Porcupine Tree - Arriving Somewhere But Not Here..

Porcupine Tree - Anesthesize !

Porcupine Tree - Anesthetize (the live version!)

Porcupine Tree - Anesthetize Mind blowing

Hell yeah! Steven Wilson is the absolute truth. Incredible mind for music. Huge inspiration for me. 🤘

Porcupine Tree - Anesthetize - live (Tilburg, Netherlands)

Gavin Harrison (drums) is a top tier drummer. He doesn't show off all the time in the recordings because he likes to service the music/stay musical, but listening to his clinics and watching his drum videos you can tell he's one of the greats. He plays a lot of styles and is incredibly clean/smooth in them all. Porcupine tree is also an amazing prog group, but they can take a little bit of exposure in order to really start to get the feel for them. Steven Wilson's composition style is heavily focused on atmosphere. If you listen to this album start to finish, it's a pretty great ride.

You guys should check out the Sound of Muzak.

YESSSSS!! Finally you guys got to Porcupine Tree! 👊

Try Porcupine Tree - Arriving Somewhere but not Here And Steven Wilson - Drive Home

Porcupine Tree - Blackest Eyes

Anesthetize is a good song, but a bit too long. I would have started with "Trains" if you want a solid song. For more complex instrumentals and composition, "Arriving Somewhere But Not Here" is probably your best bet.

wow this was unexpected so cool

I know you guys like good drummers so I'm confident you'll love "Anesthetize" by the same band. It's 17 minutes long but it has one of the best drum performances I've heard in recent years. I'd also recommend some of the frontman Steven Wilson's solo work specifically Routine, Drive Home and The Raven that Refused to Sing

I appreciate that you guys actually look at our comments to help guide future reaction videos. Count me as another vote for "Anesthetize" (especially the live at Tilburg version or even better for George, the drum-focused live version by Gavin Harrison).

Arriving somewhere but not here was my first PT song and I was sold. The joy you feel of discovering a great artist was surely there. Such a great spectrum of sounds on every record if you listen carefully to what's going on. Each porcupine tree record sounds much different from the others. You should definitely give more tracks and albums a go. I'm not saying posting a reaction video but if you really like to listen to records in general, go ahead. Cheers!

Steven Wilson (the composer, mixer, vocalist) is very deliberate in everything he creates. The vocals were supposed to be drowned out to give the listener a sense that the character is too numb to reach out. His material is NOT for casual consumption. It was entirely too much for me when I first heard it. My honest opinion is he is a modern musical genius. He is so incredibly impeccable when it comes to his mixing. He has a raw performance style, since he is not the greatest musician, but his composition and sonic abilities are unbelievable. There's no topic too taboo or too risky for him to address. He's written songs from the perspective of serial killers (Raider Part II), transgender people (Chloroform), suicidal individuals (many), people who experience near death experiences, loss of family (Routine), those who have psychosis, and more. Most artists would be too afraid to lyrically portray such menacing characters.

REACTION to The Raven That Refused To Sing Music Video by Steven Wilson!!!

Porcupine Tree - Anesthetize. Same album (Fear of a blank planet) with a guest guitar solo from Alex Lifeson of Rush!

Porcupine Tree is my favorite band of all time, and that they're different it a big part of what I like about them. Like a lot of progressive rock with complex and odd time signatures and non-traditional song structures their songs are growers that take a few listens to unfold. I think it's awesome that George recognizes that and wants to give it a chance to click with him after a few more spins. Often the most enduring songs for me that I end up still loving years later I didn't necessarily love the first time I heard them. I love music that challenges me as a listener. This is an awesome band with a really great and deep catalog. I hope you guys will sample from it again.

One of the greatest Progressive Rock bands of our generation. Not as well known as many less talented mainstream bands, but glad you guys gave em a try.

OMFG NEVER CLICKED SO FAST. STEVEN WILSON IS A GENIUS, btw listen to more Opeth 😁

Steven Wilson - The raven that refused to sing (video) you NEED yo do this one

Radiohead - Paranoid Android

I’m a metal head, and it took a little while for Porcupine Tree to grow on me. I said the same things. “I love the lyrics and I see the talent, but it’s just not quite my thing”. But now Steven Wilson, and porcupine tree are among my favorite artists to listen to. I highly recommend listening to “Arriving Somewhere but Not Here”. Steven Wilson is a lyrical and musical genius in my opinion.

Great reaction to a great band! You should do Opeth again, but a song from their album Blackwater park. That was their big break through album and was produced by Steven Wilson, the singer/guitarist in Porcupine tree.

Yes - Roundabout

I am a huge fan of porcupine tree and his mastermind Steven Wilson

Sooooo many good Porcupine Trees - Open Car, Lazarus, Arriving Somewhere but Not Here, Trains, The Sound of Muzak

Porcupine Tree "Arriving Somewhere But Not Here" is one of my favorite songs. It feels like an older song, like Pink Floyd vibes. Has a real nice groove to it.

Do Porcupine Tree - Open Car!

Do more Porcupine Tree, they really are their own animal. Too many songs to suggest but I'm sure more pushy people have already given plenty of requests for other tracks.

The lyrics deal with two common neurobehavioural developmental disorders for teenagers in the 21st Century: bipolar disorder and attention deficit disorder. Very deep and powerful stuff especially since the song was written in Mid 2007. Still relevant today and maybe even more so.

Porcupine Tree - Sound of Muzak! ..Porcupine Tree is a powerhouse of prog from the UK. The singer guitarist Steven Wilson is a great producer also, he produced Opeth's two best albums! And the drummer is now playing in King Crimson too, which is a HUuuGe deal!!

Radiohead - OK Computer An essential album, one of the most acclaimed of all time. I would be really Curious what you think of it. You might hate it, you might love it.

Porcupine Tree = instant thumbs up!

Porcupine Tree - Arriving somewhere but not here / Sound of muzak

Wow, this is surreal. For years, I listened to this band religiously, and now I see them here. Thanks for reviewing! Keep up the awesome work.

Love this band and Steven Wilson, that guy just has it all figured out how to keep nailing it.

Porcupine tree - Anesthetize (live at Tilburg) PLEEEASE! You guys need to react to that masterpiece!

Porcupine Tree - Anesthetize! Different from other progressive long minutes stuff that you guys heard, this one, despite very long, it's so good that you don't notice time passing, cause instead of virtuosis exagerated showcase that probably isn't the style of you guys, this band and the lead composer Steven Wilson are more concerned about the atmosphere, melodies and message that the song has to pass. Try this one, you guys won't regret.

Themata by Karnivool!!!!! Porcupine Tree is awesome also! Glad to see y’all listen to them!

Good review guys, I've been hanging out for this one. George, I love your reasons for putting this on your playlist, after a couple of listens it will grow on you for sure, try a few other tracks from the album too, and some stuff from the back catalogue. Their is so much joy and wonder in the world that is porcupine tree 😀

This is probably one of my top 10 favorite albums

Oh yeah.... Deftones - Diamond Eyes

Porcupine Tree - Anesthetize or Arriving Somewhere but Not Here! Both songs are must-listens

Wow, I've been suggesting porcupine tree since I first discovered your channel. The thoughts that this song provoked is pretty awesome, man. Love love love lost in vegas!

Death - Spirit Crusher

Porcupine Tree - Awesome pick!!!!

Katatonia!!

Been a PT fan nearly 25 years so I appreciate the time taken to consider their work. That said, regardless of the opinion of the music itself, I think these 2 gents got from the music exactly the message Steve Wilson was trying to convey. Well done fellas! Now KZfaq search "Voyage 34" and hold on for the ride! LOL!!!!!!!!!!

Anesthetize is off this album is a masterpiece. And their album in absentia is brilliant.

I was surprised you guys didn't comment more on Gavin's drumming, but then I realized that what makes him such an incredible drummer is the subtlety of his playing. Gavin is a jazz drummer, so his precision, discipline & groove are what stand out. Check out their songs "The Sound of Muzak", "Anesthetize" & "Deadwing". Pay close attention to what he does, how he accents certain aspects of the music. Top notch drumming 👌

Awesome! Gavin Harrison is one of the top drummers in the worlds. In the prog rock world, he's right up there with Neil Peart. And that's not hyperbole. Great review again.

I'm familiar with Steven Wilson's production and remixing work - his surround mixes of the early King Crimson albums are amazing - but this is my first time hearing Porcupine Tree also, and I'm definitely going to check them out. Thanks!

Interesting song pick, I can see why this might have been recommended, really good lyrical content! However I feel The Sound of Muzak has both great lyrics/message as well as a sick groove and music! The live video version of Anesthetize would be great too (the studio version is cool too and has Alex Lifeson of Rush on there too if I'm not mistaken!) Keep doing what your doing guys, I'm loving it!

Never heard of these guys, but I love the feel and the message. Great suggestion and reaction!

Whoa!!! You guys are full of surprises! George, did you hear that drum fill at 6:05?? Gavin Harrison is on another level! I hope you do add this to your playlist and savor that tasty drumming.

You definitely need to try Anesthetize or Arriving Somewhere But Not Here

Turned on to sweet ass new music thanks to you guys. That song was dope for sure. Gonna have to check out more of this. Excellent breakdown as always.

Gavin Harrison, ridiculously talented drummer!

Katatonia - Leaders Katatonia - My Twin Katatonia - Lethean

YES!!!! Waited so long for this, that im gonna put my wife in bed just to see this in peace!!! In a next time, please do your react for the anesthetize! For me, the most complete song in the world!!! Truly amazing. Congratz from Portugal

You Guys should listen to this band one more time, they are out of this world, i would recommend Arriving Somewhere But Not Here. Even in 2020 this band is such amazing. Also the frontman Steven Wilsons solo work is amazing.

man in the box - alice in chains

Damn good song, i better see Arriving Somewhere But Not Here on this channel eventually

don't know this song, but I like The sound of Muzak a lot. Trains too

Yes - Roundabout please!!

Porcupine tree - anesthetize (live in tilburg)!

No comments on the drums ? Gavin Harisson is one of the best drummer maybe ever. While this is subjective, this guy is in a class shared by only a few others IMO. Also, Steven Wilson is the mastermind behind Porcupine Tree. You should listen to some of his solo stuff too, he is incredible. You should try to react to a live version too, they are pretty amazing live.

Maaaaan, I thought I'd never see a PT reaction! They've been my favorite for a long, long time. You guys are always asking "How does it SOUND?" especially for prog bands. Simply put, this is a band you're gonna want to get into. Check these PT songs out, even on your own time: Dark Matter The Start Of Something Beautiful Drown With Me (live in Tilburg) Last Chance To Evacuate Planet Earth Before It Is Recycled Blind House Arriving Somewhere But Not Here Way Out Of Here

Lots of stuff out there by Steven Wilson, some I haven't even heard yet. I caught Porcupine Tree at least three times live in concert, and Steven at least 4. Check out "No Man" , "Blackfield" , Bass Communion and Steven Willson solo efforts. Welcome to the party, guys !!!

I feel like a good song for Porcupine Tree is “Sound of Muzak”. It’s a lot more accessible with an easier structure. Plus it has a killer groove. However, I feel like you guys should definitely react to either the “Raven That Refused To Sing” music video or the “Routine” music video, both by Steven Wilson’s solo project (singer/guitarist in this song). The emotions in either video are completely overwhelming and masterfully portrayed.

Muse - Knights of Cydonia!

Katatonia-the racing heart

So glad you guys took the time to read the lyrics and break it down. Porcupine Tree is one of my fave bands of all time!!!

Steven Wilson - Routine! The centerpiece of his solo career...what a song!

The more you listen to Porcupine Tree, the more you realise they're one of the most underrated, most innovative bands of our time. They're so subtle, it's easy to miss first time round. But there are so few bands that set a scene and make you feel a certain way like PT. I'd love to see you do 'Way Out Of Here', 'Time Flies', or 'Blackest Eyes' by them at some point! Huge love for doing this one!

Porcupine Tree - Gravity eyelids. It was the first song I heard by them and I fell hard. Steven Wilson is a unique talent

One of my fave groups many have never heard of, unfortunately. Saw them last year live - FANTASTIC!

Leprous

Primus Wynonas Big Brown Beaver.

Nice reaction Guys! Porcupine Tree should be a regular band on your channel. Next : Anesthetize

React to Mr Bungle: Goodbye Sober Day

Porcupine tree is one of those bands in which you have to listen to the whole album in one seating. And this Album is sublime for beginning to end....

Steven Wilson is a visionary. Both Porcupine Tree and his solo stuff is constantly surprising, involving and evolving. Definitely a trailblazer.

Well done gentlemen...free thinking in action. Long time PT fan here and it's great that more people are getting to hear them.

Yaaaas!!! Thank you gettin on PT! One of the greatest bands ever. The next should be Gravity Eyes

Y'all need to listen to the full album! I recommend listening to "Anesthesize"" and "Sentimental".

PT - Anesthetize please!

I'm so glad I came across this reaction today. My favorite reactors reacting to my favorite artist ❤

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE react to "Between the Buried and Me - Selkies: The Endless Obsession"

Porcupine Tree is a band that grows on you over time, listen to more songs and it might change your mind. Listen to Trains or Time Flies. :)

So glad to see a Porcupine Tree review. One of my favorite bands.

Great attitude and analysis guys. I was scared you wouldn't give it a chance, or wouldn't feel it, but you did! Keep up the great work. B)

I love to watch your videos. I was so excited to see this. Porcupine Tree was my dads favorite group. He was always saying how he wished more people would listen to them. You guys just brought this group to a lot of people's attention!!!!

Porcupine Tree mastermind Steven Wilson was producing Opeths "Blackwater Park" where Opeth exposed Steven to bands like Meshuggah and their own music. Due to this, and Steven fearless progressive tendencies, Fear of a Blank Planet ended up being a much heavier album than previous Porcupine Tree releases. Also, this is my fav. Porcupine Tree album. Thanks for this guys!

Kyuss - Gardenia

This song got me into this band. Happy you reviewed it!

Finally! I'm really happy you've had your first contact with Steven Wilson's music, although I don't know if it's the ideal introduction. I would recommend Routine, which is one of his solo songs, or the live version of Hatesong or Open Car, seeing how much you guys like groove.