, not for being messy

i think messy should also include how many times they flip on a plan/alliance, and how many wrong votes they get

I’m shocked Varner and frasequa aren’t on the list

After rewatching this video I think good ol’ bhanu would fit perfectly on this list

The mother snuffer 😂

7:10 killed me. 😂😂

I never would've thought Andrea would be #1 here. I tend to think of her as pretty decent as she goes far every time she played.

I would disagree with the term messiest. Some of these people, like BR are getting lots of votes because they've played a lot or because they are genuine threats. Actually messy players often don't get votes because they get dragged to the final 2/3.

I really want someone to make a video that's the players who've caught the most cummulative stray votes. Like how many times have they gotten a vote but weren't the target of a major alliance

Im surprised Karishma didn’t make it

I need to know how many votes came at Jake in 45😭😭

I wonder if a quitter will be on the list

Actually Boston Rob won twice in season 8 all starts and redemption island

Based upon the variables regarding the amount each player played, ranking how “messy” a player was is not accurately reflected in True Dork Times’ and your methodology. To account for the “frequency of play” variable, I created the “Messy Index”. Messy Index = [(Vote Outs - Wins) / Seasons Played] X (Votes / Tribals) I used your method of counting all votes even if the vote was negated by an Idol. If we calculate the Messy Index for the highlighted players, this is how they would rank. Understand that other players who weren’t included in your video might have a higher Messy Index. Player Messy Index Your Rank 1 Laura Morett 3.60 5 2 Joe Anglim 1.83 9 3 Andrea Bohlke 1.78 1 4 Ciera Easton 1.68 3 5 Ozzy Lusth 1.42 2 6 Kelley Wentworth 1.29 8 7 Jerri Manthey 1.17 7 8 Jonathon Penner 1.07 4 9 Phillip Sheppard 0.55 10 10 Boston Rob Mariano 0.30 6

Joe’s biggest problem was that he started off being such an immunity threat, and then he lacked the ability to be like Tony, another immunity threat, but who insulated himself around other people and downplayed his abilities.

I think the worst players all get carried until the final 4 or later because they’ll be easy to beat.. in fact, they may not get any votes until late in the game.

Who will probably crack this list if they ever play again? Karishma?

Jeff Varner & Francesqwa

Rob only went on 5 times.. so of course he has a lot of votes

I’m here for Zane

tho strategically not the worst - her gameplay must be seen as messy… francesca, though i like her, attended 2 tribals, in 2 seasons, and got 10 out of a potential 17 votes… And was the only double first boot… she has a 100% vote out rate! even if she wasn’t a bad player, something she’s doing is messy to claim those stats

Well...after last episode, I think we just found a new number 1

🔥🔥🔥

no way, rob should not be in this list , he ruled the game in season 8 (his second time) , if he wasnt there no way amber would have made it this far , he braught her there (amber is conseidered not one of great winners) , so no wonder in season 20 he was big threat , and in season 22 of course he won (no matter how stupid were the contastants) so therfore , boston rob is one of the best contestants of all time

In wrestling, Andrea is what we call a jobber. It's her job to lose and someone else's job to win and get over with the jury. 🤣

I thought Laura Moret (CIERA VOTED OUT HER OWN MOTHER!!!) would get less votes than that but ok

Joe on this list doesn’t make sense to me?

Ciera got her wish of not playing for 4th......cause she got 6th place,10th place, and 20th place.

Messiet/worst meaning who got the most votes?

Tony Vlachos is on that list haha

No Ghost Island Angela??

Bhanu ... #EndOfStory

Things You Probably Don't Know: 1. Sami is 19 2. Ciera voted out her Mom 3. Sandra can get loud too, what the f*ck

What does being a bad player have to do with getting more votes? People often vote for their best competition… If we go buy this rubric, Christin Hidicki is a worse player than Natalie Cole, for example. Makes no sense.

Jelinsky has to be right up there on the losingest players of all time.

I think the list has to be split into to. Because alone Phillip and Joe are two completely different beasts. Phillips gets voted because he is straight up annoying and people hate him. Not because he is a threat. He really is a bad and messy player. Joe on the other hand is a THREAT. And it does not matter how often he comes back people know it. They like him but they know, they have to send him home or he will clutch the win. He is not a bad player. Same for Laura and Boston Rob. If people know you are a threat from before. Bye bye.

What if you divide the votes against by the number of tribals

Wentworth is a great player, one of the best

Boston Rob is n will always be the BEST !❤

joe is beautiful 🥹

I'm still curious as to why every single video ends in a bible verse???

Call them messy all you want but a lot of these players aren't even bad players lmao

Most misleading title award / worst measure of what makes the "worst" player. If you are constantly receiving votes (aka seen as a big threat) but surviving episode after episode by outplaying someone else and making sure they have more votes than you... in no world does that make you the "worst" survivor player.

I likeed Phillip on his second season lol

Phillip is a savage survivor player, obviously survivors edit made him look crazy. But phillip was a hard strategic player in survivor

Andrea wasn't bad

Notice how this list is full of amazing Challenge competitors, Rob, Laura, Joe Ozzy, and Andrea are likely all top 10 of all time.

I disagree some of them were 👍

These are not messy, per se. Interesting info and video though.

I don't think messy is the right word. You could be playing really good that's why votes are coming your way and playing really good isn't messy at all.

Messiest I definitely agree with, you want to avoid getting votes. However worst is a stretch since often good players get votes often. But I see where you're getting at with the premise. I consider Rob and Ozzy quite good, but yeah having played a bunch of times you're bound to rack up votes. At least Rob got 8 votes once to net a win.

How does somebody like Mary not make this list😂😂 the lady who had to be told to pick up the idol right in front of her and cries every day. I mean clearly she’s a worse player than wentworth the criteria of this list is a little stupid but still interesting

I know the basis of determining the scale was # of votes against but I honestly dont think some of these players were the "messiest" of them all.......

sorry your criteria to determine what you call THE WORST PLAYERS IN SURVIVOR HISTORY is awful. its basically biased to returning players / players that go to more tribals ie get further. this is dumb and any fan looking at the list of names understands this makes no sense................. if instead its MESSIEST. again this makes no sense. what is messy about most of these players. do better. sorry usually you do good work but this video isnt it.

Boston Rob for me. If it takes you four times to win your a bad player in my eyes.

Receiving votes doesn't make you messy? There are numerous reasons a person could receive votes.

I hope when it comes a time when Cirie finally wins survivor, IF EVER, people are also going to be like “it took her five times to finally win” or “despite it being on her fifth try”… I love Cirie but the fact are the facts and if people are always constantly throwing it in Boston Rob’s face they should also throw it in her face. You couldn’t even make it through this video not pointing it out.. other than that, good video

This is a poor way to measure this. You should have included other factors like how often the player voted correctly (for the eliminated castaway at tribal) as well as challenge prowess.