“I know some day you’ll have a beautiful life, I know you’ll be a star in somebody else’s sky, but why can’t it be mine” slaps

This isn't a song you listen to. This is a song you feel.

To all future generations - DON’T let this song die.

One of the greatest songs ever made.

Hey, oh Sheets of empty canvas Untouched sheets of clay Were laid spread out before me As her body once did All five horizons Revolved around her soul As the earth to the sun Now the air I tasted and breathed Has taken a turn Oh and all I taught her was everything Oh I know she gave me all that she wore And now my bitter hands Chafe beneath the clouds Of what was everything Oh the pictures have All been washed in black Tattooed everything I take a walk outside I'm surrounded by Some kids at play I can feel their laughter So why do I sear Oh, and twisted thoughts that spin Round my head I'm spinning Oh, I'm spinning How quick the sun can, drop away And now my bitter hands Cradle broken glass Of what was everything All the pictures have All been washed in black Tattooed everything All the love gone bad Turned my world to black Tattooed all I see All that I am All that I'll be, yeah Uh huh, uh huh, oh I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star In somebody else's sky But why Why Why can't it be Oh can't it be mine

Lost my lovely son to cancer. He loved Pearl Jam. It's a kind of comfort. Miss him so much, its unbearable

June 2024!!!! Still Top Band!!! 🩵💛

You don't ask why someone is listening to Black. You respect whoever is listening to Black (and enjoy listening too).

God, I can't believe it's been 30 years. This song still hits me like a teenager. If you are in your teens right now I bet it hits you hard, you are lucky, enjoy your youth 😎

Can we bring this back? This music? This feeling? This vibe. The world needs more of this. Easily one of the most replayable songs of all time it never gets old.

Greatest grief one shall have is loss of someone who is still alive. This song proves it for sure.

I wonder how many tears have been shed listening to this masterpiece???? Such a powerful piece of art!!!! Thank you Eddie!!!!!

Lyrics- Hey, oh Sheets of empty canvas Untouched sheets of clay Were laid spread out before me As her body once did All five horizons Revolved around her soul As the earth to the sun Now the air I tasted and breathed Has taken a turn Oh and all I taught her was everything Oh I know she gave me all that she wore And now my bitter hands Chafe beneath the clouds Of what was everything Oh the pictures have All been washed in black Tattooed everything I take a walk outside I'm surrounded by Some kids at play I can feel their laughter So why do I sear Oh, and twisted thoughts that spin Round my head I'm spinning Oh, I'm spinning How quick the sun can, drop away And now my bitter hands Cradle broken glass Of what was everything All the pictures have All been washed in black Tattooed everything All the love gone bad Turned my world to black Tattooed all I see All that I am All that I'll be, yeah Uh huh, uh huh, oh I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star In somebody else's sky But why Why Why can't it be Oh can't it be mine

When you're happy you enjoy the music But when you're sad you enjoy the music

The greatest song ever. Anyone in 2024?

My mama passed away this morning. We listened to this song a lot over the years & recently. I will never forget how I felt listening to this with her, as she slept, as my whole world turned black this morning. I LOVE YOU MOM! You are now FREE & CANCER FREE! I’ll see you in my dreams my sweet lady 🖤😞

I played this song at my Mom's funeral in March. This was her favorite song along with Alive. This has become the MOST precious, important and extremely powerful song in my entire life... She passed away on February 27th... I'm still not over it nor do I think I ever will. She was my whole world, the reason why I got up in the morning, why I even bother to breathe. The world has become so dark with not a single beam of sunshine... It's all black.... I miss you so fucking much Mom! I hope I'll be with you soon! 🌫🖤🌫🖤🌫🖤🌫🖤🌫🖤🌫

There's a girl somewhere in the world who broke Eddie's heart, and she probably lived her life with no idea of the lasting impact of what she did. On the other hand, this song stands as a witness to a love and loss story that we've all experienced at some point. Every time this song plays, a little bit of that person and feeling comes back; sometimes, it brings a smile, other times, it draws a tear.

I just saw them last night in Seattle, they opened with this. No empty seats in the arena, everyone on their feet and singing along while we could only see their silhouettes. Perfectly black. Phenomenal.

One of those rare songs which hits you right in the feels. You can never get enough of " Why why why can't it be mine".

That rip in your heart when you realize it's just not going to happen with someone that meant all to you.. Pearl Jam threw it down on record like no other.

This is, easily, in my opinion, one of the three best songs ever written.

This is one of the greatest songs of all time. A timeless masterpiece.

One of the most beautiful songs ever written. Undoubtedly one of the most, most beautiful.

Eddie Vedder sings with so much passion yu can feel it.

This song played every now and then when my mom would drive as a kid, first time ever listening to it in depth. It’s insane how Eddie expressed his anguish so strongly through the rasp in his voice, hitting different notes, even the guitar had my hairs raised. painfully beautiful song.

It really is a masterpiece. They have a bunch of hits but Black really is their masterpiece.

nobody write songs like this anymore

Still one of the best songs of all time.

April 2024 , still one of my favourite songs ❤

summer 2024, this will be played nonstop to get over her

"Tatooed all I see. All that I am. And all I'll ever be" "I hope someday you'll have a beautiful life. I hope you'll be a star. In somebody else's sky. But why. Why, why, can't it be. Why can't it be mine? "

To be honest, I'm an Alice in Chains fan but this one hits really hard when he sings "I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star...in somebody else's sky but why , why .... whyyyyyyy can't it be ? Why can't it be miiiinnnneeee" It hits deep

Is this the most unique voice in Rock ?

Nothing sounds so good as music made by young man delusioned with life and love 🥹

Eddies voice towards the end. Just the raw emotion and pleading he is going through hits on so many levels.

I was there for her when her mother passed away and none of her friends showed up to offer her support. Helped her emotionally, Financially, etc. Treated her like a Queen and loved her like no tomorrow. Gave her everything I can possibly give and all the free time I had just so I could be with her. In the end, I was just nothing to her and she decided to rather be with someone else that didn’t give two shits about her. Yeah man, this song is hitting me hard right now and probably forever.

To a father who might have lost a daughter... this takes on a whole new meaning. 🙏

I miss great music. This is great music. Hope the future doesn't lose this.

Layne - Love, Hate, Love Trent - Hurt Corey - Snuff Kurt - Where did you sleep last night Eddie - Black Chester - Messenger Chris - Seasons Scott - Wonderful Iconic performances, filled with raw emotion and filled with pain, goes to show that some of the best music comes from the heart and life’s experiences

We don't look for old songs, we look for the memories they carry.

I'm turning 49 this year and this song brings me all the way back to my late teens. I have adored this song since the first time I heard it on the radio. Pearl Jam was also of the first band CD's I purchased, too. Repeat, repeat, repeat ❤ This song gets me right in the gut everytime. Perfection.

Thank you, Eddie Vedder and Pearl Jam for your contribution to ROCK.

This song has always haunted me and I don’t know why. I just love it and always have.

Probably one of the best ballads of all history

05=19=2024. Here in Chicago Illinois USA 💯

I'm 53 but l remember this song in the 90s, l don't think we will ever see such authenticity again

You can hear the pain in Eddie’s voice as the song progresses. It’s like the song itself is crying towards the end in the most beautiful way

why can't it be mine

Who cares who's here in march!!!! was here a long time ago.BLACK SUCH A HEAVY SONG!!!!!

This song saved my life during my darkest days. It became my safe place where I could lay down to cry. Even now, some years later, still makes me feel like I'm there, but without the relentless pain. Thank you, Eddie.

Someone once broke into my house, I didn't even know he was in my closet hiding until I played this song and he came out to sing along with me. Man pearl jam's music really brings people together, you know?

The last few guitar strings are haunting.

I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star In somebody else's sky But why Why Why can't it be Why can't it be mine H&M❤

Em pleno 2024 e eu aqui ouvindo esse som, impossível enjoar dessa música, ano passado foi a música que mais ouvi e estou vendo que não será diferente neste ano

If a guy wrote this song about me I’d love him forever.

God bless America 🎉❤😂😢😮😅😊

This just blew me away in Marley Park Dublin at the weekend. One of the greatest songs written by anyone ever. Listening to it live had me in a trance. Better than the album.

Nice song. This "Pearl Jam" band has a lot of potential.

Nothing has ever resonated more than “I know someday you’ll have a beautiful life, I know you’ll be the sun, in somebody else’s sky but why… why? WHY? Can’t it be mine.” I’m so sorry. I had everything and ruined it. Much love and light whomever sees this and/or who stumbles into this auditory masterpiece.

Who’s here June 2024? If you are, thanks for keeping the greatest song of all time Alive. “Ahhhahh, it’s still alive!”

Im not crying ,you are

This song was released just as I was starting the Fall Semester of my Freshman year at college. I was 18 years old. Two weeks ago I celebrated my 50th birthday. This song still hits 32 years later.

Nothing like the Golden 90s. There will never be another era like it. Thank you Eddie and all the amazing artists who made that time so unforgettable.

Wow the memories some songs bring back

WARNING: Do not mix with alcohol.

I'm 39 and this still hits me hard. I couldn't feel how hard this hit when I was a teenager into drugs and alcohol. I just think now of what a great and mature man I have become it makes me proud.

I’m no fan of Pearl Jam. But whenever I hear this song…I cry. Especially after my bf died. We listened to classic rock and this would come on. It’s interesting thinking about something so trivial when they’re with you. After someone close to you is gone…trivial, becomes everything.

It's crazy this is 30 years old. My kids are so glad I turned them on to this band and many others

THANK U FOR BRINGING BACK THAT GRUNGE IN ME!! I'M 47YO AND A PEARL JAM FAN FOR LIFE!!!

"I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star, in somebody else's sky. But why, why, why can't it be... Why can't it be in mine?"😢 seriously can't get through that verse without shedding a tear lol

I'm 73 years old. The sixties and nineties I got to love both

This is one of those songs where you dont even need to be drunk or high to enjoy it (it certainly does enhance the joy) and belt this song from some place deep inside

I’m crying

this song is like a drug, I can't stop listening it's just the best

Eddie used internet explorer to upload this years ago and it finally uploaded years later

Haven't heard this song for about 10 years. Such reopening

Yep one of the truly greatest songs written and performed heartfelt honesty

The gut-wrenching finality of lost love; the wreckage that is left behind and the realisation that they will shine their light onto someone new. We've all known it ❤️

The pain of loosing someone you have invested your heart and soul into only to have your world destroyed is encapsulated in this song. That's why it touches the soul so much

😢Even after all these years, can’t help but cry this song is soo beautiful! Thank God I was here in this era 🫶🏼

Masterpiece

I listened to this album everyday in my Mitsubishi Eclipse driving home from working at the bank. I HATED that job so much. Don’t work somewhere just to please someone else. It’s miserable. I do love this song though. It brings all that back.

Ah yes, they finally posted the official audio, this song is one of their best, if not their best song

This song is just perfect🤌

Seeing Pearl Jam tonight! And again in 2 Days!

Best Pearl Jam song ever

Summer of 1993. This song was constantly on the radio. Would sneak out at night to meet friends.

I’m here in May 2024 love this song

BEST EVER FROM PEARL JAM!! the dj

When I was 15 years old my parents moved to United States, this was one of pearl jam songs they kept playing on the radio stations, I've just listened to it today after so many years it actually brought tears to my eyes because it brought me right back to the uncertain part of life and I'm going to leave it at that. Great song.

Absolutely unbelievable masterpiece, and it just builds and grows and the climactic ending makes this one of the best songs ever made.

The drum after Eddie says tattooed everything in first verse is amazing

Ah yes another song to cry to

Man at 3:39 always gives me goosebumps!!! Love this song such a masterpiece

Can you feel the grief, the agony, despair? Sooner or later you will have a part of your soul taken from you. On that day the mystery of this song will be revealed to you and then you can begin to appreciate its depths, like all of the wounded who hear and decipher its secrets. May you reach that day and partake in this treasure.

The best

Every song I like has awesome covers but no one can get close to Eddie and his voice. So unique and the emotion is unmatched.

For the longest time I absolutely could not listen to this without bursting into tears, 2 years later I have finally got over and moved on but damn all the memories do still run through like a picture show and probably always will but the tears have finally gone.

Magnificent.