PCGS Unboxing #4 - Graded Coins Found Coin Roll Hunting and Others In this video, I will reveal the grading results of my coins that I found either coin roll hunting, through junk silver purchases, or have had in my collection - through my submission to PCGS. 5 of the coins submitted were found from coin roll hunting bank boxes and 3 were found through junk silver purchases (acquired through either cherry-picking LCS Shops or Silver Dealers). Here's the Links to the videos of some of the coins featured in this video: 2015 Homestead Quarter: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/b7CkmLZ5tbzSdYk.html 1929 S Buffalo Nickel: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rrGFird4lpfLnI0.html 1943 S War Nickel: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bNBon7N3v8C-po0.html 1886 and 1883 O Morgan Dollars (VAMs): kzfaq.info/get/bejne/aqqcoqZ03c61cZ8.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/p555lsKqvs2bhJ8.html 1901 Indian Head Cent: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/p7GqdJBpmM-qeWw.html Not sure which Nickel hunt yielded the 1959 D and which Junk Silver video I found the 1883 CC Morgan. I hope you enjoyed this video and found it informative. I will be doing more videos like this of more of my great finds while roll hunting Pennies, Nickels, Dimes, Quarters, Half Dollars and Dollar Coins. Keep hunting and good luck! They're still out there for us to find! Here's the link to the PCGS Population Report Website that I used in this video: www.pcgs.com/pop/uscoins By the way - I am selling my custom Coin Roll Hunting Mats on my website or on eBay (see below): robfindstreasure.com/whats-for-sale/ www.ebay.com/usr/robfindstreasure PLEASE SUPPORT MY CHANNEL - I am an Amazon Associate and if you shop on Amazon, please feel free to clink one of my links below - I get a little extra every time you shop using my link: www.amazon.com/shop/robfindstreasure Strike it Rich - Coin Errors/Varieties Book: amzn.to/2NkItnU The Microscope I use is good quality and low-priced: amzn.to/2JFQtcS US Coins Redbook - really handy: amzn.to/2kjLW8P I post several new videos weekly so please subscribe if you wish to see more: goo.gl/7jX6g5 Thanks for watching! Facebook: fb.me/RobFindsTreasure Instagram: instagram.com/robfindstreasure/ Twitter: twitter.com/RobFindTreasure paypal.me/RobFindsTreasure robfindstreasure.com

Ok. THAT just blows my mind. I 100% disagree with the 1901 IHP being a questionable color. I would say crack it open and send it to NGC. There is NO way that this is a questionable color.

You could get into a time machine, travel back to 1901 and get a fresh IHC from the mint, come back to present, submit it to PCGS and get questionable color.

Unbelieveable on the IHP. Makes me question PCGS. Sorry Rob. It's like it was struck yesterday. Send it to NGC instead.

They are probably too amazed, I would submit it to NGC

Crack it send it to NGC for or resend to pcgs cracked out. I don't see questionable color at all. I could believe wizzed or cleaned without looking at it too close. Good luck

I hate it when pcgs gives you a bs upgradable response when the coin is perfect!

That is absolutely ABSURD pcgs. IS SCARED BC ITS IN SUCH GREAT SHAPE mom and pop DIDNT DO ANYTHING TO THAT COIN so angry 😡 that coin is perfectly normal and you and I know it break it out and send it off someone paid pcgs to not grade it so their coin wouldn’t lose value lol thx for sharing see you on the next one 👍🏻👊🏻

It's interesting watching your old videos, we've all learned so much over the last few years.

That Indian Head Cent was one of my favorite coins I seen you find coin roll hunting. It broke my heart to see it designated ungradeable. I would break it out and send to NCG, and thank you for all you great and informative videos!

I’d crack it and see what NGC says I’d say. PCGS is scared too decide what to grade it at. Go for it Rob!

PCGS did the same thing to me on my 1910-S penny. I’ve had that coin for 40 years, finally submitted it, and got the same “not gradable” BS. It was given to me in change at an ice cream parlor when I was 19. I stuck it away in my coin collection, untouched for 40 years. $50 dollar loss, in my opinion.

I was in a coin shop when a customer (who knows his stuff) brought in a box from PCGS to unbox with everyone. Many of the coins were deemed cleaned. Along with the owner, another owner and myself we could not find anything wrong with them.

Hey Rob, I totally understand why you're loyal having your coins graded by PCGS, but if you're wanting the more forgiving grades on some of those MS62 or questionable colored coins, maybe try getting them graded by NGC. To be fair, they have very skilled graders too.

Man talk about getting kicked in the gut, I said some adult words, that was a devastating blow, I swore it was at least ms66+, my heart just sank when you showed the back of that case and I saw the ungradable 😢😢😢

NGC the Indian. Looks legit to me.

I think you should crack out the IHP and resubmit it to NGC. That is too nice to call it questionable!! Dang!! Congrats on the dollars.

100% break it out submit to NGC that coin is a beauty!

I would definitely crack it and re-submit to NGC.

Catch the IHC out and submit it through NGC. I had a 1890 something IHC that was kinda mirrored on the back and you could easily see it with the naked eye. PCGS said that it was done by somebody which I didn’t believe so I submitted it to NGC and they said that it’s a coin that they only seen seven of. So my opinion is to send it to NGC to see what they say and hopefully you can get my luck from my IHC. Happy hunting and good luck Rob.

No matter what - that is a phenomenal IHC. Something that merits display - even if “questionable “. Have a great week!

Yes Rob I would have split into two. That bites. I would send it to another company.

i would absolutely submit to ngc and the first 3 slabs as well.

I’ve learned so much about grading just from these reveal videos. Can’t wait to see the next one.

I'm no expert, but that sounds like a crock on the IHP. If it were me, I'd submit it for reconsideration and/or send it to NGC

Overall I prefer PCGS. However for damaged/questionable coins, I like to send them to NCS/NGC. I am a silver trader, but lately I have been getting into coins more with more junk silver I get that have been in good shape and started branching out into pennies and nickels. Some deserve grading. Some really don't but will anyway if they're for my own collection. That Indian head... I'D definitely send it to NGC (yeah I know it's a year later just offering my opinion)

I would definitely try getting a different grade on that Indian Head. It's crazy

All my slabs are NGC, I think I like their scoring better!!

Rob, that CC morgan is unbelievable! I remember that one. It could just be your camera, but I personally think the indian cent potentially looks a bit off too. Hard to say without seeing it in hand. Reselling indian head cents was my bread and butter 10 years ago, and the ones I've handled normally have a deeper orange/red color. But like I said, it's hard to tell on video. I could be completely wrong! It would be interesting to see what NGC does with it.

I'd clack the case and send it to NGC!!! Those are some nice finds Rob!

Man this sucks! I would definitely send it to NGC

Great info thanks Rob and congrats

Wow. Thanks for sharing .

I really wish that PCGS released their grading notes with the coins. Resubmit that to NGC.

I legitimately cussed at my phone.... I'm in disbelief.... they probably never saw an indian this nice before... what a drag, man...

As a fellow coin collector, the "Questionable Color" designation makes my soul hurt for you Rob. I've been watching you for months and can't believe you would submit a coin that would be altered in any way. I've paused this video at many points to try and look over and over again at this coin and I know that through video isn't the same as in hand but this looks absolutely gorgeous. I would definitely crack it and send it to NGC.

Sorry to see the IHP come back ungradable...it’s a beauty. The good news is that you got nice returns on the nickel and CC 🙌...the first thing I thought was that you should try NGC on the IHP, so I was there before you even asked :)...if I were you, I’d def seriously consider doing so. Thanks for sharing, Rob and take care ✌🏼

Rob, That extra bit on the H in Homestead is what machine doubling actually looks like on incuse lettering. The rest of that is original design, lighting, or die deterioration. Wexler and Wiles both have examples of machine doubling that looks like what you were concerned about, and they labeled it machine doubling. Valuable hub doubling on incuse letters decreases their size, and none are known for quarters. You have to look at the incuse lettering of certain 2013 and 2015 cent DDRs to see what it is supposed to look like. Also, PCGS won't label any variety, period, unless it's in the CPG. ANACS won't even label a variety unless Wexler verifies it.

There’s no way the 1901 is questionable color. At least MS66 or 66+. Beautiful coins sent in. The toning on the Morgan is really nice. Toned coins are so nice

That CC is just gorgeous!! You lucky bastard lol!

DUDE!!!!!! I was literally yelling at the screen on that IHP. I probably created some new curse words as well as shouting some old favorites!!! I would definitely NGC it. Everyone has coins where the alloy mix is not exactly a common red or brown. I have pennies from the 20s and 30s that are almost yellow. I feel that you are a victim of a pretty big injustice on that coin. That is probably one of the nicest IHPs I have ever seen. Thanks for the video Rob. Just glad you came up a bit with that Morgan.

I don’t think I ever clicked so fast in my life!

What????? I have been waiting for that IH forever!!! I guess they just couldn’t believe it. I say crack it, try NGC, can’t hurt!

Thanks for another video, I personally can't wait to see my grades and always look before getting my coins back.

Late to the party on this video but wow that CC Morgan was beautiful. I hope to get my hands on something like that in my lifetime.

On the edge of my seat about the Indian Head cent.

After dealing with PCGS for a few years I've had suspicions of shady practices....i don't deal with them anymore.

Super nice coins and grades on those coins.

Dang! Finding a full-steps nickel while coin-roll hunting is amazing! (value is $200 now) And wow - that 1883-CC DMPL was incredible! (value is $625 now) And dang it again on that IHC!... Another great video!

I'm so sorry Rob. Hopefully mine comes out better.

Lucky find on that CC Morgan!!

Go for it Rob... that IHP needs more!

Rob, dont feel bad about ‘questionable color’ they did that to seeker on a IHC too. Send it to NGC

"Questionable Color" deserves an appeal. Crack it and send it to NGC!

whenever I'm flabbergasted by something now, I say "questionable color?" over and over. Love your content, keep it up!

I have been waiting so long for this!!!

That is a weak excuse for not giving you a proper grade. Send it to NGC

Can't hurt getting another company's second opinion. Go for it and resubmit the IHC. Bummer that PCGS couldn't grade that beautiful IHC.

Amazing content. Thanks for sharing

That 1883 DMPL is beautiful. I would break that IHP and send to NGC for sure. What a beauty. I do not confess to be an expert but from what I've learned and watching your video's, that penny looks authentic. Not sure on difference between NGC and PCGS, which one being more reputable, but I'd send to NGC and get a second opinion. The 5 step nickel was awesome! That war nickel was a beaut. I have a war nickel with some steps, but not having a good microscope, can't see all of the coin.

Congrats on the Morgans I would take that IHC any day That was my thought grade at another service.

Bust it out and send it to NGC.

This is the Curse of Robs Currency Island enjoying the finds you found the real treasure Silvers and Notes Enjoying your high energy..jealous I am.. Hi UDO

great coins and video really good info

I want to see the cracked out Indian Head and submitted to NGC video, next! No way I’d take one opinion on that good of coin, plus a video on how to crack it out and resubmit to another grading service would be a good service video as well. Reinvigorate the excitement in that very special coin!

That's ridiculous. I would definitely send that to NGC.

That Morgan is beautiful! Congrats!

I am quite a young beginner so I wouldn’t understand but what the heck just do it. Crack it. Just do it, Rob. I think they re just too stunned to even imagine.

Man.... Such a high just to crash and burn with that Questionable Color. Bummer..... Amazing coins nonetheless. Congrats on the variation status labels

The H on Homestead is incuse machine doubling, not a DDR. I left a long comment explaining how it works in your original video with that coin, though probably not reasonable to expect you to see all the comments :P For the non-CPG listed varieties, you should submit those to ANACS. PCGS won't attribute anything that they don't list on their website.

The underlying ghost carbon spots are indicative of striping. Probably in the distant past to facilitate retoning. It didn't work. The carbon spots though faded can still be seen. Bummer. I love your show.

Nice!! Sorry for a few of the disappointments

Submit it to NGC. PCGS has lost their minds.

FINALLY!!!

Sorry Rob on that 1901 Indian penny that one was gorgeous, but it just tells me not send mine over there, I have 1906, 1907, and 1908 that look like yours. So mine will stay where they are at till they tone up some. Great 👍 show 👏 keep up the good work.

I would have to know for sure. Submit it to NGC. If it comes back the same way twice then live with it. Good luck!

Rob, You should think about sending the indian cents to another service. They look great.

Dang.. bummer on most of the results. At least you got what you were looking for on the Morgans! I would definitely resubmit the Indian Head to NGC!

Nice coins right there!

I would have to get a second opinion on the 1901. But you did get good grades on some of the others. I'm bummed out too on the Indian Head. That's for sharing. ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️😁♥️

The 1901 seems like it is brand new. That is probably why they rejected it, might be plated? I'm no expert but I can surmise they must have compared this coin to the ones they've had in for grading, and among the population they've recorded that coin may have toning not consistent with the others which may have lead to that issue of being ungradable. Again, one must think that the very best they've seen would have a consistent finish/toning from new -- and this being like-new would have to be consistent with that population. Again, if this coin was too bright it might raise suspicion. Either it is the best 1901 in existence, or it has been plated? Again, my mind is purely in speculation mode. Compare this to a newly minted coin, it looks similar but that is unlikely with over 100 years of oxidation unless it was stored in an air-tight container. Again another mark against it. Just trying to figure out the reasoning here, not making a judgment. I think it all comes down to plausibility and the odds this coin was stored perfectly for over 100 years and looks like this is just too unlikely, hence I think that might be what they're thinking too. On the plus side that CC morgan looks like it'll make up for all your troubles. Beautiful coin.

So... You'll have to let that 1901 cent lay outside in the elements for a few days to knock off the shine. Unfortunate, but apparently true.🙄

I really like these submission results videos

Those were some awesome looking coins

Submit to NCG they have much nicer slabs and they'll take everything into consideration I think it's at least an ms 69 or 70

On that 1901, I see a MS Grade coin not a “questionable colored” Coin. You cal those experts at PCGS, well that wasn’t very expertise of them to do so that coin and give it a wrong grade!

I’m sorry about that Indian head! It is beautiful and could be an upgrade for the book though

I really enjoy your videos. I think you do a great job. I had to chuckle when you said you called them and requested DMPL. I wish we could do that. All of my Morgans would be DMPL. 😊

PCGS was hatting they know is genuine.. The problem is that they can’t believe what they are seeing lol.. Smh.. No worries we just keep on hunting .. lovely proof like Morgan .. 😂..

I have a theory about that IHP. While I agree with what everyone else is saying, another possibility could be that the coin is in such outstanding condition that they are deliberately trying to get you to send it back for a regrade just to get more money from you. That's literally the only thing I can think of. I am absolutely appalled. There is absolutely NO WAY that coin COULDN'T have gotten a grade. Rob, I sincerely hope you can get a legitimate grade on that IHP. Believe me, we are all as bummed as you are. Good luck.

I say send it to NGC! Glad you got that DMPL rating!🔥🔥

yes I love these videos!

They give the "questionable colour" grade to most MS copper coins... Almost all the copper coins ben TheCoinGeek submits get the qustionable colour grade

"Hopefully we get good grades." (Okay now that's me when I so school.)

Nice! Congratulations on the Cc

Wow over 1k checked in to see this your subscribers are amazing!

I would send that IHP to NGC for grading as PCGS grading is "QUESTIONABLE" imo.

That 1883 cc was stunning! That indian head cent should have been at least ms 66 rd. Resubmit for sure.

Thanks alot for making these videos

Unfortunately, I've seen this a lot with conserved copper coins. They know the coin has been conserved because of the look and lack of toning (copper is very reactive), however proper conservation is allowed. Except with copper they are very picky -- they are even very picky in what copper they will conserve. So it is what it is. I suspect that NGC will say the same thing. You might have more luck with ANACS. Also, ANACS recognizes far more VAMs than PCGS or NGC, so better luck there as well. Cheers!