I agree !!! People are ignorant and negative for no reason Thanks for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe if you haven’t already 🤞🏾💕

They Do.

Tommy damaged mariah's voice resulted into premature decline. Celine in her 50 plus still sounds healthy. We are expecting mariah to sound raspy through the years. Unless if she have removed her nodules, she will continously experience roughness in her voice. But if she have it removed, no one knows how she will sound after

Mariah will always be Mariah ❤

😢

thanks so much for watching and commenting zach please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

I think they were happy because the track finally was working

she is a certified legend she deserves grace in these moments 🤞🏾 thanks so much for watching and commenting tavian! please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

EXACTLY!! ❤ thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe!

She been around since 1990 that a long time

people are just bored haters thats all...dont mind them Mariah is a legend !! thanks for watching and commenting alexia please don't forget to subscribe 💜

exactly!! people should be more respectful but 🤷🏽‍♀️ losers love to talk it gives them power lol thanks for watching and commenting jason please don't forget to subscribe 💜

a legend! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

40*

probably why they barely tour lol they want to keep it that way!! thanks so much for watching and commenting brilo please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

i mean they werent recording and releasing albums every year and always touring singing hard ass songs like what mariah did way back then but tbh its good that they didnt

@MariahXDiscography lol you are ignorant! Boyz 2 Men have not stopped performing and touring since they started. And have you heard Boyz2Men songs? Extremely vocally demanding songs on Wanya. He sounds even better than he did 30 years ago not this woman that should've stopped singing a decade ago.

​@MariahXDiscographyWanya suffers from vocal polyps.

exactly she's a legend! lol thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

i agree never disrespect a living legend !! thanks so much for watching and commenting palu please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

They did!! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don 't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

Exactly 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 Thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

exactly she's a legend! thanks for watching and commenting usagi please don't forget to subscribe 💜

Exactly. People are so degrading like we know it was not THE best but like show some humility. Mariah knows her voice better than anyone else😊

this is the fact people are failing to realize in these comments! this was. a spur of the moment performance no rehearsal at all! thanks so much for watching and commenting miguel please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

Rehearsing isn't going to fix those damaged and broken vocal chords babe

I agree. Even though it wasn’t the best it still SERVED!!

forever a queen and icon ❤️ thank you so much for watching and commenting alberto! please dont forget to subscribe ❤️💕

i loved seeing this live!! grew up hearing the song so this moment was great. thanks for watching and commenting matthew please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

she will always be a legend ❤️ thanks for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

Exactly ! They played this song at my grandpas funeral so it is very very special to me ❤️🙏🏽

my pleasure ! thanks for watching and commenting angelo please don't forget to subscribe 💜

thanks for watching and commenting perez lol please don't forget to subscribe 💜

I agree !! And being up against prime Mariah would be hard for ANYONE ! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

Yea they’re dragging it Thank you so much for watching and commenting don’t forget to subscribe 🤞🏾💕

a CLASSIC ! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️⏰💕

EXACTLY!!!!!!!!! just mean for nothing but will be quick to post and fake cry lol thank you so much for watching and commenting tremaine, please dont forget to subscribe!

a living legend !!! thanks for watching and commenting liz please don't forget to subscribe 💜

Respect to the legend! Thanks for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe 🥰❤️🤞🏾

Exactly show some respect to a legend !! Thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

yes she did! thats why i dont get all the negativity in the comments. thanks so much for watching and commenting nkosinathi, please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

Playback

@@andrewgarfield9898 fr?

@@andrewgarfield9898 get lost 2nd rated spiderman

Exactly. Mariah didn't have her own personal cold front surrounding her. Her voice has gone. It went years ago.

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

thanks so much for watching and commenting billy please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️ dont be mean to mariah

🦋🦋🦋

THANK YOU!!!! these people have no common sense lol thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️⏰💕

Y’all are mean as hell lol

Then don’t🤷🏻‍♂️

Mariah is a legend these people are just being mean! thanks for watching and commenting sam please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

Why is she shout singing is my question?

@@jaywest3734 can you sing ?

@Mister Deveraux Yes, but not like Mariah Carey. I'm a fan btw, I'm just wondering why she shout sings now when she didn't used to do that.

the comments are so viscous i thought you lambs were the nice fan base!

haterrrr lol can you sing at all jay? lol

thanks so much for watching and commenting juan please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️ i had a best friend names juan cordero in high school 💕🤗

I agree ! Thanks so much for watching and commenting, please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

thanks so much for watching and commenting lior please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️⏰💕

thanks so much for watching and commenting albert please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

The delusion

A true legend 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️⏰💕

they were incredible! thanks so much for watching and commenting capi please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

thanks for watching and commenting edilanio please don't forget to subscribe 💜

she is doing her best with what she has ❤️ gotta respect a real legend1 thanks so much for watching and commenting nhur please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

Cos everything else sounds so bad no one probably made it to that time

exactly people are just haters lol thanks for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 💜

why are yall so meannnnnnn liam! lol

@@timetotimetv mean? just being 100% honest. And I made it to the whistle and it was also terrible.

My whole life and I’m 30 😂🙌🏾 thanks for watching and commenting james, please don’t forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

AMEN !!! thanks for watching and commenting terry! Please don’t forget to subscribe 🥰💕

thanks so much for watching and commenting louii please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

she did great on the other songs, this one was spur of the moment. thanks for watching and commenting donald please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

She actually does during the climax

why are you assuming that you weren’t even there 😂

Definitely singing live! thanks for watching and commenting, please don't forget to subscribe ❤️🤞🏾

​@@timetotimetv because we have eyes and ears ma'am

@@timetotimetv because I’m not delusional.

thanks so much for watching and commenting john please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

Has to be !! Thanks for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

i think it was the corset and all the fake smoke bc on other songs she did great

@@timetotimetv The dry climate in LA and Vegas is also not good for the voice. Whitney also complained about singing out West in drier climates. Humid weather is much better for the voice. I’m a singer and my sinuses go crazy outside of the East Coast and my voice also suffers. I hope this clarifies.

thanks for watching and commenting salvatore please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

Nodules could be part of the reason why her voice like this because the weather and other things can affect your nodules also she has been in the studio recording since 2020 for an album so her voice could be tired because of that

she said that during the quarantine (2 years ago) which was true, her videos singing Acapella on instagram and her performances from her house are proof of that, but it's been a long time since that and her voice has nodules which makes it vary in short periods of time

Your voice can be in amazing shape…but if you knew anything about the vocals when it comes to singing, you’d know that there are several factors that hinder your ability to sing your best…the (Vegas) dry air, a cold, allergies, lack of sleep, etc. Y’all really love to get on here and spew negativity, but the gag is, at her worst…she still has proven herself for over 30 years as a singer AND songwriter.

Cmon, her voice is fucked and she doesnt seem to wana do anything about it. Tired of the nonsense

@@LiamCoughlin even if she did anything to fix the nodules, surgery will still alter how she sings. Maybe that's why she is hesitant. As someone else said it may also be too late for her to have the surgery done.

thanks so much for watching and commenting, please don't forget to subscribe ❤

She was fighting for her life up there what u talkin bout 💀

Anytime she does a tad bit off everyone wants to say she's struggling and can't sing When she can still sing she also has nodules people don't ever wanna mention that when they hate on her it's sad that people expect her to sound 100% great and sometimes like 90s Mariah and when she doesn't they go around hating on her. She doesn't sound that bad here but the weather and air can affect her voice

Wasnt it pre recorded??

She might be good in France but what do i care when i'm in another country where she sounds like sh*'t?

gotta ignore the haters! thanks for watching and commenting dom please don't forget to subscribe 💜

I dont think her her condition is reversible anymore, it's been two decades already since she started having problems and she probably did what she could have done.

it's not that easy, the risk is not only to lose the whistle but she could also lose her voice entirely.

She's done.

I think she needs singing classes to adapt to her new capabilities

It’s too late. She’s not a spring chicken anymore. Recovery even if it goes well will be risky

Thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe 💕❤️

definitely! people almost seem to forget she's a living legend and changed not only the standards but also the industry itself

exactly people looooooove to be mean for no reason! thank you so much for watching and commenting tyler! please don't forget to subscribe ❤️💕

​@@user-rw2dr5my1syou sure??? Whitney was booed off stage

​@@user-rw2dr5my1sin 2010 Whitney did get really bad during her last tour. It's Heartbreaking but we just have to love them for the music they made for us.

@@user-rw2dr5my1sMariah never sounded as bad as Whitney in her last performances

thanks for watching and commenting porjip please don't forget to subscribe 💜

Thanks so much for watching and commenting Miguel please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

I agree! If they’re going to hate and be mean they could simply move on !! Thanks so much for watching and commenting, please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

period! thanks so much for watching and commenting AJ please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

@@timetotimetv thank you for posting! will do

i agree bc she did great on beautiful with Miguel ! thanks so much for watching and commenting gary please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

But people will always want to hear the classics .you could always rearrange the hits tho

@@fucu41 if you want to hear the classics, go listen to tape or CDs. you know, our voice changes every day. these singers are also human. they are experiencing a lot of changes with their voices and that is normal. Mariah has nodules and it affects her singing

@@garyrizwan1024 calm down bitch.i was just saying lowering the key and simplified arrangements. I can't sing so I would never judge a great singer

they held it down for her! still an iconic moment ❤️ thanks so much for watching and commenting angel please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

check out her performance with miguel in my concert playlist! thanks so much for watching and commenting manuel please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

i agree!! thanks for watching and commenting seth please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

just HATERS!! thank you so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe if you haven’t already ❤️ 💕

she can definitely still sing, her other songs during this show were great i recorded all of them ❤️ thanks for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

You’re not helping Mariah at all. You keep defending her with these words. Retire or not perform/ sing live no more.

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don 't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

how did she not appreciate it lmao

Probably doesn’t lip sync so people don’t accuse her of doing it all the time. Double edged sword ! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don 't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

@@timetotimetvcan you do it thou

thanks for watching and commenting paulo please don't forget to subscribe 💜

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

people are just haters, dont mind them! thanks so much for watching and commenting donyell please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

shut the f up and just enjoy Mariah musicality and legacy.

thanks so much for watching and commenting ray please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

@@Nugreen lol IKR

she sounded great with miguel rigth after this ❤️ thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

i think she just came out for the fans not for the money bc no way they could afford her real rate with all the other stars that came. thanks so much for watching and commenting bernard please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

hard to stop singing songs you love im sure. thanks for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

So she should stop singing the songs that made her a star? Your comment makes no sense.

She pushed the envelope and made those records during her earlier years, cementing her place in history. But factors like age, hormone, rest, etc could affect a live performance. If her voice was not there that day, nothing can do about it. She could not change the song and she wanted to sing live with Boyz2Men. We just have to accept that she has past her prime. Nowadays whenever I hear a nice song, like Miley Cyrus’ Flowers, and I almost always think Mariah’s capable to sing that. BTW, I watched the whole performance from another video, the beginning was ok, but after one or two songs, she’s already sipping tea, then struggling with One Sweet Day; She complained about the smoke on stage. After a break and supposed wardrobe change, she came back more relaxed, and much less smoky on stage. She did well with We Belong Together, and using it as outro was nice.

It’s not painful stfp🤣

😬

Back in the day in my opinion. At her best she top3 best singer I ever heard

thanks so much for watching and commenting jay please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

It’s probably veryyyyy scary to think about and she risks not being able to sing anymore so idk. Tough choice ! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

I think she may come to a point where she has no choice. There are some very good doctors that can basically perform miracles. Is a whistle register worth your whole vocal range? I agree with her about not wanting to lose it but someone should explain to her the value we receive of her full, unique voice version a whistle note here or there. These aren’t the same surgeons who performed Lucile Ball daughter’s. These surgeries are so easy they do mine in literally 5 minutes. Some of the surgeries are also just temporary. For example, if her voice is spasming, they will inject Botox, if the vocal folds are too loose, they inject filler. Liked AND subscribed. Take care and let’s wish our best to Mariah! @@timetotimetv

I don't know she older now healing is not the same as you get older especially something as fragile as your voice box and vocal chords

@@MoncureCoyote it's a tought choice since her technique is built around the nodules, without them she'll pretty much have to re-learn to sing from 0

There’s always a reason she can’t sing isn’t there?

@aquaboy12 well, being a work horse and a constantly booked icon does tend to leave you open to having issues.

@@ohmygoodnessdillon1818 so is it “issues” or the smoke machine? Or some other excuse?

@aquaboy12 The smoke machine is the issue this time. Other times, artists always have issues. Also, get a fucking life other than jumping into people's comments and being a little bitch ass.

@@aquaboy12 she literally just ate last Sunday you weird buffoons need help

I AGREE!! this song shouldve won !! thanks so much for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️⏰💕

its not an easy decision i'm sure. probably super scary ! thanks for watching and commenting sylvester please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

It’s over sadly :(

i know she must be very scared about what could happen. thanks for watching and commenting tris please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

we have to be positive! thanks for watching and commenting Andrew please don't forget to subscribe 🤞🏾

they did what they could 💜 thank you so much for watching and commenting josh ! please don't forget to subscribe ❤️💕

thanks for watching and commenting mika please don't forget to subscribe 💜

thanks so much for watching and commenting taurayi please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

Yea we all age and are body changes over the years hell when this song came out I was a slim teenager now I’m fat grown ass man lol 😂

Lungs don't hit notes. Her washed up and very damaged vocal cords are the problem

referring to mariah as washed up should be ground to get you kicked off this platform bc whoa 😂 show some respect to a legend

😂😂😂😂😂😂 damn

thats a full body corset wayyyy more intense than a waist trainer lol there is no air being circulated at all under there i promise you 😂 thanks so much for watching and commenting julie please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

So true.

Stop being so judgmental and hateful. If it was painful to watch this you’re not a real fan.

@@jalonwatts I just don’t understand why she keeps trying to sing the songs like before instead of singing less high and better

It’s literally lowered one semi tone what are you talking about ?

@@johanguams6619 the song is in a lower key what are you talking about?? You don't know how to listen to music and you want to talk about singing???

That's what you get in return for shading other singers and her former songwriters.

​@@voiceofreason2237 huh?

I’m not really shading, just being sincere. Hope she’ll work on her recovery now, resting is not enough. In fact, I hope there is a solution for this problem, because the damage is real.

U can't be serious as nate was off key..but go off

@@voiceofreason2237 stay mad bitch

it was the smoke machines!! thanks for watching and commenting reyhan please don't forget to subscribe 💜

never count out a legend!! thanks so much for watching and commenting chester please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

So was Whitney a long time ago

who is liamani ? we all came to see mariah lol

Thanks for watching and commenting please don’t forget to subscribe ❤️💕

She’s been sick since beacon ended. 🙊

@@aquaboy12 no that just time you idiots like to come out

She isn’t sick she was hoarse and the smoke was messing with her cause she literally just ate last Sunday

Well its her new normal

i also think it was the smoke its the first thing she said when she came to the stage and they waited a long time before she came on to try to clear, didn’t work. thanks for watching and commenting O please don't forget to subscribe 💜

thank you so much for watching and commenting J rob ! please don't forget to subscribe ❤️💕

thanks so much for watching and commenting please don't forget to subscribe ❤️🤗💕

she was doing her best with all that smoke! check out her performance with migeul on my channel ❤️ thanks so much for watching and commenting gareth please don't forget to subscribe 🤗❤️

@@timetotimetvstop the bs. The “smoke” didn’t do this