Brilliant acting.But cannot accept that to become independent we have to become a sex worker. People who do become a sex worker do not become by choice. There are many sad stories behind them. Things are not so simple. And being a house wife is not an easy thing.There is no identity crisis in it. I am a doctor myself. But I am so indebted to my mother in law and my mother for building such a sweet and powerful nest ,where I used to find solace at the end of my day.I have never been able to create one ,inspire of satisfying my aspirations and earning money. Acting is brilliant. But women's liberation is not such a simple notion .You are liberated within yourself. This comes with no or minimal expectation from others and bearing patience.Same for man or woman.

বেশ ছিমছাম, মসৃণ গতির ছবি। বিষয়বস্তু অত্যন্ত গুরুত্বপূর্ণ। বোধহয় স্বল্প দৈর্ঘ্যের ছবি বলেই, বক্তব্য একটু একপেশে মনে হলো। মানে, রোজগার করলেই সেই মেয়ে বৈবাহিক ধর্ষণ কি এড়াতে পারে? সন্মান আদায় করতে পারে? আর্থিক স্বনির্ভরতা থেকেও যেটা বেশী গুরুত্বপূর্ণ বলে মনে হয় আমার, তা হলো মানসিক স্বনির্ভরতা। কিন্তু সঙ্গে এটাও বলবো যে আর্থিক স্বনির্ভরতা অত্যন্ত গুরুত্বপূর্ণ আত্মসম্মান বজায় রেখে জীবনের পথে চলতে গেলে।ভালো লেগেছে। স্বল্পদৈর্ঘ্যের ছবি না হলে হয়তো এই সমস্যার অন্যান্য দিকগুলো নিয়ে কথা বলতে পারতে। তোমার কাজের মাধ্যমে আরও মানুষের কাছে পৌঁছাও।

The script was so absolute totalitarian. Choices jerokom amader life e khub boro role play kore, shob housewife rai choiceless ba privileged background theke esheo societal norms bhenge extreme ekti choice neoa tao je ekmatro choice, etah ekebarei noye. Identity bishoy takei prochondo constrit kore deoa holo, karon two extremes doesn't define what's real. Its the synthesis between them that matters

A very meaningful message to all women... Life depends only on choices... Do whatever but make ones own identity... Even if a housewife be a happy housewife... Housewives should get that respect from their husbands... But live your life on your own terms

আমি একজন গৃহবধূ তাই আমি খুব ভালোভাবে গল্পটার সঙ্গে নিজেকে রিলেট করতে পারছি আমাদের মান-সম্মান পরিচয় কোনটাই নেই বাইরে থেকে দেখে যাকে যাই মনে হোক না কেন

দুই দুর্দান্ত অভিনেত্রীর অভিনয় অসাধারণ হয়েছে। গল্পটির ভাবনা চিন্তা খুব সুন্দর... আমারও আজও ভালোবাসা একই আছে কিন্তু বন্ধুত্বটা নষ্ট হয়ে গেছে....

খুব সুন্দর আবার আবার চলে গিয়েছিলাম শান্তিনিকেতনে খানিকক্ষণের জন্য।

The point of mutual respect is very true in a marital life. 👍

যে কোনো বয়সেই ইচ্ছে করলেই নিজের পরিচিতি তৈরী করে নেওয়া সম্ভব।এই সদর্থক ভাবনাটা খুব প্রয়োজন ছিল এই সিনেমায়। অসম্ভব ভালো একটি বিষয়। শেষটুকু এটা হলে দুর্দান্ত হতো। খুব প্রিয় অভিনেত্রীদের দারুণ মানিয়েছে।

দক্ষ এবং উন্নত ভাবনার ফসল। আজকের দিনে অত্যন্ত প্রয়োজনীয় বার্তা। ধন্যবাদ প্রমিতা এবং সব সহযোগীদের।

Yes I agree with the " Message" of the maker of this short film. "THERE IS ONLY ONE PROFESSION LEFT FOR THE EDUCATED SMART YOUNG LADY---PROSSTITUTION " No other way available in our society except selling flesh to be self supported for the young females. I do not see anyone who is working in any other profession in any where wherever I look. Excellent Messege. My dear, do you know how and why females are being forced to take this profession ? For her own choise ? Take the interview s of Sex Workers honestly and try to understand their extream struggle for existence. Making this Film, you have maligned our lacs of mothers and sisters. Please do not consider yourself a social reformer.

Being independent is nice. I mean every girl should be economically independent but that should not come in a cheap way. Shreya could have earned on other way also. So called "respectable way"

এটা প্রাণপণে অনুভব করি আজ, যাকে ভালবাসা হয় তাকে বিয়ে করতে নেই, তাহলে ভালোবাসা মরে যায়।

Neither Anuradha nor Shreya is happy as both of them, alienated from the society, are alone. In the name of identity those who know nothing but his or self only and cannot identify his or her interest with beloved one(s) of family or society, cannot contribute to the society. Anuradha feels humiliated as she is economically dependent on her husband. Had she built herself properly from her early life, like her husband ,she could be economically independent. Proper education , struggle for acquiring knowledge, skill and a strong willpower to become as strong as menfolks should be the aim . Actually in real life , lives of women of present generation is changing. Inner power of women can really empower the women and conquire the world and contribute further development of human society rejecting frustrated lives of Shreya and also Anuradha .

Why we should disrespect a housewife? It is definitely an identity. Women should respect herself.

আপনাকে ধন্যবাদ। আপনার পরিচয় জানতে পারলাম আমার খুবই প্রিয় সম্পাদক ' শঙ্খ ' এর কাছ থেকে। আজ আপনার পরিচালিত "পরিচয়" স্বল্পচিত্র দেখে মুগ্ধ হলাম। ভালো থাকুন 'প্রমিতা' আন্তরিক শুভেচ্ছা।

Takes a lot of courage to make a short film, such as this. That a woman can be a sex worker by choice, and feel confident of her identity is something that society will have difficulty in accepting and will judge the film negatively, specially more so, if the director is a woman.

খুব ভালো লাগলো । ধন্যবাদ পরিচালক কে এতো বলিষ্ঠ কাজের জন্য। Mutual respect তো দূরের ব্যাপার, নিজের স্ত্রী কে পদে পদে অসম্মান এবং অপমান করেন যে সব ভদ্রলোক, তাঁদের অনেকেই স্বঘোষিত সমাজ সংস্কারক হয়ে শ্রেয়ার by choice selected profession নিয়ে অনেক কিছুই বলবেন, বলছেন। কিন্ত অনুরাধার যন্ত্রণা ও তার উপলব্ধির বিষয়ে তাঁরা আশ্চর্যজনক ভাবেই নীরব, কারণ আমার জানা । Free bonded labour তো ,চোখ ফুটলে মুশকিল। তাই শ্রেয়ার profession নিয়ে প্রচুর comments, যাতে আসল কথাটাই লঘু হয়ে যায়।

To create one's own identity, to be aware of that, is a matter of self-realization and real education of a man/woman. Here, we see in our society, in a large perspective, that maximum no.of women, don't even know that or rather don't even realize that. The main crisis lies in economic dependency. Hope, we all, will be able to change the concept of so called old, hackneyed perceptions of this old and rotten WORLD. Best wishes to all the cast and crew of the film. SRIKANTA SARKAR, MUSIC & FILM DIRECTOR FROM CINE-TELLER PRODUCTIONS: KOLKATA: INDIA

সত্যিই এক ভাবাত্নক গল্পের কাহিনী বাস্তবতার করুন এক গল্প😮😮😮

Melancholic...But With A Dose of Pure Spirit...My Sincere Regards To The Director & Best-Est Wishes For Her Every Future Creation...Waiting With All The Eagerness For Your Next

Excellent superb performance of SUDIPTA.

Yes, Pramita!I loved "professionalism" of the film. I loved the story with so many nuances.Topping all, your message to honour all identities alike, transcending all taboo and set notions, is just awesome!

ভালো করে মনের ভেতর টা খোঁজ নিয়ে দেখবেন যে বলে গেল সে এই কাজটি করে খুশি আছে সে আদৌও খুশি আছে কিনা এটা শুধু তার নিজের মনকে শান্তনা দেওয়ার জন্য কিনা।সে ভিতরে ভিতরে আপনার মতো সুস্থ্য স্বাভাবিক জীবন ডিজার্ভ করে কিনা

সবাই যদি ওর মতন ভাবে তাহলে তো কোন শ্রেয়া ই জন্মাবে না আর সবই শেষ হয়ে যাবে

Shob shomoy house wife der emon demeen dekhanor ki dorkar.Agey toh onek mohilar kono income chilona .but they used to get lots of love and respect from their family members..very wrong interpretation..I have seen financial sound eminent women are adjusting a lot..

Women have to pass many tests and obstacles ,self realisation to bring out the real identity of herself 🙏💐

Most house wives are the pivot of a family No need to tie all of them in one frame No question of identity crisis

Sob sex worker er যেমন সব সময় চয়েস থাকে না তেমন e sob home maker o sob somoy e legal rape er sikar hoy না but bitorko চলতেই পারে that is good

A woman does not have to prove herself,she needs to be happy,whether she is a housewife or any professional...

কতো কাজ তো আছে সন্মান জনক ভাবে বেঁচে থাকার তবে এই কাজ কখনো কাম্য নয় একজন ভদ্র ঘরের মেয়ের জন্য

Identity is very much needed and Anu can do many things to have her own identity.

Life is choices and taking responsibility, No I am not a working woman,but all the things happens in our life I choose,it's not about economical independence,it s about knowing about who you are,and how much can you do to be who you are, Against society expectations, family' and friends..... The problem of women is we love the images of sita,not of Parvati... It is not the social norms,or husband's personality, thought that actually matters,the matter is are we ready enough to stand on husband's chest shamelessly with a sword and a cut head....means can we go extreme when our respect,our integrity ,our identity crushed.... No one to blame,it is our choices,to take responsibility...

I don’t disrespect the profession but it’s not essential for independence . Another thing when a woman is a home maker , I don’t think she is any way less . Managing a house , giving time to the kids , looking after old parents is indeed a blessing and if a woman does that she is no way less or it’s not she does not have an identity.

Khub sundor boleche Mansor sorir 😊😊 Darun short film ta Osadharon 👍👌

Amar khub bhalo legechhe. Sob meyrder o ekta porichoy thaka darkar.

কমেন্ট পড়ে আমি হতাশ! এরকম একটা একপেশে সাবজেক্টকে বাহবা দেয়া হচ্ছে! কোলকাতার সমাজ কি এতটাই বিকলাঙ্গ হয়ে গেছে! আলহামদুলিল্লাহ আমি বাংলাদেশি।

ধন্যবাদ।।।আমি এইরকম ই একটি ছবি খুঁজছিলাম।।।।ভীষণ সুন্দর।।।পুরোটাই আমার জীবনে মেলানো

I can't differ between identity & inner identity । Thanks film maker & director ।

Oshadharon.. Gaye kata diye uthlo

Maybe Shreya was compelled into this profession. Here she is glorifying her work.Finding it difficult to accept. Homemakers are generally looked down upon but by no means she should feel any inferior to the " independent woman".

স্বল্প দৈর্ঘ্যর ছবি হলেও, অনেক বাস্তব কথা বলে গেল।

Brilliant acting. Bravo Sudipta.

Yes every woman must hv an identity. Being a commodity is not her aim. But this sd be remembered that over all each and every person sd be responsible for making the society better to best. So this cannot be the only solution to survive. The society wl ultimately perish then. And this is happening today. There must be something in every film whether short or long to awake the society.

There definitely should be mutual respect. But in a married life the enjoyment of having your child to bring up can be so fulfilling. Also in old age it can be expected that your spouce will be beside you and children to care for you if brought up well. But being educated and funancially indep6is very important too.

first 5 mins were enough to not watch the whole film. A woman is respected by her character, not by her profession. A caring mother is respected by her child, a loving wife is respected by her husband and family, a good-hearted woman is respected by the society. Men and Women are complementary to each other to make healthy families and hence a healthy society and our future generation. Though we should not give the privilege to the society to control our emotions, but it is also true that without the society we do not exist!

Very very very very very very very very very very nice 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

Every meager deed has its result, good or bad. One who does good will get good result and be happy. One who does bad will have to cry for it. We should be aware of our deed. Good and evil are prominent and we have to decide ourselves which way to go. Good deeds have much cost and sometimes boring but its output is great, bad deeds are easy and temporarily enjoyable but its final result is misery. Choice is of course to our free will.

অসমাপ্ত অংশগুলোর মধ্যে সামঞ্জস‍্যতা আমাদের পরিচয়।

Being a house wife or a sex worker is all a choice, but what this short film tries to convey is, at the end of the day contentment is all what matters! You again might or might not have it as a housewife or a sexworker, it's on you, people choosing to be a housewife may find contentment in it same for any other profession, while at the same time some people may regret being a house wife same for any other profession At the end, we need to be content with what we do, that's all what matters 😊

Don't we all need a homemaker at the end of the day ? To feel at home , to unwind , to feel loved and cared for .. then how can a homemaker be belittled . Identity starts within our own heart , seeking elsewhere is just vulnerability . Only when we respect our own work of homemaking, others will be bound to do so . And to be economically independent, work atleast part time .. Much before that , work on your ownself , physically and mentally .... and by the way , wasn't she independent enough to say a no to the clent to save the day to be with her firiend after 15 yrs for lunch . Huh ! Independent in disguise . !! .

I don’t like the lopsided view of the movie. I cant encourage to choose such a profession. Being married and doing for the family is always appreciated

ভালো লাগলো।👍প্রত্যেকের একটা পরিচয় থাকা দরকার।

Asadharon subject...acting balar apekkha rakhe na. Nice directions 👌 👏 😋

সমাজের বাস্তব প্রতিচ্ছবি। খুব ভালো লাগলো।

Extreme paradoxes and stereotyping. So whats the point or conclusion? Leave all and become a _______ ?? Amd meanwhile... this attempt to belittle housewives is strongly condemnable.

My old crush koneenica banerjee. Nice to see after a long time

Very nice movie. Good direction, good performance.

Very nice, the identity of a woman, Have true inner meaning, ✌️

Valo laglo❤❤❤.. Shreya ontoto independent ❤❤❤...

বেশ ভালো লাগলো

সমাজ কি বললো কি ভাবলো কি যায় আসে তবে গল্পটা গল্পেই ভালো লাগে . . . . . এখনো একটা মেয়ে রাত্তির করে বাড়ি ফিরলে আমরাই আড়ালে ফিসফাস করি . . . . অতএব . . . . .

অসাধারণ ❤

Please, full film ta upload korun

Ei short filme etai bojhate chaichhe ekhonkar shikshito meyera nijer porichoyer sarthe beshya britti te nam lekhak? Eta mene neýa jayna.

Really it is a amazing... Every man should an indentity...

Well portrayed. We all want to secure ourselves with a designation. But that designation many a times is a house of cards

Both my lovely ladies..... love them both so much....

Very ❤ good ❤❤❤❤❤❤

Irrespective of gender or economic status every human being should have unique identity of his or her own. True identity is acquired by constant endeavor in the process of becoming human. Identity, which is thrusted upon a 'heap of flesh' has no choice of living his/ her own life.

এই ধরনের গল্প আমার খুব ভালো লাগে আপলোড করার জন্য ধন্যবাদ। ভালো থাকুন

Just awesome 👌

ভালো লাগলো

কেন ওই একটা পেশা ছাড়া কি আর কোনো কাজ নেই ? তাহলে ও সে একটা বাড়িতে ,থাকে, আসলে পরিবার বেশিরভাগ মানুষই চায়। কারণ বয়েস একদিন সকলেরই বাড়ে।

I don't understand the fascination of Indian women being housewives in US..? Just because you cannot afford yourself, you need someone to take your free of cost in return of providing you food and needs of life

Ekdam thik

ভালো লাগলো। তবে আমাদের সমাজ কে ধ্বংশ করে দেবে এই উদাহরণ

সুড়সুড়ি সংলাপ সর্বস্ব,, "our cinema, their cinema"- Ray.

দারুণ

What is the message? That being a sex worker is a noble choice? The girl was well educated, had all the means of chosing so many other professions but this to her proved to be the best. Well, that is her right of choosing priorities but how dare she belittle the peace achieved by someone else to prove that hers is the right choice but not the other's? Wish less of these warped views do the rounds on social media! Didn't appreciate at all.

Someone can't be young forever, After the young age What'll be the identity of this kind of human beings ❓❓❓ A very relevant question ❓❓❓ Doesn't it ❓❓❓

Asadharon aki short film

Beautiful movie

বেশ ভালো লাগলো । তবে , দুই এক্সট্রীম মেরুকরন ছাড়াও আরো অনেক সমঝোতাসহ বিভিন্ন পরিচয় আছে । তবে যা বলতে চেয়েছেন খুব গুছিয়ে পরিস্কার করে বলা । 👍🌹

খুব ভালো লাগলো 😊😊👌👌👍👍❤❤

Sensitive film but ektu chorano a bit lost from the main stream i am a marriage women ja bola hoe che sheta eke bare shotti.kintu tar jonne prostitution ke justification dea jae ki?we r mother's ,gr mother's didi hishebe sonman pai.bole sonsaar er kichu grey shades tolerate korte badho thaki.ekta Alon pros er sathe ki soman kora jae.anyway halka kore dikhle cinema ta bhalo laglo.keep it up

Excellent Sudipta and Koneenica

I would say we should educate our kids to respect & show love, sympathy to your wife.

concept is good...bt one thing if a man earns takes responsiblity when women earns independent

Bhishan bhalo laglo.

Liberty depend s upon the person Valobasle bie kora jay na Bier por sob valobasa ses hoye jay etao depends upon the situation

কিছুই বলার নেই ۔۔۔۔ আসলেই আমরা মেয়েরা বেসিক্যালি মেয়ে মানুষ ই !!

খুব ভালো লাগলো

Bah...khub bhalo laglo.. 👍

বেশ ভালো লাগলো।

Extremely good and strong message conveyed.

Wonderful ❤

Ki daroon film taaaa

Money does not mean in case it may in liquid which a women can get through love and respect by her family

অপূর্ব লাগলো, concept trembles।